Regulation of NGN: Structural Separation, Access Regulation, or No Regulation at All?

Kirsch, Fabian and Hirschhausen, Christian von (2008): Regulation of NGN: Structural Separation, Access Regulation, or No Regulation at All? Published in: Communications & Strategies No. 69 (March 2008): pp. 63-83.

Abstract

Since the introduction of Next Generation Networks (NGNs) by telecommunication network operators, national regulators have begun to adapt their access regulation regimes to the new technological conditions. The regulatory reactions gravitate towards three distinct regulatory trajectories: unregulated competition, access regulation, and structural separation. We first analyze the extent of market power in access Networks in NGNs from a technological perspective. Second, we use case studies to identify patterns between technological and market conditions and regulators' reactions in selected countries. We find that market power in the access network is likely to prevail. Regulatory reactions differ with the extent of infrastructure competition and the regulators position in the trade-off between promoting investment and protecting competition.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Next Generation Network, deregulation, access regulation, structural separation
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L5 - Regulation and Industrial Policy > L51 - Economics of Regulation

References

ARCEP (2006): Very high-speed - Points of Reference and Outlook. http://www.art-telecom.fr/fileadmin/reprise/dossiers/fibre/slides-fttx-prog-101106ang.pdf, retrieved: 10.12.2007.

BAAKE P., HAUCAP J., KÜHLING J., LOETZ S. & WEY C. (2007): Effiziente Regulierung in dynamischen Märkten, Baden-Baden.

BAKER J.B. (2007): "Market Definition: An Analytical Overview", Antitrust Law Journal, Vol. 74 / 1.

CAVE M. (2006): "Six Degrees of Separation: Operational Separation as a Remedy in European Telecommunications Regulation", COMMUNICATIONS & STRATEGIES, Vol. 64, pp. 89-103.

CAVE M., CORREA L. & CROCIONI P. (2006): "Regulating for Non-Price Discrimination - The case of UK Fixed Telecoms", Centre for Management under Regulation, Working Paper.

CRANDALL R.W., SIDAK G.J. & SINGER H.J. (2002): "The Empirical Case against Asymmetric Regulation of Broadband Internet Access", Berkeley Technology Law Journal, Vol. 17, pp. 953-987.

DE BIJL P.W. & PEITZ M. (2007): "Innovation, Convergence and the Role of Regulation in the Netherlands and Beyond", TILEC Discussion Paper no. 2007-016.

ERG (European Regulators Group): - (2007a): ERG Opinion on Regulatory Principles of NGA. - (2007b): Supplementary Document to the ERG Opinion on Regulatory Principles of NGA. European Commission (2007): Annex 1 to the European Electronic Communications Regulation and Markets 2006 (12th Report).

FCC: - (2003): Triennial Review Order, Wireline Competition Bureau. - (2004): Order on Reconsideration, Wireline Competition Bureau. - (2005): Notice of Proposed Rule Making in the Matter of Appropriate Framework for Broadband Access to the Internet over Wireline Facilities, Wireline Competition Bureau. - (2007): Trends in Telephony Service. Industry Analysis and Technology Division, Wireline Competition Bureau.

FRIEDEN R. (2003): "Adjusting the Horizontal and Vertical in Telecommunications Regulation", Federal Communications Law Journal, Vol. 55 / 2.

GANS J. & KING S. (2003): "Access Holidays for Network Infrastructure Investment", Agenda, Vol. 10 / 2, pp. 163-178.

GUTHRIE G. (2006): "Regulating Infrastructure: The Impact on Risk and Investment", Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. XLIV, pp. 925-972.

HENDRIKS P. (2007): "The Road to All-IP. VDSL – The way to Next Generation Networks", WIK International Conference, Königswinter, 21.03.2007.

ILIC D. & KULENKAMPFF G. (2007): "VDSL Roll out in Germany: An Assessment of its Economic Feasibility", 18th European Regional ITS Conference, Istanbul.

KPN (2007): KPN Wholesale. www.kpn-wholesale.com, retrieved: 05.12.2007.

LEE K.O., KIM S.K., CHUNG T.S. & KIM Y.S. (2007): "Reference Model of Broadband Convergence Network in Korea", Asia-Pacific Conference on Communications 2007, Bangkok.

MARCUS J.S. (2005): "Is the U.S. Dancing to a Different Drummer?", MPRA no. 2514.

NCA (National Computerization Agency Rzepublic of Korea) (2006): Informatization White paper 2006.

NERA (2007): Ofcom's Strategic Review of Telecommunications and BT's Undertakings, NERA Economic Consulting. OECD: - (2005): Next Generation Network Development in OECD Countries, O.F.E.C.- O.A.D. - (2007): OECD Broadband statistics: 1h. Broadband penetration, historic, top five OECD countries for June 2007, retrieved: 08.02.2007.

Ofcom: - (2004): Strategic Review of Telecommunications - Phase 2, consultation document. - (2005a): Final statements on the Strategic Review of Telecommunications, and undertakings in lieu of a reference under the Enterprise Act 2002. - (2005b): Next Generation Networks - Future arrangements for access and interconnection. - (2005c): Notice under Section 155(1) of the Enterprise Act 2002. - (2006): The Communication Market 2006. - (2007): Future broadband - Policy approach to next generation access.

OPTA: - (2006a): "Is Two Enough?", Economic Policy Note, Vol. 6. - (2006b): "KPN's Next Generation Network: All-IP", Issue Paper. - (2006c): "KPN's Next Generation Network: All-IP", Position Paper.

POIKSELKA, M., MAYER, G. & KHARTABIL, H. (2005) The IMS. Hoboken, NJ. REYNOLDS T., KELLY T. & JIN-KYU J. (2005): "Ubiquitous Network Societies: The Case of the Republic of Korea", International Telecommunication Union (ITU).

SHAKED A. & SUTTON J. (1982): "Relaxing Price Competition Through Product Differentiation", Review of Economic Studies, Vol. XLIX, pp. 3-13.

TARDIFF T. (2007): "Changes in industry structure and technological convergence: implications for competition policy and regulation in telecommunications", International Economics and Economic Policy, Vol. 4 / 2, pp. 109-133.

WAR (Wissenschaftlicher Arbeitskreis für Regulierungsfragen) (2005): Stellungnahme zum Projekt Glasfaserausbau des Zugangsnetzes der Deutsche Telekom AG.

WEY C., BAAKE P. & HEITZLER S. (2006): "What rules for IP-enabled NGNs?", ITU Workshop on Next Generation Networks, Geneva, 23-24.03.2006