Demand Shocks Change the Excess Burden From Carbon Taxes

Schaufele, Brandon (2019): Demand Shocks Change the Excess Burden From Carbon Taxes.

Abstract

Two basic propositions underlying the economics of taxation -- that excess burdens increase in elasticities and tax rates -- are shown to cause the stringency of a Pigouvian tax to vary nonlinearly with output prices. This varying stringency of carbon taxation contributes to unfavorable competitiveness consequences following shocks to demand. Empirically, this paper measures the change in carbon tax stringency by structurally recovering the supply schedule for a particular industry such that elasticities and carbon tax rates change according to the distribution of output prices. Based on this supply function, the relationship between marginal excess burden, a measure of policy stringency from the industry's perspective, and product prices is estimated. Results for the Canadian cattle industry show that with moderately high output prices, supply elasticities are small, tax rates are low and the efficiency cost of a carbon tax (gross of environmental benefits), such as the one introduced in Canada, is less than \$0.01 per dollar tax revenue. As prices decline, supply curves become increasingly elastic, tax rates rise and marginal excess burdens grow rapidly.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Carbon pricing; cattle; marginal excess burden; production function
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics

References

AAF, Alberta Agriculture & Forestry. 2003. \Development of a Farm-Level Greenhouse Gas Assessment: Identification of Knowledge Gaps and Development of a Science Plan." http://www1.agric.gov.ab.ca/Department=deptdocs:nsf=all=cl9706=FILE/ghgreport.pdf.

AAF, Alberta Agriculture & Forestry. 2015. \2015 Costs and Return Benchmarks for Crops and Forages." http://www1.agric.gov.ab.ca/$department/deptdocs.nsf/all/econ10237.

Ackerberg, Daniel A, Kevin Caves, and Garth Frazer. 2015. \Identification properties of recent production function estimators." Econometrica, 83(6): 2411{2451.

Allen, RGD, and AP Lerner. 1934. \The concept of arc elasticity of demand." The Review of Economic Studies, 1(3): 226{230.

Andersen, Dana C. 2018. \Accounting for loss of variety and factor reallocations in the welfare cost of regulations." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 88: 69{94.

Anoulioues, Lisa. 2017. \Heterogeneous firms and the environment: a cap-and-trade program." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 84: 84{101.

Antweiler, W, and S Gulati. 2016. \Frugal Cars or Frugal Drivers?" How carbon and fuel taxes influence the choice and use of cars. May, 11.

Auerbach, Alan J. 1985. \The theory of excess burden and optimal taxation." In Handbook of public economics. Vol. 1, 61{127. Elsevier.

Babiker, Mustafa H. 2005. \Climate change policy, market structure, and carbon leakage." Journal of international Economics, 65(2): 421{445.

Beauchemin, Karen A, H Henry Janzen, Shannan M Little, Tim A McAllister, and Sean McGinn. 2010. \Life cycle assessment of greenhouse gas emissions from beef production in western Canada: A case study." Agricultural Systems, 103(6): 371{379.

Boulamanti, Aikaterini, and Jose A Moya. 2017. \Production costs of the chemical industry in the EU and other countries: Ammonia, methanol and light olefins." Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 68: 1205{1212.

Brohule, Arnaud, and Michael Greenstone. 2007. \The economic impacts of climate change: evidence from agricultural output and random fluctuations in weather." The American Economic Review, 97(1): 354{385.

Brown, David P, Andrew Eckert, and Heather Eckert. 2017. \Carbon Pricing with an Output Subsidy under Imperfect Competition: The Case of Alberta's Restructured Electricity Market."

Browning, Edgar K. 1978. \The burden of taxation." Journal of Political Economy, 86(4): 649{671.

Brunel, Claire, and Arik Levinson. 2013. \Measuring environmental regulatory stringency." OECD Trade and Environment Working Papers, 2013(5): 0 1. 30

Brunnermeier, Smita B, and Arik Levinson. 2004. \Examining the evidence on environmental regulations and industry location." The Journal of Environment & Development, 13(1): 6{41.

Canfax, Canfax Research Services. 2012. \International Cost of Production Analysis." http://www.canfax.ca/Samples/CowCalf%20COP%20Analysis.pdf.

