Disequilibrium as the origin, originality, and challenges of Clower's microfoundations of monetary theory

Plassard, Romain (2017): Disequilibrium as the origin, originality, and challenges of Clower's microfoundations of monetary theory.

Abstract

Robert W. Clower’s article “A Reconsideration of the Microfoundations of Monetary Theory” (1967) deeply influenced the course of modern monetary economics. On the one hand, it questioned Don Patinkin’s (1956) project to integrate monetary and Walrasian value theory. On the other hand, it was the fountainhead of the cash-in-advance models à la Robert J. Lucas (1980), one of the most widely used approaches to monetary theory since the 1980s. Despite this influence, Clower’s (1967) project to integrate monetary and value theory remains an enigma. My paper intends to resolve it. This is a difficult task since Clower never completed the monetary theory outlined in his 1967 article. To overcome this difficulty, I characterize the intellectual context from which Clower’s (1967) contribution emerged and have recourse to a reconstruction of his project. This reconstruction is based on the analysis of published and unpublished materials, written by Clower before and after the 1967 article. It is argued that Clower (1967) sought to elaborate a disequilibrium monetary theory whilst retaining the two pillars of Patinkin’s integration, i.e., the introduction of money into utility functions and the real-balance effect. I trace the origins, account for the originality, and discuss the challenges of this project.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: integration of monetary and value theory, microfoundations of macroeconomics, disequilibrium, Clower, Patinkin.
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B21 - Microeconomics; D - Microeconomics > D4 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design > D46 - Value Theory; D - Microeconomics > D5 - General Equilibrium and Disequilibrium

References

Archibald, G.C., and Richard, G. Lipsey. (1958). Monetary and Value Theory: A Critique of Lange and Patinkin, The Review of Economic Studies, 26(1), pp. 1-22.

Archibald, G.C., and Richard, G. Lipsey. (1960). Monetary and Value Theory: Further Comments, The Review of Economic Studies, 28(1), pp. 50-56.

D’Autume, A. (1985). Monnaie, croissance et déséquilibre, Paris : Economica.

Ball, R.J., and Ronald Bodkin. (1960). The Real Balance Effect and Orthodox Demand Theory: A Critique of Archibald and Lipsey, The Review of Economic Studies, 28(1), pp. 44-49.

Baumol, W.J. (1960). Monetary and Value Theory: Comments, The Review of Economic Studies, 28(1), pp. 29-31.

Benassy, J.P. (1975). Neo-Keynesian Disequilibrium Theory in a Monetary Theory, Review of Economic Studies, 42, pp. 503-523.

Benassy, J.P. (1975a). Disequilibrium Exchange in Barter and Monetary Economies, Economic Inquiry, 13, pp. 131-156.

Benassy, J.P. (1986). Macroeconomics: An Introduction to the Non-Walrasian Approach, Academic Press: Orlando.

Boianovsky, M. (2002). Simonsen and the early history of the cash-in-advance approach, European Journal for the History of Economic Thought, 9 (1), pp. 57-71.

Brunner, K. (1951). Inconsistency and Indeterminacy in Classical Economics. Econometrica, 19(2), pp. 152-173.

Burstein, ML., and Clower, R.W. (1960). On the Invariance of Demand for Cash and Other Assets, The Review of Economic Studies, 28(1), pp. 32-36.

Bushaw, D.W., and Robert W. Clower. (1957). Introduction to Mathematical Economics, Homewood: The Irwin Series in Economics.

Bridel, P. (1997). Money and General Equilibrium Theory. Cheltenham: Elgar.

Bridel, P. (2002). Patinkin, Walras and the ‘money-in-the-utility-function’ tradition. European Journal of History of Economic Thought, 9(2), pp. 268-292.

Clower, R.W. (1963). Classical Monetary Theory Revisited, Economica, 74(2), p. 318-323, Reprinted in Walker [1984], pp. 21-26.

Clower, R.W. (1964). Monetary History and Positive Economics, Journal of Economic History, 24, pp. 364-380, Reprinted in Walker [1984], pp. 59-77.

Clower, R.W. (1965). The Keynesian Counter-Revolution: A Theoretical Appraisal, in The Theory of Interest Rates, ed. F.H. Hahn and F.P.R Brechling [1965], pp. 103-125, Reprinted in Walker [1984], pp. 34-58.

Clower, R.W. (1965a). Classical Monetary Revisited: A Reply, Economica, 32(125), p. 73.

Clower, R.W. (1967). A Reconsideration of the Microfoundations of Monetary Theory, Western Economic Journal (now Economic Inquiry), 6, pp. 1-8, Reprinted in Walker [1984], pp. 81-89.

Clower, R.W. (1968). Comment: The Optimal Growth Rate of Money. Journal of Political Economy, 76(4), pp. 876-880.

Clower, R.W. (1969). Monetary Theory: Selected Readings, England: Penguin Books Ltd.

Clower, R.W. (1970). Is there an Optimal Money Supply, The Journal of Finance, Papers and Proceedings of the Twenty-Eight Annual Meeting of the American Finance Association New-York, 25(2), pp. 425-433, Reprinted in Walker [1984], pp. 128-137.

Clower, R.W. (1971). Theoretical Foundations of Monetary Policy, in Monetary Theory and Monetary Policy in the 1970s: Proceedings of the 1970 Sheffield Money Seminar, ed. G. Clayton, J.C. Gilbert, and R. Sedgwick, Oxford University Press: London, Reprinted in Walker [1984], pp. 107-119.

