Understanding „culture‟ of pastoralism and „modern development‟ in Thar: Muslim pastoralists of north- west Rajasthan, India

Ghai, Rahul (2021): Understanding „culture‟ of pastoralism and „modern development‟ in Thar: Muslim pastoralists of north- west Rajasthan, India. Published in: Pastoralism Research Policy Practice , Vol. 11, No. 11:3 (27 February 2021): pp. 1-19.

Abstract

Abstract The paper attempts to understand relation between pastoral cultures and irrigation based intensive farming regimes promoted by modern development represented by the Indira Gandhi Canal (IGNP) in western Rajasthan. Participant observation and development practice engagement with pastoral communities over last three decades gives opportunity to reflect on epistemic rationality that constitutes the discourse of modern development, formal statecraft of technocracy and rule by experts. Historical markers of pastoralism in the interconnected regions of north-west Rajasthan and bordering regions of Multan and Bahawulpur in Pakistan are situated to trace the longuee duree of pastoral life systems in Thar. This oscillation between enhanced moisture regimes following inundation and increased desiccation of a moisture deficient arid region has been at the core of sustaining culture of pastoralism among semi nomadic pastoralists of Muslim communities in north- west Rajasthan. The IGNP canal produces a space for modern development that opens up irrigated farming and an intensive natural resource use regime. This political economy of the IGNP canal systematically marginalizes pastoral natural resource use that was ecologically embedded. The varied experiences of adaptation responses of pastoral communities to this state led marginalization points to the tenacious ability of pastoralism to continually adapt to the radically changing ecology. The paper argues for a complementarity of pastoral and farming use as an inclusive development vision. Begininnings can be made with a compassionate engagement with cultures of pastoralism that are endowed with resilience rooted in a historically constituted rationality to adapt, innovate with changing times. This may hold cues for a sustainable future of Thar.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Muslim pastoralists, Bikaner, Sustainable Thar, Sufi Mysticism, ecological impact, IGNP canal,
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q0 - General; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q2 - Renewable Resources and Conservation > Q25 - Water; Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology; Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology > Z12 - Religion

References

19th Livestock Census-2012 India Report, 2012. Department of Animal Husbandry and Dairying, Ministry of Agriculture, New Delhi: GoI. Agarwal, Arun. 1992. The grass is greener on the other side, a study of Raikas, migrant pastoralists of Rajasthan. London: IIED, Drylands Network Programme. Agarwal, Arun. 1998. Profits on the move: The economics of collective migration among the Raika shepherds in India. Human Organization 57 (4): 469–479. Ahmad, Farooq, Ali Zulfiqar, Farooq Sameer. 2005. Historical and archaeological perspectives of soil degradation in Cholistan, Sociedade & Natureza, Uberlândia, Special Issue: 864–870. Allchin, Bridget. 1976. Palaeolithic sites in the plains of Sind and their geographical implications. The Geographical Journal 142 (3): 471–489 http:// www.jstor.org/stable/1795298. Accessed 13 Apr 2020. Arya, Prawin. 2015. Sheep production system in Rajasthan sheep wool and meat. http://www.biotecharticles.com/Agriculture-Article/Sheep-Production-Systemin- Rajasthan-Sheep-Wool-and-Meat-3373.html. Accessed 12 July 20. Asani, Ali. 1988. Sufi poetry in the folk tradition of Indo-Pakistan. Religion & Literature, The Literature of Islam 20 (1): 81–94 USA: University of Notre Dam. Bernal, Victoria. 1997. Colonial moral economy and the discipline of development: The Gezira Scheme and “modern” Sudan. Cultural Anthropology 12 (4): 447–479 http://www.jstor.org/stable/656632. Accessed 12 Apr 2019. Bhati, Hari Singh. 