Carbone, Jared C., and Nicholas Rivers. 2017. \The Impacts of Unilateral Climate Policy on Competitiveness: Evidence From Computable General Equilibrium Models." Review of Environmental Economics and Policy, 11(1): 24{42.

Carlton, Dennis W, and Jeffrey M Perloff. 2015. Modern industrial organization. Pearson Higher Ed.

CFIB, Canadian Federal for Independent Business. 2019. \What carbon pricing will mean for your business." https://www.cfib-fcei.ca/en/advocacy/carbon-pricing-federal.

Cherniwchan, Jevan, and Nouri Najjar. 2018. \Do Environmental Regulations Affect the Decision to Export?"

Cherniwchan, Jevan, Brian R. Copeland, and M. Scott Taylor. 2017. \Trade and the Environment: New Methods, Measurements, and Results." Annual Review of Economics, 9(1): 59{85.

Chetty, Raj. 2009. \Sufficient statistics for welfare analysis: A bridge between structural and reduced-form methods." Annu. Rev. Econ., 1(1): 451{488.

Copeland, Brian R, and M Scott Taylor. 2004. \Trade, growth, and the environment." Journal of Economic literature, 42(1): 7{71.

Crisan, Daria, and Jack Mintz. 2016. \Alberta's new royalty regime is a step towards competitiveness: A 2016 update."

Cullen, Joseph A, and Erin T Mansur. 2017. \Inferring Carbon Abatement Costs in Electricity Markets: A Revealed Preference Approach Using the Shale Revolution." American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 9(3): 106{133.

Dahlby, Bev. 2008. The marginal cost of public funds: Theory and applications. MIT press.

Dahlby, Bev, and Ergete Ferede. 2012. \The effects of tax rate changes on tax bases and the marginal cost of public funds for Canadian provincial governments." International Tax and Public Finance, 19(6): 844{883.

Dahlby, Bev, and Ergete Ferede. 2018. \The Marginal Cost of Public Funds and the Laffer Curve: Evidence from the Canadian Provinces." FinanzArchiv: Public Finance Analysis.

De Cara, Stephane, Loic Henry, and Pierre-Alain Jayet. 2018. \Optimal coverage of an emission tax in the presence of monitoring, reporting, and verification costs." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 89: 71{93.

Dechezlepretre, Antoine, and Misato Sato. 2017. \The impacts of environmental regulations on competitiveness." Review of Environmental Economics and Policy, 11(2): 183{206. 31

De Loecker, Jan, and Frederic Warzynski. 2012. \Markups and firm-level export status." The American Economic Review, 102(6): 2437{2471.

Diamond, Peter A. 1973. \Consumption externalities and imperfect corrective pricing." The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science, 526{538.

Dion, Jason. 2016. \The beef with beef." Ecofiscal Commission, https://ecofiscal.ca/2016/09/07/the{beef{with{beef/ (last accessed May 16, 2018).

Dyck, Toban. 2017. \Amid tight margins and commodity volatility, Canadian farmers faced with a new challenge | carbon taxes." Financial Post: http://business.financialpost.com/commodities/agriculture/amid-tight-margins-and-commodity- volatility-canadian-farmers-faced-with-a-new-cost-carbon-taxes (April 10, 2017).

ECCC, Environment Climate Change Canada. 2015. \National Inventory Report, 1990- 2013." https://www.ec.gc.ca/ges-ghg/default.asp?lang=En&n=83A34A7A-1.

FAO, Food Agriculturae Organization. 2017. \Key Facts and Findings." http://www.fao.org/news/story/en/item/197623/icode/.

Fell, Harrison, Ian A MacKenzie, and William A Pizer. 2012. \Prices versus quantities versus bankable quantities." Resource and Energy Economics, 34(4): 607{623.

Fischer, Carolyn, and Alan K Fox. 2012. \Comparing policies to combat emissions leakage: Border carbon adjustments versus rebates." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 64(2): 199{216.

Fowlie, Meredith, and Mar Reguant. 2018. \Challenges in the Measurement of Leakage Risk." Vol. 108, 124{29.

Fowlie, Meredith L. 2009. \Incomplete environmental regulation, imperfect competition, and emissions leakage." American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 1(2): 72{112.

