Impact of Domestic Policies towards Agricultural Trade Liberalization and Market Reform on Food Security in Pakistan

Ahmad, Munir and Croraton, Caesar and Qayyum, Abdul and Iqbal, Muhammad and Dorosh, Paul (2005): Impact of Domestic Policies towards Agricultural Trade Liberalization and Market Reform on Food Security in Pakistan.

Abstract

Performance of the agriculture sector over the last four decades remained quite satisfactory with an average growth rate of 3.4% per annum. Still the country is far behind in its efforts to provide an acceptable level of dietary requirement to its people even at the aggregate level. The daily average availability of calories per person in the country is significantly lower than the other developing and developed nations. Though share of wheat is declining overtime, it is still the dominant source of total calories intake and thus plays a vital role in food security in the country. The government of Pakistan had been pursuing interventionist policies quite actively in agricultural inputs as well as outputs markets to ensure food security. Though most of these interventions have now been abolished, but some still remains. Particularly, wheat marketing mainly is being handled by the public sector. The comparison of incidentals of government-owned departments with that of the private traders clearly shows inefficiency of the former. In addition to cost difference, the corruption is pervasive in commodity marketing particularly in public sector. Eliminating the government interventions the results of the CGE model lead us to draw four major conclusions: 1) price of wheat would turn out to be too high to be affordable to the consumers; 2) Production may not increase much to compensate to bring the consumer prices down; 3) The loss in consumer surplus will be more than the producer gain; and 4) All household groups will face lower welfare except the urban non poor: The latter may look for cheaper food substitutes. The dynamic long-run effects have not been captured in this model. Though the existing system of procurement and distribution creates isincentives for the private sector to invest in wheat trade, it however may not be advisable to leave the wheat economy fully at the behest of the markets owing to the importance of wheat in household consumption and production. It is suggested that the government should slowly step out of the food market and let the market function freely. However, the system of effective monitoring and maintaining an optimal size of buffer stock for wheat can avoid extreme food price fluctuations and shortages in the country. The stock purchase and release by the government should be based on market prices.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Government Interventions, Wheat, Food Security, CGE MOdel
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q18 - Agricultural Policy ; Food Policy

References

Abedullah and M. Ali (2001) Wheat Self-sufficiency in Different Policy Scenarios and Their Likely Impacts on Producers, Consumers, and the Public Exchequer. The Pakistan Development Review, Vol. 40. No. 3.

Ali, Asghar (1992) Producer and Consumer Subsidy Equivalents of agricultural Policies in Pakistan: Concepts, Measurement and Implications. Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 1, No.1.

Amjad, R., and A. R. Kemal (1997) Macroeconomic Policies and their Impact on Poverty Alleviation in Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review 36:1.

Appleyard, D.R. (1987) Report on Comparative Advantage, Islamabad: Agricultural Prices Commission, Government of Pakistan.

Arif, G.M. and Munir Ahmad (2001) Poverty Across Agro-ecological Zones in Rural Pakistan. In Irrigation Against Rural Poverty: An Overview of Issues and Pro-Poor Intervention Strategies in Irrigation Agriculture in Asia. Edited by Intizar Hussain and Eric Biltonen. International Water Management Institute Colombo, Sri Lanka, and Asian Development Bank.

Arshad Zaman Associates (Pvt) Ltd. (1996) Wheat Subsidy: An Economic Review to Determine Welfare and Budgetary Effects. (Government of Sindh, Executive Policy Action and Coordination Organization, Sindh Special Development Project). (Draft Report)

Arshad, M. K (December 2005) Wheat Policy: Problems and Issues. http://www. pakissan.com/english/issues/wheat.policy.problems.and.issues.shtml

Ashfaq, M., G. Griffith, and K. Parton (2001) Welfare Effects of Government Interventions in the Wheat Economy of Pakistan. Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 4, No. 1.

CBR (various issues) Pakistan Customs and Tariffs. Islamabad: Central Bureau of Revenue.

Chaudhry, M.G. (2001) Taxation of Agriculture: Current Practice, Recommended Policies and Optimal Tax System for Pakistan. Institute of Developing Economies, Japan. V.R.F. Series No.35.

Chaudhry, M.G. and S. A. Sahibzada (1995) Agricultural Input Subsidies in Pakistan: Nature and Impact. The Pakistan Development Review, Vol. 34, No.4-II.

Chaudhry, M.G., S. Husaini, D.W. Larson, and K.C. Nobe (2000) Pakistan Agriculture Sector Review. A Study Undertaken for Asian Development Bank, Manila (T.A. No.3229-Pk).

