Theories of Risk: Testing Investor Behaviour on the Taiwan Stock and Stock Index Futures Markets

Clark, Ephraim and Qiao, Zhuo and Wong, Wing-Keung (2016): Theories of Risk: Testing Investor Behaviour on the Taiwan Stock and Stock Index Futures Markets. Published in: Economic Inquiry , Vol. 54, No. 2. (17 April 2015): pp. 907-924.

Abstract

Investor behavior towards risk lies at the heart of economic decision making in general and modern investment theory and practice in particular. This paper uses both the mean-variance (MV) criterion and stochastic dominance (SD) procedures to analyze the preferences for four of the most widely studied investor types in the Taiwan stock and stock index futures market. We find that risk averters (concave utility function) prefer spot to futures, whereas risk seekers (convex utility function) prefer futures to spot. Our findings also show that investors with S-shaped utility functions prefer spot (futures) to futures (spot) when markets move upward (downward). Finally, our results imply that investors with reverse S-shaped utility functions prefer futures (spot) to spot (futures) when markets move upward (downward). These results are robust with respect to sub-periods, spot returns including dividends and diversification. Although we do not check whether risk averters, risk seekers, and investors with S-shaped and reverse S-shaped utility functions actually exist in the market, we do show that their existence is plausible. The implications of our findings on market efficiency and the existence of arbitrage opportunities are also discussed in this study.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: stochastic dominance; risk aversion; risk seeking; prospect theory; behavioral economics; stock index futures
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General > C14 - Semiparametric and Nonparametric Methods: General; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General > C15 - Statistical Simulation Methods: General; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G12 - Asset Pricing ; Trading Volume ; Bond Interest Rates

References

Bai, Z.D., Hui, Y.C., Wong, W.K., and Zitikis, R. “Evaluating Prospect Performance: Making a Case for a Non-asymptotic UMPU Test.” Journal of Financial Econometrics, 10(4), 2012, 703-732.

Bai, Z.D., Li, H., Liu, H.X., and Wong, W.K. “Test Statistics for Prospect and Markowitz Stochastic Dominances with Applications.” Econometrics Journal, 14(2), 2011, 278-303.

Barberis, N., Huang, M., and Santos, T. “Prospect Theory and Asset Prices.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116, 2001, 1-54.

Benartzi, S., and R. Thaler. “Myopic Loss Aversion and the Equity Premium Puzzle.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110(1), 1995, 73-92.

Bishop, J.A., Formly, J.P., and Thistle, P.D. “Convergence of the South and Non-south Income Distributions.” American Economic Review, 82, 1992, 262-272.

Broll, U., Egozcue, M., Wong, W.K., and Zitikis, R. “Prospect Theory, Indifference Curves, and Hedging Risks.” Applied Mathematics Research Express, 2, 2010, 142-153.

Chan, C.Y., de Peretti, C., Qiao, Z., and Wong, W.K. “Empirical Test of the Efficiency of UK Covered Warrants Market: Stochastic Dominance and Likelihood Ratio Test Approach.” Journal of Empirical Finance, 19(1), 2012, 162-174.

Clark, E., Kassimatis, K. and Jokung, O. “Making inefficient market indices efficient.” European Journal of Operational Research, 209, 2011, 83-93.

Clark, E., and Kassimatis, K. “An Empirical Analysis of Marginal Conditional Stochastic Dominance.” Journal of Banking & Finance, 36, 2012, 1144–1151.

Davidson, R., and Duclos, J-Y. “Statistical inference for stochastic dominance and for the measurement of poverty and inequality.” Econometrica, 68, 2000, 1435-1464.

Egozcue, M., Fuentes García, L., Wong, W.K., and Zitikis, R. “Do Investors Like to Diversify? A study of Markowitz Preferences.” European Journal of Operational Research, 215(1), 2011, 188-193.

Egozcue, M., Wong, W.K., 2010. Gains from Diversification: A Majorization and Stochastic Dominance Approach. European Journal of Operational Research 200, 893-900.

Falk, H., and Levy, H. “Market Reaction to Quarterly Earnings’ Announcements: a Stochastic Dominance Based Test of Market Efficiency.” Management Science, 35, 1989, 425-446.

Fishburn, P.C., Stochastic Dominance in Nonlinear Utility Theory. in T.B. Fomby and T.K. Seo, eds., Studies in the Economics of Uncertainty (Springer-Verlag, New York),1989.

Fishburn, P.C., and G.A. Kochenberger. “Two-piece Von Neumann-Morgenstern Utility Functions.” Decision Sciences, 10, 1979, 503-518.

Fong, W.M., Wong, W.K. and Lean, H.H. “International Momentum Strategies: a Stochastic Dominance Approach.” Journal of Financial Markets, 8, 2005, 89-109.

Fong, W.M., Lean, H.H., and Wong, W.K. “Stochastic Dominance and Behavior towards Risk: the Market for Internet Stocks.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization , 68(1), 2008, 194-208.

Friedman, M., and Savage, L.J. “The Utility Analysis of Choices Involving Risk.” Journal of Political Economy, 56, 1948, 279-304.

Gasbarro, D., Wong, W.K., and Zumwalt, J.K. “Stochastic Dominance Analysis of iShares.” European Journal of Finance, 13, 2007, 89–101.

Guo, X., Post T, Wong, W.K., and Zhu, L. X. “Moment Conditions for Almost Stochastic Dominance.” Economics Letters, 124, 2014, 163–167.

Hanoch, G., and Levy, H. “The Efficiency Analysis of Choices Involving Risk.” Review of Economic Studies, 36, 1969, 335-346.

