Robustness, Low Risk-Free Rates, and Consumption Volatility in General Equilibrium

Luo, Yulei and Nie, Jun and Young, Eric (2017): Robustness, Low Risk-Free Rates, and Consumption Volatility in General Equilibrium.

Abstract

This paper develops a tractable continuous-time recursive utility (RU) version of the Huggett (1993) model to explore how the preference for robustness (RB) interacts with intertemporal substitution and risk aversion and then affects the interest rate, the dynamics of consumption and income, and the welfare costs of model uncertainty in general equilibrium. We show that RB reduces the equilibrium interest rate and the relative volatility of consumption growth to income growth when the income process is stationary, but our benchmark model cannot match the observed relative volatility. An extension to an RU-RB model with a risky asset is successful at matching this ratio. The model implies that the welfare costs of uncertainty are very large.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Robustness, Precautionary Savings, the Permanent Income Hypothesis, Low Interest Rates, Consumption and Income Inequality, General Equilibrium
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E2 - Consumption, Saving, Production, Investment, Labor Markets, and Informal Economy; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E2 - Consumption, Saving, Production, Investment, Labor Markets, and Informal Economy > E21 - Consumption ; Saving ; Wealth

References

[1] Ahn, David, Syngjoo Choi, Douglas Gale, and Shachar Kariv (2014), “Estimating Ambiguity Aversion in a Portfolio Choice Experiment,” Quantitative Economics 5, 195-223.

[2] Anderson, Evan W., Lars Peter Hansen, and Thomas J. Sargent (2003), “A Quartet of Semigroups for Model Specification, Robustness, Prices of Risk, and Model Detection,” Journal of the European Economic Association, 1(1), 68-123.

[3] Angeletos, George-Marios and Laurent-Emmanuel Calvet (2006), “Idiosyncratic Production Risk, Growth and the Business Cycle,” Journal of Monetary Economics 53(6), 1095-1115.

[4] Barillas, Francisco, Lars Peter Hansen, and Thomas J. Sargent (2009), “Doubts or Variability?” Journal of Economic Theory 144(6), 2388—2418.

[5] Bernanke, Ben S. (2005), “The Global Saving Glut and the U.S. Current Account Deficit,” Sandridge Lecture, Virginia Association of Economists, available at https://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/speeches/2005/200503102/.

[6] Bewley, Truman (1986), “Stationary Monetary Equilibrium with a Continuum of Independently Fluctuating Consumers,” in W. Hildenbrand and A. Mas-Colell, eds., Contributions to Mathematical Economics: In Honor of Gerard Debreu. New York: North-Holland, 79—102.

[7] Bhandari, Anmol, Jaroslav Boroviˇcka, and Paul Ho (2016), “Identifying Ambiguity Shocks in Business Cycle Models Using Survey Data,” Working Paper.

[8] Bidder, Rhys and Matthew Smith (2012), “Robust Animal Spirits,” Journal of Monetary Economics 59(8), 738—750.

[9] Blanchard, Olivier, Davide Furceri, and Andrea Pescatori (2014), “A Prolonged Period of Low Real Interest Rates?,” Secular Stagnation: Facts, Causes and Cures, Edited by Coen Tuulings and Richard Baldwin, CEPR Press, 2014.

[10] Blundell, Richard, Luigi Pistaferri, and Ian Preston (2008), “Consumption Inequality and Partial Insurance,” American Economic Review 98(5), 1887-1921.

[11] Boyarchenko, Nina (2012), “Ambiguity Shifts and the 2007-2008 Financial Crisis,” Journal of Monetary Economics 59(5), 493-507.

[12] Caballero, Ricardo (1990), “Consumption Puzzles and Precautionary Savings,” Journal of Monetary Economics 25(1), 113-136.

[13] Cabellero, Ricardo, Emmanuel Farhi, and Pierre-Olivier Gourinchas (2008), “An Equilibrium Model of ’Global Imbalances’ and Low Interest Rates,” American Economic Review 98(1), 358-393.

[14] Cagetti, Marco, Lars Peter Hansen, Thomas J. Sargent, and Noah Williams (2002), “Robustness and Pricing with Uncertain Growth,” Review of Financial Studies 15, 363-404.

[15] Calvet, Laurent E. (2001), “Incomplete Markets and Volatility,” Journal of Economic Theory 98(2) 295-338.

[16] Campbell, John Y. (2003) “Consumption-Based Asset Pricing.” In Handbook of the Economics of Finance Vol. 1B, edited by George Constantinides, Milton Harris, and Rene Stulz, pp. 803-887. North-Holland Press.

[17] Chen, Zengjing and Larry Epstein (2002), “Ambiguity, Risk, and Asset Returns in Continuous Time,” Econometrica 70(4), 1403-1443.

[18] Davis, Steven and Paul Willen (2000), “Using Financial Assets to Hedge Labor Income Risks: Estimating the Benefits,” manuscript, University of Chicago and Boston Fed.

[19] Duffie, Darrell and Epstein, Larry (1992), “Stochastic Differential Utility,” Econometrica 60(2), 353-94.

[20] Ellison, Martin and Thomas J. Sargent (2015), “Welfare Cost of Business Cycles in Economies with Individual Consumption Risk,” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 7(2), 40-57.

[21] Epaulard, Anne and Aude Pommeret (2003), “Recursive Utility, Growth, and the Welfare Cost of Volatility,” Review of Economic Dynamics 6(3), 672-684.

[22] Floden, Martin and Jesper Lindé (2001), “Idiosyncratic Risk in the United States and Sweden: Is There a Role for Government Insurance?” Review of Economic Dynamics 4, 406-437.

