Are Smaller Turbines the Way Forward for Wind Energy in Herefordshire?

Linnell, Peter (2010): Are Smaller Turbines the Way Forward for Wind Energy in Herefordshire? Published in: MSc Dissertation, University of East London (10 June 2010)

Abstract

This study set out to determine the social and economic viability of a proposal that smaller turbines are 'better' for wind energy in the county of Herefordshire. The study is in two parts, an opinion poll and a technical desk study. The opinion poll was to discover variations in attitude to three sizes of turbines. Data gathered to allow sample verification also allowed investigation of how attitude varied with demographic factors. Additional questions gave estimates of public perception of WECS effectiveness related to size; and some basic findings on issues of ownership and investment. A random stratified sample of 500 county residents yielded results showing strong correlation between size and attitudes. Questions were designed to also test the 'conditional' supporter model proposed by Bell and others, which was confirmed. Older and better off groups are significantly more likely to be opposed to any size of WECS; but strongest support also includes younger better off people. Respondents over estimated output of smallest and under estimated output of largest turbines. A considerable sub population supports the technology and local ownership, appearing willing to invest. Some methodological issues remain unresolved, but the results given are considered sufficiently robust for this scale of study. The economic analysis was heavily dependant on a few meta-studies, backed up with calculations from primary data for calibration. The proposal to develop arrays of small turbines in place of large machines is revealed as unviable in energy and financial terms. A model of sub urban or industrial locations for medium and large scale WECS is proposed. In addition a community ownership model for projects at this scale is advanced as a pathway to local energy resilience, supportive participation, and energy equity.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Renewable Energy, Energy Economics, Electric Cars, Wind Power
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q0 - General > Q01 - Sustainable Development; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q50 - General; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q58 - Government Policy; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R0 - General

References

ADAS/CALU 2008; Energy efficiency and energy generation on farm - a guide. ADAS/ Centre for Alternative Land Use. Bangor. Online at http://www.calu.bangor.ac.uk

AGTERBOSCH, S., VERMEULEN, W. & GLASBERG, P. 2004. Implementation of wind energy in the Netherlands:the importance of the social-institutional setting. Energy Policy 32 (2004) pp 2049-2066.

AITKEN, M. 2009. Why we still don't understand the social aspects of wind power: A critique of key assumptions within the literature. Energy Policy 2009 ( in press)

BARON, S., WATERSON, E., HOWELLS, D., & SAMUEL, B. 2008. Power in Numbers. Energy Saving Trust. London 2008

BELL, D., GREY, T. & HAGGETT, C. 2005. The Social Gap in Wind Farm Siting Decisions: Explanations and Policy Responses. Environmental Politics, Vol 14, No.4,pp 460-477, August 2005.

BLANCO, M., I. 2009. The economics of wind energy. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 13 (2009) pp 1372-1382.

BOARDMAN, B., DARBY, S., KILLIP, G., HINNELS, M., JARDINE, C.,N., PALMER, J. & SINDEN, G. 2005. 40% House. Oxford. Environmental Change Institute, University of Oxford.

BOCCARD, N. 2009. Capacity factor of wind power realized values vs. estimates. Energy Policy 37 (2009) 2679–2688

BWEA 2005. A Summary of Research Conducted into Attitudes to Wind Power from 1990-1996. British Wind Energy Association.

CAPIBUS 2003. Wind Power Research: Computer Tabulations, Prepared for BWEA download/REPORT-MORIPublicAttitudes.pdf, 09/08/2005. {as cited by McGowan & Sauter}

CHAMBERS, N., SIMMONS, C. & WACKERNAGEL, M. 2010. Sharing Nature's Interest.; Ecological Footprints as an indicator of sustainability. London, Earthscan 2010

CHOMSKY, N. & FOUCAULT, M. 1974. Human Nature: Justice vs. Power in F. ELDERS (ed) Reflexive Water: The Basic Concerns of Mankind, London, Souvenir.

