The elusive quest for the subsistence line How much does the cost of survival vary between populations?

Lindgren, Mattias (2015): The elusive quest for the subsistence line How much does the cost of survival vary between populations?

Abstract

The subsistence line, defined as the lowest possible income that can sustain a population, depends on several factors that vary between populations. For simplicity, however, the line is typically assigned a fixed dollar value, so that it represents subsistence under average conditions. We explore how much the line may differ across populations if we take relative prices, age composition, heights and climate into account. We estimate the cost of the physical minimum requirements, since this is the quantifiable part of the subsistence line. The variation of the physical minimum can shed light on the variation of the subsistence line, even though the latter is likely to be significantly higher than the physical minimum.

Our physical minimum line, under baseline assumptions, is 0.67$ per day in 2005 international prices. Differences in prices between our cases imply physical minimum lines that vary between 50% and 150% of the baseline. The range of potential heights implies lines between 84% and 115% of the baseline and the range of age compositions implies lines between 97% and 110% of the baseline. The effect of climate is by assumption small, less than 5%. We cautiously suggest that relative prices is the first thing to take into account if we want to improve the subsistence line, whereas differences in the age composition is less of a concern.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• English Title: How much does the cost of survival vary between populations?
• Language: English
• Keywords: subsistence line, poverty, living standard, income estimate
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D3 - Distribution > D31 - Personal Income, Wealth, and Their Distributions; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E0 - General > E01 - Measurement and Data on National Income and Product Accounts and Wealth ; Environmental Accounts; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I32 - Measurement and Analysis of Poverty; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O10 - General; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O15 - Human Resources ; Human Development ; Income Distribution ; Migration

References

Abrahamsson, Andersson, Becker & Nilsson (2006), 'Näringslära för Högskolan'

A'hearn, Peracchi & Vecchi (2009), 'Height and the normal distribution: evidence from italian military data', Demography, volume 46, number 1

Allen (2009), 'The British Industrial revolution in Global perspective', Cambridge

Allen (2013A), 'Poverty lines in history, theory, and current international practice', Working Paper

Allen (2013B), “The high wage economy and the industrial revolution: a restatement”,Discussion paper in economic and social history, number 115

Appleton, Emwanu, Kagugube & Muwonge (1999), 'Changes in povery in Uganda, 1992-1997', Paper provided by Centre for the Study of African Economies, University of Oxford in its series CSAE Working Paper Series with number 1999-22.

Bairoch (1979), 'Écarts internationaux des niveaux de vie avant la Révolution industrielle ',In: Annales. Économies, Soiétés, Civilisations. 34e année, N. 1. pp 145-171.

Bairoch (1993), 'Economics & World History. Myths and Paradoxes.', The university of Chicago press

Banerjee (2012), 'Transcript: The surprising truth about life on less than 1$ a day', Talk atChatham House

Banerjee & Dufflo (2006), 'The economic lives of the poor', Working paper october 2006.

Banerjee & Dufflo (2011), 'Poor economics. A radical rethinking of the way to fight global poverty.'

Baqui, Black, Arifeen, Hill, Mitra & Sabir (1998), 'Causes pf childhood deaths in Bangladesh: results of a nationwide verbal autopsy study', Bulletin of the World health organization 76 (2): 161-171

Baten (2006), 'Global height trends in industrial and devloping countries, 1810-1984: an overview', Paper presented at XIV International economic history congress, 21-25, August, 2006, Helsinki

Baten & Blum (2012), 'Growing Taller, but Unequal: Biological Well-Being in World Regions and Its Determinants, 1810-1989.” ', Economic History of Developing Regions. The data was downloaded from the Clio-Infra site in 2013.

Bengtsson & Poppel (2011), 'Socioeconomic inequalities in death from past to present: an introduction', Explorations in Economic History 48; 343-356

Bengtsson, Campbell, Lee, etal (2004), 'Life under pressure. Mortality and living standards in Europe and Asia, 1700-1900.', MIT

Blum (2011), 'Worldwide inequality, living standards and its determinants during the 19th and 20th centuries', Dissertation, university of Tübingen

Bolt & Hillbom (2013), 'Social structures and income distribution in colonial sub-saharan africa: the case of bechuanaland protectorate 1936-1964', Paper presented at the swedish economic history meeting, 4-5 october 2013, Lund