Deomampo, N.R. (1997) Agricultural Marketing Systems in Asia and the pacific Region. In ‘Marketing Systems for Agricultural Products”. A Seminar Report, Tokyo: Asian Productivity Organisation.

Dorosh, P. (2004) Wheat Policy and Food Subsidies in Pakistan: Recent Developments. The World Bank, Washington D. C. (A Memo).

Dorosh, P. and A. Valdes (1990) Effect of Exchange Rate and Trade Policies on Agriculture in Pakistan. International Food Policy Research Institute, Research Report 84.

Dorosh, P., M. K. Niazi, and Hina Nazli (2004) A Social Accounting Matrix for Pakistan, 2001-02: Methodology and Results. South Asia Rural Development Unit of the World Bank, A Background Research Paper for the Pakistan Rural Factor Markets Study.

Ender, G. (1992) The Use of Producer and Consumer Subsidy Equivalents to Measure Government Intervention in Agriculture. Pakistan Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 1, No.1.

FAO (1998) Poverty Alleviation and Food Security in Asia: Lessons and Challenges. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

FAO (2000) Agriculture, Trade and Food Security Issues and Options in the WTO Negotiations from the Perspective of Developing Countries. Vol. II: Country Case Studies, Chapter 10 – Pakistan. Rome: FAO

FAO (2002) The Sate of Food Insecurity in the World 2001. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

FAO (2003) Food Security: Concepts and Measurement. In Trade Reforms and Food Security: Conceptualizing the Linkages. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

FAOSTATS (August 2005) Food Balance Sheets. http://apps.fao.org/lim500/nph-wrap.pl?Food Balance Sheet & Domain=Food Balance Sheet&language=english

Faruqee, R. (2005) Reforming Wheat Policy in Pakistan. http://www.passlivelihoods. org.uk/site_files%5Cfiles%5Creports%5Cproject_id_240%5CFINAL_Reforming%20Wheat %20Policy%20in%20Pakistan_Faruqee_WB0229.pdf

Faruqee, R., J. R. Coleman and LT. Scott (1997) Managing Price Risk in the Pakistan Wheat Market. The World Bank Economic Review, Vol.11, No.2: 263-292.

Gotsch, G.H. and G.T. Brown (1980) Prices Taxes and Subsides in Pakistan’s Agriculture: 1960-76. Washington D.C.: World Bank (World Bank Staff Working Paper No.387).

Hamid, N., E. Nabi and A. Nasim (1990) Trade, Exchange Rate, and Agricultural Pricing Policies in Pakistan. Washington D.C.: The World Bank.

Jafri, S. M. Younis (1999), Assessing Poverty in Paksitan, in A Profile of Poverty in Pakistan, Mahbub-ul-Haq Centre for Human Development, Islamabad.

Jamal, Haroon and Aisha Ghaus-Pasha (2000); Alarming Level of Poverty in Pakistan, The News International, Monday, March 20, 2000.

Kemal, A.R. (2003) Agricultural Growth and Rural Poverty in Pakistan: A Regional Analysis. A Background Paper for the “Rural Factor Markets in Pakistan”: A Project of the World Bank.

Kemal (2005) Pakistan’s Prospects for Achieving the Millennium Development Goals on Poverty and Hunger. In ‘The Role of Agriculture in Poverty Reduction in Pakistan’. Proceedings of the Seminar Organized by IFPRI, BNU and IDS on 12 March 2005, Lahore, Pakistan.

Khan, A.A. and Ahmad, Q. M. (2005) Agricultural Terms of Trade in Pakistan: Issues and Profitability and Standard of Living of the Farmers. Paper Presented at the PSDE General Meetings and Conference, January 2005, Islamabad, Revised May 2005.

Khan, M. Azeem, M. Iqbal, Iftikhar Ahmand and Manzoor. H. Soomro (2002) Economic Evaluation of Pesticide Use Externalities in the Cotton Zone of Punjab, Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review, Vol. 41, No. 4: 683-698.

Khan, M. (2003) Nutrition: A Factor for Poverty Eradication and Human Development. In Pakistan Human Condition Report 2003. Islamabad: Center for Research on Poverty Reduction and Income Distribution, Planning Commission of Pakistan.

Khushk, A.M. and L.E.D. Smith (1996) A Preliminary Analysis of the Marketing of Mango in Sindh Province, Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review, Vol.35, No.3: 241-255.

Khushk, A.M., M.S. Chaudhry, M.I. Lashari and A-Memon (nd) Production and Marketing of Selected Fruits in Pakistan: Constraints and Opportunities. Social Sciences Division, Pakistan Agriculture Research Council, Islamabad (A draft).