Hartley R., Farrell L. “Can Expected Utility Theory Explain Gambling?” American Economic Review, 92, 2002, 613-624.

Holt, C.A., Laury, S.K. “Risk aversion and incentive effects” American Economic Review, 92 , 2002, 1644-1655.

Jarrow, R. “The Relationship between Arbitrage and First Order Stochastic Dominance.” Journal of Finance, 41, 1986, 915-921.

Jensen M.C. “Risk, the Pricing of Capital Assets and the Evaluation of Investment Portfolios.” Journal of Business, 42, 1969, 167-247.

Kahnemann D., and Tversky A. “Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision Making under Risk.” Econometrica, 47, 1979, 263-291.

Keynes, J. M. A Treatise on Money (London: Macmillan 1930).

Lean, H.H., McAleer, M., and Wong, W.K. “Market Efficiency of Oil Spot and Futures: a Mean-Variance and Stochastic Dominance Approach.” Energy Economics, 32, 2010,979-986.

Lean, H.H., Wong, W.K., and Zhang, X. “Size and Power of Stochastic Dominance Tests.” Mathematics and Computers in Simulation, 79, 2008, 30-48.

Leshno, M., and Levy, H. “Preferred by “All” and Preferred by “Most” Decision Makers: Almost Stochastic Dominance.” Management Science, 48(8), 2002, 1074-1085.

Levy, H. Stochastic Dominance: Investment Decision Making Under Uncertainty. 2006, Springer, New York.

Levy M., and Levy H. “Prospect Theory: Much Ado about Nothing?” Management Science, 48, 2002. 1334-1349.

Levy H., and Wiener Z. “Stochastic Dominance and Prospect Dominance with Subjective Weighting Functions.” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 16, 1998, 147-163. Li, C.K., and Wong, W.K. “Extension of Stochastic Dominance Theory to Random Variables.” RAIRO Operations Research, 33(4), 1999, 509-524.

Markowitz, H.M. “The Utility of Wealth.” Journal of Political Economy, 60, 1952, 151-156.

Myagkov, M., and C.R. Plott “Exchange Economies and Loss Exposure: Experiments Exploring Prospect Theory and Competitive Equilibria in Market Environments.” American Economic Review, 87, 1997, 801-828.

Pennings, J.M.E., and A. Smidts. “The Shape of Utility Functions and Organizational Behavior.” Management Science, 49(9), 2003, 1251 -1263.

Markowitz, H.M. “The Utility of Wealth.” Journal of Political Economy, 60, 1952, 151-156.

Post T., and Levy H. “Does Risk Seeking Drive Stock Prices? A Stochastic Dominance of Aggregate Investor Preferences and Beliefs.” Review of Financial Studies, 18, 2005. 925-953.

Post T., Van Vliet P., and Levy H. “Risk Aversion and Skewness Preference.” Journal of Banking and Finance, 32, 2008, 1178-1187.

Quirk J.P., and Saposnik, R. “Admissibility and Measurable Utility Functions.” Review of Economic Studies, 29, 1962, 140-146.

Rothschild, M. and Stiglitz, J. “Increasing risk I: a Definition.” Journal of Economic Theory, 2, 1970, 225-243.

Samuelson, P.A., (1967), General Proof that Diversification Pays, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 2(1), 1-13.

Shalit, H. and Yitzhaki, S. “Marginal Conditional Stochastic Dominance.” Management Science, 40, 1994, 670-684.

Sharpe W.F. “Capital Asset Prices: Theory of Market Equilibrium under Conditions of Risk.” Journal of Finance, 19, 1964. 452-442.

Shefrin, H., and M. Statman. “Behavioral Aspect of the Design and Marketing of Financial Products.” Financial Management, 22(2), 1993, 123-134.

Sriboonchita, S., Wong, W.K., Dhompongsa, D., Nguyen, H.T., Stochastic Dominance and Applications to Finance, Risk and Economics. 2009, Chapman and Hall/CRC, Boca Raton, Florida.

Statman, M. “The diversification puzzle,” Financial Analysts Journal, 60, 2004, 44-53.

Thaler, R.H., and Johnson E.J. “Gambling with the House Money and Trying to Break Even: the Effects of Prior Outcomes on Risky Choice.” Management Science, 36, 1990, 643-660.

Treynor J.L. “How to Rate Management of Investment Funds.” Harvard Business Review, 43, 1965, 63-75.

Tversky, A., and D. Kahneman. “Advances in Prospect Theory: Cumulative Representation of Uncertainty.” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 5, 1992, 297-323.

Williams, C.A. Jr. “Attitudes toward Speculative Risks as an Indicator of Attitudes toward Pure Risks.” Journal of Risk and Insurance, 33(4), 1966, 577-586.

Wong, W.K. “Stochastic Dominance and Mean-Variance Measures of Profit and Loss for Business Planning and Investment.” European Journal of Operational Research, 182, 2007, 829-843.

Wong, W.K., and Chan, R. “Markowitz and Prospect Stochastic Dominances.” Annals of Finance, 4(1), 2008, 105-129.

Wong, W.K., and Li, C.K. “A Note on Convex Stochastic Dominance Theory.” Economics Letters, 62, 1999, 293-300.

Wong, W.K., and Ma, C. “Preferences over Meyer's Location-Scale Family.” Economic Theory, 37(1), 2008, 119-146.

Wong, W.K., Phoon, K.F., and Lean, H.H. “Stochastic Dominance Analysis of Asian Hedge Funds.” Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, 16(3), 2008, 204-223.