Taxation and bond market investment strategies: Evidence from the market for Government of Canada bonds

Landon, Stuart and Smith, Constance (2008): Taxation and bond market investment strategies: Evidence from the market for Government of Canada bonds.

Abstract

This paper shows that, contrary to the suggestion of some investment advisors, for an individual Canadian investor subject to personal income taxation, the after-tax yield on a discount bond is always higher (or, at worse, equal) to the yield on a premium bond. This follows because the tax rate on capital gains is lower than the tax rate on coupon income in Canada. It is also shown that a decline in the capital gains tax rate raises the after-tax yield on discount bonds, but reduces the after-tax yield on premium bonds, and may even cause the yield on premium bonds to become negative. Further, a cut in the tax rate on interest income raises the after-tax yield on all bonds, but raises the yield on premium bonds relative to discount bonds. While the lower after-tax yields on higher coupon bonds might be expected to cause the pre-tax yields on these bonds to rise, no evidence of such tax capitalization is found using a large dataset of matched pairs of Government of Canada bonds for the period 1986-2006. The observed near equality of pre-tax yields since 1995 for bonds with different coupons implies that individuals in Canada earn a significantly smaller after-tax yield from holding premium bonds than discount bonds.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: taxation; bonds; after tax returns
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G12 - Asset Pricing ; Trading Volume ; Bond Interest Rates; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H24 - Personal Income and Other Nonbusiness Taxes and Subsidies

References

Amoako-Adu, B., M. Rashid and M. Stebbins (1992) “Capital Gains tax and Equity Values: Empirical Test of Stock Price Reaction to the Introduction and Reduction of Capital Gains Tax Exemption,” Journal of Banking and Finance 16, 275-87.

Anderson, S. and S. Lavoie (2004) “The Evolution of Liquidity in the Market for Government of Canada Bonds,” Bank of Canada Review, Summer, 19-31.

Bank for International Settlements (2005) Zero-coupon yield curves: technical documentation, BIS Papers, No 25, October.

Barber, Brad M. and Terrance Odean (2003) “Are Individual Investors Tax Savvy? Evidence from Retail and Discount Brokerage Accounts,” Journal of Public Economics, 88, 419-442.

Branion, A. (1995) “The Government of Canada Bond market since 1980,” Bank of Canada Review, Autumn, 3-21.

Brealey, R.A., S. C. Myers, G. A. Sick and R. M. Giammarino (1992) Principles of Corporate Finance, Second Canadian Edition (Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson).

Brennan, M.J. and E.S. Schwartz (1979) “A Continuous Time Approach to the Pricing of Bonds,” Journal of Banking and Finance 3, 133-55.

Chalmers, J.M.R. (1998) “Default Risk Cannot Explain the Muni Puzzle: Evidence from Municipal Bonds that are Secured by U.S. Treasury Obligations,” Review of Financial Studies 11:2, 281-308.

Chouinard, E. and Z. Lalani (2001-02) “The Canadian Fixed-Income market: Recent Developments and Outlook,” Bank of Canada Review, Winter, 15-25.

Eijffinger, S.C.W., H.P. Huizinga and J.J.G. Lemmen (1998) “Short-term and Long-term Government Debt and Nonresident Interest Withholding Taxes,” Journal of Public Economics 68, 309-34.

Elton, E.J. and T.C. Green (1998) “Tax and Liquidity Effects in Pricing Government Bonds,” Journal of Finance 53:5, 1533-62.

Erickson, M., A. Goosbee and E. Maydew (2003) “How Prevalent is Tax Arbitrage? Evidence from the market for Municipal Bonds,” National Tax Journal 56:1, 259-70.

Fama and French (1998) “Taxes, Financing Decisions, and Firm Value,” The Journal of Finance, Vol. 53, No. 3, 819-843.

Gay, G.D. and S. Kim (1991) “The Coupon-Induced Tax Clientele Effect in Bond prices,” Managerial and Decision Economics 12, 367-76.

Gravelle, T. (1999) “Markets for Government of Canada Securities in the 1990s: Liquidity and Cross-Country Comparisons,” Bank of Canada Review, Autumn, 9-18.

Green, R.C. and B.A. Ødegaard (1997) “Are There Tax Effects in the Relative pricing of U.S. Government Bonds?” Journal of Finance 52:2, 609-33.

Guenther, D.A. (1994) “The Relation between Tax Rates and Pre-Tax Returns: Direct Evidence from the 1981 and 1986 Tax Rate Reductions,” Journal of Accounting and Economics 18, 379-93.

Halpern, P. and J. Rumsey (1997) “A Note on Market Efficiency, Institutional Practice, and Economic Constraints in the Experience of the Canadian Bond Market,” Journal of Banking & Finance 21, 113-23.

Halpern, P. and J. Rumsey (2000) “Strip Bonds and Arbitrage Bounds,” Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences 17:2, 143-52.

Harvey, N. (1999) “Recent Initiatives in the Canadian Market for Government of Canada Securities,” Bank of Canada Review, Summer, 27-35.

Johnson, G. (2004-05) “Government of Canada Yield-Curve Dynamics, 1986-2003,” Bank of Canada Review, Winter, 17-28.

Jordan, B.D. and S.D. Jordan (1991) “Tax Options and the Pricing of Treasury Bond Triplets,” Journal of Financial Economics 30, 135-64.

Litzenberger, R.H. and J. Rolfo (1984) “An International Study of Tax Effects on Government Bonds,” Journal of Finance 39:1, 1-22.

Livingston, M. (1979) “Taxation and Bond Market Equilibrium in a World of Uncertain Future Interest Rates,” Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 14:1, 11-27.

Lovely, M.E. and M.J. Wasylenko (1992) “State Taxation of Interest Income and Municipal Borrowing Costs,” National Tax Journal 45:1, 37-52.

Mackay, A.E., E.Z. Prisman and Y.S. Tian (2000) “Non-Segmented Equilibria Under differential Taxation: Evidence from the Canadian Government Bond Market,” European Finance Review 4, 253-78.

McCallum, J.S. (1973) “The Impact of the Capital Gains Tax on Bond Yields,” National Tax Journal 26:4, 575-83.

McKenzie, K.J. and A.J. Thompson (1995) “The Imapct of the Capital Gains Exemption on Capital Markets,” Canadian Public Policy 21(supplement), 100-15.

Robichek, A.A. and W.D. Niebuhr (1970) “Tax-Induced Bias in Reported Treasury Yields,” Journal of Finance , 1081-90.

Schaefer, S.M. (1982) “Tax-Induced Clientele Effects in the Market for British Government Securities,” Journal of Financial Economics 10, 121-59.

Scholes, M.S. and M.A. Wolfson (1992) Taxes and Business Strategy: A Planning Approach (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall).

Whittingham, M. (1996-97) “The Canadian Market for Zero Coupon Bonds,” Bank of Canada Review, 47-62.

Zeng, T. (2002) “Corporate Dividend Yields and the Lifetime Capital Gains Tax Exemption,” Canadian Tax Journal 50:4, 1307-19.