Fowlie, Meredith L, Mar Reguant, and S Ryan. 2016a. \Measuring Leakage Risk." Technical report, California Air Resources Board.

Fowlie, Meredith, Mar Reguant, and Stephen P Ryan. 2016b. \Market-based emissions regulation and industry dynamics." Journal of Political Economy, 124(1): 249{302.

Ganapati, Sharat, Joseph S Shapiro, and Reed Walker. 2016. \Energy prices, pass-through, and incidence in US manufacturing."

Glowacki, Laura. 2017. \Don't tax us for carbon, cattle farmers plead: Beef producers say business will suffer if they are taxed for on-farm emissions." CBC News: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/beef-farmers-carbon-tax-1.4028853 (March 17, 2017).

Goulder, Lawrence H. 1995. \Environmental taxation and the double dividend: a reader's guide." International tax and public finance, 2(2): 157{183.

Griffith, Rachel, Martin O'Connell, and Kate Smith. 2017. \Design of optimal corrective taxes in the alcohol market." Institute for Fiscal Studies. 32

Hanna, Rema. 2010. \US environmental regulation and FDI: evidence from a panel of US-based multinational firms." American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 2(3): 158{189.

Hoel, Michael. 1996. \Should a carbon tax be differentiated across sectors?" Journal of public economics, 59(1): 17{32.

Hoel, Michael, and Larry Karp. 2002. \Taxes versus quotas for a stock pollutant." Resource and Energy Economics, 24(4): 367{384.

Ismer, Roland, and Karsten Neuhoff. 2007. \Border tax adjustment: a feasible way to support stringent emission trading." European Journal of Law and Economics, 24(2): 137{164.

Jacobsen, Mark R, Christopher R Knittel, James M Sallee, and Arthur A van Benthem. 2018. \The Use of Regression Statistics to Analyze Imperfect Pricing Policies."

Knittel, Christopher R, and Ryan Sandler. 2013. \The welfare impact of indirect pigouvian taxation: Evidence from transportation." National Bureau of Economic Research.

Lawley, Chad, and Vincent Thivierge. forthcoming. \Refining the Evidence: British Columbia's Carbon Tax and Household Gasoline Consumption." Energy Policy.

Legesse, G, KA Beauchemin, KH Ominski, EJ McGeough, R Kroebel, D MacDonald, SM Little, and TA McAllister. 2016. \Greenhouse gas emissions of Canadian beef production in 1981 as compared with 2011." Animal Production Science, 56(3): 153{168.

Levinsohn, James, and Amil Petrin. 2003. \Estimating production functions using inputs to control for unobservables." The Review of Economic Studies, 70(2): 317{341.

Levinson, Arik, and M Scott Taylor. 2008. \Unmasking the pollution haven effect." International economic review, 49(1): 223{254.

Li, Zhe, and Jianfei Sun. 2015. \Emission taxes and standards in a general equilibrium with entry and exit." Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 61: 34{60.

Marion, Justin, and Erich Muehlegger. 2011. \Fuel tax incidence and supply conditions." Journal of Public Economics, 95(9-10): 1202{1212.

Markusen, James R. 1975. \International externalities and optimal tax structures." Journal of international economics, 5(1): 15{29.

Mendelsohn, Robert, William D Nordhaus, and Daigee Shaw. 1994. \The impact of global warming on agriculture: a Ricardian analysis." The American economic review, 753{771.

Mundlak, Yair, Rita Butzer, and Donald F Larson. 2012. \Heterogeneous technology and panel data: The case of the agricultural production function." Journal of Development Eco- nomics, 99(1): 139{149.

Murray, Brian, and Nicholas Rivers. 2015. \British Columbia's revenue-neutral carbon tax: A review of the latest \grand experiment" in environmental policy." Energy Policy, 86: 674{683. 33

Neufeldt, Henry, and Michael Schafer. 2008. \Mitigation strategies for greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture using a regional economic-ecosystem model." Agriculture, ecosystems & environment, 123(4): 305{316.

Newell, Richard G, and William A Pizer. 2003. \Regulating stock externalities under uncertainty." Journal of environmental economics and management, 45(2): 416{432.