1984. [In Hindi] Pugal ke Bhatiyon ka Itihas (A history of Bhatis of Pugal). Bikaner: Sankhla Prakashan. Bhattacharya, B.D. 1977. A regional development plan for the Rajasthan desert: Land use issues and objectives. The Town Planning Review 48 (3): 299–307 http://www.jstor.org/stable/40103546. Accessed 11 Apr 2015. Blench R, 2001. “You can't go home again: pastoralism in the new millennium", ODI, London. Brara, Rita. 1987. Shifting sands: A study of rights in common pastures. Jaipur: Institute of Development Studies. Brara, Rita. 1989. Commons’ policy as process the case of Rajasthan, 1955-1985. Economic and Political Weekly 24 (40): 2247-2249+2251-2254 http://www.jstor. org/stable/4395430. Accessed 23 Jan 2020. Casimir, Michael J. 1996. Some recent publications on pastoralism in arid lands of western India (Rajasthan and Gujarat): A review. Nomadic Peoples 39: 155–162. Ghai Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice (2021) 11:3 Page 17 of 19 Census Bikaner District, 1981. 1991, 2001, 2011. Directorate of Census Operations, GoR, Jaipur.bof cit Central Arid Zone Research Institute (CAZRI). 1988. Progress in arid zone research 1952–1987. Jodhpur: CAZRI. Central Arid Zone Research Institute (CAZRI). 1998. Fifty years of arid zone research 1947–1997: An annotated bibliography. Jodhpur: Scientific Publishers. Command Area Development Authority-IGNP. 1992. A report on hydrological barrier studies: IGNP flow command STAGE -II, 1991–92. Bikaner: Government of Rajasthan. Cressey, George B. 1957. Water in the desert. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 47 (2): 105–124 http://www.jstor.org/stable/2561502. Accessed 12 Apr 2019. Cressey, George B. 1960. The deserts of Asia. The Journal of Asian Studies 19 (4): 389–402 http://www.jstor.org/stable/2943579. Accessed 13 Apr 2019. Devra, G.S.L. 2012. Environmental crisis and social dismemberment in Northwest India during the pre-colonial period, Occasional papers, history and society new series, 3. Delhi: Nehru Memorial Museum and Library. Dhir, R.P. 2003. Indian Thar Desert in retrospect and prospect. Proceedings of National Science Academy 69A (2): 167–184. Eaton, Richard. 2000. Essays on Islam and Indian history. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Fagan, P J. 1893, Bikaner survey and settlement report, Unpublished Report, Bikaner Archives. Frater, Judy. 1995. Threads of identity. Embroidery and Adornment of the Nomadic Rabaris. Ahmedabad: Mapin Publications. Fuller, D.Q. 2006. Agricultural origins and frontiers in South Asia: A working synthesis. Journal of World Prehistory 20: 1–86. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10963- 006-9006-8 Accessed 19 Dec 2015. Geertz, Clifford. 1973. Thick description: Towards an interpretative theory of culture. In Interpretation of cultures: Selected essays, ed. Clifford Geertz, 3–30. New York: Basic Books. Gellner, Ernest. 1969. Saints of the atlas. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Ghai, Rahul. 1995. Tradition and change among pastoralists of Chitrang a report on the ecological conditions of north West Bikaner. Arid Zone Environmental Research Centre- Uttari Rajasthan Milk Union Ltd. Bikaner: Trust, Swedish International Development Agency. Ghai, Rahul. 2002. Whither commons! State and land use in the canal command area in the Pugal region, Bikaner. Shanti Maitri Mission, Arid Zone Environmental Research Centre- Uttari Rajasthan Milk Union Ltd. Bikaner: Trust and Aga Khan Foundation. Ghai, Rahul. 2010. Qissa Mir-e-Alam: Experiences of reinvigorating Sufiyana Qalam tradition with marginalized musicians. In Interrogating development: Insights from the margins, ed. Frederique Apffel-Marglin, Sanjay Kumar, and Arvind Mishra, 185–204. New Delhi: Oxford University Press. Gilmartin, David. 1994. Scientific empire and imperial science: Colonialism and irrigation technology in the Indus Basin. The Journal of Asian Studies 53 (4): 1127–1149 http://www.jstor.org/stable/2059236. Accessed 23 Dec 2015. Goldman, Michael. 1994. There is a snake on our chests, state and development crisis in India’s desert. Unpublished PhD Thesis, Department of Sociology. Santa Cruz: University of Santa Cruz. Goldman, Michael. 1997. “Customs in common”: The epistemic world of the commons scholars. Theory and Society 26 (1): 1–37 http://www.jstor.org/ stable/658067. Accessed 23 Oct 2019. Gommans, Jos. 1998. The silent frontier of South Asia, C. A.D. 1100-1800. Journal of World History 9 (1): 1–23 http://www.jstor.org/stable/20078711. Accessed: 14 May 2020. Gray, Alice. 