Index Insurance and Cash Transfers: A Comparative Analysis from Northern Kenya

Jensen, Nathaniel and Barrett, Christopher B. and Mude, Andrew (2014): Index Insurance and Cash Transfers: A Comparative Analysis from Northern Kenya.

Abstract

Cash transfers and index insurance have become popular interventions by development agencies worldwide. But they operate in radically different ways. In principle, these could offer complementary or substitute means of improving households’ well-being, both through direct payments and through induced behavioral change. Surprisingly, little is known about these programs’ comparative impacts on participant behavior or well-being, nor about their prospective interactions. This paper exploits four years of household panel data from northern Kenya, where the government launched a Hunger Safety Net Program (HSNP) offering cash transfers just prior to the commercial launch of an index-based livestock insurance (IBLI) product. By exploiting the known selection mechanism behind HSNP participation and the randomization of IBLI extension education and premium discounts, we are able to make novel comparisons of the causal impacts of each type of program among the same population at the same time, which spans a catastrophic drought. We find that both programs benefit participants, but there is no evidence of positive synergies between the two programs. HSNP participation increases the likelihood that a household maintains mobility, an important pastoral production strategy, and improves child health, as indicated by a mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC). IBLI coverage increases expenditures on livestock health services, milk production, MUAC, and income per adult equivalent. Standardizing the estimated benefits by total program costs reveals that the two programs perform comparably, while from a marginal cost perspective the IBLI program has impacts per unit of expenditure at least an order of magnitude greater than HSNP.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: HSNP, IBLI, pastoralism, social protection, safety nets
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D60 - General; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O2 - Development Planning and Policy > O22 - Project Analysis

References

Admassu, B., Nega, S., Haile, T., Abera, B., Hussein, A., & Catley, A. (2005). Impact assessment of a community-based animal health project in Dollo Ado and Dollo Bay districts, southern Ethiopia. Tropical animal health and production, 37(1), 33-48.

Alderman, H., & Haque, T. (2007). Insurance against covariate shocks: The role of index-based insurance in social protection in low-income countries of Africa (No. 95). World Bank Publications.

Annan, R. A., Webb, P., & Brown, R. (2014). Management of Moderate Acute Malnutrition (MAM): Current Knowledge and Practice. CMAM Forum Technical Brief.

Arnold, C., Conway, T., & Greenslade, M. (2011). Cash transfers evidence paper. London: Department for International Development.

Azariadis, C., & Stachurski, J. (2005). Poverty traps. Handbook of economic growth, 1, 295-384.

Barnett, B. J., Barrett, C. B., & Skees, J. R. (2008). Poverty traps and index-based risk transfer products. World Development, 36(10), 1766-1785.

Barrett, C. B., & Carter, M. R. (2013). The Economics of Poverty Traps and Persistent Poverty: Empirical and Policy Implications. Journal of Development Studies, 49(7), 976-990.

Barrett, C. B., Chabari, F., Bailey, D., Little, P. D., & Coppock, D. L. (2003). Livestock pricing in the northern Kenyan rangelands. Journal of African Economies, 12(2), 127-155.

Barrett, C. B., Marenya, P. P., McPeak, J., Minten, B., Murithi, F., Oluoch-Kosura, W., Place, F., Randrianarisoa, J., Rasambainarivo, J. & Wangila, J. (2006). Welfare dynamics in rural Kenya and Madagascar. Journal of Development Studies, 42(2), 248-277.

Barrett, C. B., & Swallow, B. M. (2006). Fractal poverty traps. World Development, 34(1), 1-15. Baulch, B., & Quisumbing, A. (2010). Testing and adjusting for attrition in household panel data. CPRC Toolkit Note.

Bianchi, M., & Bobba, M. (2012). Liquidity, risk, and occupational choices. The Review of Economic Studies, 129 (2): 697-752.

Binswanger-Mkhize, H. P. (2012). Is there too much hype about index-based agricultural insurance? Journal of Development Studies, 48(2), 187-200.

Blattman, C., Fiala, N., & Martinez, S. (2014). Generating skilled self-employment in developing countries: Experimental evidence from Uganda. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 129(2), 697-752.

Bowles, S., Durlauf, S. N., & Hoff, K. (Eds.). (2006). Poverty traps. Princeton University Press.

Brown, L.H. (1963). The development of the Semiarid Areas of Kenya. Nairobi, Kenya: Ministry of Agriculture.

