In the shadow of coal: How large-scale industries contributed to present-day regional differences in personality and well-being

Obschonka, Martin and Stuetzer, Michael and Rentfrow, Peter J. and Shaw-Taylor, Leigh and Satchell, Max and Silbereisen, Rainer K. and Potter, Jeff and Gosling, Samuel D. (2018): In the shadow of coal: How large-scale industries contributed to present-day regional differences in personality and well-being. Published in: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , Vol. 115, No. 5 (2018): pp. 903-927.

Abstract

Recent research has identified regional variation of personality traits within countries but we know little about the underlying drivers of this variation. We propose that the Industrial Revolution, as a key era in the history of industrialized nations, has led to a persistent clustering of well-being outcomes and personality traits associated with psychological adversity via processes of selective migration and socialization. Analyzing data from England and Wales, we examine relationships between the historical employment share in large-scale coal-based industries (coal mining and steam-powered manufacturing industries that used this coal as fuel for their steam engines) and today’s regional variation in personality and well-being. Even after controlling for possible historical confounds (historical energy supply, education, wealth, geology, climate, population density), we find that the historical local dominance of large-scale coal-based industries predicts today’s markers of psychological adversity (lower Conscientiousness [and order facet scores], higher Neuroticism [and anxiety and depression facet scores], lower activity [an Extraversion facet], and lower life satisfaction and life expectancy). An instrumental variable analysis, using the historical location of coalfields, supports the causal assumption behind these effects (with the exception of life satisfaction). Further analyses focusing on mechanisms hint at the roles of selective migration and persisting economic hardship. Finally, a robustness check in the U.S. replicates the effect of the historical concentration of large-scale industries on today’s levels of psychological adversity. Taken together, the results show how today’s regional patterns of personality and well-being may have their roots in major societal changes underway decades or centuries earlier.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Industrial Revolution, regional well-being, adversity, Big Five personality traits, historical factors
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I31 - General Welfare, Well-Being; N - Economic History > N9 - Regional and Urban History > N93 - Europe: Pre-1913

References

Ananat, E. O., Gassman-Pines, A., Francis, D. V., & Gibson-Davis, C. M. (2017). Linking job loss, inequality, mental health, and education, Science, 356, 1127-1128.

Andrews, M. G. (1987). The men and the mills: A history of southern textile production. Macon, GA: Mercer University Press.

Angrist, J. D., Imbens, G. W., & Rubin, D. B. (1996). Identification of causal effects using instrumental variables. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 91, 444-455.

Asendorpf, J. B., Borkenau, P., Ostendorf, F., & Van Aken, M. A. (2001). Carving personality description at its joints: Confirmation of three replicable personality prototypes for both children and adults. European Journal of Personality, 15, 169-198.

Audretsch, D. B. (2007). The entrepreneurial society. New York: Oxford University Press.

Auger, A., Farkas, G., Burchinal, M. R., Duncan, G. J., & Vandell, D. L. (2014). Preschool center care quality effects on academic achievement: An instrumental variables analysis. Developmental Psychology, 50, 2559-2571.

Banks, J., Marmot, M., Oldfield, Z., & Smith, J. P., (2006). Disease and disadvantage in the United States and in England. Journal of American Medical Association, 295, 2037-2045.

Barrick, M. R., & Mount, M. K. (1991). The big five personality dimensions and job performance: A meta‐analysis. Personnel Psychology, 44, 1-26.

BBC (2016). U.K.'s last deep coal mine Kellingley Colliery capped off. Retrieved from http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-york-north-yorkshire-35803048.

Beatty, C., & Fothergill, S. (1996). Labour market adjustment in areas of chronic industrial decline: The case of the UK coalfields. Regional Studies, 30, 627-640.

Beatty, C., Fothergill, S., & Powell, R. (2007). Twenty years on: Has the economy of the UK coalfields recovered? Environment and Planning A, 39, 1654-1675.

