A Conceptual Model of the Socioeconomic Impacts of Unconventional Fossil Fuel Extraction

Measham, Thomas and Fleming, David and Schandl, Heinz (2015): A Conceptual Model of the Socioeconomic Impacts of Unconventional Fossil Fuel Extraction. Published in: Global Environmental Change , Vol. 36, (8 January 2016): pp. 101-110.

Abstract

As global energy demand increases, the rapid expansion of the unconventional fossil fuel sector has triggered an urgent need for social, economic and policy research to understand and predict how this sector affects host communities and how governance systems can respond to changes presented by this sector. In response to this need, this paper addresses three linked objectives. The first is to review the literature on regional impacts of energy extraction, presented in the form of a framework of hierarchical effects. The second is to consider how these are playing out differently in the context of conventional compared with unconventional fossil fuels. The third is to draw attention to the institutional avenues for addressing these impacts, including an overview of the lessons from existing research on the human and policy dimensions associated with conventional energy industries. In particular, we consider the importance of multi-stakeholder dialogue, which plays an important role in how regions respond to the challenges brought about through extractive industries. Overall, we demonstrate that experiences from conventional energy development provide a useful starting point for navigating the human and policy dimensions of unconventional energy for host communities and discuss how these experiences differ when unconventional energy seeks to co-exist with other land uses such as agriculture. The paper draws attention to the dispersed nature of impacts (positive and negative) and how this may shape winners and losers from unconventional energy development, particularly in regions with pre-existing land uses such as agriculture.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: unconventional energy, shale, community impacts, dialogue, governance
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy > Q42 - Alternative Energy Sources; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R11 - Regional Economic Activity: Growth, Development, Environmental Issues, and Changes

References

Azapagic, A. 2004. Developing a framework for sustainable development indicators for the mining and minerals industry. Journal of Cleaner Production 12(6), 639–662.

Ballard, C., and G. Banks. 2003. Resource Wars: The Anthropology of Mining. Annual Review of Anthropology 32 (1):287–313.

Baker, M., and N.M. Fortin. 2001. Occupational gender composition and wages in Canada, Canadian Journal of Economics 34 (2), 345–376.

Bang, G. 2015. The United States and international climate negotiations; in Backstrand K. and Lovbrand E. (eds) Research Handbook on Climate Governance, Edward Elgar, UK (forthcoming).

Bergquist, E., Evangelista, P., Stohlgren, T. J. and Alley, N., 2007. Invasive species and coal bed methane development in the Powder River Basin, Wyoming. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 128 (1–3), 381–394.

Betz, Mike, M. Farren, L. Lobao, and Mark D. Partridge. 2014. Coal Mining, Economic Development, and the Natural Resource Curse. MPRA Paper 58016 [online] http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/58016/.

Bice, S., and K. Moffat. 2014. Social licence to operate and impact assessment. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 32 (4):257–262.

Black, D., T. McKinnish, and S. Sanders. 2005. The economic impact of the coal boom and bust. The Economic Journal 115 (503), 449–476.

Brandt, A. R., G. A. Heath, E. A. Kort, F. O'Sullivan, G. Pétron, S. M. Jordaan, P. Tans, J. Wilcox, A. M. Gopstein, D. Arent, S. Wofsy, N. J. Brown, R. Bradley, G. D. Stucky, D. Eardley, and R. Harriss. 2014. Methane Leaks from North American Natural Gas Systems. Science 343 (6172):733–735.

Brasier, K.J., M.R. Filteau, D.K. McLaughlin, J. Jacquet, R.C. Stedman, T.W. Kelsey, , & S.J. Goetz, (2011). Residents’ perceptions of community and environmental impacts from development of natural gas in the Marcellus Shale: a comparison of Pennsylvania and New York cases. Journal of Rural Social Sciences, 26(1), 32-61.

Brasier, K.J., L. Davis, L. Glenna, T.W. Kelsey, D.K. McLaughlin, K. Schafft, K. Babbie, C. Biddle, A. DeLessio-Parson, D. Rhubart, and M. Suchyta. 2015. Communities Experiencing Shale Gas Development. In Economics of Unconventional Shale Gas Development, edited by W. E. Hefley and Y. Wang: Springer International Publishing.

