Fuzzy reporting as a way for a company to greenwash: perspectives from the Colombian reality

Contreras-Pacheco, Orlando E. and Claasen, Cyrlene (2017): Fuzzy reporting as a way for a company to greenwash: perspectives from the Colombian reality. Published in: Problems and Perspectives in Management , Vol. 15, No. 2 (2017): pp. 526-536.

Abstract

Drawing on the legitimacy theory framework, this study introduces an alternative means to spot “fuzzy reporting” signals as a way to detect greenwashing at the firm level. Its approach is based on the way the sustainability reporting process can mislead stakeholders after critical incidents take place. In order to do so, a single environmental incident, which took place in Colombia, is analyzed in light of what happened before, during and afterwards, with special emphasis on the corporate disclosure process performed by the company involved. Results obtained give support to the assumption that fuzzy reporting can be objectively detected not only through the analysis of annual sustainability reports, but also by tracking other forms of corporate messages when a specific concern is carefully followed. This study’s contribution is two-fold. First, it builds on the theoretical notions of greenwashing and fuzzy reporting by illustrating a practical and objective way to identify some deceiving corporate practices. Second, it empirically evaluates this approach in a sensitive context in order to obtain better illustration and prepare the groundwork for further studies.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Legitimacy, corporate social responsibility (CSR), greenwashing, sustainability reports, social and environmental reporting, fuzzy reporting, mining industry, Colombia
• Subjects: M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M41 - Accounting; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q0 - General > Q01 - Sustainable Development; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q58 - Government Policy

References

Adams, C. A., & Frost, G. R. (2006). Accessibility and functionality of the corporate web site: implications for sustainability reporting. Business Strategy and the Environment, 15(4), 275-287.

Ali, W., Frynas, J. G., & Mahmood, Z. (2017). Determinants of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Disclosure in Developed and Developing Countries: A Literature Review. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management.

Alonso-Almeida, M. M., Marimon, F., Casani, F., & Rodriguez-Pomeda, J. (2015). Diffusion of sustainability reporting in universities: Current situation and future perspectives. Journal of Cleaner Production, 106, 144-154.

ANLA (2013). Resolución 1309 del 2013: Por la cual se impone sanción ambiental y se toman otras determinaciones. República de Colombia. Ministerio de Ambiente y Desarrollo Sostenible. Autoridad Nacional de Licencias Ambientales. 201p. December 18, 2013. Retrieved April 29, 2016, from: http://www.anla.gov.co/sites/default/files/11078_res_1309_181213.pdf.

ANLA (2014). Resolución 763 del 2014: Por la cual se resuelve un recurso de reposición y se toman otras determinaciones. República de Colombia. Ministerio de Ambiente y Desarrollo Sostenible. Autoridad Nacional de Licencias Ambientales. 93p. July 14, 2014. Retrieved April 29, 2016, from: http://www.anla.gov.co/sites/default/files/12923_res_0763_140714.pdf.

Bansal, P., & Clelland, I. (2004). Talking trash: Legitimacy, impression management, and unsystematic risk in the context of the natural environment. Academy of Management Journal, 47(1), 93-103.

Bachmann, P., & Ingenhoff, D. (2016). Legitimacy through CSR disclosures? The advantage outweighs the disadvantages. Public Relations Review, 42(3), 386-394.

Berrone, P., Fosfuri, A., & Gelabert, L. (2015). Does Greenwashing Pay Off? Understanding the Relationship Between Environmental Actions and Environmental Legitimacy. Journal of Business Ethics, 1-17.

Berrone, P. (2016). Green Lies: How Greenwashing can destroy a company (and how to go green without the wash). Createspace Independent Publishing Platform. 340p.

Bowen, F., & Aragon-Correa, J. A. (2014). Greenwashing in Corporate Environmentalism Research and Practice: The Importance of What We Say and Do. Organization & Environment, 27(2), 107-112.

Bruno, K. (1992). The Greenpeace Book on Greenwash released at the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro. Amsterdam: Greenpeace International.

Campbell, D. J. (2000). Legitimacy theory or managerial reality construction? Corporate social disclosure in Marks and Spencer Plc corporate reports, 1969–1997. In Accounting Forum (Vol. 24, No. 1, pp. 80-100). Blackwell Publishers Ltd.

Cho, C. H., & Patten, D. M. (2007). The role of environmental disclosures as tools of legitimacy: A research note. Accounting, organizations and society, 32(7), 639-647.

