Joseph Schumpeter and Gabriel Tarde on Technological Change and Social Evolution

Michaelides, Panayotis G. and Theologou, Kostas (2009): Joseph Schumpeter and Gabriel Tarde on Technological Change and Social Evolution.

Abstract

In this paper, we show that the certain elaborations of the French sociologist Gariel Tarde may be traced throughout Schumpeter’s works. More specifically, we show that Joseph Schumpeter’s views were influenced by the French social philosopher and theoretician Gabriel Tarde who delivered a theory of Social Evolution based on Technological Change as its driving force, closely related to the profiteering function of the economy. Also, we demonstrate that Tarde’s approach has striking similarities with the Schumpeterian vision of Economic Development, Change and Social Evolution. But there are similarities in their respective methodological approaches as well. For instance, the most striking similarity is that despite the importance he gave to the social stratum, Tarde, just like Schumpeter’s early approach, never fully admitted the determination of the individual’s will by the social forces. In other words, they both attempted to explain social evolution by means of individual initiative. At this point it should be mentioned that Tarde’s theory has been delivered and published about a decade before the publication of the first edition of Schumpeter’s influential Theory of Economic Development. In this context, much of this similarity in visions could be attributed to Schumpeter having carefully read Tarde and, probably, to certain common intellectual sources of influence. Part of the explanation why this similarity in visions has been inadequately acknowledged, so far, lies in the ignorance of the approaches on which Schumpeter built his treatises. In this framework, after examining the affinities of Schumpeter’s work with Gabriel Tarde, it is evident that certain Schumpeterian elaborations appear to be less unique.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Schumpeter, Tarde, evolution, invention, technology, individualism.
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B1 - History of Economic Thought through 1925 > B13 - Neoclassical through 1925 (Austrian, Marshallian, Walrasian, Stockholm School); B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B1 - History of Economic Thought through 1925 > B15 - Historical ; Institutional ; Evolutionary; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B25 - Historical ; Institutional ; Evolutionary ; Austrian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B3 - History of Economic Thought: Individuals

References

Baumol, W. J., 2005. Return of The Invisible Men: The Microeconomic Value Theory of Inventors and Entrepreneurs, Manuscript. New York University, New York.

Borch, C., 2005. Urban imitations: Tarde’s sociology revisited. Theory, Culture, & Society 22 (3), 81–100.

Clark, T. N. (Ed.), 1969. Gabriel Tarde on Communication and Social In-fluence: Selected Papers. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, Ill.

Clemence, R. V., 1951. Essays of Economic Topics of J. A. Schumpeter, Port Washington, Kennikat Press.

Davis, M.M., 1902. Review of Tarde’s Psychologie Economique. Political Science Quarterly 17 (3), 540–542.

de Vecchi, N., 1995. Entrepreneurs, Institutions and Economic Change: The Economic Thought of J. A. Schumpeter (1905-1925). Aldershot: Edward Elgar.

Ebner, A., 2006. Institutions, Entrepreneurship, and the Rationale of Gov-ernment: An outline of the Schumpeterian Theory of the State, Jour-nal of Economic Behavior & Organization 59 (4), April, 497-515.

Ekelund, R. B., Hébert, R.F., 1990. A History of Economic Theory and Method, third ed. McGraw-Hill, Singapore.

Ellwood, C.A., 1901. The theory of imitation in social psychology. American Journal of Sociology 6 (6), 721–741.

Faltello, R. and Jovanovic, M., 1996. Rudolf Hilferding und Das Finanzkapital in Imperialismus & Marxistische Theorie, Teil 1: Die klassiker, Marxismus 7, Wien, März, available at: http://www.agmarxismus.net/vergrnr/m07_2hil.html (in German).

Giddings, F. H., 1896. Review of Les lois de l’imitation. Political Science Quarterly 11 (2), 346–352.

Gide, C., 1904. Principles of Political Economy. D.C. Heath&Co., Publish-ers, Boston, U.S.A. (2nd American Edition, translated by C.W.A. Veditz).

Gide, C., 1909. Economic literature in France at the beginning of the twentieth century. Economic Journal 17, 192–212.

Haberler, G. 1950. Joseph Alois Schumpeter: 1883-1950. Quarterly Journal of Economics 64, 333-72.

Hamilton, C.J., 1903. Review of Tarde’s La Psychologie ´ Economique. Economic Journal 13, 615–620.

Hodgson, G., 2007. Meanings of Methodological Individualism, Economic Methodology, 14 (2), June, 211-226.

