The value of formal planning for strategic decisions: review of empirical research

Armstrong, J. Scott (1982): The value of formal planning for strategic decisions: review of empirical research. Published in: Strategic Management Journal No. 3 (1982): pp. 197-211.

Abstract

A review of research from organizational behavior supported the guidelines by corporate planners: that is, use an explicit approach for setting objectives, generating strategies, evaluating strategies, monitoring results, and obtaining commitment. To determine whether these findings could be applied to strategic decision making in organizations, a review was made of all published field research on the evaluation of formal planning. Formal planning was superior in 10 of the 15 comparisons drawn from 12 studies, while informal planning was superior in only two comparisons. Although this research did not provide sufficient information on the use of various aspects of the planning process, mild support was provided for having participation by stakeholders. Formal planning tended to be more useful where large changes were involved, but, beyond that, little information was available to suggest when formal planning is most valuable. Future research should assess the formal planning process, the situation in which it is used, and its effects on the total system.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: strategy, formal planning
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance

References

Al-Bazzaz, Shawki and Grinyer, P.H., 1980, “How planning works in practice-A survey of 48 U.K. companies,” Long Range Planning 13, August, pp. 30-42.

Ang, James S. and Chua, Jess H., 1979, “Long-range planning in large United States corporations-A survey,” Long Range Planning 12, pp. 99-102.

Ansoff, H. Igor, et al. “Does planning pay? The effect of planning on success of acquisitions in American firms,” Long Range Planning 3, December 1970, pp.2-7.

Ansoff, H. Igor. Corporate Strategy. McGraw-Hill, New York, 1965.

Armstrong, J. Scott. “Strategic planning and forecasting,” in Kenneth Albert (ed.), The Strategic Management Handbook, McGraw-Hill, N.Y. (1982), pp. 2-1 to 2-32.

Arvey, R. D., H. D. Dewhirst and J. C. Boling. `Relationships between goal clarity, participation in goal setting, and personality characteristics on job satisfaction in a scientific organization', Journal of Applied Psychology, 61, 1976, pp. 103-105.

Bass, Bernard M. “Utility of managerial self-planning on a simulated production task with replications in twelve countries,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 62, 1977, pp. 506-509.

Becker, L. J. “Joint effect of feedback and goal setting on performance: a field study of residential energy conservation,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 63, 1978, pp. 428-433.

Blumberg, Paul. Industrial Democracy: The Sociology of Participation. Schocken Books, New York, 1968.

Bouchard, Thomas J., Jr. “A comparison of two group brainstorming procedures,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 56, 1972, pp.418-421.

Coe, Barbara J. “Use of strategic planning concepts by industrial marketers,” in Kenneth Bernhardt et al. (eds). The Changing Marketing Environment: New Theories and Applications, American Marketing Association, Chicago, 1981, pp.13-16.

Cosier, Richard A. “The effects of three potential aids for making strategic decisions on prediction accuracy,” Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 22, 1978, pp. 295-306.

Dosset, Dennis L., Gary P. Latham and Lise M. Saari. “The impact of goal setting on survey returns,” Academy of Management Journal, 23, 1980, pp. 561-567.

Erez, Miriam. “Feedback: a necessary condition for the goal setting-performance relationship,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 62, 1977, pp. 624-627.

Fulmer, Robert M. and Leslie W. Rue. “The practice and profitability of long-range planning,” Managerial Planning, 22, May/June 1974, pp. 1-7.

Grinyer, P. H. and D. Norburn. “Planning for existing markets: perceptions of executives and financial performance,” Journal of the Royal Statistical Society (A), 138, 1975, pp. 70-97.

Harju, Paavo. Attitude of Strategic Managers Toward Formalized Corporate Planning. School of Economics, Turku, Finland, 1981.

Herold, David, M. R. J. House and S. S. Thune, “Long-range planning and organizational performance: A cross-validation study,” Academy of Management Journal, 15, 1972, pp. 91-102.

Hofer, Charles W. “Research on strategic planning: a survey of past studies and suggestions for future efforts,” Journal of Economics and Business, 28, Spring/Summer 1976, pp. 261-286.

Horovitz, J. H. “Strategic control: A new task for top management,” Long-Range Planning, 12, June 1979, pp. 2-7.

Ilgen, Daniel R., C. D. Fisher and M. S. Taylor. “Consequences of individual feedback on behavior in organizations,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 64, 1979, pp. 349-371.

Ivancevich, John M. “Different goal setting treatments and their effects on performance and job satisfaction,” Academy of Management Journal, 20, 1977, pp. 406-419.

Kallmann, Ernest J. and H. Jack Shapiro. “The motor freight industry-a case against planning,” Long Range Planning, 11, 1978, pp.81-86..

Karger, Delmar W. and Zafar A. Malik. “Long-range planning and organizational performance,” Long Range Planning, 8, December 1975, pp.60-64.

