Raising Revenue with a Progressive Value-Added Tax

Gale, William G. (2020): Raising Revenue with a Progressive Value-Added Tax. Published in: Tacking the Tax Code: Efficient and Equitable Ways to Raise Revenue : pp. 191-236.

Abstract

To raise revenue in a progressive, efficient, and administrable manner, this chapter proposes a new national consumption tax: a broad-based credit-invoice value-added tax (VAT). The proposal comes with several qualifications: the VAT should complement, not substitute for, new direct taxes on the wealth or income of affluent households; to ensure the policy change is progressive, the VAT should be coupled with adjustments to government means-tested programs to account for price level changes, and with a universal basic income (UBI) program; to avoid having the VAT depress the economy, revenues should be used to raise aggregate demand in the short run and the Federal Reserve should accommodate the tax by allowing prices to rise. A 10 percent federal VAT that funded a UBI equal to 20 percent of the federal poverty line would be highly progressive (with net income rising among the bottom forty percent and not changing in the middle quintile) and would still raise more than 1 percent of GDP in net revenue. VATs are a proven success, existing in 168 countries. VATs have been proposed by both Democrats and Republicans in recent years. Concerns about small businesses, vulnerable populations, and the states can be easily addressed.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Consumption Tax, Progressive, Revenue
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D63 - Equity, Justice, Inequality, and Other Normative Criteria and Measurement; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H20 - General; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H27 - Other Sources of Revenue

References

Ainsworth, Richard. 2006. “Carousel Fraud in the EU: A Digital VAT Solution.” Working Paper 06- 23. Boston University School of Law.

Alm, James, and El-Ganainy, Asmaa. 2012. “Value-Added Taxation and Consumption.” International Tax and Public Finance 20 (1) 105–28.

Altig, David, Alan J. Auerbach, Laurence J. Kotlikoff, Kent A. Smetters, and Jan Walliser. 2001. “Simulating Fundamental Tax Reform in the United States.” The American Economic Review 91 (3): 574—95.

Americans for Tax Reform. 2019. “Pledge Database.” Accessed December 12, 2019. https://www.atr. org/pledge-database.

Auerbach, Alan. 2006. “The Choice Between Income and Consumption Taxes: A Primer.” NBER Working Paper 12307. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Auerbach, Alan, William Gale, and Aaron Krupkin. 2019. “Revising the Federal Budget Outlook.” Tax Notes, August 5.

Auerbach, Alan, and Roger Gordon. 2002. “Taxation of Financial Services under a VAT.” American Economic Review 92 (2): 411–16.

Auerbach, Alan, and Laurence Kotlikoff. 1987. “Evaluating Fiscal Policy with a Dynamic Simulation Model.” American Economic Review 77 (2): 49–55.

Avi-Yonah, Reuven. 2011. “The Political Pathway: When Will the U.S. Adopt a VAT?” In The VAT Reader: What a Federal Consumption Tax Would Mean for America,. Washington, DC: Tax Analysts.

Bartlett, Bruce. 2007. “‘Starve the Beast’: Origins and Development of a Budgetary Metaphor.” Independent Review 12 (Summer 2007): 5–26.

———. 2011. “Reagan’s Forgotten Tax Record.” February 22. http://capitalgainsandgames.com/blog/ bruce-bartlett/2154/reagans-forgotten-tax-record.

Batchelder, Lily, and David Kamin. 2019. “Taxing the Rich: Issues and Options.” The Aspen Institute Economic Strategy Group.

Becker, Gary S., and Casey B. Mulligan. 2003. “Deadweight Costs and the Size of Government.” Journal of Law and Economics 46 (2): 293–340.

Benartzi, Youssef, and Alisa Tazhitdinova. 2018. “Do Value-Added Taxes Affect International Trade Flows? Evidence from 30 Years of Tax Reforms.” NBER Working Paper 26195. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Benge, Matt, Marie Pallot, and Hamish Slack. 2013. “Possible Lessons for the United States From New Zealand’s GST.” National Tax Journal 66 (2): 479–98.

