Fat tax, subsidy or both? The role of information and children’s pester power in food choice

Papoutsi, Georgia and Nayga, Rodolfo and Lazaridis, Panagiotis and Drichoutis, Andreas (2013): Fat tax, subsidy or both? The role of information and children’s pester power in food choice.

Abstract

Using a discrete choice experiment with real economic incentives, this paper studies how food fiscal policies and external influences (such as pestering and information) can affect parental choice of food for their child. Using pairs of a parent and child, the experimental design varies the food prices of healthier and unhealthier alternatives of food products for children as part of specific food fiscal policies. We then examine the interplay of children’s pester power as well as information about the fiscal policies. The results from our lab experiment suggest that (a) implementing a fat tax and a subsidy simultaneously can shift parental behavior to healthier food products to a greater degree than a fat tax or a subsidy alone, (b) providing information regarding the food fiscal policies can further increase the impact of the intervention, and (c) child pestering is one of the causes of the moderate effectiveness of the policies as it strongly affects parents in making unhealthier choices.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Choice experiment; Fat tax; Subsidy; Information; Pestering power
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments; D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D12 - Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I10 - General

References

Alfnes, F., Guttormsen, A.G., Steine, G., Kolstad, K., 2006. Consumers' Willingness To Pay For The Color Of Salmon:A Choice Experiment With Real Economic Incentives. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 88(4), 1050-1061.

Andreyeva, T., Long, M.W., Brownell, K.D., 2010. The Impact of Food Prices on Consumption: A Systematic Review of Research on the Price Elasticity of Demand for Food. Am J Public Health 100(2), 216-222.

Ashraf, N., Jack, B.K., Kamenica, E., 2013. Information and subsidies: Complements or substitutes? Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 88(C), 133-139.

Barlow, S.E., Dietz, W.H., 1998. Obesity Evaluation and Treatment: Expert Committee Recommendations. Pediatrics 102(3), e29.

Beaudoin, C.E., Fernandez, C., Wall, J.L., Farley, T.A., 2007. Promoting Healthy Eating and Physical Activity: Short-Term Effects of a Mass Media Campaign. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 32(3), 217-223.

Birch, L., 1988. Development of food acceptance patterns in the first years of life. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 57(4), 617-624.

Burros, M., 2005, Federal Advisory Group Calls for Change in Food Marketing to Children. The New York Times, pp. C4.

Campbell, S., James, E.L., Stacey, F.G., Bowman, J., Chapman, K., Kelly, B., 2014. A mixed-method examination of food marketing directed towards children in Australian supermarkets. Health Promotion International 29(2), 267-277.

Carey, L., Shaw, D., Shiu, E., 2008. The impact of ethical concerns on family consumer decision-making. International Journal of Consumer Studies 32(5), 553–560.

Cawley, J., 2006. Markets and Childhood Obesity Policy. The Future of Children 16(1), 69-88. CDC, 2009. How is childhood overweight and obesity measured?

Cole, T., Bellizzi , M., Flegal, K., Dietz, W., 2000. Establishing a standard definition for child overweight and obesity worldwide: international survey. BMJ 320(7244), 1240-1243.

Cole, T.J., Flegal, K.M., Nicholls, D., Jackson, A.A., 2007. Body mass index cut offs to define thinness in children and adolescents: international survey. British Medical Journal 335(7612), 194-197.

Cook, D.T., 2003. Spatial biographies of children’s consumption. Journal of Consumer Culture 3(2), 147–169.

Cross-Government Obesity Unit, 2008. Healthy weight, healthy lives: a cross government strategy for England, Department of Health and Department of Children Schools and Families.

Dong, D., Lin, B.-H., 2009. Fruit and vegetable consumption by low-income americans: Would a price reduction make a difference? Economic Research Report 70, U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, Washington, D.C.

Epstein, L., Dearing, K., Handley, E., Roemmich, J., Paluch, R., 2006. Relationship of mother and child food purchases as a function of price: a pilot study. Appetite 47(1), 115-118.

