Impact Evaluation of Remittance for Pakistan: Propensity Score Matching Approach

Siddiqui, Rizwana (2011): Impact Evaluation of Remittance for Pakistan: Propensity Score Matching Approach. Published in: The Pakistan Development Review , Vol. 52, No. 1 (2013): pp. 17-44.

Abstract

This study attempts to uncover the biases in the impact evaluation of remittances when the problems relating to selection bias and counter factual are not taken into account. Taking migration as an intervention and foreign remittances as an input, the study measures the socioeconomic impact using an approach which yields more accurate non-experimental estimates in self-select cases through multiple output and outcome indicators such as income, expenditure, saving, and capital accumulation which, directly and indirectly, affect households’ welfare, poverty incidence and growth prospects of a country. Using PIHS data, the study first calculates the difference in socioeconomic characteristics of treated or remittances beneficiary households (RBH) and control or remittances non-beneficiary households (NRBH) ignoring endogeneity and observable differences. Second, it calculates the propensity score and evaluates the impact using data from common support area for both RBH and NRBH households. Third, it evaluates the impact using the propensity score matching approach which replicates the experimental benchmark. The difference in the first and the third estimates reveals the bias originating from the issues of selection and difference in observable characteristics. The results show that after controlling for observable characteristics of households, regional difference, networking and applying the selection correction technique, the average impact of remittances is significantly reduced. A disaggregated analysis shows that the socioeconomic impact of remittances differs by the level of skills. The impact is significant for relatively low skilled poor households but for high skilled households it remains significant only in case of bank deposits. The paper concludes that estimates are biased upward if the selectivity issue and endogeniety problems are ignored which may lead to wrong policy implications.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• English Title: Impact Evaluation of Remittances for Pakistan: Propensity Score Matching Approach
• Language: English
• Keywords: Propensity Score Matching, Remittances, Poverty
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business > F24 - Remittances; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I32 - Measurement and Analysis of Poverty

References

Adams, J. R. H. (1998) Remittances, Investment, and Rural Asset Accumulation in Pakistan. Economic Development and Cultural Change 47, 155–173.

Adams, J. R. H. (2008) The Demographic, Economic and Financial Determinants of International Remittances in Developing Countries. Development Economics Department, Developing Prospects Group. The World Bank, Washington, D. C. (Policy Research Working Paper 4583).

Aggarwal, R., A. D. Kunt, and M. S. M. Peria (2006) Do Worker Remittances Promote Financial Development? World Bank, Washington, DC. (World Bank Policy Research Paper 3957).

Amjad, R. (1986) Impact of Workers’ Remittances from the Middle East on Pakistan’s Economy: Some Selected Issues. The Pakistan Development Review 25:4, 757–782.

Amjad, R. (1988) To the Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of Asian Labour Migration (eds.). New Delhi: ILO/ARTEP.

Arif, G. M. (1999) Remittances and Investments at the Household Level in Pakistan. Pakistan Institute of Development Economics, Islamabad. (Research Report No. 166).

Burney, N. A. (1987) Workers’ Remittances from the Middle East and their Effect on Pakistan’s Economy. The Pakistan Development Review 26:4, 745–763.

Burney, N. A. (1988) A Macro-Economic Analysis of the Impact of Workers’ Remittances from the Middle East on Pakistan’s Economy. In R. Amjad (ed.) To the Impact Evaluation of Remittances 43 Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of Asian Labour Migration. New Delhi: ILO/ARTEP. 197–222.

Dehejia, R. and S. Wahba (2002) Propensity Score Matching Methods for Non-Experimental Causal Studies. Review of Economics and Statistics 84:1, 151–161.

Deininger, K. and L. Yanyan (2008) Economic and Social Impacts of Self-Help Group in India.Paper presented at the American Agricultural Economic Association Annual Meeting, Orlando, FL, July 2007-29.

Fajnzylber, P. and J. H. Lopez (2007) Close to Home, The Development Impact of Remittances in Latin America, Conference Edition, The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank, Washington, D.C.

Farchy, E. (2009) The Impact of EU Accession on Human Capital Formation: Can Migration Fuel a Brain Gain? The World Bank, Development Economics, Policy Review Unit. Washington, D.C. (Policy Research Working Paper No. 4845).

Gilani, I., M. K. Faheem, and M. Iqbal (1981) Labour Migration from Pakistan to the Middle East and Its Impact on the Domestic Economy. Pakistan Institute of Development Economics, Islamabad. (Research Report Series No.126).

Ham, C., X. L. John, and B. R. Patricia (2005) Propensity Score Matching, a Distance—Based Measure of Migration and the Wage Growth of Young Men. Federal Reserve Bank of New York. (Staff Report No. 212).

Heckman, J. J., I. Hidehiko, and T. Petra (1997) Matching as an Econometric Evaluation Estimator: Evidence from Evaluating a Job Training Programme. Review of Economic Studies 64, 605–654.

