External determinants of small business survival – The overwhelming impact of GDP and other environmental factors and a new proposed framework

GUIMARÃES BARBOSA, EVALDO (2016): External determinants of small business survival – The overwhelming impact of GDP and other environmental factors and a new proposed framework.

Abstract

This article claims that the basic relationships between, on the one side, the small firms’ hazard of exit, and, on the other side, the GDP growth rate and the industry growth rate are U-shaped. This means that there are more births and deaths for this segment of manufacturing enterprises during both cyclical downturns and booms in the economy. Higher competition in the economy in the first case comes from necessity entrepreneurs and in the second case from opportunity ones. The article also claims that the quadratic specification would rarely be the most adequate, since other combinations of different pairs of exponents would certainly better capture nuances of the relationships being regressed, in view of the fact that the actual U-shaped relationship is rarely symmetric. This is exactly why the artificial exclusive monotonic fitting normally produces parameter estimates that signalize the existence of a decreasing relationship. So, what may wonder many people, the invariably detected inverse relationship is not caused by the second half segment (where the economic upturns occur) of the continuous of the GDP growth rate, but rather by the first (where the economic downturns occur), whose impact on the hazard of exit is normally stronger. Also, even a direct relationship may occur because of this asymmetry and findings of lack of statistical significance result from a misguided attempt to fit a linear specification to a perfect, or almost perfect, symmetrical actual U-shaped relationship. The article conclusively claims that these realizations, and the fact that authors overfit by specifying contemporaneously the GDP growth rate, the industry growth rate and the industry entry rate, explain findings in the extant literature that are awkward, unexpected and embarrassing and interpretations that are many times completely inapplicable.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Small business; Survival determinants; GDP growth; Cox regression
• Subjects: M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M2 - Business Economics > M21 - Business Economics

References

Anagnostaki, V. and H. Louri (1995), Entry and exit from Greek manufacturing industry: a test of the symmetry hypothesis, International Review of Applied Economics 9(1): 86-95.

Audretsch, David B. (1995), Innovation, growth and survival, International Journal of Industrial Organization - Special issue: the Post Entry Performance of Firms 13(4):441-57.

Audretsch, David B., Patrick Houweling and A. Roy Thurik (2004), Industry Evolution: Diversity, Selection and the Role of Learning, International Small Business Journal 22(4): 331–48.

Audretsch, David B. and Talat Mahmood (1995), New Firm Survival: New Results Using a Hazard Function, Review of Economics and Statistics 97:97–103.

Barbosa, Evaldo Guimarães (2009), Common Determinants of the Firm’s Capital Structure and Business Survival – The Case of Very Small Enterprises of Traditional Manufacturing Sectors in Brazil, Charleston, SC, USA.

Barbosa, Evaldo Guimarães (2016), Determinants of Small Business Survival: The Case of Very Small Enterprises of the Traditional Manufacturing Sectors in Brazil, Working Paper.

Barbosa, Evaldo Guimarães (2016b), The Relationships Between, on the one hand, Size, Growth and Age of the Firm and, on the other hand, Small Business Survival – A Constructive Critique and a Proposal of a New Framework, Working Paper.

Bertin, Amy L., Timothy F. Bresnahan and Daniel M. G. Raff (1996), Localized Competition and the Aggregation of Plant-Level Increasing Returns: Blast Furnaces, 1929-1935, Journal of Political Economy 104(2): 241-66.

Boeri, Tito and Lutz Bellmann (1995), Post-entry behaviour and the cycle: Evidence from Germany, International Journal of Industrial Organization 13: 483-500.

Buehler, Stefan, Christian Kaiser and Franz Jaeger (2006), Merge or Fail? The Determinants of Mergers and Bankruptcies in Switzerland, 1995-2000, Economics Letters 90(1):88–95.

Buehler, Stefan, Christian Kaiser and, Franz Jaeger (2012), The geographic determinants of bankruptcy: evidence from Switzerland, Small Business Economics 39:231–251.

Bunn, Philip and Victoria Redwood (2003), Company accounts based modelling of business failures and the implications for financial stability, Working Paper no. 210, Bank of England.

Calá, Carla Daniela (2014), Regional Issues on Firm Entry and Exit in Argentina: Core and Peripheral Regions, PhD Dissertation, Department of Economics, Universitat Rovira i Virgili, Reus, Argentina.

Calá, Carla Daniela (2015), Firm Dynamics in Developing Countries: A Single Policy for all Regions?, Working paper, Facultad de Ciencias Económicas y Sociales (Universidad Nacional de Mar del Plata) Funes - Mar del Plata (Argentina).

Carreira, Carlos and Paulino Teixeira (2011), The shadow of death: analysing the pre-exit productivity of Portuguese manufacturing firms, Small Business Economics 36:337–51.

Christie, Tamoya and David L. Sjoquist (2012), New Business Survival in Georgia: Exploring the Determinants of Survival Using Regional Level Data, Growth and Change 43(1):110–42.

Disney, Richard, Jonathan Haskel and Ylva Heden (2003), Entry, Exit and Establishment Survival in UK Manufacturing, The Journal of Industrial Economics 51, Issue 1 (March): 91–112.

