External Trade Diversion, Exclusion Incentives and the Nature of Preferential Trade Agreements

Missios, Paul and Saggi, Kamal and Yildiz, Halis Murat (2014): External Trade Diversion, Exclusion Incentives and the Nature of Preferential Trade Agreements.

Abstract

In a game of endogenous trade agreements, we examine whether the pursuit of free trade agreements (FTAs) affects the prospects of global free trade differently than the pursuit of customs unions (CUs). Our analysis is driven by a fundamental difference between these two types of preferential trade agreements (PTAs): while CU members impose jointly optimal common tariffs on non-members, members of an FTA adopt individually optimal external tariffs. This implies that (a) FTAs are relatively more flexible than CUs in the sense that an FTA member can decide to undertake further trade liberalization with respect to non-members on its own whereas a CU member can do so only if all other members also wish to do the same and (b) coordination during tariff setting allows CU members to pool their market power. In our comparative advantage based three country framework, the formation of either type of PTA induces the non-member to lower its external tariffs due to the reduction in the volume of exports flowing from members to the non-member (we call this external trade diversion). While the pursuit of CUs prevents free trade from emerging as a coalition-proof Nash equilibrium, the pursuit of FTAs does not. This key result is driven by the relative flexibility of FTAs; the higher market power of CUs by itself does not undermine the objective of reaching global free trade.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Free Trade Agreement, Customs Union, Hub and Spoke Agreements, Free Trade, Optimal Tariffs
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F12 - Models of Trade with Imperfect Competition and Scale Economies ; Fragmentation; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F13 - Trade Policy ; International Trade Organizations

References

Bagwell, Kyle and Robert. W. Staiger, 1997a. "Multilateral Tariff Cooperation During the Formation of Customs Unions." Journal of International Economics, Elsevier 42, 91-123.

Bagwell, Kyle and Robert. W. Staiger, 1997b. "Multilateral Tariff Cooperation During the Formation of Free Trade Areas." International Economic Review 38, 291-319.

Bagwell, Kyle and Robert. W. Staiger, 1998. "Regionalism and Multilateral Tariff Cooperation." In John Piggott and Allan Woodland, eds, International Trade Policy and the Pacific Rim, London: MacMillan.

Bernheim, Douglas B., Bezalel Peleg and Michael Whinston, 1987. "Coalition-proof Nash Equilibria I. Concepts." Journal of Economic Theory 42, 1-12.

Bond, Eric W., and Constantinos Syropoulos, 1996. "The Size of Trading Blocs: Market Power and World Welfare Effects." Journal of International Economics 40, 411-437.

Bond, Eric W., Raymond G. Riezman, and Constantinos Syropoulos, 2004. "A Strategic and Welfare Theoretic Analysis of Free Trade Areas." Journal of International Economics 64, 1-27.

Broda, Christian, Nuno Limao and David E. Weinstein, 2008. "Optimal Tariffs and Market Power: The Evidence," American Economic Review, 98(5), 2032-65.

Coates, Daniel and Rodney Ludema, 2001. "A Theory of Trade Policy Leadership." Journal of Development Economics 65, 1--29.

Estevadeordal, Antoni, Caroline Freund and Emanuel Ornelas, 2008. "Does Regionalism Affect Trade Liberalization toward Non Members?" Quarterly Journal of Economics 123(4), 1531-1575.

Feenstra, Robert, 2004. Advanced International Trade. Princeton University Press.

Freund, Caroline and Emanuel Ornelas, 2010. "Regional Trade Agreements," Annual Review of Economics 2, 139-167.

Grossman, Gene M. and Elhanan Helpman, 1995. "The Politics of Free-Trade Agreements." American Economic Review 85, 667-690.

Horn, Henrik, Giovanni Maggi, and Robert W. Staiger, 2010. "Trade agreements as endogenously incomplete contracts." American Economic Review 100(1), 394-419.

Kennan, John and Raymond Riezman, 1990. "Optimal Tariff Equilibria with Customs Unions?" Canadian Journal of Economics 23, 70-83.

Krishna, Pravin, 1998. "Regionalism and Multilateralism: A Political Economy Approach." Quarterly Journal of Economics 113, 227-251.

Krishna, Pravin and Devashish Mitra, 2005. "Reciprocated Unilateralism in Trade Policy." Journal of International Economics 65, 461--487.

Mrázová, Monika, David Vines, and Ben Zissimos, 2013. "Is the GATT/WTO's Article XXIV Bad?" Journal of International Economics 89(1), 216-232.

Olarreaga, Marcelo, Isidro Soloaga, and Alan Winters, 1999. "What's Behind MERCOSUR's Common External Tariff?" Policy Research Working Paper Series 2231, World Bank.

Ornelas, Emanuel, 2005a. "Trade Creating Free Trade Areas and the Undermining of Multilateralism." European Economic Review 49, 1717-1735.

Ornelas, Emanuel, 2005b. "Rent Destruction and the Political Viability of Free Trade Agreements." Quarterly Journal of Economics 120, 1475-1506.

Saggi, Kamal and Halis M. Yildiz, 2010. "Bilateralism, Multilateralism, and the Quest for Global Free Trade." Journal of International Economics 81, 26-37.

Saggi, Kamal, Alan Woodland and Halis M. Yildiz, 2013. "On the Relationship between Preferential and Multilateral Trade Liberalization: The Case of Customs Unions." American Economic Journal: Microeconomics, 5(1), 63-99.