Looking at the determinants of efficiency in banking: evidence from Italian mutual-cooperatives

Francesco, Aiello and Graziella, Bonanno (2015): Looking at the determinants of efficiency in banking: evidence from Italian mutual-cooperatives.

Abstract

Italy has experienced a restructuring and consolidation process in the banking industry since the 1990s’ that is expected to foster efficiency and competition. Despite the reforms, a peculiarity of the industry is the persistence of small mutual-cooperative banks (BCCs) active in narrowed markets. The scope of this paper is to evaluate the level and the dynamics of BCC efficiency compared with other bank-types and to analyze its main determinants over the period 2006-2011. Efficiency is firstly estimated with stochastic frontiers and then used as dependent variable in fixed and random effects models that have been run to regress BCC efficiency against individual and environmental factors. The latter are meant to gauge the structure of the provincial banking market, that is to say the reference market of BCCs. Results show that BCCs perform better than other banks, even though efficiency has decreased over time, owing to the effect of the current crisis. Furthermore, BCC efficiency increases with market concentration and demand density and decreases as bank branches increase in local markets. This holds whatever the frontier (cost or profit). Finally, local development negatively affects (only) cost efficiency, while BCCs gain in generating profits when systemic credit risk increases.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Mutual-cooperative banks; local markets; stochastic frontiers; efficiency determinants
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General > C13 - Estimation: General; D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D21 - Firm Behavior: Theory; D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D22 - Firm Behavior: Empirical Analysis; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G21 - Banks ; Depository Institutions ; Micro Finance Institutions ; Mortgages; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O16 - Financial Markets ; Saving and Capital Investment ; Corporate Finance and Governance; P - Economic Systems > P1 - Capitalist Systems > P13 - Cooperative Enterprises

References

Acharya V.V., Viswanathan S. (2011) “Leverage, Moral Hazard, and Liquidity”, Journal of Finance, 46, 99-138

Aigner D., Lovell C.A.K., Schmidt P. (1977) “Formulation and Estimation of Stochastic Frontier Production Function Models”, Journal of Econometrics, 6, 21-37

Alessandrini P., Presbitero A.F., Zazzaro A. (2009) “Banks, Distances and Firms’ Financing Constraints”, Review of Finance, 13, 2, 261-307

Andries A.M. (2011) “The Determinants of Bank Efficiency and Productivity Growthin the Central and Eastern European Banking Systems”, Eastern European Economics, 49, 6, 38-59

Ayadi R., Arbak E., Schmidt R.H., Carbò Valverde S., Fernandez F.R. (2009), “Investigating Diversity in the Banking Sector in Europe: the Performance and Role of Saving Banks”, Center for European Policy, Brussels

Baele L., De Jonghe O., Vennet R.V. (2007) “Does the Stock Market Value Bank Diversification?”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 31, 7, 1999-2023

Barra C., Destefanis S., Lubrano Lavadera G. (2014), The Crisis and the Efficiency of Italian Cooperative Banks, Paper Presented at the 55th Annual Meeting of the Italian Economic Society, 23-25 October 2014, Trento (Italy)

Battaglia F., Farina V., Fiordelisi F., Ricci O. (2010) “The Efficiency of Cooperative Banks: the Impact of Environmental Economic Conditions”, Applied Financial Economics, 20, 17, 1363-1376

Battese G.E., Coelli T.J. (1992) “Frontier Production Functions and the Efficiencies of Indian Farms using Panel Data from ICRISAT’s Village Level Studies”, Journal of Quantitative Economics, 5, 327–348

Battese G.E., Coelli T.J. (1995) “A Model for Technical Inefficiency Effects in a Stochastic Frontier Production Function for Panel Data”, Empirical Economics, 20, 2, 325-332

Berger A.N. (1995) “The Profit-Structure Relationship in Banking-Tests of Market-Power and Efficient-Structure Hypotheses”, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 27, 2, 404-431

Berger A.N., Humphrey D.B. (1997) “Efficiency of Financial Institutions: International Survey and Directions for Future Research”, European Journal of Operation Research, 98, 175-212

Berger A.N., Mester L.J. (1997) “Inside the Black Box: What Explains Differences in the Efficiencies of Financial Institutions?”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 21, 7, 895-947

Berger A.N., Miller N.H., Petersen M.A., Rajan R.G., Stein J.C. (2005) “Does Function Follow Organizational Form? Evidence from the Lending Practices of Large and Small Banks”, Journal of Financial Economics, 76, 2, 237-269

Bonin J.P., Hasan I., Wachtel P. (2005) “Privatization Matters: Bank Efficiency in Transition Countries”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 29, 8-9, 2155-2178

Bos J.W.B., Kool C.J.M. (2006) “Bank Efficiency: the Role of Bank Strategy and Local Market Conditions”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 30, 1953-74