Olley, GS, and A Pakes. 1996. \The dynamics of productivity in the telecommunications equipment industry." Econometrica, 64(6): 1263{1297.

Peters, Mark, Robert House, Jan Lewandrowski, and Howard McDowell. 2001. \Economic impacts of carbon charges on US agriculture." Climatic Change, 50(4): 445{473.

Phaneuf, Daniel J, and Till Requate. 2016. A Course in Environmental Economics: Theory, Policy, and Practice. Cambridge University Press.

Pizer, William A. 2002. \Combining price and quantity controls to mitigate global climate change." Journal of public economics, 85(3): 409{434.

Plourde, Andre. 2009. \Oil sands royalties and taxes in Alberta: An assessment of key developments since the mid-1990s." The Energy Journal, 111{139.

Rivers, Nicholas. 2017. \The impact of carbon pricing on Canada's agricultural sector."

Rivers, Nicholas, and Brandon Schaufele. 2015a. \The effect of carbon taxes on agricultural trade." Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue canadienne d'agroeconomie, 63(2): 235{257.

Rivers, Nicholas, and Brandon Schaufele. 2015b. \Salience of carbon taxes in the gasoline market." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 74: 23{36.

Sandmo, Agnar. 1975. \Optimal taxation in the presence of externalities." The Swedish Journal of Economics, 86{98.

Schaufele, Brandon. 2018. \Carbon Taxes and Cattle: Evidence from Canadian Feedlots." https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract id=3165735.

Schlenker, Wolfram, and Michael J Roberts. 2009. \Nonlinear temperature effects indicate severe damages to US crop yields under climate change." Proceedings of the National Academy of sciences, 106(37): 15594{15598.

Schneider, Uwe A, and Bruce A McCarl. 2005. \Implications of a carbon-based energy tax for US agriculture." Agricultural and Resource Economics Review, 34(2): 265{279.

Scott, K Rebecca. 2015. \Demand and price uncertainty: Rational habits in international gasoline demand." Energy, 79: 40{49.

Severen, Christopher, Christopher Costello, and Olivier Deschenes. 2016. \A Forward Looking Ricardian Approach: Do Land Markets Capitalize Climate Change Forecasts?" National Bureau of Economic Research. 34

Slade, Peter. 2018. \The Effects of Pricing Canadian Livestock Emissions." Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics/Revue canadienne d'agroeconomie. Statistics Canada, A. 2016. \Farm Cash Reciepts, Annual." Cansim, Table 002{0001.

Syverson, Chad. 2011. \What determines productivity?" Journal of Economic literature, 49(2): 326{65.

Taylor, M Scott. 2004. \Unbundling the pollution haven hypothesis." Advances in Economic Analysis & Policy, 3(2).

Tombe, Trevor, and Jennifer Winter. 2015. \Environmental policy and misallocation: The productivity effect of intensity standards." Journal of Environmental Economics and Manage- ment, 72: 137{163.

Triest, Robert K. 1990. \The relationship between the marginal cost of public funds and marginal excess burden." The American Economic Review, 80(3): 557{566.

USDA, United States Department of Agriculture. 2016. \Overview of the United States Cattle Industry." National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS), Agricultural Statistics Board, United States Department of Agriculture.

USDA, United States Department of Agriculture. 2017. \Livestock and Poultry: World Markets and Trade." Foreign Agricultural Service.

Verge, XPC, JA Dyer, RL Desjardins, and D Worth. 2008. \Greenhouse gas emissions from the Canadian beef industry." Agricultural Systems, 98(2): 126{134.

Weitzman, Martin L. 1974. \Prices vs. quantities." The review of economic studies, 41(4): 477{ 491.

Weitzman, Martin L. 2018. \Prices or Quantities Dominate Banking and Borrowing." National Bureau of Economic Research.

WSJ, Wall Street Journal. 2018. \Exxon Puts Up $1 Million to Promote Carbon Tax." https://www.wsj.com/articles/exxon-puts-up-1-million-to-campaign-for-a-carbon-tax.

Yamazaki, Akio. 2017. \Jobs and Climate Policy: Evidence from British Columbia's Revenue- Neutral Carbon Tax." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management.