Bind, M. A., Lepeule, J., Zanobetti, A., Gasparrini, A., Baccarelli, A. A., Coull, B. A., … Schwartz, J. (2014). Air pollution and gene-specific methylation in the normative aging study: Association, effect modification, and mediation analysis. Epigenetics, 9, 448-458.

Bleidorn, W., Schönbrodt, F., Gebauer, J. E., Rentfrow, P. J., Potter, J., & Gosling, S. D. (2016). To live among like-minded others: Exploring the links between personality-city fit and self-esteem. Psychological Science, 27, 419-427.

Bogg, T., & Roberts, B. W. (2004). Conscientiousness and health-related behaviors: A meta-analysis of the leading behavioral contributors to mortality. Psychological Bulletin, 130, 887-919.

Bogg, T., & Roberts, B. W. (2013). The case for conscientiousness: Evidence and implications for a personality trait marker of health and longevity. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 45, 278-288.

Campbell, B. M. S. (2008). Benchmarking medieval economic development: England, Wales, Scotland, and Ireland, c.1290. The Economic History Review, 61, 896-945.

Chamorro-Premuzic, T., Bennett, E., & Furnham, A. (2007). The happy personality: Mediational role of trait emotional intelligence. Personality and Individual Differences, 42, 1633-1639.

Champion, A. (2005). Population movement within the UK. In R. Chappell (Ed.), Focus on people and migration. Office for National Statistics. Retrieved from http://www.statistics.gov.uk.

Combes, P.-P., Duranton, G., Gobillon, L., & Roux, S. (2010). Estimating agglomeration economies with history, geology and worker efforts. In E. L. Glaeser (Ed.), The Economic of Agglomeration (pp.15-66). Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.

Crafts, N., & Mulatu, A. (2005). What explains the location of industry in Britain, 1871–1931? Journal of Economic Geography, 5, 499-518.

Crafts, N., & Mulatu, A. (2006). How did the location of industry respond to falling transport costs in Britain before World War I? Journal of Economic History, 66, 575-607.

Crafts, N., & Wolf, N. (2013). The location of the UK cotton textiles industry in 1838: A quantitative analysis (Ehes Working Papers in Economic History No. 45). Retrieved from http://cep.lse.ac.uk/seminarpapers/13-01-12-NC.pdf

Crouter, A. C., Bumpus, M. F., Maguire, M. C., & McHale, S. M. (1999). Linking parents’ work pressure to adolescents’ well-being: Insights into dynamics in dual-earner families. Developmental Psychology, 35, 1453–1461.

Cutrona, C. E., Wallace, G., & Wesner, K. A. (2006). Neighborhood characteristics and depression: An examination of stress processes. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 15, 188-192.

Cutter, S. L., Ismail-Zadeh, A., Alcantara-Ayala, I., Altan, O., Baker, D. N., Briceno, S., … Wu, G. (2015). Global risks: Pool knowledge to stem losses from disasters. Nature, 522, 277-279.

Deaton, A. (2008). Income, health, and well-being around the world: Evidence from the Gallup World Poll. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 22, 53-72.

Dias, B. G., & Ressler, K. J. (2014). Parental olfactory experience influences behavior and neural structure in subsequent generations. Nature Neuroscience, 17, 89-96.

Diener, E. (2012). New findings and future directions for subjective well-being research. American Psychologist, 67, 590.

Diener, E., Emmons, R. A., Larsen, R. J., & Griffin, S. (1985). The Satisfaction with Life Scale. Journal of Personality Assessment, 49, 71-75.

Diener, E., Oishi, S., & Lucas, R. E. (2003). Personality, culture, and subjective well-being: Emotional and cognitive evaluations of life. Annual Review of Psychology, 54, 403-425.

Elder, G. H., Jr. (1999). Children of the great depression: Social change in life experience (25th Anniversary Edition). Boulder, CO: Westview. (Original work published 1974).

Evans, G.W., Wells, N.M., Chan, H.Y.E., & Saltzman, H. (2000). Housing quality and mental health. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 68, 526–530.