Carbò Valverde S., Humphrey D.B., Rodriguez F.R. (2003) “Deregulation, Bank Competition and Regional Growth”, Regional Studies, 37, 3, 227-237

Carnevali F. (2005) Europe’s Advantage Banks and Small Firms in Britain, France, Germanyu and Italy since 1918, Oxford University Press, Oxford

Casu B., Molyneux P. (2003) “A Comparative Study of Efficiency in European Banking”, Applied Economics, 35, 17, 1865-1876

Coccorese P., (2009) “Market Power in Local Banking Monopoliesi”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 33, 1196-2120

Delis M., Papanikolaou N. (2009) “Determinants of Bank Efficiency: Evidence from a Semi-parametric Methodology”, MPRA, Working Paper N. 13893

Demirgüç-Kunt A., Levine R. (2001) Bank-based and Market-based Financial Systems: Cross-Country Comparisons. In Demirgüç-Kunt A., Levine R. (Eds.): Financial Structure and Economic Growth: A Cross-Country Comparison of Banks, Markets, and Development. MIT Press, Cambridge

Dietsch M., Lozano-Vivas A. (2000) “How the Environment Determines Banking Efficiency: a Comparison between French and Spanish Industries”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 24, 985-1004

Dongili P., Rossi S.P.S., Zago A. (2008) Efficienza e competitività delle banche italiane: un confronto con alcuni sistemi bancari europei. In Cella G., Zago A. (Eds.): Competitività ed efficienza dell’economia italiana: fattori sistemici e valutazioni quantitative. Il Mulino: Bologna

Drake L. (2001) “Efficiency and Productivity Change in UK Banking”, Applied Financial Economics, 11, 5, 557-571

Fethi M.D., Pasourias F. (2010) “Assessing Bank Efficiency and Performance with Operational Research and Artificial Intelligence Techniques: a Survey”, European Journal of Operational Research, 204, 189-198

Fiordelisi F., Mare D.S. (2013) “Probability of Default and Efficiency in Cooperative Banking”, Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money, 26, 30-45

Fitzpatrick P., McQuinn K. (2005) Measuring Bank Profit Efficiency, Economic Analysis and Research Department, Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland, Research Technical Paper N. 3

Fontani A., Vitali L. (2007) “L’efficienza di costo dei gruppi bancari italiani: un’analisi mediante frontiera stocastica”, Department of Economics and Business, Luiss, Rome

Fries S., Taci A., (2005) “Cost Efficiency of Banks in Transition: Evidence from 289 Banks in 15 Post-Communist Countries”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 29, 1, 55-81

Giannola A., Lopes A., Ricci C., Scarfiglieri G. (1997) Divari territoriali ed efficienza del sistema bancario italiano. In Quintieri B. (Ed.): Finanza, istituzioni e sviluppo regionale. Il Mulino: Bologna

Giannola, A. (2009) Bank Mergers and Credit Allocation Among Italian Regions. In Silipo D.B. (Ed.): The Banks and the Italian Economy. Springer Phisyca-Verlag: Berlin Heidelberg

Giannola A., Scarfiglieri G. (1998) “Cost vs Profit Efficiency, Nontraditional Activities and Financial Capital: an European Perspective”, Paper presented at the 5th Financial Conference at Università di Tor Vergata, Rome

Gillen D., Lall A. (1997) “Developing Measures of Airport Productivity and Performance: an Application od Data Envelopment Analysis”, Transportation Research, 33, 4, 261-273

Giordano L., Lopes A. (2006) Preferenza al rischio e qualità degli impieghi come determinanti dell'efficienza del sistema bancario italiano. In Giannola A. (Ed.): Riforme istituzionali e mutamento strutturale. Mercati, imprese e istituzioni in un sistema dualistico. Carocci, Rome

Giordano L., Lopes A. (2008) “L’efficienza del sistema bancario italiano in un contesto dualistico e la rilevanza della dimensione e degli aspetti giuridici”, Il Risparmio, N. 2

Giordano L., Lopes A. (2012) Le banche italiane tra consolidamento e recuperi di efficienza (1998-2008). Una promessa mantenuta?, in Giannola A., Lopes A., Sarno D. (Eds.) I problemi dello sviluppo economico e del suo finanziamento nelle aree deboli, Carocci, Rome

Girardone C., Molyneux P., Gardener E.P.M. (2004) “Analysing the Determinants of Bank Efficiency: the Case of Italian Banks”, Applied Economics, 36, 3, 215-227

Goldberg L.G., Rai A. (1996) “The Structure-Performance relationship for European Banking”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 20, 4, 745–771

Greene W.H. (1993), The Econometric Approach to Efficiency Analysis, in The Measurement of Productivity Efficiency: Techniques and Applications, Oxford University Press: New York, 92-250

Gutiérrez E., (2008) “The Reform of Italian Cooperative Banks,: Discussion and Proposals”, IMF WP/08/74, IMF Washington