Cain, E. (2007). Addressing Chronic Poverty: Linking Social Protection, Economic Growth and EU Development Cooperation. Background briefing paper. The European Working Group on Social 21 Protection and Decent Work in Development Cooperation & The Grow Up Free from Poverty Coalition. Roundtable on Social Protection on International Poverty Day. Brussels, 17th October 2007.

Carter, M. R. (1997). Environment, technology, and the social articulation of risk in West African agriculture. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 45(3), 557-590.

Carter, M. R., & Barrett, C. B. (2006). The economics of poverty traps and persistent poverty: An asset-based approach. Journal of Development Studies, 42(2), 178-199. Carter, M. R., & Lybbert, T. J. (2012). Consumption versus asset smoothing: testing the implications of poverty trap theory in Burkina Faso. Journal of Development Economics, 99(2), 255-264.

Chantarat, S., Mude, A. G., Barrett, C. B. and Carter, M. R. (2013). Designing Index-Based Livestock Insurance for Managing Asset Risk in Northern Kenya. Journal of Risk and Insurance, 80, 205–237.

Chantarat, S., Mude, A. G., Barrett, C. B., & Turvey, C. G. (2014). Welfare Impacts of Index Insurance in the Presence of a Poverty Trap. Unpublished.

Child, R. D., Heady H. F., Hickey, W. C., Peterson, R. A., & Pieper, R. D. (Eds.). (1984). Arid and Semi-Arid Lands: Sustainable Use and Management in Developing Countries. Washington DC: National Park Service.

Conway, T., de Haan, A., & Norton, A. (2000). Social protection: new directions of donor agencies. Paper for the DFID-ODI Inter-Agency Seminar on Social Protection. Easthamstead Park.

Coppock, D. L. (Ed.). (1994). The Borana Plateau of Southern Ethiopia: Synthesis of pastoral research, development, and change, 1980-91 (No. 5). ILRI (aka ILCA and ILRAD).

Covarrubias, K., Davis, B., & Winters, P. (2012). From protection to production: productive impacts of the Malawi social cash transfer scheme. Journal of Development Effectiveness, 4(1), 50-77.

Devereux, S. (2001). Livelihood insecurity and social protection: a re‐emerging issue in rural development. Development Policy Review, 19(4), 507-519.

Fafchamps, M., Udry, C., & Czukas, K. (1998). Drought and saving in West Africa: Are livestock a buffer stock?. Journal of Development Economics, 55(2), 273-305.

Fitzgerald, J., Gottschalk, P., & Moffitt, R. (1998). An Analysis of Sample Attrition in Panel Data: The Michigan Panel Study of Income Dynamics. Journal of Human Resources, 33(2), 251-299.

Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). (2001). Pastoralism in the New Millennium. United Nations.

Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO). (1987). Improving Productivity of Dryland Areas. Rome.

Fiszbein, A., Schady, N. R., & Ferreira, F. H. (2009). Conditional cash transfers: reducing present and future poverty. World Bank Publications. G8 Summit Declaration on Freedom of Investment, Investment Environment and Social Responsibility. June 2007.

Gertler, P. J., Martinez, S. W., & Rubio-Codina, M. (2012). Investing cash transfers to raise long-term living standards. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 4(1), 164-192.

Giné, X., Townsend, R., & Vickery, J. (2008). Patterns of rainfall insurance participation in rural India. The World Bank Economic Review, 22(3), 539-566.

Heffernan, C. (2001). Consumer preferences and the uptake of animal healthcare by the poor: a case study from Kenya. Journal of International Development, 13(7), 847-861.

Holtzman, J. S., & Kulibaba, N. P. (1995). Livestock marketing in pastoral Africa: Policies to increase competitiveness, efficiency and flexibility. In Scoones, I. (Ed.). Living with uncertainty: New directions in pastoral development in Africa. IIED, London.

Homewood, K., Trench, P., Randall, S., Lynen, G., & Bishop, B. (2006). Livestock health and socio-economic impacts of a veterinary intervention in Maasailand: infection-and-treatment vaccine against East Coast fever. Agricultural Systems, 89(2), 248-271.

Hurrell, A., MacAuslan, I., & Merttens, F. (2008). Kenya Hunger Safety Net Programme: Monitoring and evaluation strategy. Oxford Policy Management.

Hurrell, A., & Sabates-Wheeler R. (2013). Kenya Hunger Safety Net Programme Monitoring and Evaluation Component: Quantitative Impact Evaluation Final Report: 2009 to 2012. Oxford Policy Management.

Ikegami, M., Barrett, C. & Chantarat, S. (2012). Dynamic effects of index based livestock insurance on household intertemporal behavior and welfare. Unpublished.