Bickley, James. 2012. “Value-Added Tax (VAT) as a Revenue Option: A Primer.” Congressional Research Service, Washington, DC.

Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve. 2016. “Survey of Consumer Finances.” Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve, Washington, DC.

Bradford, David F. 1986. Untangling the Income Tax. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Brashares, Edith, Matthew Knittel, Gerald Silverstein, and Alexander Yuskavage. 2014. “Calculating the Optimal Small Business Exemption Threshold for a U.S. VAT.” National Tax Journal 67 (2): 283–320.

Bureau of Economic Analysis. 2019. “Government Current Receipts and Expenditures.” National Income and Product Accounts. U.S. Department of Commerce, Washington, DC.

Burman, Leonard. 2009. “A Blueprint for Tax Reform and Health Reform.” Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, Washington, DC.

———. 2019. “A Universal EITC: Sharing the Gains from Economic Growth, Encouraging Work, and Supporting Families.” Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, Washington, DC.

Burman, Leonard E., William G. Gale, Sarah Gault, Bryan Kim, Jim Nunns, and Steve Rosenthal. 2016. “Financial Transaction Taxes in Theory and Practice.” National Tax Journal 69 (1): 171–216.

Burman, Leonard, Jane Gravelle, and Jeff Rohaly. 2005. “Towards a More Consistent Distributional Analysis.” The Urban Institute, Washington, DC.

Cahalan, M., Perna, L. W., Yamashita, M., Wright, J., and Santillan, S. 2018. “Indicators of Higher Education Equity in the United States: 2018 Historical Trend Report.” The Pell Institute for the Study of Opportunity in Higher Education, Washington, DC.

Cardin, Ben. 2015. “Progressive Consumption Tax Act.” http://www.cardin.senate.gov/pct.

Carroll, Robert, Robert Cline, and Tom Neubig. 2010. The Macroeconomic Effects of an Add-on Value-Added Tax. Ernst and Young, prepared for the National Retail Federation.

Carroll, Robert, and Alan D. Viard. 2012. Progressive Consumption Taxation: The X Tax Revisited. American Enterprise Institute, Washington DC.

Casperson, Eric, and Gilbert Metcalf. 1994. “Is a Value Added Tax Regressive? Annual Versus Lifetime Incidence Measures.” National Tax Journal 47 (4): 731–46.

Cassidy, John. 2005. “The Ringleader: How Grover Norquist Keeps the Conservative Movement Together.” New Yorker, August 1.

Center for Social and Economic Research. 2019. “Study and Reports on the VAT Gap in the EU-28 Member States: 2019 Final Report.” Institute for Advanced Studies, Warsaw.

Cnossen, Sijbren. 2011. “A VAT Primer for Lawyers, Economists, and Accountants.” In The VAT Reader: What a Federal Consumption Tax Would Mean for America. Washington, DC: Tax Analysts.

Congressional Budget Office. 2019. Historical Data and Economic Projections. Retrieved from https://www.cbo.gov/about/products/budget-economic-data#7.

Corlett, W.J., and Douglas Hague. 1953. “Complementarity and the Excess Burden of Taxation.” The Review of Economic Studies 21 (1): 21–30.

Crawford, Ian, Michael Keen, and Stephen Smith. 2010. “Value Added Tax and Excises.” In Dimension of Tax Design: The Mirrlees Review, edited by James Mirrlees. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Cruz Campaign. 2015. “The Simple Flat Tax Plan.” Web page. https://www.tedcruz.org/tax_plan/index.html.

Debt Reduction Task Force. 2010. “Restoring America’s Future: Reviving the Economy, Cutting Spending and Debt, and Creating a Simple, Pro-Growth Tax System.” Bipartisan Policy Center, Washington, DC.

De Paula, Áureo, and José A Scheinkman. 2010. “Value-Added Taxes, Chain Effects, and Informality.” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 2 (4): 195–221.

Devereux, Paul, and Joseph Altonji. 2000. “The Extent and Consequences of Downward Nominal Wage Rigidity.” Research in Labor Economics 19: 383–431.