Falck, O., Fritsch, M., & Heblich, S. (2011). The phantom of the opera: Cultural amenities, human capital, and regional economic growth. Labour Economics, 18, 755-766.

Falck, O., Heblich, S., Lameli, A., & Südekum, J. (2012). Dialects, cultural identity, and economic exchange. Journal of Urban Economics, 72, 225-239.

Fonken, L. K., Xu, X., Weil, Z. M., Chen, G., Sun, Q., Rajagopalan, S., & Nelson, R. J. (2011). Air pollution impairs cognition, provokes depressive-like behaviors and alters hippocampal cytokine expression and morphology. Molecular Psychiatry, 16, 987-995.

Frese, M., Garst, H., & Fay, D. (2007). Making things happen: Reciprocal relationships between work characteristics and personal initiative in a four-wave longitudinal structural equation model. Journal of Applied Psychology, 92, 1084-1102.

Frey, B. S., & Stutzer, A. (2000). Happiness, economy and institutions. Economic Journal, 110, 918-938.

Friedman, H. S. (2000). Long‐term relations of personality and health: Dynamisms, mechanisms, tropisms. Journal of Personality, 68, 1089-1107.

Friedman, H. S., Tucker, J. S., Tomlinson-Keasey, C., Schwartz, J. E., Wingard, D. L., & Criqui, M. H. (1993). Does childhood personality predict longevity? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 65, 176–185.

Fritsch, M., & Wyrwich, M. (2014). The long persistence of regional levels of entrepreneurship: Germany 1925-2005. Regional Studies, 48, 955-973.

Gallo, L. C., & Matthews, K. A. (2003). Understanding the association between socioeconomic status and physical health: Do negative emotions play a role? Psychological Bulletin, 129, 10-51.

Gallup (2015). U.S. state well-being rankings. Retrieved from http://info.healthways.com/hubfs/Well-Being_Index/2015_Data/Gallup-Healthways_State_of_American_Well-Being_2015_State_Rankings.pdf?t=1467233894980.

Glaeser, E. L., & Gottlieb, J. D. (2009). The wealth of cities. Journal of Economic Literature, 47, 983-1028.

Glaeser, E. L., Kerr, S. P. & Kerr, W.R. (2015). Entrepreneurship and urban growth: An empirical assessment with historical mines. Review of Economics and Statistics, 97, 498-520.

Glymour, M. M., Avendaño, M., & Berkman, L. F. (2007). Is the ‘Stroke Belt’worn from childhood? Risk of first stroke and state of residence in childhood and adulthood. Stroke, 38, 2415-2421.

Greif, A. (1994). Cultural beliefs and the organization of society: A historical and theoretical reflection on collectivist and individualist societies. Journal of Political Economy, 102, 912-950.

Gresser, T. (2001). Pittsburgh and the Ruhr Area: Common patterns in the fight against shutdowns during the decline of steel. Jahrbuch für Wirtschaftsgeschichte/Economic History Yearbook, 42, 65-74.

Guiso, L., Sapienza, P., & Zingales, L. (2008). Long term persistence. NBER Working Papers No. 14278.

Hacking, J. M., Muller, S., & Buchan, I. E. (2011). Trends in mortality from 1965 to 2008 across the English north-south divide: Comparative observational study. British Medical Journal, 342, 508.

Hatcher, J. (1993). The history of the British coal industry: Volume 1 before 1700: Towards the age of coal. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Heijmans, B. T., Tobi, E. W., Stein, A. D., Putter, H., Blauw, G. J., Susser, E. S. … Lumey, L. H. (2008). Persistent epigenetic differences associated with prenatal exposure to famine in humans. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 105, 17046-17049.

Heim, C. E. (1997). Dimensions of decline: Industrial regions in the United States and Europe, 1970-1990. International Regional Science Review, 20, 211-238.

Humphrey, S. E., Nahrgang, J. D., & Morgeson, F. P. (2007). Integrating motivational, social, and contextual work design features: A meta-analytic summary and theoretical extension of the work design literature. Journal of Applied Psychology, 92, 1332-1356.

