New Accounting Rules for Loan Loss Provisions in Europe: Much Ado about Nothing?

Onali, Enrico and Ginesti, Gianluca (2015): New Accounting Rules for Loan Loss Provisions in Europe: Much Ado about Nothing?

Abstract

While there is a vigorous academic and policy debate about the implications of the Incurred Loss Model (ILM) for financial stability, there is no empirical evidence on whether the new Expected Loss Model (ELM) introduced by IASB benefits international investors. We address this relevant issue by investigating the price reaction to announcements related to the impairment rules incorporated in IFRS 9 on a sample of 137 European listed banks for the period from November 2009 to July 2014. We provide evidence that the abnormal returns related to these events are substantially uncorrelated with proxies of timely loss recognition, earnings management, and capital management, suggesting that the new ELM is not perceived to bring about substantial benefits as compared to the ILM. These results are robust to confounding events, international media coverage, and winsorizing techniques. Bootstrap analysis supports the hypothesis that significant results for some of the events and some of the proxies may be due to over-sized tests for the sample period under examination. Our findings shed light on a recent claim in the literature that the quality of financial statements bears at best second-order effects on firm value.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Commentary on: Eprints 0 not found.
• Language: English
• Keywords: earnings management; IFRS 9; impairment; loan loss provisions; stock market reaction
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M41 - Accounting

References

Ahmed, A.S., Takeda, C., Thomas, S., 1999. Bank loan loss provisions: a re-examination of capital management, earnings management and signaling effects. Journal of Accounting and Economics 28, 1-26.

Armstrong, C., Barth, M., Jaqolinzer, A., Riedl, E., 2010. Market Reaction to the Adoption of IFRS in Europe. The Accounting Review 85 (1), 31-62.

Bae, K.-E., Lim, C., Wei, K. C. J., 2006. Corporate Governance and Conditional Skewness in the World’s Stock Markets. Journal of Business 79 (6), 2999-3028.

Barth, M. E., Landsman, W. R., 2010. How did financial reporting contribute to the financial crisis? European Accounting Review 19 (3), 399-423.

Basel Committee on Banking Supervisor, 2009. Guiding principles for the replacement of IAS 39, press release.

Beatty, A., Ke, B., Petroni, K. R., 2002. Earnings management to avoid earnings declines across publicly and privately held banks. The Accounting Review 77, 547-570.

Beatty, A., Liao S., 2011. Do delays in expected loss recognition affect banks' willingness to lend? Journal of Accounting and Economics 52, 1-20.

Bornemann, S., Kick, T., Memmel, C., Pfingsten, A., 2012. Are banks using hidden reserves to beat earnings benchmarks? Evidence from Germany. Journal of Banking & Finance 36 (8), 2403-2415.

Bouvatier, V., Lepetit, L., 2008. Banks' procyclical behavior: Does provisioning matter? Journal of International Financial Markets, Institution and Money 18, 513-526.

Brown, S., Warner, J., 1980. Measuring Security Price Performance. Journal of Financial Economics 8, 205-58.

Bushman, M.R., Williams, C.D., 2012. Accounting discretion, loan loss provisioning, and discipline of banks' risk-taking. Journal of Accounting and Economics 5 (1), 1-18.

Carhart, M.M., 1997. On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance. Journal of Finance 52, 57-82.

Chen, C., Young, D., Zhuang, Z., 2013. Externalities of Mandatory IFRS Adoption: Evidence from Cross-Border Spillover Effects of Financial Information on Investment Efficiency. The Accounting Review 88 (3), 881-894.

Cohen, L.J., Millon Cornett, M., Marcus, A.J., Tehranian, H., 2014. Bank Earnings Management and Tail Risk during the Financial Crisis. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 46 (1), 171-197.

Dechow, P.M., W. Ge, Schrand, K.M., 2010. Understanding Earnings Quality: A Review of the Proxies, Their Determinants and Their Consequences. Journal of Accounting and Economics 50, 344-401.

Dichev, I., Graham, J., Harvey, C., Rajgopal, S., 2014. Earnings quality: Evidence from the field. Journal of Accounting and Economics 56, 1-33.