Borgonha, Shetty & Kurpad (2000), 'Total energy expenditure & physical activity level in chronically energy deficient Indian males measured by the doubly labelled water technique', Indian Journal of Medical Research 111; 138-46

Broadberry, Campbell, Klein, Overton, Leeuwen (2011), 'British economic growth, 1270-1870: an output based approach', Working paper, 18 december 2011

Cafiero (NA), 'Advances in hunger measurement. Traditional FAO methods and recent innovations',

Carlson-Kanyama & Boström-Carlsson (2001), 'Energy use for cooking and other stages in the life cycle of food. A study of wheat, spaghetti, pasta, barley, rice, potatoes, couscous and mashed potatoes', Forskningsgruppen för miljöstrategiska studier, report no 160

Carmody & Wrangham (2009), “The energetic significance of cooking”, Journal of human evolution 57, 379-391

Clark (2006), 'The file "England prices and wages since 13th (Clark)", downloaded 2013 from Global price and income history group, available at: http://gpih.ucdavis.edu/Datafilelist.htm',

Cliggett (2005), 'Grains from Grass: Aging, Gender, and Famine in Rural Africa',

Coleman-Jensen, Nord, Andrews & Carlson (2011), “Household food security in the United States in 2010”, USDA Economic Research Report Number 125.

Collins (1995), 'The limit to human adaption to starvation', Nature medicine, volume 1, number 8

Collins, Morduch, Rutherford and Ruthven (2009), “Portfolios of the poor. How the wolrd’s poor live on $2 a day”

Dikhanov and Swanson (2010), “Comment: Maddison and Wu: ‘Measuring China’s economic performance’”, World Economics 11 (1)

Dinour, Bergen & Yeh (2007), “The food insecurity-obesity paradox: a review of the literature and the role food stamps may play.”, J Am Diet Assoc. 2007 Nov; 107(11): 1952-61.

Dufour & Piperata (2008), 'Energy expenditure among farmers in developing countries: what do we know?', American journal of Human Biology 20: 249-258

Dugas, Harders, Merrill, Ebersole, Shoham, Rush, Forrester, Durazo-Arvizu & Luke (2011), 'Energy expenditure in adults living in developing compared with industrialized countries: a meta-analysis of doubly labeled water studies', The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 93: 427-41

Durnin (1992), 'Low body mass index, physical work capacity and physical activity level', In "The functional significance of low body mass index", edited by James & Ralph. Proceedings of an IDECG workshop held in Rome, Italy, November 4-6, 1992.

El Ghoch, Alberti, Capelli, Calugi & Grave (2012), 'Resting energy expenditure in anorexia nervosa: measured versus estimated', Journal of nutrition and metabolism, Article ID 652932

Endicott (1999), 'The batek of peninsular Malaysia', In "The Cambridge encyclopedia of Hunters and Gatherers", edited by Lee & Daly

FAO (1996), 'The Sixth World Food Survey'

FAO (2013), 'Food security indicators, revision March 15, 2013', Data file downloaded from: http://www.fao.org/economic/ess/ess-fs/ess-fadata/en/

FAO (jointly with WHO & UNU) (2001), 'Human energy requirements. Report of a joint FAO/WHO/UNU expert consultation.'

Ferro-Luzzi, Petracchi, Kuriyan & Kurpad (1997), 'Basal metabolism of weight-stable chronically undernourished men and women: lack of metabolic adaption and ethnic differences', The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition , 66: 1086-93

Floud, Fogel, Harris & Hong (2011), 'The changing body. Health, nutrition, and human development in the western world since 1700'

Garille & Gass (1999), 'Stigler's diet problem revisisted', Operations research, volume 49, number 1.

Goldberg & Black (1998), 'Assessment of the validity of reported energy intakes - review and recent developments', Scandinavian journal of nutrition, volume 42: 6-9

Gray (1995), 'Social and biological consequences of nutritional adaption: do the costs outweight the gains?', Totem: The University of Western Ontario Journal of Anthropology. Volume 2, Issue 1, Article 7.