Brown, T. C., W. B. Bankston, C. J. Forsyth, and E. R. Berthelot. 2011. Qualifying the Boom-Bust Paradigm: An Examination of the Off-Shore Oil and Gas Industry. Sociology Mind, 1(03), 96.

Carrington, K., A. McIntosh, and J. Scott. 2010. Globalization, Frontier Masculinities and Violence: Booze, Blokes and Brawls. British Journal of Criminology 50 (3), 393–413.

Caselli F and G .Michaels. 2013. Do oil windfalls improve living standards? Evidence from Brazil. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 5(1), 208–238.

Chapman, R., P. Plummer, and M. Tonts. 2015. The resource boom and socio-economic well-being in Australian resource towns: a temporal and spatial analysis. Urban Geography:1–25 doi: 10.1080/02723638.2015.1018032.

Cheshire, L. 2010. A corporate responsibility? The constitution of fly-in, fly-out mining companies as governance partners in remote, mine-affected localities. Journal of Rural Studies 26(1), 12–20.

Colvin, R.M., G. Bradd Witt, and J. Lacey. 2015. Strange bedfellows or an aligning of values? Exploration of stakeholder values in an alliance of concerned citizens against coal seam gas mining. Land Use Policy 42 (0):392–399.

Conde, M. and G. Kallis. 2012. The global uranium rush and its Africa frontier. Effects, reactions and social movements in Namibia. Global Environmental Change 22 (3):596–610.

Connell, J. 1991. Compensation and conflict: the Bougainville copper mine, Papua New Guinea. Mining and indigenous peoples in Australasia, 55.

Connell, J. 2012. Population Resettlement in the Pacific: lessons from a hazardous history? Australian Geographer 43 (2):127–142.

Cotton, M. 2015. Stakeholder perspectives on shale gas fracking: A Q-method study of environmental discourses. Environment and Planning A. doi:10.1177/0308518X15597134.

Cust, J. and S. Poelhekke. 2015. The Local Economic Impacts of Natural Resource Extraction. Annual Review of Resource Economics 7 (1) doi:10.1146/annurev-resource-100814-125106.

Dare, M., J. Schirmer, and F. Vanclay. 2014. Community engagement and social licence to operate. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 32 (3):188–197.

de Rijke, Kim. 2013. The Agri-Gas Fields of Australia: Black Soil, Food, and Unconventional Gas. Culture, Agriculture, Food and Environment 35 (1):41–53.

Douglas, S. and A.W. Walker. 2013. Coal Mining and the Resource Curse in the Eastern United States (December 29, 2013). Available at Social Science Research Network: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2385560.

Ennis, G., M. Tofa, and M. Finlayson. 2014. Open for Business but at What Cost? Housing issues in ‘boomtown’ Darwin. Australian Geographer 45 (4):447–464.

Evensen, D., J.B. Jacquet, C.E. Clarke, and R.C. Stedman. 2014. What's the ‘fracking’ problem? One word can’t say it all. The Extractive Industries and Society 1 (2):130–136.

Feser E.J. and E.M. Bergman. 2000. National Industry Cluster Templates: A Framework for Applied Regional Cluster Analysis. Regional Studies 34(1), 1–19.

Filteau, M.R. 2015. A Localized Masculine Crisis: Local Men's Subordination within the Marcellus Shale Region's Masculine Structure. Rural Sociology DOI: 10.1111/ruso.12072.

Fleming, D.A. and T.G. Measham. 2014. Local Job Multipliers of Mining. Resources Policy, 41, 9–15.

Fleming D.A. T.G. Measham, and D. Paredes. 2015. Understanding the resource curse within countries: Theory, empirical challenges and an application to Australia, Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics Vol 59 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/1467-8489.12118.

Fleming, D.A. and T.G. Measham. 2015. Local Economic Impacts of an Unconventional Energy Boom: The Coal Seam Gas Industry in Australia, Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 59 (1): 78–94 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/1467-8489.12043.

