Assessment of income distribution and a hypothetical flat tax reform in Hungary

Lelkes, Orsolya and Benedek, Dora (2007): Assessment of income distribution and a hypothetical flat tax reform in Hungary.

Abstract

The paper presents evidence on the effects of taxes and benefits on household incomes in Hungary referring to the 2006 system and a hypothetical flat tax reform. For this, a microsimulation model is used, which is based on a matched sample of an income and a consumption survey and administrative tax records. The Hungarian budget receives more revenues from VAT than from PIT. This has major implications on equity, as while PIT is progressive, VAT is regressive, imposing a higher tax burden on low-income households. We highlight the importance of tax allowances. The absolute amount of total tax allowances tends to increase with income, and the share of allowances within total incomes is around 5-7% in all income groups, except the top fifth, where it declines. Targeting is thus inadequate, and it is especially so in case of child support. Family tax allowance reaches the bottom decile only to a limited extent. This is in sharp contrast with the universal child benefit, which is well targeted to the poorest. The second part explores the likely impact of the introduction of a flat tax, where VAT and PIT rates are set at 20%, and a tax free bracket for low incomes is kept. We show that a budget neutral solution would have a largely regressive effect, where 70% of the population would lose, with a minority on the top of the distribution gaining.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Tax-benefit microsimulation, redistribution, flat tax reform, Hungary
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D3 - Distribution > D31 - Personal Income, Wealth, and Their Distributions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C8 - Data Collection and Data Estimation Methodology ; Computer Programs > C80 - General

References

Alm, J. (1996). “What Is an „Optimal Tax System?”. National Tax Journal, Vol. 49 no. 1, 117-133, Atkinson, A.B., Stiglitz, J.E., (1976), “The design of tax structure: direct versus indirect taxation”. Journal of Public Economics 6, 55– 75. Benedek D., R. Firle and Á. Scharle (2006). “Degree and efficiency of redistribution”. Ministry of Finance Working Papers No. 17, Hungary Benedek D., Lelkes O., Scharle Á. és Szabó M. (2006). „A magyar államháztartási bevételek és kiadások szerkezete 1991-2004 között [The structure of general government expenditure and revenues in Hungary, 1991-2004].” Közgazdasági Szemle 53: 119-143 Benedek D., Lelkes O. (2005). „Assesment of Income Distribution in Hungary using a Microsimulation model”. Ministry of Finance Working Papers No. 10, Hungary Boadway, R., M. Marchand and P. Pestieau (1994). “Towards a Theory of Direct-Indirect Tax Mix”. Journal of Public Economics 55, 71–88. Förster, M. F., Tóth I. Gy. (1997). "Poverty, inequalities and social policies in the Visegrád countries." Economics of Transition 5(2): 505-510. Förster, M. F. and I. G. Tóth (2001). "Child poverty and family transfers in the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland." Journal of European Social Policy 11(4): 324-341 Immervol, H., O'Donoghue, C., Sutherland, H., (1999). “An introduction to EUROMOD.” EUROMOD Working Paper No. EM0/99. Ivanova, A., M. Keen and A. Klemm (2005). "The Russian 'Flat Tax' Reform." Economic Policy 20(43): 397-444. Central Statistical Office (2004), Háztartás-statisztikai közlemények, 25. szám, 2004. I. félév, Central Statistical Office, Budapest. Retrieved on 10 January 2005 from: http://portal.ksh.hu/pls/ksh/docs/hun/xftp/idoszaki/haztart/haztart0406.pdf Lelkes, O. (2000). “A great leap towards liberalism? The Hungarian welfare state.” International Journal of Social Welfare 9(2): 92-102. Lelkes, O. (2006). “Tasting Freedom: Happiness, religion and economic transition.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 59(2): 173-194. Lelkes, O (2007, forthcoming). “Tax-benefit microsimulation models in Eastern Europe.” International Journal of Microsimulation Ministry of Finance, Hungary (2007). “A központi költségvetés előzetes mérlege.” [Balance sheet of the central government, preliminary figures]. Retrieved on 15 July 2007 from www.pm.gov.hu Okun, A. M. (1975). “Equality and Efficiency: the Big Trade-Off.” Washington, The Brookings Institution Redmond, G. (1999). “Incomes, incentives and the growth of means-testing in Hungary.” Fiscal Studies 20(1): 77-99 Saez, E. (2002). “The desirability of commodity taxation under non-linear income taxation and heterogeneous tastes.” Journal of Public Economics 83, 217– 230. Sutherland, H., H. Levy and A. Paulus (2006). “The effects of taxes and benefits on income distribution in the EU.” In: Final Report of the Network on Social Inclusion and Income Distribution. European Observatory on the Social Situation, financed by the European Commission (DG Employment, Social Affairs and Equal Opportunities) Retrieved on 16 July 2007 from http://ec.europa.eu/employment_social/social_situation/docs/sso2005_social_inclusion_report.pdf Szivós P., Rudas T., Tóth I. Gy., (1998). “TÁRSZIM97 Mikroszimulációs modell az adók és támogatások hatásvizsgálatára.” [Microsimulation model for analysing the impact of taxes and benefits]. TÁRKI Társadalompolitikai tanulmányok 10., TÁRKI, Budapest. TÁRSZIM 2005 Professional microsimulation modell v3.2. Manual. TÁRKI Rt., Budapest Tóth, I. Gy. (2005). “Jövedelemeloszlás. A gazdasági rendszerváltástól az uniós csatlakozásig” [Income Distribution. From Economic Transition to the Accession to the European Union]. Budapest, Századvég Kiadó. Andorka Rudolf Társadalomtudományi Társaság. N., A. Gábos, P. Szivós and V. Györgyi (2006). Euromod I-CUE Feasibility Study: Hungary. The 2005 Tax-Benefit System. Vienna, European Centre, Retrieved on 10 July 2007 from http://www.euro.centre.org/icue