Fairness in international trade policy: equality and differential treatment in theory and practice (working paper)

Häußermann, Johann Jakob (2017): Fairness in international trade policy: equality and differential treatment in theory and practice (working paper).

Abstract

In Fairness in Practice – A Social Contract for a Global Economy (2012) Aaron James proposes a substantial normative framework for a theory of fairness in the global economy. Based on a distinctive methodology of interpretive constructivism, James argues for an internal justification of fairness requirements in the field of international trade, and consequently defends three basic egalitarian principles of fairness. However, Mathias Risse and Gabriel Wollner, among others, have criticized James’s view for multiple reasons. In the following article, I will first engage with their critique, contending that their arguments do not prove that James’s view should be dismissed. Instead, I will introduce a new proposal, arguing that it is rather by a notion of differential treatment of countries that James’s account should be complemented. Taking into account all the relevant differences between countries, the concept of differential treatment allows for the provision and establishment of equal participation as a basis for considerations of fairness. To this end, I shall therefore propose an additional fourth principle of fairness called Equal Participation. I argue that it is necessary to significantly expand James’s contractualist and practice-dependent foundations, in order to reconcile crucial methodological concerns and to render James’s formulations applicable to current debates on free trade agreements. The article will conclude with an exploration of the applicability of this new approach to current trade policy issues, illustrating not only its practicability but also the urgent need for normative considerations in the context of international trade agreements.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: International Trade; Free Trade Agreements; Fairness; Special and Differential Treatment; Constructivism; Aaron James
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D63 - Equity, Justice, Inequality, and Other Normative Criteria and Measurement; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F13 - Trade Policy ; International Trade Organizations

References

Aichele, Rahel, and Gabriel Felbermayr. 2015. ‘The Impact of TTIP on Third Countries’. In Catalyst? TTIP’s Impact on the Rest, edited by M. Sait Akman, Simon J. Evenett, and Patrick Low, 27–34. London: CEPR Press.

Akman, M. Sait, Simon J. Evenett, and Patrick Low. 2015. ‘Introduction’. In Catalyst? TTIP’s Impact on the Rest, edited by M. Sait Akman, Simon J. Evenett, and Patrick Low, 1–10. London: CEPR Press.

Barry, Christian. 2014. ‘The Regulation of Harm in International Trade: A Critique of James’s Collective Due Care Principle’. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 44 (2): 255–263. doi:10.1080/00455091.2014.929856.

Beitz, Charles R. 2014. ‘Internal and External’. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 44 (2): 225–238. doi:10.1080/00455091.2014.930581.

Berger, Axel, and Clara Brandi. 2013. ‘Das Transatlantische Freihandelsabkommen: Bedenkt Die Folgen!’ Die Aktuelle Kolumne, Deutsches Institut Für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE).

Berger, Axel, Clara Brandi, and Julia Kubny. 2013. ‘What Are the Implications of the Planned US-EU Free Trade Agreement for Developing Countries?’ KFW-Development Research 18.

Bohnenberger, Fabian. 2016. ‘Mega-Regional Agreements and Global Trade Governance: Ensuring Openness and Inclusiveness in an Increasingly Complex System’. Bridges Africa (ICTSD) 5 (4): 4–9.

Brandi, Clara. 2008. ‘Development, International Organizations and Fairness as Justice: Normative Perspectives on the WTO’. Annual Bank Conference on Development Economics (ABCDE), 1–21.

Brandi, Clara. 2014. ‘On the Fairness of the Multilateral Trading System’. Moral Philosophy and Politics 1 (2): 227–247. doi:10.1515/mopp-2014-0006.

Christensen, James. 2013. ‘Practice-Dependence, Trade, & Equality: A Review of Aaron James’s Fairness in Practice: A Social Contract for a Global Economy (New York: Oxford University Press, 2012)’. Raisons Politiques 51 (3): 155. doi:10.3917/rai.051.0155.

Christensen, James. 2015. ‘Fair Trade, Formal Equality, and Preferential Treatment’. Social Theory and Practice 41 (3): 505–526. doi:10.5840/soctheorpract201541326.

Cotton, Simon. 2014. ‘Review of: Fairness in Practice: A Social Contract for a Global Economy by Aaron James’. Ethics & International Affairs 28 (2).

Dworkin, Ronald. 1986. Law’s Empire. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.

Fabry, Elvire, and Emett Strickland. 2015. ‘TTIP and Third States’. Synthesis (4 June), Jacques Delors Institute, 1–4.

Felbermayr, Gabriel, and Rahel Aichele. 2015. How to Make TTIP Inclusive for All? Potential Economic Impacts of the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) on Developing Countries. Study of the IFO Institute for Bertelsmann Stiftung. München.

Francois, Joseph, Bernard Hoekman, and Doug Nelson. 2015. ‘TTIP, Regulatory Diversion and Third Countries’. In Catalyst? TTIP’s Impact on the Rest, edited by M. Sait Akman, Simon J. Evenett, and Patrick Low, 19–26. London: CEPR Press.

Gauthier, David. 1986. Morals by Agreement. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hoekman, Bernard. 2005. ‘More Favorable Treatment of Developing Countries: Ways Forward’. In Trade, Doha, and Development - A Window into the Issues, edited by Richard Newfarmer, 213–221. Washington, D.C.: The World Bank. doi:10.1596/978-0-8213-6437-6.