Henry (2005), 'Basal metabolic rate studies in humans: measurement and development of new equations', Public health nutrition 8 (7A); 1133-1152

Henry (2001), 'The biology of human starvation: some new insights', Nutrition Bulletin, 26, 205-211

Henry (2012), 'How much food does man require? New insights', Nutrition Bulletin, 37, 241-246

Human Mortality Database (2013), 'University of California, Berkeley (USA), and Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research (Germany). Available at www.mortality.org or www.humanmortality.de (data downloaded 2013, august)',

IHME (Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation) (2013), 'Data visualizations', Accessed 2014 Januari, from: http://www.healthmetricsandevaluation.org/tools/data-visualizations

Irena, Ross, Salama & Collins (2013), 'Anthropometric predictors of mortality in undernourished adults in the Ajiep feeding programme in southern Sudan', The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 98: 335-9

James (1992), 'Introduction: the challange of adult chronic energy deficiency', In "The functional significance of low body mass index", edited by James & Ralph. Proceedings of an IDECG workshop held in Rome, Italy, November 4-6, 1992.

Kothari (2005), 'Economic, social and cultural rights. Report of the special rapporteur on adequate housing as a component of the right to an adequate standard of living',

Krishna (2010), 'One illness away. Why people become poor and how they escape poverty.',

Kungliga socialstyrelsen (1961), 'Konsumentpriser och indexberäkningar åren 1931-1959', Sveriges officiella statistik, Priser och konsumtion, Stockholm 1961

Kurpad, Muthayya & Vaz (2005), 'Consequences of inadequate food energy and negative energy balance in humans', Public health nutrition 8 (7A); 1053-1076

Lieberson (2004), 'How long can a person survive without food?', Scientific American, Monday, November 8, 2004

Lindgren (2014), 'GDP per capita by purchasing power parities', Gapminder Documentation 001 - version 13

Lipton (2012), 'Poverty: some issues', – paper based on a Centennial Lecture delivered at Bristol University on 9 June 2009.

Livi-Bacci (2007), 'A consise history of world population. Fourth edition',

Livsmedelsverket (2013), ”Livsmedelsdatabasen”, accessed 2013 august from http://www.slv.se/sv/grupp1/Mat-och-naring/Vad-innehaller-maten/Livsmedelsdatabasen-/

Luzer (2013), 'How lobsters got fancy', Passific Standard on-line, june 7, 2013

Maddison & Wu (2008), 'Measuring China's economic performance', World Economy, vol 9, no 2.

Milanovic (2013), 'The inequality possibility frontier: the extensions and new applications', Working Paper

Milanovic, Lindert & Williamson (2007), 'Measuring ancient inequality', MPRA Paper no. 5388

Mullainathan & Shafir (2013), “Scarcity. Why having too little means so much”

Naidu & Rao (1992), 'Body mass index: a measure of the nutritional status of Indian populations', In "The functional significance of low body mass index", edited by James & Ralph. Proceedings of an IDECG workshop held in Rome, Italy, November 4-6, 1992.

National Bureau of Statistics Tanzania (2002), 'Household budget survey 2000/01 Tanzania', NBES (National bureau of statistics Tanzania) (2002), 'Household budget survey 2000/01', Dar es Salaam, july 2002

Nordhaus (1996), “Do real-output measures and real-wage capture reality? The history of lighting suggests not”

Norgan & Ferro-Luzzi (1996 (on-line 2011)), 'Human adaption to energy undernutrition', Handbook of Physiology, Environmental Physiology

Overseas Development Institute (2014), “The chronic poverty report 2014-2015: The road to zero extreme poverty”, available at: http://www.odi.org/chronic-poverty

Payne & Lipton, with Longhurst, North & Treagust (1994), 'How third world rural households adapt to dietary stress. The evidence and the issues.', Food Policy review 2

Pednekar, Hakama, Hebert & Gupta (2008), 'Association of body mass index with all-cause and cause-specific mortality: findings from a prospective cohort study in Mumnbai (Bombay), India', International Journal of Epidimiology 37; 524-535

Persson (2010), ‘The End of the Malthusian Stagnation Thesis’, working paper, 26 april 201 version

Polito, Fabbri, Ferro-Luzzi, Cuzzolaro, Censi, Ciarapica, Fabbrini & Gianni (2000), 'Basal metabolic rate in anorixia nervosa: relation to body composition and leptin concentrations', The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition , 71; 1495-502

Pontzer, Raichlen, Wood, Mapulla, Racette & Marlowes (2012), 'Hunter-gatherer energetics and human obesity', PLOS One 7 (7)

Prentice, Coward, Davies, Murgatroyd, Black, Goldberg, Ashfor & Sawyer (1985), 'Unexpectedly low level of energy expenditure in healthy women', The Lancet, june 22, 1985

Pritchet (1997), 'Divergence, Big time', The Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 11, No. 3 (Summer, 1997), pp. 3-17

Ravallion, Chen & Sangraula (2008), 'Dollar a day revisited', World bank Policy Research Working Paper 4620

Ravallion, Datt, van de Walle (1991), 'Quantifying absolute povery in the developing world', Review of income and wealth, series 37, number 4.