2013. Of permaculture and pastoralism: Heroes and villains. New South Wales: Permacultre Research Institute https://www.permaculturenews.org/2 013/05/24/of-permaculture-and-pastoralism-heroes-and-villains/. Accessed 22 Sept 2019. Grewal, J.S. 2004. Historical geography of Punjab. Journal Of Punjab Studies 11 (1): 1–18 https://punjab.global.ucsb.edu/sites/default/files/sitefiles/journals/ volume11/no1/2_grewal.pdf. Accessed 24 Nov 2020. Gujarathi, and Shah. 1994. Socio economic impact of irrigation on pastoralists in the IGNP command area. In Planning for sustainability in irrigation, ed. Rakesh Hooja and P.S. Kavadia, 153–159. Jaipur: Rawat Publications. Habib, Mohammad. 1974. Chisti Mystic Records of the Sultnate period. In Politics and society during the early medieval period, ed. K.A. Nizami, 374–392. Delhi: Peoples Publishing House. Hare, F.K., R.W. Kates, and A. Warren. 1977. The making of deserts: Climate, ecology, and society. Economic Geography 53 (4): 332–346. Hatfield, Richard, and Jonathan Davies. 2006. Global review of the economics of pastoralism. The world initiative for sustainable pastoralism. Nairobi: International Union for Conservation of Nature. Hooja, Rakesh. 2001. Greening the desert. Jaipur: Rawat Publications. Hooja, Rakesh, and P.S. Kavadia, eds. 1994. Planning for sustainability in irrigation. Jaipur: Rawat Publications. Jodha, N.S. 1982. The role of administration in desertification, land tenure as a factor in the historical ecology of western Rajasthan. In Desertification and development: Dryland ecology in social perspective, ed. H.S. Mann and Brian Spooner, 333–350. London: Academic. Jodha, N.S. 2001. Life on the edge. Delhi: Oxford University Press. Joshi, D.C., and R.P. Dhir. 1997. Waterlogging and salinisation in Indian arid region. In Desertification control, ed. Surendra Singh and Amal Kar, 245–276. Jodhpur: Scientific Publishers. Kalanov, Komil, and Antonio Alonso. 2008. Sacred places and ‘folk’ Islam. In Central Asia, UNISCI Discussion Papers, vol. 17, 173–185. Madrid: Universidad Complutense de Madrid. Kar, A. 2014. Agricultural land use in arid Western Rajasthan: Resource exploitation and emerging issues. Agropedology 24 (2): 179–196. Kavoori, P. 1996. Pastoralism in expansion: The transhuming sheep herders of western Rajasthan. Unpublished Phd Thesis. The Hague: The Institute of Social Studies. Kavoori, P. 1999. Pastoralism in expansion: The transhuming herders of western Rajasthan. Delhi: Oxford University Press. Kavoori, P. 2005. Pastoral underdevelopment and the developmental state: Or why the government has given up on the pastoralists of Rajasthan? Geography Research Forum 25: 28–42. Kenoyer, J. 1991. The Indus Valley tradition of Pakistan and Western India. Journal of World Prehistory 5 (4): 331–385 http://www.jstor.org/stable/25800603. Accessed 20 Dec 2015. Khazanov, A. 1984. Nomads and the outside world. Vol. 1994. 2nd ed. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press. Kohller-Rollefson, Ilse, Paul Robbins, D.V. Rangnekar, Sangeeta Rangnekar, Richard Cincotta, Ganesh Pangare, Arun Agrawal, et al. 1994. Pastoralism in Rajasthan and Gujurat. London: ODI Pastoral Network. Leshnik, Lawrence S. 1972. Pastoral nomadism in the archaeology of India and Pakistan. World Archaeology 4 (2): 150–166 http://www.jstor.org/stable/123 973. Accessed 11 Apr 2018. Malhotra, S.P., Bharara, and L.P. Joshi. 1965. Report on the socio-economic survey of livestock breeders of Anupgarh-Pugal region of western Rajasthan. Jodhpur: Central Arid Zone Research Institute (CAZRI). Mann, H.S., and Brian Spooner, eds. 1982. Desertification and development: Dryland ecology in social perspective. London: Academic. McGahey, D., J. Davies, N. Hagelberg, and R. Ouedraogo. 2014. Pastoralism and the green economy – A natural nexus? x + 58. Nairobi: International Union for Conservation of Nature and United Nations Environment Program. Mcintosh, Jane R. 2008. The ancient Indus Valley new perspectives. USA: ABC CLIO. Merrey, J. Douglas. 