Epstein, L., Dearing, K., Paluch, R., Roemmich, J., Cho, D., 2007. Price and maternal obesity influence purchasing of low- and high-energy-dense foods. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 86(4), 914-922.

Epstein, L., Jankowiak, N., Nederkoorn, C., Raynor, H., French, S., Finkelstein, E., 2012. Experimental research on the relation between food price changes and food-purchasing patterns: a targeted review. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 95(4), 789-809.

Epstein, L.H., Dearing, K.K., Roba, L.G., Finkelstein, E.A., 2010. The influence of taxes and subsidies on energy purchased in an experimental purchasing study. Psychological Science 21(3), 406-414.

Fischbacher, U., 2007. z-tree: Zurich toolbox for ready-made economic experiments. Experimental Economics 10(2), 171-178.

Fletcher, J.M., Frisvold, D.E., Tefft, N., 2010. The effects of soft drink taxes on child and adolescent consumption and weight outcomes. Journal of Public Economics 94(11-12), 967-974.

French, S., A, Jeffery, R., W, Story, M., Breitlow, K., K, Baxter, J., S, Hannan, P., Snyder, M., P, 2001. Pricing and promotion effects on low-fat vending snack purchases: the CHIPS Study. American Journal of Public Health 91(1), 112-117.

French, S.A., 2003. Pricing Effects on Food Choices. Journal of Nutrition 133(3), 841S-843S.

French, S.A., Lin, B.-H., Guthrie, J.F., 2003. National trends in soft drink consumption among children and adolescents age 6 to 17 years: Prevalence, amounts, and sources, 1977/1978 to 1994/1998. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 103(10), 1326-1331.

Goldman, D.P., Lakdawalla, D., Zheng, Y., 2011. Food Prices and the Dynamics of Body Weight. In: M. Grossman, N.H. Mocan (Eds.). Economic Aspects of Obesity. University of Chicago Press, 65 - 90.

Gunter, B., Furnham, A., 1999. Children as Consumers: A Psychological Analysis of the Young People’s Market. Routledge, London.

Hannan, P., French, S., Story, M., Fulkerson, J., 2002. A pricing strategy to promote sales of lower fat foods in high school cafeterias: acceptability and sensitivity analysis. American Journal of Health Promotion 17(1), 1-6.

Hensher, D.A., Greene, W.H., 2003. The Mixed Logit model: The state of practice. Transportation 30(2), 133-176

Hensher, D.A., Rose, J.M., Greene, W.H., 2005. Applied Choice Analysis: A Primer. Cambridge: Cambridge University

Hilton, D., Charalambides, L., Demarque, C., Waroquier, L., Raux, C., 2014. A tax can nudge: The impact of an environmentally motivated bonus/malus fiscal system on transport preferences. JOurnal of Economic Phychology 42(C), 19-29.

Johnson, J.P., Myatt, D.P., 2006. On the Simple Economics of Advertising, Marketing, and Product Design. The American Economic Review 96(3), 756-784.

Kapferer, J.-N., 1985. Réfléchissez au nom de votre societé. Harvard L`Expansion nº38, 104-118.

Kelder, S.H., Perry, C.L., Klepp, K.I., Lytle, L.L., 1994. Longitudinal tracking of adolescent smoking, physical activity, and food choice behaviors. American Journal of Public Health 84(7), 1121-1126.

Lewis, G., 2011. Asymmetric Information, Adverse Selection and Online Disclosure: The Case of eBay Motors The American Economic Review 101(4), 1535-1546.

Lien, N., Lytle, L., Klepp, K., 2001. Stability in Consumption of Fruit, Vegetables and Sugary Foods in a Cohort from Age 14 to Age 21. Preventive Medicine 33(3), 217-226.

Louviere, J., Street, D., 2000. Stated-preference methods. In: D. Hensher, K. Button (Eds.). Handbook of Transport Modelling. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 132-143.