[23] Guvenen, Fatih (2006), “Reconciling Conflicting Evidence on the Elasticity of Intertemporal Substitution: A Macroeconomic Perspective,” Journal of Monetary Economics 53(7), 1451-1472.

[24] Guvenen, Fatih and Anthony A. Smith, Jr., (2014), “Inferring Labor Income Risk and Partial Insurance from Economic Choices,” Econometrica 82(6), 2085-2129.

[25] Hall, Robert E. (1978), “Stochastic Implications of the Life Cycle-Permanent Income Hypothesis: Theory and Evidence,” Journal of Political Economy 86(6), 971-87.

[26] Hall, Robert E. (1988), “Intertemporal Substitution in Consumption,” Journal of Political Economy 96(2), 339-57.

[27] Hall, Robert E. (2016), “The Role of the Growth of Risk-Averse Wealth in the Decline of the Safe Real Interest Rate,” manuscript, Stanford University.

[28] Hamilton, James D., Ethan S. Harris, Jan Hatzius, and Kenneth D. West (2015), “The Equilibrium Real Funds Rate: Past, Present and Future,” NBER Working Paper 21476.

[29] Hansen, Lars Peter and Thomas J. Sargent (1995), “Discounted Linear Exponential Quadratic Gaussian Control,” IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 40, 968-71.

[30] Hansen, Lars Peter and Thomas J. Sargent (2007), Robustness, Princeton University Press.

[31] Hansen, Lars Peter, Thomas J. Sargent, and Thomas D. Tallarini, Jr. (1999), “Robust Permanent Income and Pricing,” Review of Economic Studies 66(4), 873-907.

[32] Hansen, Lars Peter, Thomas J. Sargent, and Neng Wang (2002), “Robust Permanent Income and Pricing with Filtering,” Macroeconomic Dynamics 6(1), 40-84.

[33] Hansen, Lars Peter, Thomas J. Sargent, Gauhar Turmuhambetova, and NoahWilliams (2006), “Robust Control and Model Misspecification,” Journal of Economic Theory 128(1), 45-90.

[34] Havránek, Tomáš (2015), “Measuring Intertemporal Substitution: The Importance of Method Choices and Selective Reporting,” Journal of the European Economic Association 13(6), 1180-1204.

[35] Heaton, John and Deborah Lucas (2000), “Portfolio Choice in the Presence of Background Risk,” Economic Journal 110: 1-26.

[36] Huggett, Mark (1993), “The Risk-Free Rate in Heterogeneous-Agent Incomplete-Insurance Economies,” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 17(5-6), 953-969.

[37] Ilut, Cosmin and Scheinder, Martin (2014), “Ambiguous Business Cycles,” American Economic Review 104(8), 2368-99.

[38] Kasa, Kenneth (2006), “Robustness and Information Processing,” Review of Economic Dynamics 9(1), 1-33.

[39] Kasa, Kenneth and Xiaowen Lei (2017), “ Risk, Uncertainty, and the Dynamics of Inequality,” manuscript.

[40] Laubach, Thomas and John C. Williams (2015), “Measuring the Natural Rate of Interest Redux,” Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco Working Paper 2015-16.

[41] Liu, Jun, Jun Pan, and Tang Wang (2005), “An Equilibrium Model of Rare-Event Premia and Its Implication for Option Smirks,” Review of Financial Studies 18(1), 131-164.

[42] Lucas, Robert E. (1987), Models of Business Cycles, New York: Basil Blackwell.

[43] Luo, Yulei (2008), “Consumption Dynamics under Information Processing Constraints” Review of Economic Dynamics 11(2), 366-385.

[44] Luo, Yulei, Jun Nie, and Eric R. Young (2012), “Robustness, Information-Processing Constraints, and the Current Account in Small Open Economies,” Journal of International Economics 88(1), 104-120.

[45] Luo, Yulei, Jun Nie, Gaowang Wang, and Eric R. Young (2016), “Rational Inattention and Dynamics of Consumption and Wealth in General Equilibrium,” Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City Working Paper 14-14.

[46] Luo, Yulei and Eric R. Young (2010), “Risk-sensitive Consumption and Savings under Rational Inattention,” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 2(4), 281-325.

[47] Maenhout, Pascal (2004), “Robust Portfolio Rules and Asset Pricing,” Review of Financial Studies 17, 951—983.

[48] Summers, Larry (2014), “U.S. Economic Prospects: Secular Stagnation, Hysteresis, and the Zero Lower Bound,” Business Economics 49(2), 49-65.

[49] Svensson, Lars (1989), “Portfolio Choice with Non-expected Utility in Continuous Time,” Economics Letters 30(4), 313-317.

[50] Tallarini, Thomas D. (2000), “Risk-sensitive Real Business Cycles,” Journal of Monetary Economics 45(3), 507-532.

[51] Vissing-Jørgensen, Annette and Orazio P. Attanasio (2003), “Stock-Market Participation, Intertemporal Substitution, and Risk-Aversion,” American Economic Review 93(2), 383-391.

[52] Wang, Neng (2003), “Caballero Meets Bewley: the Permanent-Income Hypothesis in General Equilibrium,” American Economic Review 93(3), 927-936.

[53] Wang, Neng (2006), “An Equilibrium Model of Wealth Distribution,” Journal of Monetary Economics 54(7), 1882-1904.

[54] Wang, Neng (2009), “Optimal Consumption and Assets Allocation with Unknown Income Growth,” Journal of Monetary Economics 56(4), 524-34.

[55] Young, Eric R. (2012), “Robust Policymaking in the Face of Sudden Stops,” Journal of Monetary Economics 59(5), 512-527.