Elsby, Michael, and Gary Solon. 2019. “How Prevalent in Downward Rigidity in Nominal Wages? International Evidence from Payroll Records and Pay Slips.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 33 (3): 185–201.

Erb, Kelly P. 2019. “Free Doughnuts (and Tax Tidbits) on National Doughnut Day.” Forbes, June 7. European Parliament. 2018. “VAT Fraud: Economic Impact, Challenges, and Policy Issues.” Policy Department for Economic, Scientific and Quality of Life Policies.

Federal Bureau of Investigation. 2015. “Famous Cases & Criminals: Willie Sutton.” https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/history/famous-cases/willie-sutton.

Feenberg, Daniel, Andrew Mitrusi, and James Poterba. 1997. “Distributional Effects of Adopting a National Retail Sales Tax.” NBER Working Paper 5885. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Finkelstein, Amy. 2009. “E-Z Tax: Tax Salience and Tax Rates.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 124 (3): 969–1010.

Gadenne, Lucie, Tushar K. Nandi, and Roland Rathelot. 2019. IFS Working Paper W19/21. Institute for Fiscal Studies, London.

Gale, William G. 2005. “The National Retail Sales Tax: What Would the Rate Have to Be?” Tax Notes 107 (7): 889–911.

———. 2019. Fiscal Therapy: Curing America’s Debt Addiction and Investing in the Future. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Gale, William G., Hilary Gelfond, and Aaron Krupkin. 2016. “Entrepreneurship and Small Business under a Value-Added Tax.” Brookings Institution, Washington, DC.

Gale, William G., and Benjamin Harris. 2013. “Creating an American Value-Added Tax.” Brookings Institution, Washington, DC.

Gale, William G., and Janet Holtzblatt. 2002. “The Role of Administrative Factors in Tax Reform: Simplicity, Compliance, and Administration.” In United States Tax Reform in the Twenty-First Century, edited by George R. Zodrow and Peter Mieszkowski, 179–214. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Gale, William G., and Peter R. Orszag. 2004. “Economic Effects of Making the 2001 and 2003 Tax Cuts Permanent.” Brookings Institution, Washington, DC.

Gale, William G., and Andrew A. Samwick. 2016. “Effects of Income Tax Changes on Economic Growth.” Brookings Institution, Washington, DC.

Gendron, Pierre-Pascal. 2011. “VAT Treatment of Nonprofits and Public-Sector Entities.” In The VAT Reader: What a Federal Consumption Tax Would Mean for America. Washington, DC: Tax Analysts.

Gentry, William, and R. Glenn Hubbard. 1996. “Distributional Implications of Introducing a Broad-Based Consumption Tax.” NBER Working Paper 58362. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Gong, Yifan, Lance Lochner, Ralph Stinebrickner, and Todd R. Stinebrickner. 2019. “The Consumption Value of College.” NBER Working Paper 26335. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Graetz, Michael. 1997. The Decline (and Fall?) of the Income Tax. New York: W.W. Norton.

———. 2008. 100 Million Unnecessary Returns: A Simple, Fair, and Competitive Tax Plan for the United States. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

———. 2013. “The ‘Competitive Tax Plan’ Updated for 2015.” Presentation at the National Tax Association, Tampa, FL.

Guvenen, Fatih, Gueorgui Kambourov, Burhanettin Kuruscu, Sergio Ocampo-Diaz, and Daphne Chen. 2019. “Use It or Lose It: Efficiency Gains from Wealth Taxation.” NBER Working Paper 26284. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Hall, Robert E., and Alvin Rabushka. 1985. The Flat Tax. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press. Her Majesty’s Revenues and Customs. 2018. Internal Manual, VAT Food. Retrieved from https://www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/vat-food.

Holtzblatt, Janet. 2019. “Warren’s Wealth Tax Revenue May Not Meet Expectations.” Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center: Washington, DC.

Huntley, John, Richard Prisinzano, and John Ricco. 2019. “Policy Options: A 1% Value-Added Tax.” Penn Wharton Budget Model, Philadelphia, PA.