Kurosaki, T. (1996) Government Interventions, Market Integration, and Price Risk in Pakistan’s Punjab. The Pakistan Development Review, Vol.35, No.2: 129-144.

Lashari, M.I., J. A. Lund, A.M. Khuskh, and M.A. Memon (2002) Production and Marketing of Onion in Sindh, In K.M. Aujla, W. Malik and M. Sharif (ed), Socioeconomic Research Studies 2001-2002, , PARC, Islamabad.

Lofgren, H., R. L. Harris, S. Robinson with M. Thomas and Moataz El-Said (2002) A Standard Computable General Equilibrium (CGE) Model in GAMS. International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington D.C., Microcomputers in Policy Research Report No. 5.

Malik, S. J. (2003) Agricultural Growth and Rural Poverty in Pakistan. Manila: Asian Development Bank .

Mellor, J (1988) Lectures on Agricultural Growth and Employment. Lectures in Development Economics, No. 7. Islamabad: Pakistan Institute of Development Economics. Mohammad, F. (1977) Pricing Efficiency in Agricultural Markets in Pakistan. Pakistan Institute of Development Economics, Islamabad. (Research Report Series No.106).

Mohy-ud-Din, Q. (1992) Improving Marketing of Citrus Fruit in the Punjab Province. In Proceedings of the First International Seminar on Citriculture in Pakistan, 2-5 December. I.A. Khan (ed) University of Agriculture, Faisalabad.

Muslehuddin and T. A. But (1997) An Efficiency Appraisal of Government’s Wheat Marketing Operations. A report submitted to Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Livestock, Islamabad.

Mustafa, U, and M. Iqbal (1996) Inter-Provincial Trade of Fruits in Pakistan. Paper presented at “National Workshop on Agricultural Marketing held on 27-29 August, Quetta, Pakistan.

Naqvi, S. N. H., M. H. Khan and M. G. Chaudhry (1992) On Raising the Level of Economic and Social Well-Being of the People. Islamabad: Pakistan Institute of Development Economics.

Naqvi, S. N. H., M. H. Khan and M. G. Chaudhry (1994) How Fast Agriculture be Growing. Islamabad: Pakistan Institute of Development Economics.

Pakistan, Government of (2005) Economic Survey 2004-05. Islamabad: Finance Division.

Pakistan, Government of (2002a) Statistical Supplement 2001-2002. Islamabad: Finance Division.

Pakistan, Government of (2004 and previous issues) Agricultural Statistics of Pakistan 2003-04, Islamabad. Food, Agriculture and Livestock Division (Economic Wing).

Planning Commission and UNICEF (2004) National Nutrition Survey 2001-2002. Planning Commission, Government of Pakistan. Qureshi, S.K. (1974) The Performance of Village Markets for Agricultural Produce: A Case Study of Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review, Vol.3, No.3: 280-307.

Qureshi, S.K. (1993) Fiscal Impact of Government Interventions in Agriculture. In Agricultural Prices Study Prepared by John Mellor Associates, Inc. and Asianics Agro-Dev. International (Pvt.) Ltd.

Qureshi, S.K and G. M. Arif (1999) Profile of Poverty in Pakistan, 1998-99. Pakistan Institute of Development Economics, Islamabad.

Rizvi, S.A. (2003) New Agricultural Package. Pakistan and Gulf Economist, Vol. XXII, No 17 R.No. SS-189.

Siddiqui, S.A. (1979) Marketing of Agricultural Products in Sindh. Department of Agricultural Economics and Rural Sociology, Sindh Agriculture University, Tando Jam.

Slam, A. (2003) Agribusiness: From Parastatals to Private Trade. Country Paper on Pakistan, Prepared for the Workshop on ‘Agribusiness: From Parastatals to Private Trade’, Held at New Delhi, India, 15-16 December, 2003.

Smith, L.D.E., A.M. Khushk and M. Stockbridge (1999) Case Studies of Corruption in Agricultural Markets in Sindh Province, Pakistan, and Implications for Market Liberalization. Journal of International Food and Agribusiness Marketing, Vol.II, No.1, 19-41.

Tahir, Z. and K. Riaz (1997) Integration of Agricultural Commodity Markets in Punjab. The Pakistan Development Review, Vol.36, No.3: 263-273.

Turvey, R. and E. Cook (1976) Government Procurement and Price Support of Agricultural Commodities: A Case Study of Pakistan. Oxford Economic Papers, Vol.28, No.1: 102-112.

UNSP (2000) United Nations Statement on Food Security in Pakistan. Islamabad: The United Nations System in Pakistan.

WTO (January 2002) Trade Policy Review: First Press Release, Secretariat and Government Summaries.