Franks, D.M., R. Davis, A.J. Bebbington, S.H. Ali, D. Kemp, and M. Scurrah. 2014. Conflict translates environmental and social risk into business costs. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 111 (21):7576–7581.

Frantál, B. & E. Nováková. 2014. A Curse of Coal? Exploring Unintended Regional Consequences of Coal Energy in The Czech Republic. Moravian Geographical Reports, 22(2): 55-65. doi:10.2478/mgr-2014-0012.

Glaeser, E., S. Kerr, and W. Kerr. 2012. Entrepreneurship and urban growth: An empirical assessment with historical mines. National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper 18333.

Gramling, R, and S. Brabant. 1986. Boomtowns and Offshore Energy Impact Assessment: The Development of a Comprehensive Model. Sociological Perspectives 29 (2):177–201.

Gylfason, T., T. Herbertsson, and G. Zoega. 1999. A mixed blessing: Natural resources and economic growth. Macroeconomic Dynamics 3 (2):204–225.

Gylfason, T. 2001. Natural resources, education, and economic development. European Economic Review 45 (4-6):847–859.

Gunter, W. D., Gentzis, T., Rottenfusser, B. A. and Richardson, R. J. H., 1997. Deep coalbed methane in Alberta, Canada: A fuel resource with the potential of zero greenhouse gas emissions. Energy Conversion and Management 38, (Supplement), pp. S217–S222.

Haggerty, J., P.H. Gude, M. Delorey, and R. Rasker. 2014. Long-term effects of income specialization in oil and gas extraction: The U.S. West, 1980–2011. Energy Economics 45:186–195.

Halseth, G. 1999. “We came for the work”: Situating employment migrration in B.C.’s small resource-based communities. Canadian Geographer / Le Géographe canadien 43 (4):363–381.

Hamawand, I., T. Yusaf, and S.G. Hamawand. 2013. Coal seam gas and associated water: A review paper. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 22:550–560.

Haslam McKenzie, F.M. and S. Rowley. 2013 Housing Market Failure in a Booming Economy. Housing Studies 1–16.

Headwaters Economics. 2008. Fossil Fuel Extraction as a County Economic Development Strategy: Are Energy-focusing Counties Benefiting? Bozeman Montana. http://headwaterseconomics.org/pubs/energy/headwaterseconomics_energyfocusing.pdf.

Ivanova, G., and J. Rolfe. 2011. Using input-output analysis to estimate the impact of a coal industry expansion on regional and local economies. Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 29 (4):277–288.

Jacquet, J.B. 2012. Landowner attitudes toward natural gas and wind farm development in northern Pennsylvania. Energy Policy 50:677–688.

Jacquet, J.B. and D. L. Kay. 2014. The unconventional boomtown: Updating the impact model to fit new spatial and temporal scales. Journal of Rural and Community Development, 9(1), 1-23.

Jacquet, J., and R., Stedman. 2011. Natural gas landowner coalitions in New York State: emerging benefits of collective natural resource management. Journal of Rural Social Sciences 26 (1), 62–91.

Jacobsen, G.D., and D.P. Parker. 2014. The Economic Aftermath of Resource Booms: Evidence from Boomtowns in the American West. The Economic Journal: (forthcoming) DOI: 10.1111/ecoj.12173.

James, A, and D. Aadland. 2011. The curse of natural resources: An empirical investigation of U.S. counties. Resource and Energy Economics 33 (2):440–453.

Johnson, C. and T. Boersma. 2013. Energy (in)security in Poland the case of shale gas. Energy Policy 53:389–399.

Kargbo, D. M., R. G. Wilhelm, and D. J. Campbell. 2010. Natural Gas Plays in the Marcellus Shale: Challenges and Potential Opportunities. Environmental Science & Technology 44 (15):5679–5684.

Kerschner, C., C. Prell, K. Feng, and K. Hubacek. 2013. Economic vulnerability to Peak Oil. Global Environmental Change 23 (6):1424–1433.