Kaeding, Nicole. 2019. “Tax this but not that at Halloween, depending on where you live—there’s a lesson here.” Fox Business, October 31.

Kaplow, Louis. 2008. The Theory of Taxation and Public Economics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Keen, Michael. 2001. “Preferential Regimes Can Make Tax Competition Less Harmful” National Tax Journal 54 (4): 757–62.

Keen, Michael, Russell Krelove, and John Norregaard. 2016. “Policy Forum: The Financial Activities Tax.” Canadian Tax Journal 64 (2): 389–400.

Keen, Michael, and Ben Lockwood. 2006. “Is the VAT a Money Machine?” National Tax Journal 59(4) 905–98.

Keen, Michael, and Jack Mintz. 2004. “The Optimal Threshold for a Value-Added Tax.” Journal of Public Economics 88 (3–4): 559–76.

Keen, Michael, and Stephen Smith. 2006. “VAT Fraud and Evasion: What Do We Know and What Can Be Done?” National Tax Journal 59 (4): 861–87.

Lee, Dungeon, Dongil Kim, and Thomas E. Borcherding. 2013. “Tax Structure and Government Spending: Does the Value-Added Tax Increase the Size of Government?” National Tax Journal 66 (3): 541–70.

López-Laborda, Julio, and Guillermo Peña. 2018. “A New Method for Applying VAT to Financial Services.” National Tax Journal 71 (1): 155–82.

McLure, Charles E., Jr. 2002. “The Nuttiness of State and Local Taxes—and the Nuttiness of Responses Thereto.” State Tax Notes 25 (12): 841–56.

Merrill, Peter R. 2011. “VAT Treatment of the Financial Sector.” In The VAT Reader: What a Federal Consumption Tax Would Mean for America. Washington, DC: Tax Analysts.

Metcalf, Gilbert. 1994. “Lifecycle vs. Annual Perspectives on the Incidence of A Value Added Tax.” NBER Working Paper 4619. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.

Mitchell, Daniel J. 2010. “VAT Attack.” New York Post, April 8.

———. 2011. “The Case Against the Value-Added Tax.” Cato Institute, Washington, DC.

Morris, Debra. 2011. “VAT Treatment of Charities and Public Bodies in the United Kingdom.” In The VAT Reader: What a Federal Consumption Tax Would Mean for America. Washington, DC: Tax Analysts.

Naritomi, Joana. 2019. “Consumers as Tax Auditors.” American Economic Review 109 (9): 3031–72. Nunns, Jim, and Eric Toder. 2015. “Effects of a Federal Value-Added Tax on State and Local Governments.” Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, Washington, DC. June 15.

OECD. 2016. Consumption Tax Trends 2016. Paris: OECD Publishing.

———. 2017. “Revenue Statistics—Comparison Tables.” OECD Stat. Paris: OECD Publishing.

———. 2018. Consumption Tax Trends 2018. Paris: OECD Publishing.

———. 2019. Social Security Contributions. Retrieved from https://data.oecd.org/tax/social- security-contributions.html

Paul, Rand. 2015. “Blow Up the Tax Code and Start Over.” Fair and Flat Tax Plan. Retrieved from https://www.randpaul.com/news/rand-pauls-fair-and-flat-tax.

Penn Wharton Budget Model. 2019. “Senator Elizabeth Warren’s Wealth Tax: Projected Budgetary and Economic Effects.” University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA.

Phillips, Andrew, and Muath Ibaid. 2019. “The Impact of Imposing Sales Taxes on Business Inputs.” Ernst and Young LLP and the Council on State Taxation, Washington DC.

Pomeranz, Dina. 2015. “No Taxation without Information: Deterrence and Self-Enforcement in the Value Added Tax.” American Economic Review 105 (8): 2539–69.

President’s Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform. 2005. “Simple, Fair, and Pro-Growth: Proposals to Fix America’s Tax System.” President’s Advisory Council on Federal Tax Reform, Washington, DC.