Hannan T.H., Prager R.A. (2009) “The Profitability of Small Single-Market Banks in an era of Multi-Market Banking”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 33, 2, 263-271

Hauner D. (2005) “Explaining Efficiency Differences among Large German and Austrian Banks”, Applied Economics, 37, 9, 969-980

Hausman J.A., Taylor W.E. (1981) “Panel Data and Unobservable Individual Effect”, Econometrica, 49, 6, 1377-1398

Huang M.Y., Fu T.T. (2013) “An Examination of the Cost Efficiency of Banks in Taiwan and China using the Metafrontier Cost Function”, Journal of Productivity Analysis, 40, 3, 387-406

Hughes, J.P. Mester, I.J., (2008) “Efficiency in Banking: theory, practice and evidence”, WP 08/01, Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelfia, Philadelfia, USA

Huizinga, H.P., Nelissen, J.H.M., Vander Vennet, R. (2001) “Efficiency Effects of Bank Mergers and Acquisitions in Europe”, Tinbergen Institute, Working Paper N. 088/3

Iannotta, G., Nocera G., Sironi A. (2007) “Ownership Structure, Risk and Performance in the European Banking Industry, Journal of Banking and Finance, 31, 7, 248-263

Jimborean R., Brack E. (2010) “The Cost-Efficiency of French Banks”, MPRA, Working Paper N.23471

Kasman A., Tunc G., Vardar G., Okan B. (2010) “Consolidation and Commercial Bank Net Interest Margins: Evidence from the Old European Union Members and Candidate Countries”, Economic Modeling, 27, 648-655

Kodde D., Palm F. (1986) “Wald Criteria for Jointly Testing Equality and Inequality Restrictions”, Econometrica, 54, 5, 1243-1248

Kumbhakar S.C., Lovell C.A.K. (2000) Stochastic Frontier Analysis, Cambridge University Press

Lensink R., Meesters A. (2014) “Institutions and Bank Performance: a Stochastic Frontier Analysis”, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 76, 1, 67-92

Maddala G.S. (1991) “A Perspective on the Use of Limited-Dependent and Qualitative Variables Models in Accounting Research”, Accounting Review, 66, 788-807

Maudos J., Pastor J.M., Perez F., Quesada J. (2002) “Cost and Profit Efficiency in European Banks”, Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money, 12, 1, 33-58

McDonald J. (2009) “Using Least Squares and Tobit in Second Stage DEA Efficiency Analyses”, European Journal of Operational Research, 197, 792-798

Meeusen D., van de Broek J. (1997) “Efficiency Estimation from Cobb-Douglas Production Functions with Composed Error”, International Economic Review, 18, 2, 435-444

Messori M., Tamburini R., Zazzaro A. (2003) Il sistema bancario italiano, Carocci Editore: Rome

Pilloff S.J. (1996) “Performance Changes and Shareholder Wealth Creation: Associated with Mergers of Publicly Traded Banking Institutions, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 28, 3, 59-78

Sealey C..W., Lindley J.T. (1977) “Input, Output and a Theory of Production and Cost at Depository Financial Institutions”, The Journal of Finance, 32, 4, 1251-1266

Shao B.B.M, Lin W.T. (2001) “Measuring the Value of Information Technology in Technical Efficiency with Stochastic Production Frontier”, Information and Software Technology, 43, 447-456

Silipo D.B. (2009) “The Banks and the Italian Economy”. Springer Phisyca-Verlag: Berlin Heidelberg

Simar L., Wilson P.W. (2000) “A General Methodology for Bootstrapping in Nonparametric Frontier Models”, Journal of Applied Statistics, 27, 779-802

Turati G., (2004) “Are Cooperative Banks and Stock Banks Different Cosntrast” Empirical Evidence Using a Cost Function Approach”, Mimeo, University of Turin, Turin.

Turati G. (2008) La valutazione del grado di concorrenza nell’industria bancaria negli anni Novanta. In Cella G., Zago A. (Eds.): Competitività ed efficienza dell’economia italiana: fattori sistemici e valutazioni quantitative, Il Mulino: Bologna

Vallascas F., Keasey K. (2012) “Bank Resilience to Systemic Shocks and the Stability of Banking Systems: Small is Beautiful”, Journal of International Money and Finance, 31, 1745-1776

Vander Vennet, R. (2002) “Cost and Profit Efficiency of Financial Conglomerates and Universal Banking in Europe”, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 34, 254-282

Wagner W. (2010) “Diversification at Financial Institutions and Systemic Crises”, Journal of Financial Intermediation, 19, 373-386

Wang H.J., Schimdt P. (2002) “One-Step and Two-Step Estimation of the Effect of Exogenous Variables on Technical Efficiency Levels”, Journal of Productivity Analysis, 18, 129-144