CLARK, B. 1994. Improving public participation in environmental impact assessments. Built Environment 20 (4) pp 294-308. Quoted by Glasson et.al.2005

CLASON, D., L. & DORMODY, T., J. 1994. Analysing Data Measured by Individual Likert-type Items. Journal of Agricultural Education Vol. 35 No 4 pp 31-35.

CLIFF, N. 2007. Note J; Ordinal, Nominal and Likert Scale Variables 9/4/07 to 9/9/07. Downloaded on 14.6.2010 from http://www.daheiser.info/excel/notes/NOTE%20J.pdf

COOKE, P. 2010 Herefordshire contractor. Personal communication; 30th May 2010

COUNTRY GUARDIAN 2010. http://www.countryguardian.net accessed 10.6.20120

Council for Protection of Rural England (CPRE) 2009. Policy Position Statement, Onshore Wind Turbines. London. CPRE Publications.

Department for Energy and Climate Change (DECC) 2009. Maps showing domestic, industrial and commercial electricity consumption at local authority level. Department of Energy and Climate Change URN 09D/535.

DECC 2010. http://www.decc.gov.uk/en/content/cms/what_we_do/uk_supply/energy_mix/renewable/fee din_tariff.aspx. [no line break]. accessed 23.5.2010.

DECC 2010b. Sub-national authority electricity consumption statistics 2005,2006,2007,2008. Department of Energy and Climate Change URN 10D/487A.

DEVINE-WRIGHT, P. 2005. Beyond NIMBYism: towards an integrated framework for understanding public perceptions of wind energy. Wind Energy 8 (2) pp 125-140.

DEVINE-WRIGHT, P., WALKER, G., HUNTER, S., HIGH, H. & EVANS, B. 2007. An empirical study of public beliefs about community renewable energy projects in England and Wales. Working Paper 2: Community Energy Initiatives Project. Manchester Architecture Research Centre. Manchester.

DEWI 2002. Studie zur aktuellen kostensituation 2002 der Windenergienutzung in Deutschland. Available at http://www.dewi.de

DILLMAN, D., A. 2002. Navigating the rapids of change:some observations on survey methodology in the early twenty-first century. Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol 66 pp 473-494

Department of Trade and Industry (DTI)/ Scottish Executive Social Research 2004. MORI Scotland. {as cited by McGowan & Sauter}

DTI 1994. Public Attitudes Towards Wind Power - A Survey of Opinion in Cornwall and Devon. DTI. Exeter Enterprises. { as cited by BWEA}

DTI 2007. Meeting the Energy Challenge, A White Paper on Energy. London. The Stationery Office.

DTI 2007(a). Impact of banding the Renewables Obligation- Costs of electricity production. April 2007 Ernst and Young. URN No. 07/948.

DTI 2007(b). Study of costs of offshore wind generation. A report to the Renewables Advisory Board (RAB) and DTI. URN No. 07/779.

ECOTRICITY (2010); http://www.ecotricity.co.uk/wind-parks/ 28.5.2010

Energy Networks Stategy Group (ENSG) 2009. Our Electricity transmission network: A vision for 2020. DECC URN 09/752

EST 2008. Power in Numbers. London. Energy Saving Trust.

Energy Saving Trust 2010 . http://www.energysavingtrust.org.uk/

EXCHANGE-RATES.ORG. 2010. http://www.exchange rates.org/history/EUR/GBP/G accessed 1.6.2010

FENDERSON, A. 2006. Energy Descent Action Plans - a primer. Post Carbon Institute 2006: http://www.energybulletin.net/node/16859

FERRANDO, P., J. 1999. Likert Scaling Using Continuous, Censored, and Graded Response Models: Effects on Criterion- Related Validity. Applied Psychological Measurement, Vol 23, No 2 PP 161-175.