Katerberg, Ralph. “An examination of the quality of goal setting: Relationships to job attitudes and role stress,” Proceedings of the American Institute for Decision Sciences, November 1980, pp. 387-389.

Kim, Jay S. and W. C. Hamner. “Effect of performance feedback and goal setting on productivity and satisfaction in an organizational setting,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 61, 1976, pp.48-57.

Kudla, Ronald J. “The effects of strategic planning on common stock returns,” Academy of Management Journal, 23, 1980, 5-20.

Kudla, Ronald J.. “Strategic planning and risk,” Review of Business and Economic Research, 17, Fall 1981,pp.1-14.

Latham, Gary P. and Sydney B. Kinne, III. “Improving job performance through training in goal setting,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 59, 1974, pp. 187-191.

Latham, Gary P., Terence R. Mitchell and Dennis L. Dossett, “Importance of participative goal setting and anticipated rewards on goal difficulty and job performance,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 63, 1978, pp.163-171.

Latham, Gary P. and Lise M. Saari. “Importance of supportive relationships in goal setting,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 64, 1979, pp. 151-156.

Latham, Gary P. and G. A. Yukl. “The effects of assigned and participative goal setting on performance and satisfaction,” Journal of Applied Psychology, 61, 1976, pp. 166-171.

Latham, Gary P. and G. A. Yukl. “A review of research on the application of goal setting in organizations,” Academy of Management Journal, 18, 1975, pp. 824-845.

Leontiades, Milton and Ahmet Tezel. “Planning perceptions and planning results,” Strategic Management Journal, 1, 1980, pp. 65-75.

Lindsay, William M. and Leslie W. Rue. “Impact of the organization environment on the long-range planning process: a contingency view,” Academy of Management Journal , 23, 1980, pp. 385-404.

Locke, E. A., N. Cartledge and J. Koeppel. “Motivational effects of knowledge of results: A goal setting phenomenon,” Psychological Bulletin, 70, 1968, pp. 474-485.

Locke, Edwin A., K. N. Shaw, L. M. Saari and G. P. Latham. “Goal setting and task performance: 1969-1980,” Psychological Bulletin , 90, 1981, pp. 125-152.

Maier, Norman R. F. Problem-solving Discussions and Conferences. McGraw-Hill, New York, 1963.

Malik, Zafar A. and Delmar W. Karger. “Does long-range planning improve company performance?” Management Review , 64, September 1975, pp.27-31.

Montanari, John R., G. Moorhead and E. O. Montanari. “A laboratory study of a strategic decision making methodology,” Proceedings of the American Institute for Decision Sciences , November 1980, pp. 472-474.

Nemeroff, Wayne F. and Joseph Cosentino. “Utilizing feedback and goal setting to increase performance appraisal interviewer skills of managers,” Academy of Management Journal , 22, 1979, pp. 566-576.

Nutt, Paul C. “Field experiments which compared the effectiveness of design methods,” Decision Sciences , 7, 1976, pp. 739-758.

Nutt, Paul C. “An experimental comparison of the effectiveness of three planning methods,” Management Science, 23, 1977, pp. 499-511.

Perlmutter, Lawrence C. and Richard A. Monty. “The importance of perceived control: fact or fantasy?” American Scientist , 65, 1977, pp. 759-765.

Rosenberg, Richard D. and Eliezer Rosenstein. “Participation and productivity: an empirical study,” Industrial and Labor Relations Review , 33, 1980, pp. 355-367.

Rue, Leslie W. and Robert M. Fulmer. “Is long-range planning profitable?” Proceedings of the Academy of Management, Boston, Mass., 1973, pp. 66-73.

Seligman, Clive and J. M. Darley. “Feedback as a means of decreasing residential energy consumption,” Journal of Applied Psychology , 62, 1977, pp. 363-368.

Steiner, George A. Top Management Planning. Collier-Macmillan, London, 1969.

Terpstra, David E. “Relationship between methodological rigor and reported outcomes in organization development evaluation research,” Journal of Applied Psychology , 66, 1981, pp. 541-543.

Thune, Stanley S. and Robert J. House. “Where long-range planning pays off,” Business Horizons,13, August 1970, pp. 81-87.

Tolchinsky, Paul D. and Donald C. King. “Do goals mediate the effects of incentives on performance?” Academy of Management Review , 5, 1980, pp.455-467.

Van de Ven, Andrew H. “Problem solving, planning, and innovation, Part. 1. Test of the program planning model,” Human Relations , 33, 1980, pp.711-740.

Wexley, Kenneth N. and Wayne F. Nemeroff. “Effectiveness of positive reinforcement and goal setting as methods of management development,” Journal of Applied Psychology , 60, 1975, pp.446-450.

Wood, D. Robley, 1r. and R. L. LaForge. “The impact of comprehensive planning on financial performance,” Academy of Management Journal , 22, 1979, pp. 516-526.

Wood, D. Robley, Jr. and R. L. LaForge. “Toward the development of a planning scale: an example from the banking industry,” Strategic Management Journal , 2, 1981, pp.209-216.