Catching the Tail: Empirical Identification of the Distribution of the Value of Travel Time

Börjesson, Maria and Fosgerau, Mogens and Algers, Staffan (2012): Catching the Tail: Empirical Identification of the Distribution of the Value of Travel Time. Published in: Transportation Research Part A , Vol. 46, No. 2 : pp. 378-391.

Abstract

Recent methodological advances in discrete choice analysis in combination with certain stated choice experiments have allowed researchers to check empirically the identification of the distribution of latent variables such as the value of travel time (VTT). Lack of identification is likely to be common and the consequences are severe. E.g., the Danish value of time study found the 15% right tail of the VTT distribution to be unidentified, making it impossible to estimate the mean VTT without resorting to strong assumptions with equally strong impact on the resulting estimate. This paper analyses data generated from a similar choice experiment undertaken in Sweden during 2007-2008 in which the range of trade-off values between time and money was significantly increased relative to the Danish experiment. The results show that this change allowed empirical identification of effectively the entire VTT distribution. In addition to informing the design of future choice experiments, the results are also of interest as a validity test of the stated choice methodology. Failure in identifying the right tail of the VTT would have made it difficult to maintain that respondents’ behaviour is consistent with utility maximization in the sense intended by the experimenter.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: value of time; transport; discrete choice
• Subjects: R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R4 - Transportation Economics

References

Abrantes, P. A. L. and Wardman, M. R. (2011). Meta-analysis of UK values of travel time: An update. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 45(1), 1-17.

Ahern, A. A. and Tapley, N. (2008). The use of stated preference techniques to model modal choices on interurban trips in Ireland. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 42(1), 15-27.

Bateman, I., Munro, A., Rhodes, B., Starmer, C., Sugden, R., (1997). A test of the theory of reference-dependent preferences. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 112 (2), 479–505.

Bates, J. and Whelan, G. (2001). "Size and sign of Time Savings", ITS Working Paper no. 561.

Beesley, M. E. (1965). "The Value of Time Spent in Travelling: Some New Evidence", Economica, vol. 32, no. 126, pp. 174-185.

Bierlaire, M. (2003). BIOGEME: a free package for the estimation of discrete choice models, Proceedings of the 3rd Swiss Transport Research Conference, Monte Verità, Ascona, Switzerland.

Bierlaire, M. (2008). "An introduction to Biogeme", http://biogeme.epfl.ch/.

Brownstone, D., & Small, K. A. (2005). Valuing time and reliability: assessing the evidence from road pricing demonstrations. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 39(4), 279-293.

Börjesson, M., Fosgerau, M., and Algers, S. (2009). The income elasticity of the value of travel time is not one number. Paper presented at the 2009 European Transport Conference, Leiden, The Netherlands.

Cairns, J. and van der Pol, M. (2004). Repeated follow-up as a method for reducing non-trading behaviour in discrete choice experiments. Social Science and Medicine 58, pp 2211–2218

Cameron, T. A. (1988). "A New Paradigm for Valuing Non-Market Goods Using Referendum Data: Maximum Likelihood Estimation by Censored Logistic Regression." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 15, 355-79.

Cameron, T. A. and James, M. D. (1987). "Efficient Estimation Methods for "Closed-Ended" Contingent Valuation Surveys", Review of Economics and Statistics, vol. 69, no. 2, pp. 269-276.

Cantillo, V., Heydecker, B., and de Dios Ortuzar, J. (2006). "A discrete choice model incorporating thresholds for perception in attribute values", Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, vol. 40, no. 9, pp. 807-825.

Cirillo, C., & Axhausen, K. W. (2006). Evidence on the distribution of values of travel time savings from a six-week diary. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 40(5), 444-457.

De Borger, B. and Fosgerau, M., (2008). A test of the theory of reference-dependent preferences: the trade-off between money and time. Journal of Urban Economics, Volume 64 (1), 101-115.

Fosgerau, M. (2007). Using nonparametrics to specify a model to measure the value of travel time. Transportation Research Part A 41 842–856

Fosgerau, M. and Bierlaire, M. (2007). A practical test for the choice of mixing distribution in discrete choice models. Transportation Research Part B 41 784–794

Fosgerau, M. (2006). Investigating the distribution of the value of travel time savings. Transportation Research Part B 40 (2006) 688–707

Fosgerau, M., Hjorth, K., and Vincent Lyk-Jensen S. (2006). An integrated approach to the estimation of the value of travel time. ETC proceedings, http://www.etcproceedings.org/

Fowkes, A.S. and Wardman, M. (1988). The Design of Stated Preference Travel Choice Experiments with Particular Regard to Inter-Personal Taste Variations. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 22(1), 27-44

Hensher, D. A. (2006). Towards a practical method to establish comparable values of travel time savings from stated choice experiments with differing design dimensions. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 40(10), 829-840.

Hess, S., Bierlaire, M., & Polak, J. W. (2005). Estimation of value of travel-time savings using mixed logit models. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 39(2-3), 221-236.

Hess, S., Rose, J.M. and Polak, J. (2010). Non-trading, lexicographic and inconsistent behaviour in stated choice data Transportation Research Part D 15 (2010) 405–417

Horowitz, J. and McConnell, K.E. (2002). "A Review of WTA/WTP Studies" Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 44 426-447.

Hultkrantz, L. and Mortazavi, R. (2001). "Anomalies in the Value of Travel-Time Changes", Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, vol. 35, no. 2, pp. 285-300.

Killi, M., Nossum, Å. and Veisten, K. (2007). Lexicographic answering in travel choice: Insufficient scale extensions and steep indifference curves? EJTIR, 7, no. 1 (2007), pp. 39-62

Lancsar, E. and Louviere, J. (2006). Deleting ‘irrational’ responses from discrete choice experiments: a case of investigating or imposing preferences? Health Economics. 15: 797–811

Potoglou, D., Robinson, N., Kim, C. W., Burge, P. and Warnes, R. (2010). Quantifying individuals’ trade-offs between privacy, liberty and security: The case of rail travel in UK. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 44(3), 169-181.

Randall, A. and Stoll, J. R. (1980). "Consumer's Surplus in Commodity Space", American Economic Review, vol. 70, no. 3, pp. 449-455.

Ryan, M., Watson, V. and Entwistle, V. (2009). Rationalising the ‘irrational’: a think aloud study of discrete choice experiment responses. Health Economics 18: 321–336 (2009)

Ramjerdi, F., S Flügel, H. Samstad, M. Killi, (2010) Value of time, safety and environment in passenger transport. TØI-reports. 1053b/2010.

Tversky, A. and Kahneman, D. (1991). Loss Aversion in Riskless Choice: A Reference Dependent Model. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, MIT Press, vol. 106(4), pages 1039-1061, November.

Wardman, M. and Ibáñez, N. (2011). The congestion multiplier: Variations in motorists’ valuations of travel time with traffic conditions. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, In Press.