John, O. P., & Srivastava, S. (1999). The big five trait taxonomy: History, measurement, and theoretical perspectives. In L. A. Pervin & O. P. John (Eds.), Handbook of personality: Theory and research (2nd ed., pp. 102–138). New York: Guilford Press.

Jokela, M. (2015). Does neighbourhood deprivation cause poor health? Within-individual analysis of movers in a prospective cohort study: Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health, 69, 899-904.

Jokela, M., Bleidorn, W., Lamb, M. E., Gosling, S. D., & Rentfrow, P. J. (2015). Geographically varying associations between personality and life satisfaction in the London metropolitan area. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 112, 725-730.

Jokela, M., Elovainio, M., Kivimäki, M., & Keltikangas-Järvinen, L. (2008). Temperament and migration patterns in Finland. Psychological Science, 19, 831-837.

Judge, T. A., Erez, A., Bono, J. E., & Thoresen, C. J. (2003). The core self‐evaluations scale: Development of a measure. Personnel Psychology, 56, 303-331.

Judge, T. A., Heller, D., & Mount, M. K. (2002). Five-factor model of personality and job satisfaction: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 87, 530-541.

Kanefsky, J. W. (1979). The diffusion of power technology in British industry 1760-1870. Faculty of Social Studies, University of Exeter.

Kitayama, S., Ishii, K., Imada, T., Takemura, K., & Ramaswamy, J. (2006). Voluntary settlement and the spirit of independence: Evidence from Japan's “Northern Frontier.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 91, 369-384.

Kitson, P. M., Shaw-Taylor, L., Wrigley, E. A., Davies, R. S., Newton, G., & Satchell, A. E. M. (2013). The creation of a ‘census’ of adult male employment for England and Wales for 1817 [Online]. Retrieved from http://www.geog.cam.ac.uk/research/projects/occupations/britain19c/papers/paper4.pdf

Kohn, M. L., & Schooler, C. (1982). Job conditions and personality: A longitudinal assessment of their reciprocal effects”. American Journal of Sociology, 87, 1257-1286.

Kohn, M. L., & Schooler, C. (1983). Work and personality: An inquiry into the impact of social stratification. Norwood, N.J.: Ablex Publishing Corporation.

Krugman, P. (1991). History and industry location: The case of the manufacturing belt. The American Economic Review, 81, 80-83.

Landes, D. (1969). The unbound Prometheus: Technological change and industrial development in western Europe from 1750 to the present. Cambridge, New York: Press Syndicate of the University of Cambridge.

Lundberg, U., Granqvist, M., Hansson, T., Magnusson, M., & Wallin, L. (1989). Psychological and physiological stress responses during repetitive work at an assembly line. Work and Stress, 3, 143-153.

Luster, T., Rhoades, K., & Haas, B. (1989). The relation between parental values and parenting behavior: A test of the Kohn hypothesis. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 51, 139-147.

Lynch, J. W., Kaplan, G. A., & Shema, S. J. (1997). Cumulative impact of sustained economic hardship on physical, cognitive, psychological, and social functioning. New England Journal of Medicine, 337, 1889-1895.

Marx, K. (1859). Zur Kritik der Politischen Ökonomie. [A critique of political economy]. Berlin: Franz Duncker.

Marmot, M. G. & Wilkinson, R. G. (Eds.) (2005). Social Determinants of Health (2nd ed.). London, England: Oxford University Press.

Matthews, K. A., & Gallo, L. C. (2011). Psychological perspectives on pathways linking socioeconomic status and physical health. Annual Review of Psychology, 62, 501-530.

McCloskey, D. (2004). Review of the Cambridge economic history of modern Britain (edited by Roderick Floud and Paul Johnson). Times Higher Education Supplement, 15 January 2004.

McCrae, R. R., Costa, P. T. (1991). Adding liebe und arbeit: The full five-factor model and well-being. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 17, 227-232.