Crilly, D., Hansen, M., & Zollo, M. (2016). The grammar of decoupling: A cognitive-linguistic perspective on firms’ sustainability claims and stakeholders’ interpretation. Academy of Management Journal, 59(2), 705-729.

Deegan, C. (2014). An overview of legitimacy theory as applied within the social and environmental accounting literature. Sustainability accounting and accountability, 248-272.

De Villiers, C., & van Staden, C. J. (2006). Can less environmental disclosure have a legitimising effect? Evidence from Africa. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 31(8), 763-781.

Delmas, M. A., & Burbano, V. C. (2011). The drivers of greenwashing. California Management Review, 54(1), 64-87.

Dienes, D., Sassen, R. & Fischer, J. (2016). What are the drivers of sustainability reporting? A systematic review. Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal, 7(2), 154-189.

Dowling, J., & Pfeffer, J. (1975). Organizational legitimacy: Social values and organizational behavior. Pacific sociological review, 18(1), 122-136.

Drummond Ltd. (2013, December). Hallazgos de la contingencia de la barcaza. Revista DRUMMOND, (1), 4-6. Retrieved March 29, 2016, from http://www.emagcloud.com/semana/DRUMMOND_Ed_01/index.html#/1/

Drummond Ltd. (2015). Informe de Sostenibilidad 2013-2014 (Rep.). Retrieved March 27, 2016, from http://www.drummondltd.com/noticias-publicaciones/informes-de-sostenibilidad/

Drummondltd.com (2013, February 14). Declaración de Drummond LTD – Resultados de la investigación interna sobre el accidente de la barcaza [Press release]. Retrieved March 27, 2016, from http://www.drummondltd.com/declaracion-de-drummond-ltd-accidente-resultados-investigacion-interna/

Drummondltd.com (2014, January 19). Drummond Ltd. responde con hechos y pregunta ¿por qué? [Press release]. Retrieved March 29, 2016, from http://www.drummondltd.com/drummond-ltd-responde-con-hechos-y-pregunta-por-que/

Elpais.com.co (2013, February 21). “No sabemos cuántas toneladas de carbón cayeron al mar”: Drummond. EL PAÍS. Retrieved April 2, 2016, from http://www.elpais.com.co/elpais/economia/noticias/sabemos-cuantas-toneladas-carbon-cayeron-mar-drummond.

Eltiempo.com (2013, February 17). 'Cayeron al mar 300 toneladas de carbón', dice la Drummond. EL TIEMPO. Retrieved March 30, 2016, from http://www.eltiempo.com/archivo/documento/CMS-12600377

Eisenhardt, K. M. (1989). Building theories from case study research. Academy of management review, 14(4), 532-550.

Festinger, L. (1962). A theory of cognitive dissonance (Vol. 2). Stanford University Press.

Forbes.com. (2017). “America’s Largest Private Companies”. [online] Available at: https://www.forbes.com/companies/drummond/ [Accessed 13 Mar. 2017].

Frost, G., Jones, S., Loftus, J. and Van Der Laan, S. (2005), A Survey of Sustainability Reporting Practices of Australian Reporting Entities. Australian Accounting Review, 15: 89–96.

Garay, L.J., Rudas, G., Espitia, J.E., Mena, J.A., Pardo, L.A., Fierro, J., Olivero, J., Caballero, K., Guerrero, A., Vargas, F., & Negrete, R.E. (2013). Minería en Colombia: Institucionalidad y territorio, paradojas y conflictos. Bogotá: Contraloría General de la República.

Gray, R., Owen, D., & Adams, C. (1996). Accounting & accountability: changes and challenges in corporate social and environmental reporting. Prentice Hall.

Guthrie, J., & Parker, L. D. (1989). Corporate social reporting: a rebuttal of legitimacy theory. Accounting and business research, 19(76), 343-352.

Huertas, J. I., Huertas, M. E., Izquierdo, S., & González, E. D. (2012). Air quality impact assessment of multiple open pit coal mines in northern Colombia. Journal of environmental management, 93(1), 121-129.