Hughes, E. C., 1961. Tarde’s Psychologie Economique: an unknown classic by a forgotten sociologist. American Journal of Sociology 66 (6), 553–559.

Katona, G., 1975. Psychological Economics. Elsevier, New York.

Katz, E., 1999. Theorizing diffusion: Tarde and Sorokin revisited. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 144–155.

Katz, E., 2006. Rediscovering Gabriel Tarde. Political Communication 23 (3), 263–270.

Kinnunen, J., 1996. Gabriel Tarde as a founding father of innovation dif-fusion research. Acta Sociologica 39, 431–442.

Kirsch, H. 1979. Joseph Alois Schumpeter, Journal of Economic Issues 13.1, 141-57.

Leeson, R. 1997. Influence (or the Lack of It) in the Economics Profession: The Case of Lucien Albert Hahn. History of Political Economy, Vol. 29, No. 4 (Winter), 635–638.

Mahaim, M., 1903. L’économie politique de M. Tarde. Revue d’économie politique 17, 1–34.

McCraw, T. K., 2007, Prophet of Innovation: Joseph Schumpeter and Creative Destruction, Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.

Menger, C., 1871. Grundsätze der Volkswirtschaftslehre. Hölder-Pichler-Tempsky, Vienna.

Michaelides, P. and Milios, J. 2004. Hilferding’s Influence on Schumpeter: A First Discussion, European Association for Evolutionary Political Economy, Proceedings of 16th Annual International Conference (CD), Crete, Greece, October 28-31.

Michaelides, P. and Milios, J. 2005a. Did Hilferding Influence Schumpeter? History of Economics Review 41, 98-125.

Michaelides, P. and Milios, J. 2005b. The Influence of the German Histori-cal School on Schumpeter, European Association for Evolutionary Political Economy, Proceedings of the 17th Annual International Conference (CD), Bremen, Germany, November 10-12.

Michaelides, P., Milios., J., Vouldis, A., 2007a, Schumpeter, Lederer and Hilferding, on Economic Development, Credit and Business Cycles, 9th International Conference of Greek Historians of Economic Thought, University of Athens, May 11-12.

Michaelides, P., Milios., J., Vouldis, A. 2007b, Emil Lederer and the Schumpeter, Hilferding, Tugan-Baranowsky Nexus, Workshop in Political Economy, International Initiative for the Promotion of Political Economy (IPPE), University of London & University of Crete, September.

Michaelides, P., Milios., J., Vouldis, A., 2007c, Schumpeter and Lederer on Economic Growth, Technology, Credit and Business Cycles, European Association for Evolutionary Political Economy, Proceedings of the 19th Annual International Conference (CD), Porto, 2007, November, 1-3.

Michaelides, P. and Milios, J. 2008. Joseph Schumpeter and the German Historical School, Cambridge Journal of Economics (accepted for publication - forthcoming).

Michaelides, P., Milios., J., Vouldis, A. and Lapatsioras, S. 2009a. Emil Lederer and Joseph Schumpeter on Economic Growth, Technology and Business Cycles. Forum for Social Economics. published online February 15, 2009, DOI: 10.1007/s12143-009-9032-2 (in Press).

Michaelides, P., Milios., J. and Vouldis, A. 2009b. Schumpeter’s and Lederer’s Visions of Growth and Business Cycles and their Marxist Roots. Review of Political Economy (accepted for publication – forthcoming).

Michaelides, P., Milios., J., Vouldis, A. and Lapatsioras, S. 2009c. Heterodox Influences on Schumpeter, International Journal of Social Economics (accepted for publication - forthcoming).

Milet, J., 1970. Gabriel Tarde et la philosophie de l’histoire. Vrin, Paris.

Mill, J. S., 1843. The Logic of the Moral Sciences. In: A System of Logic, Ratiocinative and Inductive, (Book VI), eighth ed. Longman, Green, & Co, London [1925].

Mucchielli, L., 2000. Tardomania? Réflexions sur les usages contemporains de Tarde. Revue d’histoire des sciences humaines 3, 161–185 (Reprinted in Mythes et histoire des sciences humaines, Paris, La Dé-couverte, 2004, 45–72).

Paulhan, F., 1890. Revue de Les lois de l’imitation. Revue philosophique 15, 170–182.

Pieters, R. and Robben, H., 1999. Consumer evaluation of money as a gift: a two-utility model and an empirical test. Kyklos 52 (2), 173–201.

Prendergast, R., 2006. Schumpeter, Hegel and the Vision of Development. Cambridge Journal of Economics 30 (2), 253-275.

Reinert, E., 2002. Schumpeter in the Context of two Canons of Economic Thought, Industry and Innovation, Vol. 6, No. 1, 23-39.

