Wolfgang Mühlpfordt and the ‘transformation problem’: some remarks on articles by Howard and King and Gilibert

Quaas, Friedrun (1994): Wolfgang Mühlpfordt and the ‘transformation problem’: some remarks on articles by Howard and King and Gilibert. Published in: Cambridge Journal of Economics No. 18 : pp. 323-326.

Abstract

Until recently, the name of Wolfgang Mühlpfordt (1872-1928) was certainly not among those a theoretical economist was expected to know. Mühlpfordt has now been rehabilitated not only in the Cambridge Journal of Economics (Howard and King: 1987 and Gilibert:1991), but also in the German Jahrbücher für Nationalökonomie und Statistik (Quaas:1991). There are many points of correspondence between my own interpretation and the assessments of Mühlpfordt by Gilibert and by Howard and King. However, I believe it is possible to add some further remarks and also to make some corrections. We do not know why Mühlpfordt did not react to Bortkiewicz's famous articles (1907), to which he would certainly have had something to say. Mühlpfordt was more advanced than Bortkiewicz, since his mathematical approach is of more general validity and he prepared the way for the modern theory of production prices which is now associated with, among others, the name of Piero Sraffa.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: transformation problem; Wolfgang Mühlpfordt; Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz; labour theory of value
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B51 - Socialist; Marxian; Sraffian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B3 - History of Thought: Individuals > B31 - Individuals; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B1 - History of Economic Thought through 1925 > B16 - History of Economic Thought: Quantitative and Mathematical

References

Gilibert, G. (1991), Dr. Mühlpfort and the 'transformation problem': a reassessment, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 15, p. 353-354

Howard, M.C. and King, J.E. (1987), Dr. Mühlpfort, Professor von Bortkiewicz and the 'transformation problem', Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 11, p. 265-268

Howard, M.C. and King, J.E. (1991), Dr. Mühlpfort and the 'transformation problem': a reply to Giorgio Gilibert, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 15, p. 355-358

Koerner, B. (1930) (ed.), Deutsches Geschlechterbuch, vol. 68, Görlitz

Mühlpfordt, W. (1893), Preis und Einkommen in der privatkapitalistischen Gesellschaft, Königsberg, Hartungsche Buchdruckerei

Mühlpfort, - (1895), Karl Marx und die Durchschnittsprofitrate, Jahrbücher für Nationalökonomie und Statistik, vol. 10 (3.F.), p. 92-99

Mühlpfordt, W. (1898), Deutschlands Handelsverträge und die deutsche Zollpolitik der Zukunft, Gegenwart (35)

Mühlpfordt, W. (19191), Die gelernten Arbeiter und die Vergesellschaftung der Produktionsmittel, Berlin, H. S. Hermann

Mühlpfordt, W. (19192), Grenzen des Sozialismus, Der Einzelne. Halbmonatsschrift für Politik, Wirtschaft, Kunst, (1), p. 13-21

Mühlpfordt, W. (19193), Die Räte-Frage, Der Einzelne (2), p. 39- 46

Mühlpfordt, W. (19194), Das Weltgericht, Der Einzelne, (3), p. 77-83

Mühlpfordt, W. (1922), Die Arbeitsgesellschaft; eine Forderung deutschen Rechtsempfindens, Berlin-Friedenau

Quaas, F. (1991), Wolfgang Mühlpfordt - ein Vorgänger von Bortkiewicz? Zu den theoretischen Quellen des sogenannten Transformationsproblems, Jahrbücher für Nationalökonomie und Statistik, vol. 208/5, p. 493-504

Quaas, F. (1992), Das Transformationsproblem, Metropolis, Marburg

Seton, F. (1956), The Transformation Problem, Review of Economic Studies, vol. 14, p. 149-160