1992. Reorganising irrigation: Local level management in the Punjab (Pakistan). In Desertification and development: Dryland ecology in social perspective, ed. H.S. Mann and Brian Spooner, 83–110. London: Academic. Metcalf, Barbara D. 1995. Presidential address: Too little and too much: Reflections on Muslims in the history of India. The Journal of Asian Studies 54 (4): 951–967 http://www.jstor.org/stable/2059955. Accessed 20 Jan 2013. Metcalf, Barbara D. (n.d.). A historical overview of Islam in South Asia, Introduction http://press.princeton.edu/chapters/i9061.pdf. Miller, Daniel, and Dennis Sheehy. 2008. The relevance of Owen Lattimore’s writings for nomadic pastoralism research and development in inner Asia. Nomadic Peoples 12 (2): 103–115. Mumtaz, Kamil Khan. 1981. Habitat and desert: The case of Cholistan. Bahawalpur: UNESCO & Cholistan Develoment Authority. Naqvi, S.M.K., Kalyan De, and G.R. Gowane. 2013. Sheep production system in arid and semi-arid regions of India. Annals of Arid Zone 52 (3&4): 265–274. Oba, G., E. Post, N.C. Stensth, and W.J. Luisigi. 2000. The role of small ruminants in arid zone environments: A review of research perspectives. Annals of Arid Zone 39 (3): 305–322. Possehl, Gregory. 1984. A note on Harappan settlements in the Punjab. In Studies in archeology and paleoanthropology of South Asia, ed. Kenneth Kennedy and Gregory Possehl, 83–87. New Delhi: Oxford and IBH Publishing, American Institute of Indian Studies. Ghai Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice (2021) 11:3 Page 18 of 19 Prakash, Ishwar. 1993. The changing ecology of the Thar Desert. Proceedings of Indian National Science Academy B59 (5): 465–470. Qureshi, Regula. 1972. Indo-Muslim religious music, an overview. Asian Music 3 (2): 15–22. Rajasthan Canal Project. 1984. Rajasthan Canal Project – Stage II, revised project estimate, VOL-I. Jaipur: RCP Dept. GoR. Ramanathan, S., and Sanjoy Ghose. 1994. Irrigation management turnover: A user’s perspective the case of the Indira Gandhi Canal, Rajasthan, India. International Conference on Irrigation Management Transfer. Wuhan: International Water Management Institute and University of Wuhan. Rao, A., and M. Casimir, eds. 2003. Nomadism in South Asia. New Delhi: Oxford University Press. Rao, K.K. 1958. The problem of the Indus and its tributaries: An alternative view. The World Today 14 (6): 266–276 http://www.jstor.org/stable/40393886. Accessed 12 June 2019. Rao, Radhakrishna. 1992. Pitfalls of the Indira Gandhi Canal. Ambio 21 (6): 439 http://www.jstor.org/stable/4313979. Accessed 11 Apr 2019. Ray, Sunil. 1995. In the shadow of ‘Kotris’: An analysis of wool markets of Rajasthan. Economic and Political Weekly 30 (47): M143-M145+M148-M150 http://www.jstor.org/stable/4403482. Accessed 13 Apr 2018. Ray, Sunil. 1999. Declining production conditions of raw wool: Analysis of emerging conflicts in sheep husbandry in Rajasthan. Economic and Political Weekly 34 (20): 1209–1214 http://www.jstor.org/stable/4407962. Accessed 11 Apr 2018. Robbins, P. 1988a. Authority and environment: Institutional landscapes in Rajasthan, India. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 88 (3): 410–435 http://www.jstor.org/stable/2564236. Accessed 11 Apr 2018. Robbins, P. 1998b. Nomadization in Rajasthan, India: Migration, institutions, and economy. Human Ecology 26 (1): 87–112 http://www.jstor.org/stable/460326 7. Accessed 11 Apr 2018. Robbins, P. 2001. Tracking invasive land covers in India, or why our landscapes have never been modern. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 91 (4): 637–659 http://www.jstor.org/stable/3651226. Accessed 20 Jan 2013. Roy, Ajoy K., and Jai P. Singh. 2013. Grasslands in India: Problems and perspectives for sustaining livestock and rural livelihoods. Tropical Grasslands – Forrajes Tropicales 1: 240–243 Cali, Colombia: International Center for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT). Saberwal, Satish. 2006. On the making of Muslims in India historically. Sociological Bulletin 55 (2): 237–266 New Delhi: Sage Publications. Sain, Kanwar. 1978. Reminiscences of an engineer. Delhi: Young Asia Publications. Salzman, Phillip Carl. 1986. Shrinking pastures for Rajasthani pastoralists. Nomadic Peoples 20: 49–61. Schimmel, Annmarie. 1982. Islam in India and Pakistan. Leiden: E J Brill. Schwarz J., M.Harai, Z. Herman. 