Objectivity and independence: the dual roles of external auditors and forensic accountants

Di Gabriele, James and Ojo, Marianne (2013): Objectivity and independence: the dual roles of external auditors and forensic accountants. Published in: Journal of Forensic and Investigative Accounting , Vol. 6, No. 2 (July 2014)

Abstract

This paper is aimed at illustrating that certain capacities exist whereby the dual role of the external auditor (in undertaking internal audit roles as well as skilled persons roles) could be exercised to the optimal and maximum benefit of an entity or organisation. It also aims to accentuate on why a return to and focus on traditional auditing techniques, as well as auditing techniques which focus on internal controls is a much needed move. In so doing, it contributes to the extant literature by highlighting why such a move should be facilitated, as well as proposing means whereby such a move would be facilitated - namely, through a focus on benefits which could be derived where the external auditor is able to incorporate certain internal audit responsibilities. The paper also draws attention to safeguards which require due consideration if the ever important attributes of objectivity and independence are not to be compromised. Risks associated with the overlapping roles of testifying and consulting experts in Forensic Accounting will also be considered in this paper.

Whilst the benefits and potentials of the dual roles assumed by external auditors are emphasized, as well as the need to ensure that safeguards operating to guard against a compromise of objectivity and independence are in place, authors' opinions in support of dual roles also take into consideration the utmost priority of ethical values. The paper hence also highlights the fact that such dual roles are appropriate in certain cases – as illustrated by justifications for limitations imposed by the Sarbanes Oxley Act and other relevant and applicable legislation – even though instances also persist where section 201 of Sarbanes-Oxley, with regard to internal audit outsourcing, may have been over-reactionary and may continue to hinder both companies and their auditors.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: independence; objectivity; Sarbanes Oxley Act; FSMA section 166; ISA 610; Amended Rule 26 (Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 26)
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K2 - Regulation and Business Law; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M41 - Accounting; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M42 - Auditing

References

Ahlawat, S.S. and J.D. Lowe. (2004) "An Examination of Internal Auditor Objectivity: In-House versus Outsourcing." Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory. 23.2 147-58.

Aldhizer III, G.R., J. D. Cashell, and D.R. Martin. (2003) "Internal Audit Outsourcing." The CPA Journal. 8:3:30-25.

Al-Harshani, M. (2003) "The Effect of Inherent Risk, Knowledge Spillover, and Litigation Risk on External Auditors' Reliance on Client's Internal Audit Functions." Diss. University of Arkansas.

Auditing Practices Board, Ethical Standards 1 http://www.frc.org.uk/Our- Work/Publications/APB/ES-1-(Revised)-Integrity,-objectivity-and-inde-(1).aspx

Basel Committee on Banking Supervision. (2012). "The Internal Audit Function in Banks" June 2012. www.bis.org/publ/bcbs223.pdf

Beattie, V., Fearnley, S. and Brandt, R. (2001). Behind Closed Doors: What Company Audit Is Really About (Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales).

Cunningham, L. (2006). "Too Big to Fail: Moral Hazard in Auditing and the Need to Restructure the Industry Before it Unravels" Boston College Law School Faculty Papers Paper 165

DeZoort et al, (2001). "The Impact of Internal Auditor Compensation and Role on External Auditor's Planning Judgments and Decisions, Contemporary Accounting Research, Summer 2001 Vol 18 Issue 2, p257 - 281

Di Gabriele, J. (2011). "An Observation of Differences in the Transparent Objectivity of Forensic Accounting Expert Witnesses, Journal of Forensic & Investigative Accounting Vol.3, Issue 2, Special Issue, 2011

Di Gabriele J.„A Narrative Inquiry of the Inchoate Ethical Risks of <forensic Accounting Experts under Amended Rule 26 Communications, Ethics & Critical Thinking Journal (Volume 2012 Issue 1)

Ernst &Young, (2006). Trends in Australian and New Zealand Internal Auditing, Third Annual Benchmarking Survey 2006, Ernst & Young, Australia.

Garrett, A. (2012) "The Role of Internal Audits in External Audits" CAE Conference, Abu Dhabi 2013 18 November 2012.

Geiger, M., Jordan Lowe, D. and Pany, K.(2002). "Outsourced Internal Audit Services and The Perception of Auditor Independence" The CPA Journal, http://www.nysscpa.org/cpajournal/2002/0402/features/f042002.htm

Grant Thornton, (2010). "Evaluating the Internal and External Audit Function" The Audit Committee Guide Series (adapted from the Audit Committee Handbook, Fifth Edition published by Wiley and Sons).

Hitchins, J. Hogg, M. and Mallet, D. (2001) Banking: A Regulatory Accounting and Auditing Guide Institute of Chartered Accountants England and Wales

HM Treasury "Cooperation Between Internal and External Auditors", A Good Practice Guide http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/d/auditors_190105.pdf

IFAC, "Basis for Conclusions on ISA 610 and ISA 315, Prepared by the Staff of the IAASB"

Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA), (2009). "The Role of Internal Auditing in Resourcing the Internal Audit Activity" IIA Position Paper January 2009 pages 4 and 5 https://na.theiia.org/standards-guidance/Public %20Documents/IPPF_PP_Role_of_IA_in_Resourcing_the_IAA_01-09.pdf

ISA 610 (Revised), Using the Work of Internal Auditors

ISA 315 (Revised), Identifying and Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatement through Understanding the Entity and Its Environment

Michaelson, W.M. (2005). Advocacy and the Expert Witness. Expert Witnessing in Forensic Accounting. 1, 1, 63-70. Monsanto v. Tidball 2009 WL 2757047 (E.D. Mo.)

Ojo, M. (2006). General Literature on the Audit Expectations Gap, Journal of Forensic Accounting, Vol. VIII, Nos. 1 & 2, January-December 2007

Paape, L. (2007). "Corporate Governance: The Impact on the Role, Position, and Scope of Services of the Internal Audit Function, Unpublished PhD Dissertation, Erasmus Research Institute of Management, Erasmus University, Netherlands.

Pedneault, S. (2009). Fraud 101 Techniques and Strategies for Understanding Fraud. John Wiley & Sons Inc. Hoboken, NJ.

Prawitt, D.F., N.Y. Sharp, and D.A. Wood. (2011) Internal Audit Outsourcing and the Risk of Misleading or Fraudulent Financial Reporting: Did Sarbanes-Oxley Get It Wrong? Comtemporary Accountign Research. 19-11.38-46

Singh, D. (2003). The Role of Third Parties in Banking Regulation and Supervision 4(3) Journal of International Banking Regulation

Stewart, J. and Subramaniam, N. (2010). " Internal Audit Independence and Objectivity: Emerging Research Opportunities" January 2010