Ring Jr., Raymond L. 1989. “The Proportion of Consumers and Producers’ Goods in the General Sales Tax.” National Tax Journal 42 (2) 167–79.

Robinson, Philip, and Jeffery Saviano. 2011. “Facilitating Better VAT Compliance.” In The VAT Reader: What a Federal Consumption Tax Would Mean for America. Washington DC: Tax Analysts.

Romer, Christina D., and David H. Romer. 2009. “Do Tax Cuts Starve the Beast? The Effect of Tax Changes on Government Spending.” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, Spring 2009: 139–214.

Rosen, Jan M. 1988. “Tax Watch: The Likely New Forms of Taxes.” New York Times, December 19. Rubin, Richard. 2019. “Warren Wealth Tax Would Raise Nearly 30% Less Than Projected, Study Finds.” Politics, December 12, Wall Street Journal.

Ryan, Paul. 2008. Roadmap for America’s Future Act of 2008. 110th Congress, 2nd Session. Ryan, Paul, and Kevin Brady. 2016. “A Better Way: Our Vision for a Confident America.” Tax Reform Tax Force, United States Congress: Washington, DC.

Saez, Emmanuel, and Gabriel Zucman. 2019a. “Progress Wealth Taxation.” Conference Draft. Brookings Papers on Economic Activities, Fall 2019.

———. 2019b. The Triumph of Injustice: How the Rich Dodge Taxes and How to Make them Pay. New York, NY: W.W. Norton & Co.

Schenk, Alan. 2011. “Prior Flirtations with VAT.” In The VAT Reader: What a Federal Consumption Tax Would Mean for America. Washington, DC: Tax Analysts.

Slemrod, Joel. 2011. “Does a VAT Promote Exports?” In The VAT Reader: What a Federal Consumption Tax Would Mean for America. Washington DC: Tax Analysts.

Social Security Administration. 2016. “Income of the Population 55 or Older, 2014.” Social Security Administration Office of Retirement and Disability Policy, Washington, D.C.

Sullivan, Martin A. 2011. “VAT Lessons from Canada.” In The VAT Reader: What a Federal Consumption Tax Would Mean for America. Washington, DC: Tax Analysts.

———. 2012. “Was the VAT a Money Machine for Europe?” Washington, DC: Tax Analysts. Summers, Lawrence H., and Natasha Sarin. 2019. “A ‘Wealth Tax’ Presents a Revenue Estimation Puzzle.” Opinion, April 4, Washington Post.

Supreme Court of the United States. 2018. South Dakota v. Wayfair. 585 U.S. ____. Washington, DC.

Tait, Alan. 1991. “Value-Added Tax; Administrative and Policy Issues.” IMF Occasional Papers 88, International Monetary Fund.

Tanzi, Vito. 1995. Taxation in an Integrating World. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.

Toder, Eric, Jim Nunns, and Joseph Rosenberg. 2011. “Using a VAT for Deficit Reduction.” Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, Washington, DC.

Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. 2011. “Herman Cain’s 9-9-9 Tax Plan.” Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, Washington, DC.

———. 2019. “Income Measure Used in Distributional Analyses by the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center.” Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, Washington, DC. Accessed 12 December 2019. https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/resources/income-measure-used-distributional-analyses-tax- policy-center.

U.S. Census Bureau. 2019. “2018 Quarterly Summary of State & Local Sales Tax Revenue Tables.” U.S. Census Bureau, Suitland, MD.

U.S. Department of Agriculture. 2019. Food Expenditure Series. Economic Research Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington DC.

Warren, Elizabeth. 2019. “Ultra-Millionaire Tax.” Accessed December 12, 2019. Retrieved from https://elizabethwarren.com/plans/ultra-millionaire-tax

Weiss, Antonio, and Laura Kawano. 2020. “A Proposal to Tax Financial Transactions.” In Tackling the Tax Code: Efficient and Equitable Ways to Raise Revenue, edited by Jay Shambaugh and Ryan Nunn, Washington, DC: The Hamilton Project.