Everett, Jim and John Watson (1998), Small Business Failure and External Risk Factors, Small Busines Economics 11(4):371-90.

Falk, Martin (2012), A survival analysis of ski lift companies, Tourism Management xxx: 1-14.

Farinha, Luisa A. (2005), The Survival of New Firms: Impact of Idiosyncratic and Environmental Factors, Financial Stability Report 2005, Banco de Portugal.

Feizpour, Mohammad Ali, Hossain Hajikhodazadeh and Abolfazl Shahmohammadi Mehrjardi (2014), Life Duration of New Firms in Iranian Manufacturing Industries Using Cox Proportional Hazard Model, Iranian Economic Review 18(3):133-56.

Fernandes, Ana M. and Caroline Paunov (2015), The Risks of Innovation: Are Innovating Firms Less Likely to Die?, The Review of Economics and Statistics 97(3):638-53. July.

Fotopoulos, Giorgios and Helen Louri (2000a), Determinants of Hazard Confronting New Entry: Does Financial Structure Matter?, Review of Industrial Organization 17:285-300.

Andraz, Georgette, J. Sant’ana Fernandes, Cristina Gonçalves and J. Rodrigo Guerreiro (2015), Portuguese manufacturing industry: determinants of new firm entry, Tourism & Management Studies 11(2): 138-45.

Georgios Fotopoulos (2014), The Determinants of Firm Entry and Exit into Greek Manufacturing Industries: Sectoral, Temporal and Spatial Variation, Ph.D. Thesis, The London School of Economics and Political Science, University of London.

Geroski, Paul A. (1995), What do we know about entry?, International Journal of Industrial Organization - Special issue: the Post Entry Performance of Firms 13:421-40.

Geroski, Paul A., José Mata and Pedro Portugal (2010), Founding Conditions and The Survival of New Firms, Strategic Management Journal 31(5):510–29.

Gimeno, J., T. Folta, A. Cooper, C. Woo (1997), Survival of the fittest? Entrepreneurial human capital and the persistence of underperforming firms, Administrative Science Quarterly 42: 750-83.

Harris, R. and Q.C. Li (2010), Export-market dynamics and the probability of firm closure: evidence for the United Kingdom, Scottish Journal of Political Economy 57(2):145-68.

Helmers, Christian and Mark Rogers (2010), Innovation and the Survival of New Firms in the UK, Review of Industrial Organization 36(3): 227-48.

Holmes, Phil, Paul Braidford and Ian Stone (2010), An analysis of new firm survival using a hazard function, Applied Economics 42(2).

Hosmer, David W. Jr. and Stanley Lemeshow (1999), Applied Survival Analysis – Regression Modeling of Time to Event Data, John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY.

Ilmakunnas, Pekka and Jukka Topi (1999), Microeconomic and Macroeconomic Influences on Entry and Exit of Firms, Review of Industrial Organization 15: 283–301.

Jensen, Paul H., Elizabeth Webster and Hielke Buddelmeyer (2008), Innovation, technological conditions and new firm survival, The Economic Record 84:434-48.

Klapper, Leora and Christine Richmond (2011), Patterns of business creation, survival and growth: Evidence from Africa, Labour Economics 18: S32–S44.

Low, Murray B. and Ian C. MacMillan (1988), Entrepreneurship: Past Research and Future Challenges, Journal of Management 14(2):139-61.

Mahmood, Talat (1992), Does the Hazard Rate of New Plants Vary between High-and-Low-Tech Industries?, Small Business Economics 4(3):201–210.

Mata, José, Pedro Portugal and Paulo Guimarães (1995), The survival of new plants: Start-up conditions and post-entry evolution, International Journal of Industrial Organization 13:459-81.

Oh, Inha, Almas Heshmati, Chulwoo Baek and Jeong-Dong Lee (2009), Comparative Analysis of Plant Dynamics by Size: Korean Manufacturing, The Japanese Economic Review 60(4): 512-38. December.

Resende, Marcelo, Vicente Cardoso and Luis Otávio Façanha (2016), Determinants of survival of newly created SMEs in the Brazilian manufacturing industry: an econometric study, Empirical Economics 50(4):1255-74.

Shiferaw, Admasu (2009), Survival of private sector manufacturing establishments in Africa: The role of productivity and ownership, World Development, Elsevier 37(3):572-84.

Stonebraker, Robert J. (1979), Turnover and Mobility among the 100 Largest Firms: An Update, The American Economic Review 69(5): 968-73.

Strotmann, Harald (2007), Entrepreneurial Survival, Small Business Economics 28:87–104.

Varum, Celeste, Vera Catarina Rocha and Hélder Valente da Silva (2014), Economic slowdowns, hazard rates and foreign ownership, International Business Review 23:761–73.

Wennekers, Sander, André van Stel, Roy Thurik and Paul Reynolds (2005), Nascent Entrepreneurship and the Level of Economic Development, Small Business Economics 24:293-309.

Wennekers, Sander, André van Stel, Martin Carree and Roy Thurik (2010), The Relationship between Entrepreneurship and Economic Development: Is It U-Shaped?, Foundations and Trends in Entrepreneurship 6(3): 167-237.