Fama, E.F., French, K., 1993. Common risk factors in the returns of stocks and bonds. Journal of Financial Economics 33, 3-56.

Fiechter, P., 2011. Reclassification of financial assets under IAS 39: Impact on European banks’ financial statements. Accounting in Europe 8 (1), 49-67.

Filip, A., Raffournier, B., 2014. Financial Crisis And Earnings Management: The European Evidence, The International Journal of Accounting 49, 455-478

Financial Stability Forum, 2009. Report of the Financial Stability Forum on addressing procyclicality in the financial system, 2 April.

Financial Crisis Advisory Group, 2009. Report of the Financial Crisis Advisory Group, July 28.

Fuller, K., Netter, J., Stegemoller, M., 2002, What Do Returns to Acquiring Firms Tell Us? Evidence From Firms That Make Many Acquisitions. Journal of Finance 57, 1763-93.

Gebhardt, G., Novotny-Farkas, Z., 2011. Mandatory IFRS adoption and accounting quality of European banks. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 38 (3/4), 289-333.

Gropp, R., Heider, F. 2010. The determinants of bank capital structure. Review of Finance 14 (4), 587-622.

Joos, P.P.M., Leung, E., 2013. Investor Perceptions of Potential IFRS Adoption in the United States. The Accounting Review 88 (2), 577-609.

IASB, 2014. IASB completes reform of financial instruments accounting, press release.

IASB, 2014. IFRS 9: A Complete Package for Investors, press release.

Kanagaretnama, K., Lobob G.J., Yang D.H., 2005. Determinants of signaling by banks through loan loss provisions. Journal of Business Research 58, 312-320.

Kaplanski, G., Levy, H., 2010. Sentiment and stock prices: The case of aviation disasters. Journal of Financial Economics 95, 174-201.

Laeven, L., Majnoni, G., 2003. Loan loss provisioning and economic slowdowns: Too much, too late? Journal of Financial Intermediation 12, 178-197.

Laux, C., Leuz, C., 2010. Did fair-value accounting contribute to the financial crisis? Journal of Economic Perspectives 24 (1), 93-118. Laux, C., 2012. Financial Instruments, Financial Reporting, and Financial Stability. Accounting and Business Research 42 (3), 1-22.

Leuz, C. Nanda, D., Wysocki, P.D., 2003. Earnings management and investor protection: an international comparison. Journal of Financial Economics 69, 505-527.

MacKinlay, A.C., 1997. Event Studies in Economics and Finance. Journal of Economic Literature 35, 13-39.

Norden, L., Stoian, A., 2014. Bank Earnings Management Through Loan Loss Provisions: A Double-Edged Sword? De Nederlandsche Bank Working Paper No. 404.

O'Hanlon, J., 2013. Did loan-loss provisioning by UK banks become less timely after implementation of IAS 39 ? Accounting and Business Research 43 (1), 1-34.

Onali, E., 2014. Moral hazard, dividends, and risk in banks. Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 41 (1-2), 128-155.

Onali, E., Ginesti, G., 2014. Pre-adoption market reaction to IFRS 9: A cross-country event-study. Journal of Accounting of Public Policy 33 (6), 628-637.

Paananen, M., Renders, A., Shima Kim, M., 2012. The amendment of IAS 39 Determinants of reclassification behaviour and capital market consequences. Journal of Accounting, Auditing Finance 27 (2), 208-235.

Petersen, M. 2009. Estimating standard errors in finance panel data sets: Comparing approaches. Review of Financial Studies, 22 (1), 435-480.

Prather-Kinsey, J.J., Tanyi, P.T., 2014. The Market Reaction to SEC IFRS-Related Announcements: The Case of American Depository Receipt (ADR) Firms in the U.S. Accounting Horizons, Vol. 28 (3), 579-603.

Vyas, D., 2011. The Timeliness of Accounting Write-Downs by U.S. Financial Institutions During the Financial Crisis of 2007–2008. Journal of Accounting Research 49 (3), 823-860.

Zimmerman, J.L., 2013. Myth: External Financial Reporting Quality Has a First-Order Effect on Firm Value. Accounting Horizons 27, 887-894.