1994. Indira Gandhi Nahar Project - Mission Findings and Recommendations. Govt. of Israel in Collaboration with USAID. Tel Aviv: MASHAV & CINDACO. Scoones, Ian. 1999. New ecology and the social sciences: What prospects for a fruitful engagement? Annual Review of Anthropology 28: 479–507 http:// www.jstor.org/stable/223403. Accessed 7 Aug 2016. Scoones, Ian, and Olivia Graham. 1994. New directions for pastoral development in Africa. Development in Practice 4 (3): 188–198 http://www.jstor.org/stable/4 028818. Accessed 24 Dec 2018. Scott, James. 1998. Seeing like a state: How certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed. New Haven: Yale University Press. Sen, A.K., P.K. Ghosh, K.N. Gupta, and H.C. Bohra. 1981. Sheep in Rajasthan. Jodhpur: Central Arid Zone Research Institute (CAZRI). Shackle, Christopher. 2000. Beyond Hindu and Turk: Crossing the boundaries in indo- Muslim romance. In Beyond Turk and Hindu, rethinking religious identities in Islamicate South Asia, ed. David Gilmartin and Bruce B. Lawrence, 55–74. Florida: University Press of Florida. Sharma, Bharat, K.V. Rao, and Govind Sharma. 2009. Groundwater externalities of large surface irrigation transfers: Lessons from India Gandhi Nahar Pariyojna, Rajasthan, India. https://doi.org/10.22004/ag.econ.257992 International Water Management Institute, Conference Proceedings, https://econpapers.repec. org/RePEc:ags:iwmicp:257992. Accessed 12 Nov 2017. Singh, Dool. 1964. Land reforms in Rajasthan. Research programmes committee, planning commission. Jaipur: Government of Rajasthan. Singh, Surinder. 2006. Islamic mysticism in north West India: An exploration of the poetry of Khwaja Ghulam Farid (1841-1901 AD). In The Islamic Path: Sufism, politics and society in India, ed. Saiyid Hussain Jafri and Helmut Reifeld, 75–109. New Delhi: Rainbow Publishers. Singhvi, A.K., and Amal Kar. 1992. Thar Desert in Rajasthan: Land man and environment. Bangalore: Geological Society of India. Sinha, Saurabh. 1996. Resisting change? Adaptations by traditional pastoralists to the Rajasthan Canal Project, 62. UK: International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED). Sørbø, Gunnar M. 2003. Pastoral ecosystems and the issue of scale. Ambio 32 (2): 113–117 http://www.jstor.org/stable/4315346. Accessed 24 Dec 2015. Spate, O.H.K. 1947. The partition of the Punjab and of Bengal. The Geographical Journal 110 (4/6): 201–218 http://www.jstor.org/stable/1789950. Accessed 12 Apr 2011. Srivastava, Vinay. 1989. [In Hindi] Raika jati ka vikas: kuch vichar (‘Progress of the Raika caste: Some ideas’). Manav 17 (3): 107–110. Srivastava, Vinay. 1991. Who are the Raikas/Rabaris? Man in India 71 (1): 279–304. Srivastava, Vinay. 1997. Religious renunciation of a pastoral people. Delhi: Oxford University Press. Srivastava, Vinay. 1999a. Some characteristics of ‘herding caste’ of Rajasthan. In Rajasthan: Ecology, culture and society, ed. M.K. Bhasin and Veena Bhasin, 303–319. Delhi: Kamla-Raj Enterprises. Srivastava, Vinay. 1999b. Renunciation in a pastoral community. In Rajasthan: Ecology, culture and society, ed. M.K. Bhasin and Veena Bhasin, 321–335. Delhi: Kamla-Raj Enterprises. Vyas, V.S. 1998. Sustainable irrigation in the arid regions of India. In The cornerstone of development, integrating environmental social and economic policies, ed. Jamie Schnurr and Susan Holtz, 221–239. Canada & Lewis: IDRC. Warren, Andrew. 1995. Changing understandings of African pastoralism and the nature of environmental paradigms. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 20 (2): 193–203 http://www.jstor.org/stable/622431. Accessed 24 Dec 2015. Water and Power Consultancy Services (India). 1989. Ecological and environmental studies for integrated development of Indira Gandhi Nahar Project stage II draft report. New Delhi: WAPCOS. Wink, Andre. 2004. Al hind the making of the Indo Islamic world vol. III: Indo-Islamic Society, 14th-15 centuries. Leiden: E J Brill. Workneh, Tessema, Paul Ingenbleek, and Hans Trijp. 2014. Pastoralism, sustainability, and marketing. A review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development 34: 75–92 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01234790/ document. Accessed Feb 2020.