FLYVBERG, B. 1998. Habermas and Foucault: Thinkers for Civil Society? The British Journal of Sociology, Vol 49, No.2 June 1998. pp 210-233. Blackwell Publishing/London School of Economics and Political Science.

FOXON, T., J., GROSS, R., CHASE, A., HOWES, J., ARNALL, A. & ANDERSON, D. 2005. “UK Innovation systems for new and renewable energy technologies: drivers, barriers and systems failures.” Energy Policy 33, 2005, pp2123-2137. Downloaded from www.elsevier.com/locate/enpol .

GIPE, P. 1995. Wind Energy Comes of Age. New York, John Wiley.

GLASSON, J., THERIVAL, R., & CHADWICK, A. 2005. Introduction to Environmental Impact Assessment 3rd. Ed. Routledge. London

GOODENERGY 2010. http://www.goodenergygeneration.co.uk/about-us/where-our-energy-comes-from.aspx 28.5.2010

GROVES, R., M., 2004. Survey Errors and Survey Costs (2004 ed.) Hoboken,NJ. John Wiley & Sons Inc.

GUNN-WILKINSON, P. 2009. Small-scale schemes are a better way to get electricity. Hereford Times letters; 20.8.2009.

GWILLIM, R. 2009. Wind Analysis. Lecture notes for UEL REBE course module. CAT March 2009.

HABERMAS, J. 1987. The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity. Cambridge, Mass. MIT Press.

HAGGETT, C. & TOKE, D. 2006. Crossing the Great Divide - Using Multi-Method Analysis to Understand Opposition to Windfarms. Public Administration Vol.84, No.1 2006 pp103-120.

HARPER, P. 2008 Mainstream Aspirations and Low-carbon lifestyles. CAT/GSE Lecture March 2008. CAT, Machynlleth.

HAYES MCKENZIE 2006; The Measurement of low frequency noise at three UK wind farms. DTI URN Number 06/1412. 2006

HEAL, A. 2009. personal communication 23.11.2009

HCC 2010(1) Key Statistics for Herefordshire County http:www.herefordshire.gov.uk/docs/Research/KS_hfds_comp_Eng_Wales.pdf Downloaded on 12.01.2010

HCC 2010(2) The Population of Herefordshire ( November 2009) http:www.herefordshire.gov.uk/docs/Research/Current_Hfds_Population_Digest.pdf Downloaded on 12.01.2010

HCC 2010(3) Broadband in Herefordshire; http://www.herefordshire.gov.uk/community_and_living/45221.asp accessed 27.6.2010

Hodge, B. M. S., Huang, S., Shukla, A., Pekny, J. F., & Reklaitis, G. V. (2010). The effects of vehicle-to-grid systems on wind power integration in California. Computer Aided Chemical Engineering, 28, 1039-1044.

Van der HORST, D. 2007. Nimby or not? Exploring the relevance of location and the politics of voiced opinions in renewable energy siting controversies. Energy Policy 35 pp 2705-2714.

Van der HORST, D. & TOKE D. 2010. Exploring the landscape of wind farm developments; local area characteristics and planning process outcomes in rural England. Land Use Policy 27 ( 2010) pp 214-221

IGO, S., E. 2006. "A Gold mine and a tool for democracy": George Gallup, Elmo Roper, and the business of scientific polling 1935-1955. Journal of the History of the Behavioural Sciences Vol. 42 No.2 pp109-134.

ILLICH, I., D. 1974 Energy and Equity. Calder and Boyars. London 1974.

JAMIESON, S. 2004. Likert scales: how to (ab)use them. Medical Education 2004; 38: pp1212-1218

JEFFERSON, M. 2008. The Economics of Renewable Energy http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200708/ldselect/ldeconaf/195/195we48 .htm. accessed 30.5.2010

JEFFERSON, M. 2008(2). Accelerating the transition to sustainable energy systems. Energy Policy 36 (2008) pp 411`6-4125

KATZ, D. 1942 Do interviewers bias poll results? Public Opinion Quarterly 6 (1942) pp 248 -268.