International Livestock Research Institute (IRLI). (2012). Index Based Livestock Insurance for northeastern Kenya’s arid and semi-arid lands: The Marsabit Pilot Project-Codebook for IBLI evaluation baseline survey. Nairobi, Kenya: ILRI.

Janzen, S. A., & Carter, M. R. (2013). After the Drought: The Impact of Microinsurance on Consumption Smoothing and Asset Protection (No. w19702). National Bureau of Economic Research.

Jensen, N., Barrett, C., & Mude, A. (2014). Basis Risk and the Welfare Gains from Index Insurance: Evidence from Northern Kenya. Unpublished.

Jensen N., Mude, A., & Barrett, C. (2014) How Basis Risk and Spatiotemporal Adverse Selection Influence Demand for Index Insurance: Evidence from Northern Kenya. Unpublished.

Jensen N., Sheahana, M., Barrett, C., & Mude, A. (2014) Hunger Safety Net Program (HSNP) and Index Based Livestock Insurance (IBLI) baseline comparison. Unpublished.

Karlan, D., Osei, R. D., Osei-Akoto, I., & Udry, C. (2014). Agricultural decisions after relaxing credit and risk constraints. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 129 (2): 597-652.

Leblois, A., & Quirion, P. (2010). Agricultural Insurances Based on Meteorological Indices: Realizations, Methods and Research Agenda. Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei Working Papers. Paper 460. http://services.bepress.com/feem/paper460

Little, P. D., McPeak, J., Barrett, C. B., & Kristjanson, P. (2008). Challenging orthodoxies: understanding poverty in pastoral areas of East Africa. Development and Change, 39(4), 587-611.

Lybbert, T. J., Barrett, C. B., Desta, S., & Coppock, D. (2004). Stochastic wealth dynamics and risk management among a poor population. Economic Journal, 114(498), 750-777.

Mahul, O., & Stutley, C. J. (2010). Government support to agricultural insurance: Challenges and Options for Developing Countries. World Bank Publications.

McPeak, J. (2005). Individual and collective rationality in pastoral production: Evidence from Northern Kenya. Human Ecology, 33(2), 171-197.

McPeak, J. (2004). Contrasting income shocks with asset shocks: livestock sales in northern Kenya. Oxford Economic Papers, 56(2), 263-284.

McPeak, J., Little, P., & Doss, C. (2011). Risk and Social Change in African Rural Economics. New York: Rutledge.

Mobarak, A., & Rosenzweig, M. (2012). Selling formal insurance to the informally insured. Yale University Economic Growth Center Discussion Paper, (1007).

Morduch, J. (1995). Income smoothing and consumption smoothing. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 103-114.

Niamir-Fuller, M. (1999). Managing mobility in African rangelands. London: Food and Agricultural Organization and the Beijer International Institute of Ecological Economics.

Niamir-Fuller, M. (2005). Managing mobility in African rangelands. Collective Action and Property Rights for Sustainable Rangeland Management. CAPRi research brief. CAPRi.

Rosenzweig, M., and Binswanger, H. (1993) Wealth, Weather Risk and the Composition and Profitability of Agricultural Investments. Economic Journal, 103(416), 56-78.

Sahn, D. E., & Stifel, D. C. (2000). Poverty comparisons over time and across countries in Africa. World Development, 28(12), 2123-2155.

Scoones, Ian, ed. (1994). Living with Uncertainty: New Directions in Pastoral Development in Africa. London, UK: Intermediate Technology Publications.

Sieff, D. F. (1999). The effects of wealth on livestock dynamics among the Datoga pastoralists of Tanzania. Agricultural Systems, 59(1), 1-25.

Stoeffler, Q., & Mills, B. (2014). Households’ investments in durable and productive assets in Niger: quasi-experimental evidences from a cash transfer project. Paper presented at AAEA Annual Meetings, July 27-29, 2014, Minneapolis, MN.

Toth, R. (2015). Traps and thresholds in pastoralist mobility. American Journal of Agricultural Economics. Am. J. Agr. Econ. 97 (1): 315-332 United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (2009). Guidelines for Selective Feeding: The Management of Malnutrition in Emergencies. UNHCR: Geneva, Switzerland. Available at: http://www.unhcr.org/4b7421fd20.pdf (Accessed October 2012).

World Health Organization. (2011). Public health risk assessment and interventions - The horn of Africa: Drought and famine crisis. Available at: http://www.who.int/diseasecontrol_emergencies/ publications/who_hse_gar_dce_2011_3.pdf?ua=1 (Accessed October 2012).

Wooldridge, J. (2002). Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.