Clower, R.W. (1971a). The Keynesian Paradigm: An Attempt at Reconstruction. Manuscript. Robert Clower Papers, Box 2, David M. Rubenstein Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Duke University.

De Boyer des Roches, J. (2003). La pensée monétaire, Paris: Les solos.

Deleplace, G. (1999). Histoire de la pensée économique. Du royaume agricole de Quesnay au monde à la Arrow-Debreu, Paris : Dunod.

Frevert, P. (1968). Disequilibrium in a Macro-Economic Model. In Papers in Quantitative Economics, Quirck and Zarley: University of Kansas Press, pp. 359-371.

Grandmont, J.-M., and Laroque, G. (1976). On temporary Keynesian equilibria. Review of Economic Studies, 43, pp. 53-67.

Grossman, H.I. (1969). Theories of Markets without Recontracting. Journal of Economic Theory, 1, pp. 476-479.

Grossman, H.I. (1971). Money, Interest, and Prices in Market Disequilibrium. Journal of Political Economy, 79(5), pp. 943-961.

Friedman, M., and Anna Schwartz. (1963). A Monetary History of the United States, 1867-1960, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Grandmont, J-M., and Yves Younès. (1972). On the role of money and the existence of a monetary equilibrium. The Review of Economic Studies, 39, pp. 355-372.

Hahn, F.H. (1960). The Patinkin Controversy, The Review of Economic Studies, 28(1), pp. 37-43.

Hahn, F.H., and Takashi Negishi. (1962). A Theorem on Non-Tâtonnement Stability. Econometrica, 30, pp. 463-469.

Hahn, F.H. (1965). On Some Problems of Proving the Existence of an Equilibrium in a Monetary Theory, in Hahn and F.P.R Brechling [1965], pp. 126-136.

Hahn, F.H, and F.P.R., Brechling. (1965). The Theory of Interest Rates. Proceedings of a Conference held by the International Economic Association, London: Mac Millan and Co.

Hahn, F.H. (1970). Some Adjustment Problems, Econometrica, 38(1), pp. 1-17.

Hahn, F.H., and Kenneth J., Arrow. (1971). General Competitive Analysis. Holden-Day, INC and Oliver & Boyd: San Francisco.

Hickman, W.B. (1950). The Determinacy of Absolute Prices in Classical Economic Theory. Econometrica, 18 (1), pp. 9-20.

Hicks, J.R. (1935). A Suggestion for Simplifying the Theory of Money, in Critical Essays in Monetary Theory, Oxford: Claredon Press (1967).

Hicks, J. R. ([1939] 1946). Value and Capital, an inquiry into some Fundamental Principles of Economic Theory. 2nd ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Keynes, J. M. ([1936] 2007) The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Kohn, M. (1988). The Finance Constraint Theory of Money: A Progress Report, Economics Working Paper Archive, working paper, Levy Economics Institute.

Lange, O. (1942). Say’s Law: a Restatement and Criticism, in Lange O et al (eds), Studies in Mathematical Economics and Econometrics, Chicago.

Lange, O. (1945). Price Flexibility and Employment, San Antonio: Principia Press of Trinity University.

Leijonhufvud, A. On Keynesian economics and the Economics of Keynes. Oxford University Press: New York.

Leontief, W. (1950). The Consistency of the Classical Theory of Money and Prices. Econometrica, 18 (1), pp. 21-24.

Lucas, R. E. Jr. (1980). Equilibrium in a Pure Currency Economy, Economic Inquiry, 18 (2), pp 203-220.

Patinkin, D. (1956). Money, Interest and Prices. Evanston: Row Peterson.

Patinkin, D. ([1956] 1965). Money, Interest and Prices. Harper & Row: New-York.

Phipps, C.G. (1950). A Note on Patinkin’s ‘Relative Prices’. Econometrica, 18 (1), pp. 25-26.

Plassard, R. (2016). Clower’s volte-face regarding the Keynesian Revolution: Working paper.

Plassard, R. (2017). Searching for a General Theory of Adjustment Processes: A Reconstruction of Clower’s Disequilibrium Program of Microfoundations: Working paper.

Rakshit, M.K. (1965). Classical Monetary Theory Revisited: A Comment. Economica, 32(125), pp. 70-72.

Rebeyrol, A. (1999). La pensée économique de Walras, Dunod : Paris. Robertson, D.H. (1933). Saving and Hoarding. Economic Journal, 43(3), pp. 399-413.

Rubin, G. (2011). Oskar Lange and the influence of Walrasian theory during the Keynesian revolution. Working paper.

Samuelson, P.A. (1947). Foundations of Economic Analysis. New York: Atheneum.

Tsiang, S-C. (1966). Walras’ law, Say’s law and Liquidity Preference in General Equilibrium Analysis, International Economic Review, 7(3), pp. 329-345.

Uzawa, H. (1960). Walras’ Tâtonnement in the Theory of Exchange. Review of Economic Studies, 27, pp. 182-194.

Valavanis, S. (1955). A Denial of Patinkin’s Contradiction. Kyklos, 8 (4), pp. 351-368.

Walker, D.A. (1984). Money and Markets: Essays in Honor of Robert W. Clower. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Weintraub, E.R. (1979). Microfoundations: the compatibility of Microeconomics and Macroeconomics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Younès, Y. 1975. On the role of money in the process of exchange and the existence of a non-Walrasian equilibrium. Review of Economic Studies, 42, pp.489-501.