Ravallion (2014), “Are the world’s poorest being left behind”, NBER working paper 20791

Rotimi, Okosun, Johnson, Owoaje, Lwaoyin, Asuzu, kaufman, Adeyemo & Cooper (1999), 'The distribution and mortality impact of chronic energy deficiency among adult Nigerian men and women', European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 53: 734-739

Sauvaget, Ramadas, Thomas, Vinoda, Thara & Sankaranarayanan (2008), 'Body mass index, weight change and mortality risk in a prospective study in India', International Journal of Epidimiology 37; 990-1004

Schneider (2012), 'Real wages and the family: adjusting real wages to changing demography in pre-modern England', University of Oxford, Discussion Papers in Economic and Social History, number 99.

Schön & Krantz (2012), “Swedish Historical National Accounts 1560―2010” Lund Papers in Economic History 123, Lund University.

Shetty (2005), 'Energy requirements of adults', Public health nutrition 8 (7A); 994-1009

Shetty & James (1994), 'Body mass index - a measure of chronic energy deficiency in adults', FAO food and nutrition papers 56

Smith etal (2010), 'Wealth transmission and inequality among hunter-gatherers', Current Anthropology. Volume 51, number 1.

Speakman & Westerterp (2010), 'Associations between energy demands, physical activity, and body composition in adult humans between 18 and 96 y of age', The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 92:826-34

Stigler (1945), 'The cost of subsistence', Journal of farm economics, volume 27, number 2.

Svedberg (2002), 'Undernutrition overestimated', Economic Development and Cultural Change Vol. 51, No. 1 (October 2002), pp. 5-36"

Walker etal (2006), 'Growth rates and life histories in twenty-two small scale societies.', American journal of Human Biology 18: 295-311

van Zanden, Baten, Foldvari & van Leeuwen (2013), 'The Changing Shape of Global Inequality 1820–2000; Exploring a New Dataset', Review of Income and Wealth 60 (2), pages 279–297, June 2014

Westerterp (2013), 'Physical activity and physical activity induced energy expenditure in humans: measurement, determinants, and effects', Frontiers in physiology, volume 4, article 90

WHO (1995), 'Physical status: the use and interpretation of anthropometry', Report of a WHO expert committee

WHO (2013), 'The dataset 'BMI females % moderate and severe thinness (<=17) '', Accessed 2013 August, from: http://apps.who.int/bmi/index.jsp?introPage=intro_3.html

Williamson (2014), 'What Was the U.K. GDP Then?', MeasuringWorth

World bank (1995), 'Senegal. An assessment of living conditions', Report no. 12517-SE

World Bank data (2013A), 'GDP deflator (base year varies by country)’, accessed august 2013, from: http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.DEFL.ZS

World Bank data (2013B), ‘PPP conversion factor, GDP (LCU per international $)’, accessed august 2013, from: http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/PA.NUS.PPP

World Bank data (2013C), ‘GDP per capita, PPP (constant 2005 international $)’, accessed august 2013, from: http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.PP.KD

World Bank data (2013D), ‘PovcalNet’, accessed august 2013, from: http://iresearch.worldbank.org/PovcalNet/index.htm

World Value Survey (2014). WORLD VALUES SURVEY Wave 6 2010-2014 OFFICIAL AGGREGATE v.20141107. World Values Survey Association (www.worldvaluessurvey.org). Aggregate File Producer: Asep/JDS, Madrid SPAIN.

World Population Prospects (2010A), 'Extended Model Life Tables', Downloaded from http://esa.un.org/wpp/Model-Life-Tables/download-page.html Accessed 2012.

World Population Prospects (2010B), ”World Population Prospects: The 2010 Revision”, Population by Age data.

Wrangham & Conklin-Brittain (2003), 'Review ‘Cooking as a biological trait’', Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part A: Molecular & Integrative Physiology. Volume 136, Issue1, September 2003, Pages 35–46"