Heckman, J., H. Ichimura, and P. Todd (1998) Matching as an Econometric Evaluation Estimator. Review of Economic Studies 65, 261–294.

Hyun, O. S. (1988) The Impact of Overseas Migration on National Development: The Case of the Republic of Korea. In R. Amjad (ed.) To the Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of Asian Labour Migration.New Delhi: ILO/ARTEP. 143–166.

Iqbal, Z. and A. Sattar (2005) The Contribution of Workers’ Remittances to Economic Growth in Pakistan. Pakistan Institute of Development Economics, Islamabad. (Research Report No. 187).

Jalan, J. and M. Ravallion (2001) Does Piped Water Reduce Diarrhea for Children in Rural India? Development Research Group, Poverty. The World Bank, Washington, D. C. (Policy Research Working Paper 2664).

Jongwanich, J. (2007) Worker’s Remittances, Economic Growth and Poverty in Developing Asia and the Pacific Countries, United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (UNESCAP) (Working Paper, WP/07/01).

Kazi, S. (1988) Domestic Impact of Overseas Migration: Pakistan. In R. Amjad (ed.) To the Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of Asian Labour Migration. New Delhi: ILO/ARTEP.

Knerr, B. (1992) Methods for Assessing the Impact of Temporary Labour Emigration. The Pakistan Development Review 31:4, 1207–1239.

Mahmud, W. (1988) The Impact of Overseas Labour Migration on the Bangladesh Economy: A Macro-Economic Perspective. In R. Amjad (ed.) To the Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of Asian Labour Migration. New Delhi: ILO/ARTEP. 44

Malik, S. J. and N. Sarwar (1993) Some Tests for Difference in Consumption Pattern: The Impact of Remittances using Household Income and Expenditure Survey data of Pakistan 1987-88. The Pakistan Development Review 32:4, 699–711.

Maqsood, A. and I. Sirajeldin (1994) International Migration, Earnings, and the Importance of Self-selection. The Pakistan Development Review 33:3, 211–227.

Mansuri, G. (2007) Does Work Migration Spur Investment in Origin Communities? In CaglarOzden and Maurice Schiff (eds.) Entrepreneurship, Schooling, and Child Health in Rural Pakistan in International Migration, Economic Development and Policy. Washington, DC.: World Bank and Palgrave Macmillan.

McKenzie, D., J. Gibson, and S. Stillman (2006) How Important is Selection? Experimental vs. Non-experimental Measures of Income Gains from Migration. Department of Economics. (Working Paper in Economics 3/06).

Nishat, M. and N. Bilgrami (1993) The Determinants of Workers Remittances in Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review 32:4, 1235–1245.

Nayyar, D. (1988) International Migration from India: Amacro Economic Analysis. In R. Amjad (ed.) To the Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of Asian Labour Migration.New Delhi: ILO/ARTEP.

Pakistan, Government of (2002) Pakistan Integrated Household Survey. Islamabad: Federal Bureau of Statistics.

Pakistan, Government of (2008-09) Pakistan Economic Survey. Islamabad: Planning Commission, Finance Division.

Quisumbing, R. A. and S. McNiven (2007) Moving Forward, Looking Back: The Impact of Migration and Remittances on Assets, Consumption and Credit Constraints in the Rural Philippines. Agriculture Development Economics Division, The Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United States. (ESA Working Paper No. 07-05).

Rodrigo, C. and R. A. Jayatissa (1988) Maximising Benefits from Labour Migration: Sri Lanka. In R. Amjad (ed.) To the Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of Asian Labour Migration. New Delhi: ILO/ARTEP.

Ravallion, M. (Forthcoming) Evaluating Three Stylised Interventions, Forthcoming. Journal of Development Effectiveness.

Rosenbaum, P. R. and D. B. Rubin (1983) The Central Role of the Propensity Score in Observational Studies for Causal Effects. Biometrika 70:1, 41–55.

Siddiqui, R. (2011) Pakistan: Migration, Remittances, and Development. Chapter 3. In Saman Kelegama (ed.) Migration, Remittances, and Development in South Asia. India: SAGE.

Siddiqui, R. and A. R. Kemal (2006) Remittances, Trade Liberalisation and Poverty in Pakistan, The Role of Excluded Variable. The Pakistan Development Review 45:3, 383–415.

Tan, E. A. and D. B. Canlas (1988) Migrant’s Saving, Remittances and Labour Supply Behaviour: The Philippines Case. In R. Amjad (ed.) To the Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of Asian Labour Migration. New Delhi: ILO/ARTEP. 223–254.

Tingsabadh, C. (1988) Maximising Development Benefits from Labour Migration: Thailand. In R. Amjad (ed.) To the Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of Asian Labour Migration. New Delhi: ILO/ARTEP. 304–343.

White, H. (2005) Challenges in Evaluating Development Effectiveness. Institute of Development Studies, Brighton. (IDS Working Paper 242).

White, H. (2006) Impact Evaluation: The Experience of the Independent Evaluation Group of The World Bank. Washington, DC.: World Bank.