Mokyr, J. (2001). The rise and fall of the factory system: Technology, firms, and households since the Industrial Revolution. Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, 55, 1-45.

Müller, B., Finka, M., & Lintz, G. (2006). Rise and decline of industry in Central and Eastern Europe: A comparative study of cities and regions in eleven countries. Berlin: Springer.

Nakaya, M., Oshio, A., & Kaneko, H. (2006). Correlations for adolescent resilience scale with big five personality traits. Psychological Reports, 98, 927-930.

Nettle, D. (2010). Dying young and living fast: Variation in life history across English neighborhoods. Behavioral Ecology, 21, 387-395.

Nunn, N., & Wantchekon, L. (2011). The slave trade and the origins of mistrust in Africa. American Economic Review, 101, 3221-3252.

Nuvolari, A., Verspagen, B., & Von Tunzelmann, N. (2011). The early diffusion of the steam engine in Britain, 1700–1800: A reappraisal. Cliometrica, 5, 291-321.

Obschonka, M., Schmitt-Rodermund, E., Silbereisen, R. K., Gosling, S. D., & Potter, J. (2013). The regional distribution and correlates of an entrepreneurship-prone personality profile in the United States, Germany, and the United Kingdom: A socioecological perspective. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 105, 104–122.

Obschonka, M., Stuetzer, M., Audretsch, D. B., Rentfrow, P. J., Potter, J., & Gosling, S. D. (2016). Macropsychological factors predict regional economic resilience during a major economic crisis. Social Psychology and Personality Science, 7, 95-104.

OECD (2011). How’s life? Measuring well being. http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264121164-en

Oishi, S. (2014). Socioecological psychology. Annual Review of Psychology, 65, 581-609.

Oswald, A. J., & Wu, S. (2011). Well-being across America. Review of Economics and Statistics, 93, 1118-1134.

Panagos P., Van Liedekerke M., Jones A., & Montanarella, L. (2012). Response to European policy support and public data requirements. Land Use Policy, 29, 329-338.

Paulhus, D. L., & Williams, K. M. (2002). The dark triad of personality: Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy. Journal of Research in Personality, 36, 556-563.

Pennebaker, J. W., Rimé, B., & Blankenship, V. E. (1996). Stereotypes of emotional expressiveness of northerners and southerners: A cross-cultural test of Montesquieu's hypotheses. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 70, 372.

Perloff, H. (1960), Regions, resources, and economic growth. Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press.

Plaut, V. C., Markus, H. R., Treadway, J. R., & Fu, A. S. (2012). The cultural construction of self and well-being: A tale of two cities. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 38, 1644-1658.

Putnam, R. D. (2000). Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community. New York: Simon & Schuster.

Redford, A., & Chaloner, W. H. (Eds.). (1976). Labour migration in England, 1800-1850. Manchester UK: Manchester University Press.

Reid, W. V., Mooney, H. A., Cropper, A., Capistrano, D., Carpenter, S. R. Chopra, K., … & Zurek, M. B. (2005). Millennium ecosystem assessment synthesis report. Washington, D.C.: Island Press.

Rentfrow, P. J. (2014). Geographical psychology: Exploring the interaction of environment and behavior. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.

Rentfrow, P. J., Gosling, S. D., Jokela, M., Stillwell, D. J., Kosinski, M., & Potter, J. (2013). Divided we stand: Three psychological regions of the United States and their political, economic, social, and health correlates. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 105, 996-1012.

Rentfrow, P. J., Gosling, S. D., & Potter, J. (2008). A theory of the emergence, persistence, and expression of geographic variation in psychological characteristics. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 3, 339–369.

Rentfrow, P. J., Jokela, M., & Lamb, M. E. (2015). Regional personality differences in Great Britain. PloS ONE, 10(3), e0122245.

Roberts, B. W., Caspi, A., & Moffitt, T. E. (2003). Work experiences and personality development in young adulthood. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84, 582-593.

