Competition and vested interests in taxis in Ireland: a tale of two statutory instruments

Gorecki, Paul (2016): Competition and vested interests in taxis in Ireland: a tale of two statutory instruments.

Abstract

This paper addresses, for the taxi market in Ireland, whether judicial, legislative and regulatory processes promote taxi users’ welfare or taxi license holders’ welfare. It is argued that the 2000 decision to remove quantitative restrictions on taxi numbers favoured taxi users; the 2010 decision to re impose such restrictions, with the exception of wheelchair accessible taxis) had the effect of favouring taxi license holders, while doing little to meet its declared object to increase the number of wheelchair accessible taxis and the ready availability of such vehicles for wheelchair customers. Whether the late 2000s/early 2020s will be a rerun of the late 1990s, with increasing waiting times for taxi users, is a moot point. An applicant refused a taxi license might, as in 2000, successfully bring a High Court case contesting the legal basis for the present quantitative restrictions. The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission might spark debate on taxi regulatory policy, while the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport might issue a policy direction to the National Transport Authority, the taxi regulator, requiring it to clarify the objectives and benchmarks for success of its existing prohibition on taxi licenses and to consider how best to create incentives for those with wheelchair accessible taxis to use them to service wheelchair users.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: regulation; taxi; wheelchair accessible
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L5 - Regulation and Industrial Policy

References

ANDREWS, P, P GORECKI & D MCFADDEN (2015) Modern Irish Competition Law. Netherlands: Wolters Kluwer.

BARRETT, S (2003) “Regulatory Capture, Property Rights and Taxi Deregulation: A Case Study.” Economic Affairs. Vol. 23, No. 4, Dec. pp. 34-40.

BARRETT, S (2011) “An Economic Analysis of the Public Transport Regulation Act, 2009.” Economic and Social Review, Vol. 42, No. 1, Spring, pp. 49-70.

COMMISSION FOR TAXI REGULATION (2009) Improving Accessibility to SPSV Services. Commission for Taxi Regulation’s Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA) of Proposed Actions for Building on Progress to Date. Dublin: the Commission.

COMPETITION AUTHORITY (2009) Submission on Economic Review. Submission S/09/001. Dublin: the Authority.

COMPETITION AUTHORITY (2014a) Submission to the National Transport Authority. Proposals to Make Regulations Under the Provisions of the Taxi Regulation Act 2013. Submission S/14/02. Dublin: the Authority.

COMPETITION AUTHORITY (2014b) Submission to the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport. National Transport Authority. Strategy Statement 2015-2017. Submission S/14/06. Dublin: the Authority.

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT, TOURISM & SPORT (2009) “The Need for the Minister of Transport to Introduce a Moratorium on Taxi Numbers.” Dail Adjournment Debate. 12 March. Press Release. Dublin: the Department.

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT, TOURISM & SPORT (2011) Ministerial Brief. March Dublin: the Department.

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT, TOURISM & SPORT (2012) Government Announces Major Changes for Taxi Sector – Minister Alan Kelly. Press release. 31 January. Dublin: the Department.

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT, TOURISM & SPORT (2016a) Ministerial Brief 2016. Dublin: the Department.

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT, TOURISM & SPORT (2016b) Key Issues. Ministerial Brief. Dublin: the Department.

DISABILITY FEDERATION OF IRELAND, IRISH WHEELCHAIR ASSOCATION, NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR THE BLIND OF IRELAND, NATIONAL TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE, NOT FOR PROFIT BUSINESS ASSOCIATION, REHABCARE, TRANSPORT PLANNING (INTERNATIONAL) LTD (2004) Towards an Accessible Taxi Service for All. Dublin: Disability Association of Ireland & ors.

FINGELTON, J, J EVANS & O HOGAN (1998) The Dublin Taxi Market: Re-Regulate or Stay Queuing? Studies in Public Policy: 3. Dublin: the Policy Institute.

GOODBODY ECONOMIC CONSULTANTS (GOODBODY) (2009) Economic Review of the Small Public Service Vehicle Industry. Dublin: Commission for Taxi Regulation.

GOODBODY ECONOMIC CONSULTANTS IN ASSOCIATION WITH INSTITUTE OF TRANSPORT ECONOMICS, NORWAY, & MILLWARD BROWN IMS (GOODBODY) (2005) National Review of Taxi, Hackney and Limousine Services. Dublin: Commission for Taxi Regulation.

GORECKI, P (2010) “The Recession, Budgets, Competition, and Regulation: Should the State Supply Bespoke Regulation?” in Tim Callan (ed) Budget Perspectives 2010. Dublin: ESRI, pp. 19-48.

GORECKI, P (2012) Regulating Small Public Service Vehicles in Ireland: Is There a Problem of Oversupply? Working Paper 441. Dublin: ESRI.

GORECKI, P (2013) “The Small Public Service Vehicle Market in Ireland: Regulation and the Recession.” Economic and Social Review, Vol. 44, Summer, No. 2, pp. 247-272.

GORECKI, P (2014a) Ex Post Assessment of Government Intervention in the Taxi market in Ireland: 1978-2014. Paper prepared for Working Party No. 2 on Competition and Regulation. Paris: OECD.

GORECKI, P. (2014b) “Taxi Regulation in Ireland: Will it be Different This Time?” ESRI Research Bulletin, 2014/02/05.

GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND (2016) A Programme for a Partnership Government. Dublin: Department of the Taoiseach.

INDECON INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC CONSULTANTS (INDECON) (2011) Economic Analysis of the Taxi Market. Report Submitted to the Department of Transport, Tourism & Sport. Dublin: Indecon.

JACOBS ENGINEERING IRELAND LIMITED (JACOBS) (2013) Review of Small Wheelchair Accessible Taxis. Dublin: NTA

NATIONAL DISABILITY AUTHORITY (2004) Towards Best Practice in Provision of Transport Services for People with Disabilities in Ireland. Dublin: National Disability Authority.

NATIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (NTA) (2014) Taxi Statistics for Ireland. Statistical Bulletin No 02/2014. Dublin: NTA.

NATIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (NTA) (2015a) Annual Report 2014. Dublin: NTA.

NATIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (NTA) (2015b) Using SPSV Online Service Vehicle Rentals. Dublin: NTA.

NATIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (NTA) (2015c) Taxi Statistics for Ireland. Statistical Bulletin No 03/2015. Dublin: NTA.

NATIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (NTA) (2016a). Vehicle Licences County and Category – 31th July 2016. Dublin: NTA. https://www.nationaltransport.ie/taxi-and-bus-licensing/taxi/taxi-statistics/vehicle-licences-county-and-category-30th-april-2015/

NATIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (NTA) (2016b) WAV16 – Wheelchair Accessible Vehicle Grant Scheme Waiting List. Press Release 20 April. Dublin: NTA.

NATIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (NTA) (2016c) Taxi Statistics for Ireland. Statistical Bulletin No 01/2016. Dublin: NTA.

NATIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (NTA) (2016d) Taximeter Survey 2015. Dublin: NTA.

NATIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (NTA) (2016e) “WAV16 Reopened August 2016.” SPSV Industry Update, Issue 34, August. Dublin: NTA.

WEIR, S (2011) “The Evolution of Taxi Policy in Ireland.” Journal of Public Affairs. Vol. 11, No. 2, May, pp. 80-87.

WHISH, R. & D. BAILEY (2015) Competition Law. Eighth Edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.