National debt brakes as a remedy for diverging economies in the European Monetary Union?

Colombier, Carsten (2013): National debt brakes as a remedy for diverging economies in the European Monetary Union? Published in: Political Economy of Eurozone Crisis – Reforms and their Limits (2013): pp. 100-122.

Abstract

Due to the ongoing crisis, several reforms have been implemented at the EU-level, which are tilted towards strengthening the budget discipline of EMU member states. These reforms underlie the view that government profligacy is the main culprit of the crisis. Consequently, a fiscal compact that includes national debt brakes at its core has been introduced in the EU. However, several economists emphasise that the EMU is an incomplete currency union. As a result, massive external imbalances have been built up in the pre-crisis years. Therefore, this present paper analyses whether a debt break, which is viewed as supportive for sustainable public finances, can also contribute to a convergent development in the EMU. The back-of-the-envelope simulations run for a typical current-account surplus and -deficit country (Germany and Spain respectively) provide mixed results. It is shown that under a debt brake current-account deficits can be lowered in a boom phase. This is because automatic stabilisers are allowed to work properly. Additionally, it is less probable that the working of automatic stabilisers is counteracted by pro-cyclical fiscal policy. But the impact of the debt brake on current-account balances depends on various factors, i.e. the position of an economy in the business cycle, the sign of the current-account balances and the instruments chosen to adjust the structural budget balance. Consequently, European policy-makers should be aware of the fact that the structural drawbacks of the EMU cannot be resolved by the attempt to balance structural government budgets. For this other measures than a fiscal compact such as a delegation of fiscal powers to the union level are necessary.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: European Monetary Union, debt brake, current-account imbalances
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C2 - Single Equation Models ; Single Variables > C20 - General; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E62 - Fiscal Policy; F - International Economics > F4 - Macroeconomic Aspects of International Trade and Finance > F42 - International Policy Coordination and Transmission; H - Public Economics > H6 - National Budget, Deficit, and Debt > H60 - General

References

Andrews, D.W.K. (1991), Heteroskedasticity and Autocorrelation Consistent Covariance Matrix Estimation. Econometrica, 59, 817–858.

Baldwin, R. and Wyplosz. C. (2006) The Economics of European Integration, 2nd ed., London, McGraw Hill Education.

Barro, R. J. and X. Sala-I-Martin (1992) Public finance in models of economic growth, Review of Economic Studies, 59, 645-61.

Baumann, E., Dönnebrink, E. and Ch. Kastrop (2008) A concept for a new budget rule for Germany, CESifo Forum No. 2/2008, 37-45.

Bofinger, P. (2003) Should the European Stability and Growth Pact be changed?, Intereconomics – Review of European Economic Policy, 38, 4 – 7.

Carlin, W. and D. Soskice (2006) Macroeconomics – Imperfections, Institutions and Policies, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Colombier, C. (2006) Does the Swiss Debt Brake Outperform the New Stability and Growth Pact in Terms of Stabilising Debt and Smoothing the Business Cycle?, Schmollers Jahrbuch - Journal of Applied Social Science Studies, 126(4), 521-533. (published in German)

Colombier, C. (2009), Growth Effects of Fiscal Policies: An Application of Robust Modified M-Estimator, Applied Economics - Special Issue: The Applied Economics of Fiscal Policy, 41(7), 899 - 912.

Colombier, C. (2011), How to Consolidate Government Budgets in View of External Imbalances in the Euro Area? Evaluating the Risk of a Savings Paradox, in: Lacina, L., Rozmahel, P., Rusek, A. (eds.). Financial and Economic Crisis: Causes, Consequences and the Future. Bucovice: Martin Stritz Publishing, Chapter 6, 104-127.

Colombier, C. (2013) National debt brakes and convergence in the EMU, paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Swiss Society of Economics and Statistics, held in Neuchâtel, Switzerland, June 2013, and the International Conference “Political Economy of Eurozone Crisis: Is Fiscal Union Feasible?” at Mendel University Brno, Czech Republic, November 2012.

De Grauwe, P. (2009a) Economics of Monetary Union, 8th ed., Oxford University Press, Oxford.

De Grauwe, P. (2009b) The Fragility of the Eurozone's Institutions, Open Economics Review, 21, 167-174.

De Grauwe, P. (2011) Too much punishment, too little forgiveness, CEPS Policy Brief No. 230/ January 2011, Centre for European Policy Studies, Brussels.

Denis, C., Grenouilleau, D., McMorrow, K. and W. Röger (2006) Calculating potential growth rates and output gaps – a revised production function approach, European Economy Economic Papers, no. 247.

Economist, Spain – The golden amendment, September 3rd 2011, http://www.economist.com/node/21528317.

EU-Memo/11/647, EU Economic Governance "Six Pack" – State of Play, 28.09.2011, http://europa.eu/rapid/pressReleasesAction.do?reference=MEMO/11/647.

Deutsche Bundesbank (2011) The debt brake in Germany – key aspects and implementation, Monthly Report, October 2011, 15-39.

Dullien, S. and D. Schwarzer (2009) Bringing Macroeconomics into the EU Budget Debate: Why and how?, Journal of Common Market Studies, 47(1), 153-174.

Girouard, N. and C. André (2005) Measuring cyclically-adjusted budget balances for OECD countries, OECD Economics Department Working Papers, No. 434.

Greenwald, B. and J.Stiglitz, (1993), New and Old Keynesians, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 7(1), 23-44. Hishow, O.N. (2011) Germany's debt brake: pulling the EU out of its debt trap?, Intereconomics – Review of European Economic Policy, 46(6), 327-331.

Kahneman, D. (2003) Maps of bounded rationality: psychology for behavioral economics, American Economic Review, 93(5), 1449-1474.

Pesaran, M. H. Shin, Y. and R. J. Smith (2001) Bounds testing approaches to the analysis of level relationships, Journal of Applied Econometrics, 16, 289–326.

Narayan, P.K. (2005) The saving and investment nexus for China: evidence from cointegration tests, Applied Economics, 37, 1979-1990.

Nijkamp, P. and J. Poot (2004) Meta-analysis of the effect of fiscal policies on long-run growth, European Journal of Political Economy, 20, 91-124.

Temple, J. (2000) Growth regressions and what the textbooks don't tell you, Bulletin of Economic Research, 52, 181-205.

TSCG, Treaty on Stability, Coordination and Governance in the Economic and Monetary Union (2012), signed by the EU head of governments on 12th March 2012.

Yohai, V. J., Stahel, W. A. and R. H. Zamar (1991) A procedure for robust estimation and inference in linear regression, in Directions in Robust Statistics – Part II, Vol. 34 (Eds) W. A. Stahel and S. Weisberg, IMA Volumes in Mathematics and its Application, Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 365-374.