Maes, L., Cauwenberghe, E.V., Lippevelde, W.V., Spittaels, H., Pauw, E.D., Oppert, J.-M., Lenthe, F.J.V., Brug, J., Bourdeaudhuij, I.D., 2012. Effectiveness of workplace interventions in Europe promoting healthy eating: a systematic review. European Journal of Public Health 22(5), 677-683

McFadden, D., Train, K., 2000. Mixed MNL models for discrete response. Journal of Applied Econometrics 15(5), 447–470.

McNeal, J.U., Mindy, J.F., 2003. Children’s visual memory of packaging. Journal of Consumer Marketing 20(5), 400–427.

Mytton, O.T., Clarke, D., Rayner, M., 2012. Taxing unhealthy food and drinks to improve health. British Medical Journal 344:e2931.

Nederkoorn, C., Havermans, R., Giesen, J., Jansen, A., 2011. High tax on high energy dense foods and its effects on the purchase of calories in a supermarket. An experiment. Appetite 56(3), 760-765.

New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, 2008. Board of health votes to require chain restaurants to display calorie information in New York City. Available at: www.nyc.gov/html/doh/html/pr2008/pr008-08.shtml, Accessed November 7, 2013.

Nicholls, A.J., Cullen, P., 2004. The child-parent purchase relationship:'pester power', human rights and retail ethics. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services 11(2), 75-86.

OECD, 2012. http://www.oecd.org/health/49716427.pdf

Powell, L.M., Chaloupka, F., 2009. Food prices and obesity: evidence and policy implications for taxes and subsidies. Milbank Quarterly 87(1), 229–257.

Rao, M., Afshin, A., Singh, G., Mozaffarian, D., 2013. Do healthier foods and diet patterns cost more than less healthy options? A systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ Open. 3(12), e004277.

Reger, B., Wootan, M., Booth-Butterfield, S., 1999. Using mass media to promote healthy eating: a community-based demonstration project. Preventive Medicine 29(5), 414–421.

Resnicow, K., Smith, M., Baranowski, T., Baranowski, J., Vaughan, R., Davis, M., 1988. 2-year tracking of children's fruit and vegetable intake. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 98(7), 785-789.

Richard, J.-F., 1990. La notion de représentation et les formes de représentations. In: C. Bonnet, R. Ghiglione, J-F. Richard (Eds.). Traité de Psychologie Cognitive: Le traitement de l’information symbolique, Paris: Dunod.

Rossiter, J.R., 1976. Visual and verbal memory in children's product information utilization. In: B.B. Anderson (Ed.). Advances in Consumer Research: Volume 4, Cincinnati, Ohio: Association for Consumer Research, 523-527

Singer, M.R., Moore, L.L., Garrahie, E.J., Ellison, R.C., 1995. The tracking of nutrient intake in young children: the Framingham Children's Study. American Journal of Public Health 85(12), 1673-1677.

Spungin, P., 2004. Parent power, not pester power. Young Consumers 5(3), 37-40.

Tadelis, S., Zettelmeyer, F., 2011. Information Disclosure as a Matching Mechanism: Theory and Evidence from a Field Experiment. Working papers SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1872465.

The European Food Information Council (EUFIC), 2005. The Determinants of Food Choice. EUFIC Review 04/2005, EUFIC.

Thow, A., Jan, S., Leeder, S., Swinburn, B., 2010. The effect of fiscal policy on diet, obesity and chronic disease: a systematic review. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 88(8), 609-614.

Train, K., 2003. Discrete Choice Methods with Simulation Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Waterlander, W., Steenhuis, I., De Boer, M., Schuit, A., Seidel, K.D., 2012. Introducing taxes, subsidies or both: The effects of various food pricing strategies in a web-based supermarket randomized trial. Preventive Medicine 54(5), 323–330.

WHO, 1995. Physical Status: The use and interpretation of anthropometry. Technical Report Series No. 854, Geneva.