Kilkenny M. and M.D. Partridge. 2009. Export Sectors and Rural Development. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 91(4), 910–929.

Kinnaman, TC. 2011. The economic impact of shale gas extraction: A review of existing studies. Ecological Economics 70 (7):1243–1249.

Larsen, E. R. 2006. Escaping the Resource Curse and the Dutch Disease? American Journal of Economics and Sociology 65 (3):605–640.

Law, B. E. and Spencer, C. W., 1993. Gas in tight reservoirs-an emerging major source of energy. United States Geological Survey Professional Paper 1570. Edited by: Howell, D. pp. 233–252

Lawrence, G., C. Richards, and K. Lyons. 2013. Food security in Australia in an era of neoliberalism, productivism and climate change. Journal of Rural Studies 29:30–39.

Lawrie, M., M. Tonts, and P. Plummer. 2011. Boomtowns, Resource Dependence and Socio-economic Well-being. Australian Geographer 42 (2):139–164.

Lockie, S., M. Franettovich, V. Petkova-Timmer, J. Rolfe, and G. Ivanova. 2009. Coal mining and the resource community cycle: A longitudinal assessment of the social impacts of the Coppabella coal mine. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 29 (5):330–339.

Marchand J. 2012. Local labor market impacts of energy boom-bust-boom in Western Canada. Journal of Urban Economics 71(1), 165–174.

Measham, T. G., and D. A. Fleming. (2014a). Impacts of unconventional gas development on rural community decline. Journal of Rural Studies 36:376–385.

Measham, T.G. and D.A. Fleming. (2014b). Assess benefits and costs of shale energy, Nature, Vol 510 (7506): 473.

Measham T.G., T. Darbas, R. Williams and B. Taylor. 2012. Rethinking rural futures: Qualitative scenarios for reflexive regional development. Rural Society 21(3), 176–189.

Measham T.G. and H. Schandl. 2013. How to enhance government capacity to deliver benefits from resource extraction including through social impact assessment and environmental impact assessment? Presented at the UNDP Pacific Symposium on Managing Extractive Industries in Pacific Island States to Improve Human Development, Nadi, Fiji, March 2013.

Measham T.G., E. Jakku and R. Williams. 2010 Tripartite dialogue in Gunnedah Basin and Liverpool Plains: report on findings from first interviews. Report to the Department of Premier and Cabinet. CSIRO Ecosystem Sciences, Canberra.

Michaels G. 2011. The long term consequences of resource-based specialisation. The Economic Journal 121(551), 31–57.

MMSD. 2002. Breaking New Ground: Mining, Minerals, Sustainable Development Final Report. International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED). World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD).

Morrison, T. H., C. Wilson, and M. Bell. 2012. The role of private corporations in regional planning and development: Opportunities and challenges for the governance of housing and land use. Journal of Rural Studies 28 (4):478–489.

Obeng-Odoom, F. 2014 Oiling the Urban Economy: Land, Labour, Capital, and the State in Sekondi-Takoradi, Ghana. Routledge, London.

Obeng-Odoom, F. 2015. Oil boom, human capital and economic development: Some recent evidence. The Economic and Labour Relations Review 26 (1):100–116.

Papyrakis, E. and R. Gerlagh. 2007. Resource abundance and economic growth in the United States. European Economic Review 51 (4):1011–1039.

Paredes, D., T., Komarek, and S. Loveridge. 2015. Income and employment effects of shale gas extraction windfalls: evidence from the Marcellus region, Energy Economics 47, 112–120

Perry, S.L. 2012. Development, Land Use, and Collective Trauma: The Marcellus Shale Gas Boom in Rural Pennsylvania. Culture, Agriculture, Food and Environment 34 (1):81–92.

Petrova, S., and D. Marinova. 2013. Social impacts of mining: Changes within the local social landscape. Rural Society 22 (2):153–165.

Porter M.E. and M.R. Kramer. 2011. Creating shared value: How to Reinvent Capitalism—and Unleash a Wave of Innovation and Growth. Harvard Business Review 89(1/2), 62–77.