Roche-Agussol, M., 1920. La psychologie économique chez Cournot. Revue d’histoire économique et sociale 8, 179–188.

Roche-Agussol, M., 1926. Tarde et l’ économie psychologique. Revue d’histoire économique et sociale 14, 68–114, 273–319.

Rogers, E. M., 1962. Diffusion of Innovations. The Free Press, New York.

Ross, E. A., 1904. Review of the Laws of Imitation. Journal of Political Economy 13 (1), 117–118.

Scherer, F., 1984. Innovation and Growth. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Schumpeter, J. A., 1910. Die neuere Wirtschaftstheorie in den Vereinigten Staaten. Schmollers Jahrbuch fuer Gesetzgebung. Verwaltung und Volkswirtschaft im Deutschen Reiche 34, 1–52.

Schumpeter, J. A., 1912. The Theory of Economic Development, Cambridge: Harvard University Press [1934, 1951, 1961].

Schumpeter, J. A., 1928. The Instability of Capitalism, Economic Journal 38.151, 361-86.

Schumpeter, J. A., 1935. The analysis of economic change. Review of Eco-nomic Statistics, 14.4, 2–10.

Schumpeter, J. A., 1939. Business Cycles. New York: McGraw-Hill [1964].

Schumpeter, J. A., 1942. Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy. New York: Harper and Row [1950].

Schumpeter, J. A., 1949. Economic theory and entrepreneurial history, in H.G.J. Aitken 1965, Explorations in Enterprise, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA, 45-64.

Senn, P., 2003. The Influence of Schumpeter’s German Writings on the Mainstream Economic Literature in English, in: Backhaus, J. Joseph Alois Schumpeter. Kluwer Academic Publishers, The Netherlands, 141-162.

Shionoya, Y., 1990. Instrumentalism in Schumpeter’s economic methodol-ogy, History of Political Economy, 22 (summer), pp. 187-222.

Shionoya, Y. 1997. Schumpeter and the Idea of Social Science, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Shionoya, Y., 2005. The Soul of the German Historical School, New York: Springer.

Smithies, A., 1951. Memorial: Joseph Alois Schumpeter, 1883-1950, in Schumpeter, Social Scientist, (ed.) Seymour Harris, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Swedberg, R., 1991. Joseph A. Schumpeter, Cambridge, Polity Press.

Tarde, G., 1880. La croyance et le désir. La possibilité de leur mesure. Re-vue Philosophique 5, 150–180, 264–283.

Tarde, G., 1881. La psychologie en économie politique. Revue Philoso-phique 6, 232–250, 401–418.

Tarde, G., 1888. Les deux sens de la valeur. Revue d’économie politique 2, 526–540, 561–576.

Tarde, G., 1890. Les lois de l’imitation. Alcan, Paris.

Tarde, G., 1893. La logique sociale. Alcan, Paris.

Tarde, G., 1899. Social laws: an outline of sociology, translated from the French by H. C. Warren, Batoche Books.

Tarde, G., 1901. L’opinion et la foule, Paris: Les Presses universitaires de France.

Tarde, G., 1902, L’invention considerée comme moteur de l’évolution so-ciale, paper presented in Société de Sociologie de Paris, June 11th, 1-12 (also in : Revue Internationale de Sociologie 7, 561–574).

Tarde, G., 1902b. La psychologie économique, 2 vols. Alcan, Paris.

Tarde, G., 1902c. La philosophie de Cournot, Cours au Collège de France.

Taymans, A., 1950. Tarde and Schumpeter: a similar vision. Quarterly Journal of Economics 64 (4), 611–622.

te Velde, R.A. 2001. Schumpeter’s Theory of Economic Development Re-vised, Conference on ‘The Future of Innovation Studies’. Eindhoven University of Technology, The Netherlands, 20-23 September.

Tosti, G., 1897. The sociological theories of Gabriel Tarde. Political Science Quarterly 12 (3), 490–511.

Toye, J., 2006. Hans Singer’s debts to Schumpeter and Keynes, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 30 (6), 819-833.

Veblen, T., 1902. Review of La psychologie économique. Journal of Political Economy 11 (1), 146–148.

Wärneryd, K. E., 2008, The psychological underpinnings of economics: Economic psychology according to Gabriel Tarde, in The Journal of Socio-Economics 37, 1685–1702.

Whittaker, T., 1890. Review of Les Lois de l’imitation. Mind 15, 304–311.

Worms, R., 1905. La philosophie sociale de G. Tarde. Revue Philosophique 60, 120–156.