KEMP, M. & WEXLER, J. 2010 .(Eds.) Zero Carbon Britain 2030. Machynlleth, CAT Publications.

KORNBROT, D. 2007 Quoted in CLIFF 2007

KUBISZEWSKI, I., CLEVELAND, C., J., & ENDRES, P., K. 2010. Meta-analysis of net energy return for wind power systems. Renewable Energy 35 (2010) pp218-225

LA TENE MAPS 2005. Wales, Electricity Generation and Transmission. La Tene Maps, Dublin. 1st.ed 2005.

LINDER, J., R., MURPHY, T., H. & BRIERS, G., E. 2001. Handling Nonresponse in Social Science Research. Journal of Agricultural Education Vol 42 issue 4.

LINNELL, P. 2009 Abergynolwyn - A study in transferable futility. Unpublished MSc AEES essay UEL/CAT GSE. Available from the author at [e-mail].

LOWRY 2010. http://faculty.vassar.edu/lowry/pbcorr.html As of 5.5.2010

MACAULAY 2010. Landscape Designations. Macaulay Land Use Research Institute. downloaded from www.macaulay.ac.uk/ccw/task-two/designations.html on 22.6.2010

McGOWAN, F. & SAUTER, R. 2005. Public Opinion on Energy Research: A Desk Study for the Research Councils. Brighton, Sussex Energy Group, University of Sussex.

MEADOWS, D., RANDERS, J., & MEADOWS, D. 2005. Limits to Growth; The 30 - year update. London. Earthscan. 2005.

MINTEL 2010. http://academic.mintel.com/sinatra/oxygen_academic/my_reports/display/id=395621&anch or=atom/display/id=496175 ( no line break) Downloaded on 12.01.2010

MITCHELL, C. & CONNOR, P. 2004. Renewable energy policy in the UK 1990-2003. Energy Policy Vol 32 No.17 November 2004 pp 1935-1947

MOLLISON, B., C. 1990. Permaculture: a practical guide for a sustainable future. Washington DC. Island Press.

MORI 2004. "Attitudes to Renewable Energy in Devon", Social Research Institute for Regen SW http://www.regensw.co.uk/content-download/DevonMORIPollReport-091104.pdf, 09/08/2005. {as cited by McGowan & Sauter}

MOSER, C., A. & KALTON, G. 1971. Survey Methods in Social Investigation (2nd ed.) London, Heinemann Educational Books.

NETA 2010. http://www.bmreports.com/bsp/bsp_home.htm accessed 29.5.2010

NEWELL, R. 1993. Questionnaires. In GILBERT, N. ed. Researching Social Life. London. Sage Publications.

OPPENHEIM, A., N. 1992. Questionnaire Design, Interviewing and Attitude Measurement. 1992 edition. London: Pinter Publishers Ltd.

ORNSTEIN, M. 1998. Questionnaire Design. Current Sociology 1998; 46; 7.

PIERPONT, N. 2009. Wind Turbine Syndrome, A report on a Natural Experiment. Santa Fe NM. K-Select Books. Abstract available at http:/www.windcows.com/files/Pierpont s Abstract-8-9-08.pdf as of 26.6.2010.

PROCTER, M. 1993. Measuring Attitudes. in Researching Social Life; GILBERT, N. ed. London, Sage Publications.

PROVEN, 2010. http://www.provenenergy.co.uk/windcrofting.php accessed on 19.5.2010

QUIETREVOLUTION 2009. Product Specification qr5 v 1.4 Vertical Axis Wind Turbine. Quietrevolution ltd. London. http://www.quietrevolution.co.uk accessed 28.4.2010

RACKHAM, O.1986. The History of the Countryside; Phoenix Press, London.