Ramankutty, N., and J.A. Foley. 1999. Estimating historical changes in land cover: North American croplands from 1850 to 1992. Global Ecology and Biogeography 8, 381–396.

Reeson A.F., T.G. Measham and K. Hosking. 2012. Mining activity, income inequality and gender in regional Australia. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 56(2), 302–313.

Rolfe, J. 2013. Predicting the economic and demographic impacts of long distance commuting in the resources sector: A Surat basin case study. Resources Policy 38 (4):723–732.

Ross, D.J.K., and R.M. Bustin. 2007. Shale Gas potential of the lower Jurassic Gordondale Member, Northeastern British Columbia, Canada. Bull. Can. Pet. Geol. 55 (1),51–75.

Schandl, H. and T. Darbas. 2008. Surat Basin Scoping Study. Enhancing regional and community capacity for mining and energy driven regional economic development. Report to the Southern Inland Queensland Area Consulatative Committee and Australian Government Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development and Local Government. CSIRO Sustainable Ecosystems, Canberra.

Schulz, H.-M., B. Horsfield, and R.F. Sachsenhofer. 2010. Shale gas in Europe: a Regional Overview and Current Research Activities. In: Petroleum Geology Conference Series 7. Geological Society, London, pp. 1079–1085.

Selley, R.C., 2005. UK shale-gas Resources. In: Petroleum Geology Conference Series 6. Geological Society, London, pp. 707–714.

Seydlitz, R., P. Jenkins, and S.Hampton. 1995. Economic impacts of energy development. Society & Natural Resources 8 (4):321–337.

Sherval, M., and K. Hardiman. 2014. Competing Perceptions of the Rural Idyll: responses to threats from coal seam gas development in Gloucester, NSW, Australia. Australian Geographer 45 (2):185–203.

Simshauser, P. and T. Nelson. 2015. Australia's coal seam gas boom and the LNG entry result. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics DOI: 10.1111/1467-8489.12117.

Söderholm, P. and N. Svahn. 2015. Mining, regional development and benefit-sharing in developed countries. Resources Policy 45:78–91.

Solomon, F., E. Katz, and R. Lovell. 2008. Social dimensions of mining: Research, policy and practice challenges for the minerals industry in Australia. Resources Policy 33 (3):142–149.

Stedman, R.C., J.B. Jacquet, M.R. Filteau, F.K. Willits, K.J. Brasier, and D. K McLaughlin. 2012. Marcellus Shale Gas Development and New Boomtown Research: Views of New York and Pennsylvania Residents. Environmental Practice 14 (4):382–393.

Storey, K. 2010. Fly-in/Fly-out: Implications for Community Sustainability. Sustainability 2 (5):1161–1181.

Tolbert, C. M. 2006. Sustainable community in oil and gas country: Final report. US Department of the Interior, Minerals Management Service, Gulf of Mexico OCS Region.

Turton, D.J. 2015. Unconventional Gas in Australia: Towards a Legal Geography. Geographical Research 53 (1):53–67.

van der Ploeg, F. 2011. Natural resources: Curse or blessing? Journal of Economic Literature 49, 366–420.

Vickas, M., P. McManus, and C. Dey. 2015. From the Seam to the Stove: greenhouse gas assessment and the coal seam gas industry in Australia. Australian Geographer 46 (1):73–90.

Warhurst, A. 2001. Corporate Citizenship and Corporate Social Investment. Journal of Corporate Citizenship 2001(1):57–73.

Weber J.G. 2012. The effects of a natural gas boom on employment and income in Colorado, Texas, and Wyoming. Energy Economics 34(5), 1580–1588.

Weijermars, R. 2013. Economic appraisal of shale gas plays in Continental Europe. Appl. Energy 106, 100–115.

Wiśniewski, B. 2011. Promises and Pitfalls of the North American Shale-Gas revolution: global implications and lessons for Europe. Pol. Q. Int. Aff. 20 (3), 91–112.

Wright, S. 2012. An Unconventional Bonanza, pp. 1–18. The Economist Special Report, 14 July 2012.