Invemar (2013). Concepto técnico sobre el efecto del derrame de carbón sobre el ecosistema marino, producido por la maniobra de rescate de la barcaza TS-115 de propiedad de la Compañía American Port Company INC. (Tech. No. CPT-BEM-005-13) for Ministerio de Ambiente y Desarrollo Sostenible y la ANLA. Retrieved February 01, 2016, from Drummond Ltd. website: http://www.drummondltd.com/wp-content/uploads/4.-Concepto-CPT-BEM-005-13-Informe-INVEMAR.pdf

Jiménez, G. (2014). Multinacionales y responsabilidad social empresarial en la construcción de paz en Colombia. Cuadernos de administración, 27(48), 67-96.

Katamba, D., & Nkiko, C. M. (2017). The CSR Communications and Reporting Landscape in Developing Countries. In Handbook of Integrated CSR Communication (pp. 343-358). Springer International Publishing.

Layton, J. C. (2013, February 22). Mineros prometen reducir la pobreza extrema en Colombia - See more at: Http://www.lapatria.com/economia/mineros-prometen-reducir-la-pobreza-extrema-en-colombia-26902#sthash.Xw5P26Yi.dpuf. LA PATRIA. Retrieved May 4, 2016, from http://www.lapatria.com/economia/mineros-prometen-reducir-la-pobreza-extrema-en-colombia-26902

Linares, J. M. (2013, February 21). Rescue Operation of the Barge TS115. In 2nd. Conference of the High Scale Mining Industry (SMGE). Retrieved April 01, 2016, from http://www.drummondltd.com/wp-content/uploads/2.-Drummond-LTD_-Presentacion-congreso-SMGE-Febrero2013.pdf

Mahoney, L. S., Thorne, L., Cecil, L., & LaGore, W. (2013). A research note on standalone corporate social responsibility reports: Signaling or greenwashing?. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 24(4), 350-359.

Marquis, C., & Toffel, M. W. (2011). The Globalization of Corporate Environmental Disclosure: Accountability or Greenwashing?. Harvard Business School.

Milne, M. J., & Patten, D. M. (2002). Securing organizational legitimacy: An experimental decision case examining the impact of environmental disclosures. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 15(3), 372-405.

Molinski, D. (2013, December 19). Colombia Fines Drummond for Dumping Coal. [online] The Wall Street Journal. Available at: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702303773704579268432078935884 [Accessed 13 Mar. 2017].

Morhardt, J. E., Baird, S., & Freeman, K. (2002). Scoring corporate environmental and sustainability reports using GRI 2000, ISO 14031 and other criteria. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 9(4), 215-233.

Otálora, R. (2015). El Poder Negociador de la Empresa Transnacional en la Expedición de la Legislación Minera en Colombia. Revista Republicana, (18), 181-210.

Plazas, F. A. (2016). Análisis de la evolución de la inversión extranjera directa en el sector minero del carbón en Colombia de 2004 a 2013*/Analysis of the evolution of foreign direct investment in the coal mining sector in Colombia from 2002 to 2013. Apuntes del CENES, 35(61), 51.

Sarmiento, N. (2008). ¿Bondad o estrategia?: tejiendo responsabilidad social en el mundo del carbón. Colombia Internacional, (67), 132-151.

Shaefer, S. (2014, February 7). Drummond and Colombia Both Suffer in Clash. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved April 12, 2016, from http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304851104579363322390004550.

Simco.gov.co. (n.d.). Sistema de Información Minero Colombiano. [online] Available at: http://simco.gov.co [Accessed 9 Apr. 2017].

Snider, J., Hill, R. P., & Martin, D. (2003). Corporate social responsibility in the 21st century: A view from the world's most successful firms. Journal of Business ethics, 48(2), 175-187.

Spence, C. (2009). Social and environmental reporting and the corporate ego. Business Strategy and the Environment, 18(4), 254-265.

Valencia, J. A. (Ed.) (2014). Indicadores De La Minería En Colombia (Colombia, Ministerio de Minas y Energía, Unidad de Planeación Minero- Energética). Retrieved April 22, 2016, from http://www.upme.gov.co/Docs/Plan_Minero/2014/Indicadores de la Minería en Colombia.pdf.

Walker, K., & Wan, F. (2012). The Harm of Symbolic Actions and Green-Washing : Corporate Actions and Communications on Environmental Performance and Their Financial Implications. Journal of business ethics, 109(2), 227-242.

Yekini, K. C., Burrows, L., & Omoteso, K. (2014). A Semiotic approach to evaluating the quality and veracity of CSR reporting. Accounting and Finance.

Yin, R. (1994). Case study research: Design and methods . Beverly Hills.