Hoekman, Bernard, Constantine Michalopoulos, and L. Alan Winter. 2004. ‘Special and Differential Treatment of Developing Countries in the WTO: Moving Forward After Cancun’. The World Economy 27 (4): 481–506. doi:10.1111/j.0378-5920.2004.00610.x.

James, Aaron. 2005. ‘Constructing Justice for Existing Practice: Rawls and the Status Quo’. Philosophy & Public Affairs 33 (3): 281–316. doi:10.1111/j.1088-4963.2005.00034.x.

James, Aaron. 2012. Fairness in Practice. A Social Contract for a Global Economy. New York: Oxford University Press. James, Aaron. 2013. ‘Why Practices?’ Raisons Politiques 51 (3): 43. doi:10.3917/rai.051.0043.

James, Aaron. 2014a. ‘A Theory of Fairness in Trade’. Moral Philosophy and Politics 1 (2): 177–200. doi:10.1515/mopp-2014-0007.

James, Aaron. 2014b. ‘Reply to Critics’. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 44 (2): 286–304. doi:10.1080/00455091.2014.929858.

Julius, A.J. 2014. ‘Practice Independence’. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 44 (2): 239–254. doi:10.1080/00455091.2014.942142.

Keck, Alexander, and Patrick Low. 2004. ‘Special and Differential Treatment in the WTO: Why , When and How ?’ SSRN Electronic Journal, 37.

Manrique Gil, Manuel, and Marika Lerch. 2015. The TTIP’s Potential Impact on Developing Countries: A Review of Existing Literature and Selected Issues. Directorate General for External Policies (EXPO/B/PolDep/Note/2015_84).

Miller, David. 2014. ‘Symposium on Fair Trade: Introduction’. Moral Philosophy and Politics 1 (2): 171–175. doi:10.1515/mopp-2014-0030.

Miller, David. 2016. ‘Fair Trade: What Does It Mean and Why Does It Matter?’ Journal of Moral Philosophy, June. doi:10.1163/17455243-46810053.

Moellendorf, Darrel. 2013. ‘Fairness in Practice: A Social Contract for a Global Economy, by Aaron James.’ Mind 122 (486): 548–553. doi:10.1093/mind/fzt067.

Olson, Kristi A. 2014. ‘Autarky as a Moral Baseline’. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 44 (2): 264–285. doi:10.1080/00455091.2014.929857.

Pogge, Thomas W. 2002. World Poverty and Human Rights: Cosmopolitan Responsibilities and Reforms. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Pogge, Thomas W. 2005. ‘World Poverty and Human Rights’. Ethics & International Affairs 19 (1): 1–7. doi:10.1111/j.1747-7093.2005.tb00484.x.

Rawls, John. 1971. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.

Reiter, Joakim. 2015. ‘The Effects of TTIP on Developing Countries’. CATO Online Forum: The Economics, Geopolitics, and Architecture of the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership.

Risse, Mathias. 2005a. ‘What We Owe to the Global Poor’. The Journal of Ethics 9 (1–2): 81–117. doi:10.1007/s10892-004-3321-z.

Risse, Mathias. 2005b. ‘Do We Owe the Global Poor Assistance or Rectification?’ Ethics & International Affairs 19 (1): 9–18. doi:10.1111/j.1747-7093.2005.tb00485.x.

Risse, Mathias. 2005c. ‘How Does the Global Order Harm the Poor?’ Philosophy & Public Affairs 33 (4): 349–376. doi:10.1111/j.1088-4963.2005.00036.x.

Risse, Mathias, and Gabriel Wollner. 2013. ‘Critical Notice on Aaron James, Fairness in Practice: A Social Contract for a Global Economy’. Canadian Journal of Philosophy 43 (3): 382–401. doi:10.1080/00455091.2013.847351.

Risse, Mathias, and Gabriel Wollner. 2014. ‘Three Images of Trade: On the Place of Trade in a Theory of Global Justice’. Moral Philosophy and Politics 1 (2): 201–225. doi:10.1515/mopp-2014-0013.

Scanlon, Thomas M. 1998. What We Owe to Each Other. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.

Schmieg, Evita. 2015. ‘TTIP – Opportunities and Risks for Developing Countries. Contributions in International Journals and Think Tank Publications 2013–2014’. SWP-Zeitschriftenschau (Stiftung Wissenschaft Und Politik (SWP), German Institute for International and Security Affairs) 1e: 1–8.

Singer, Peter. 1972. ‘Famine, Affluence, and Morality’. Philosophy & Public Affairs 1 (3): 229–243.

Stiglitz, Joseph E., and Andrew Charlton. 2005. Fair Trade for All. How Trade Can Promote Development. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Walton, Andrew. 2014. ‘Do Moral Duties Arise from Global Trade?’ Moral Philosophy and Politics 1 (2): 249–268. doi:10.1515/mopp-2014-0005.

Weinhardt, Clara, and Fabian Bohnenberger. 2015. ‘Risks of TTIP and TPP’. Development and Cooperation 8: 34.

Wollner, Gabriel. 2012. ‘Review of: Fairness in Practice: A Social Contract for a Global Economy’. Notre Dame Philosophical Review, 2012.10.10.