REISMAN, D. & GLAZER, N. 1948 The Meaning of Opinion. Public Opinion Quarterly Vol 12 No.4 pp 633-648

RENSMART 2010b. http://www.rensmart.com/Weather/BERR

RENSMART 2010a. http://www.rensmart.com/Tools/SitePlanner?Project=Example Wind Turbine. accessed 30.5.2010

RHODES, M. 2008. The Warwick Wind Trials: Insights into a tragedy of inflated expectations and cultural ignorance. Environment Protection UK (Wales) Managing the impacts of micro-generation in Wales. Gorseinon July 24th 2008. [e-mail]

ROWE, G. & FREWER L., J. 2000. Public Participation Methods: A Framework for Evaluation Science, Technology, & Human Values, Vol 25 No 1 Winter 200 pp 3-29

SIMS, S., DENT, P. & OSKROCHI, G., R. 2008. Modelling the Impact of Wind Farms on House Prices in the UK. International Journal of Strategic Property Management (2008) 12 pp 251-269

SIMS, R., E., H., ROGNER, H. & GREGORY, K. 2003. Carbon emission and mitigation cost comparisons between fossil fuel, nuclear and renewable energy resources for electricity generation. Energy Policy 31 (2003) pp 1315-1326.

Somerset County Council 2004. "Somerset Environment & Quality of Life Questionnaire 2004", http://www.somerset.gov.uk/somerset/media/6844B/SomEnvQOL%20Report. pdf, 10/08/2005. {as cited by McGowan & Sauter}

STATSOFT.COM 2010. http://www.statsoft.com/textbook/nonparametric-statistics accessed 18.6.2010.vvvvv

STEVENSON, R. 2009. Discourse, power and energy conflicts: understanding Welsh renewable energy planning policy. Environment and Planning c: Government and Policy 2009, vol 27, pp 512-526.

SUROWIECKI, J. 2004. The Wisdom of Crowds: Why the many are Smarter Than the Few and How collective Wisdom Shapes Business,Economies, Societies and Nations. New York: Doubleday 2004

SZARKA, J. 2004. Wind power, discourse coalitions and climate change: Breaking the stalemate. European Environment; Nov/Dec 2004; 14, 6. pp 317-330

ukplanning.com. http://www.ukplanning.com/ukp/showCaseFile.do;jsessionid=FBF8D88D7F859BA0852C6 [no return]508D9CC15F0.wam2?action=show&appType=planning folder&appNumber=DCNW2008/1289/F. Accessed 18.5.2010. NB this URL goes to an active server page. Access may be gained by following UK planning portal links to Herefordshire and using either Reeves Hill or Application No.DCNW2008/1289/F as search criteria.

UKERC (2007). United Kingdom Energy Research Centre. {No specific document is cited by Blanco for this data.}

WALKER, G., HUNTER, S., DEVINE-WRIGHT, P., EVANS, B. & FAY, H. 2007. Harnessing community energies: explaining and evaluating community-based localism in renewable energy policy in the UK. Global Environmental Politics, Special issue on Climate Governance, Vol 7 issue 2 May 2007.

WARREN, C. R. & McFADYEN, M. 2010. "Does community ownership affect public attitudes to wind energy? A case study from south-west Scotland. Land Use Policy 27, pp 204-213.

WELLS, S. (2010). 7Y Energy Ltd. Personal communication May 30th, 2010

WHITE, L., & TAKET, A. 1997. Beyond Appraisal: Participatory Appraisal of Needs and the Development of Action (PANDA). International Journal of Management Science; Vol 25, No 5, pp 523-534

WOLSINK, M. 2007. Wind power implementation; the nature of public attitudes: equity and fairness instead of "backyard motives". Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 11 (6) pp 1188-1207.

WOODS, M. 2003. Deconstructing rural protest: the emergence of a new social movement. Journal of Rural Studies 19, pp 309-325.

WWYLIE, R. & HAGUE, R. 2003. Energy Choices 2003. NIA/BNES Conference 4th Dec. 2003 London