Roberts, B. W., Kuncel, N. R., Shiner, R., Caspi, A., & Goldberg, L. R. (2007). The power of personality: The comparative validity of personality traits, socioeconomic status, and cognitive ability for predicting important life outcomes. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 2, 313-345.

Roberts, B. W., Walton, K. E., & Bogg, T. (2005). Conscientiousness and health across the life course. Review of General Psychology, 9, 156-168.

Robins, R. W., John, O. P., Caspi, A., Moffitt, T. E., & Stouthamer-Loeber, M. (1996). Resilient, overcontrolled, and undercontrolled boys: Three replicable personality types. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 70, 157.

Sachs, J. D., & Warner, A. M. (2001). The curse of natural resources. European Economic Review, 45, 827-838.

Silbereisen, R. K., & Chen, X. (Eds.). (2010). Human development and social change: Concept and results. London: Sage.

Smith, A. (1776). An inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations. Edwin Cannan's annotated edition (Volume I: liv, 524; Volume II: 568, 1977).

Soto, C. J., & John, O. P. (2009). Ten facet scales for the big five inventory: Convergence with NEO PI-R facets, self-peer agreement, and discriminant validity. Journal of Research in Personality, 43, 84-90.

Soto, C. J., John, O. P., Gosling, S. D., & Potter, J. (2011). Age differences in personality traits from 10 to 65: Big five domains and facets in a large cross-sectional sample. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 100, 330-348.

Soto, C. J., & Luhmann, M. (2013). Who can buy happiness? Personality traits moderate the effects of stable income differences and income fluctuations on life satisfaction. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 4, 46-53.

Staiger, D. & Stock, J. H. (1997). Instrumental variables regression with weak instruments. Econometrica, 65, 557-586.

Steel, P., Schmidt, J., & Shultz, J. (2008). Refining the relationship between personality and subjective well-being. Psychological Bulletin, 134, 138-161.

Stuetzer, M., Audretsch, D.B., Obschonka, M., Gosling, S.D., Rentfrow, P.J., & Potter, J. (2017). Entrepreneurship culture, knowledge spillovers, and the growth of regions. Regional Studies, DOI: 10.1080/00343404.2017.1294251.

Stuetzer, M., Obschonka, M., Audretsch, D. B., Wyrwich, M., Rentfrow, P. J., Coombes, M., & Satchell, M. (2016). Industry structure, culture, and entrepreneurship. An empirical assessment using historical coalfields. European Economic Review, 86, 52-72.

Talhelm, T. (2015). The rice theory of culture (Doctoral dissertation). University of Virginia: Charlottesville, Virginia.

Talhelm, T., Zhang, X., Oishi, S., Shimin, C., Duan, D., Lan, X., & Kitayama, S. (2014). Large-scale psychological differences within China explained by rice versus wheat agriculture. Science, 344, 603-608.

Tarr R. S., & McCurry F. M. (1910) New geographies. New York: Macmillan Company (Map downloaded from http://etc.usf.edu/maps/pages/2000/2085/2085.htm).

Teaford, J. C. (1993). Cities of the heartland: The rise and fall of the industrial Midwest. Bloomington and Indianapolis, IN: Indiana University Press.

The Gallup Organization. (2007). The state of global well-being. New York: The Gallup Organization.

Thompson, E. P. (1966). The making of the English working class. New York: Vintage.

U.S. Census Office (1913). Thirteenth census of the United States (Volume 11, Chapter 3, Table 32: Coal Mines – General Statistics, by States). United States: U.S. Census Office.

U.S. Census Office (1901a). Twelfth Census of the United States (Volume VII, Chapter 12, Table 5: Groups of Industries, by States and Territories: 1900). United States: U.S. Census Office.

U.S. Census Office (1901b). Twelfth Census of the United States (Volume I, Part I, Table 5: Population of states and territories). United States: U.S. Census Office.

Van Lange, P. A., Rinderu, M. I., & Bushman, B. J. (in press). Aggression and violence around the world: A model of Climate, aggression, and self-control in humans (CLASH). Behavioral and Brain Sciences. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X16000406