The political economy of social protection adoption

Niño-Zarazúa, Miguel and Santillán Hernández, Alma (2021): The political economy of social protection adoption. Published in: Handbook on Social Protection Systems (August 2021): pp. 520-536.

Abstract

In this paper, we present evidence that indicates that democratization has had a positive and significant effect on the current expansion of social transfers in low- and middle income countries. Overall, we find that electoral democracies seem to have favoured the expansion of conditional cash transfer (CCTs) programmes and social pensions, whereas autocracies and infant electoral democracies seem to have favoured pure cash transfers and public works, which are, on average, smaller in scale and more prone to political clientelism. Our findings also show that consumption taxes, and natural resource rents in particular, have contributed to the expansion of social transfers over the past two decades, although at the cost of delaying tax reforms that are necessary to guarantee the survival of welfare benefits. The current tax structure has also exposed net resource-exporting countries to the vagaries of commodity markets and reduced the fiscal space that these countries enjoyed just a decade ago. The policy implications of our findings are threefold: first, a strong technical approach to the formulation of social transfers is clearly desirable to maximize the poverty-reducing and welfare-enhancing effects of these programmes. However, a narrow focus on technical considerations can miss out wider implications of certain policy choices, especially in contexts characterized by electoral autocratic regimes. Second, state capabilities matter for an effective distribution of welfare benefits. However, without strong institutional settings and effective checks and balances, pro-poor redistribution can be subject to the capture of opportunistic clientelistic regimes. Third, any effort to expand social protection systems without parallel reforms to tax systems risks the long-term sustainability of transfer programmes. However, attempts to introduce more progressive forms of taxation would be destinated to fail without a good understanding of the strength and upfront position of elites.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: social protection, political economy, democratization, developing countries
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I30 - General; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs

References

Acemoglu, D. and J.A. Robinson (2000). Democratization or repression? European Economic Review 44 (4–6), 683–93.

Acemoglu, D. and J.A. Robinson (2001). A theory of political transitions. American Economic Review 91 (4), 938–63.

Acemoglu, D. and J.A. Robinson (2012). Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty. New York: Crown Business.

Acemoglu, D., D. Ticchi and A. Vindigni (2011). Emergence and persistence of inefficient states. Journal of the European Economic Association 9 (2), 177–208.

Addison, T., M. Niño-Zarazúa and J.M. Villa (Forthcoming). Natural Resources, Electoral Behaviour and Social Assistance in Latin America. Helsinki.

Alesina, A., R. Baqir and W. Easterly (1999). Public goods and ethnic divisions. Quarterly Journal of Economics 114 (4), 1243–84.

Alesina, A., E. Glaeser and B. Sacerdote (2001). Why doesn’t the US have a European-style welfare state? Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 2 (September), 187–277.

Allen, S.H. and M.E. Flynn (2018). Donor government ideology and aid bypass. Foreign Policy Analysis 14 (4), 449–68.

Baird, S., F. Ferreira, B. Özler and M. Woolcock (2013). Relative effectiveness of conditional and unconditional cash transfers for schooling outcomes in developing countries: A systematic review. Campbell Systematic Reviews 9 (8).

Bardhan, P.K. and D. Mookherjee (2000). Capture and governance at local and national levels. American Economic Review 90 (2), 135–9.

Bardhan, P.K., D. Mookherjee and M. Torrado Parra (2010). Impact of political reservations in West Bengal local governments on anti-poverty targeting. Journal of Globalization and Development 1 (1).

https:// doi .org/ 10 .2202/ 1948 -1837 .1025. Barr, N. (1992). Economic theory and the welfare state: A survey and interpretation. Journal of Economic Literature 30 (2), 741–803.

Barrientos, A. and M. Niño-Zarazúa (2010). Effects of non-contributory social transfers in developing countries: A compendium. In ILO (ed.), Extending Social Security to All: A Guide through Challenges and Options. Geneva: International Labour Organization.

Barro, R.J. (1999). Determinants of democracy. Journal of Political Economy 107 (S6), S158–83.

Bastagli, F., J. Hagen-Zanker, L. Harman, V. Barca, G. Sturge and T. Schmidt (2019). The impact of cash transfers: A review of the evidence from low- and middle-income countries. Journal of Social Policy 48 (3), 569–94.

Besley, T. and T. Persson (2011). Pillars of Prosperity: The Political Economics of Development Clusters. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Bird, R.M. (2014). Foreign advice and tax policy in developing countries. In R.M. Bird and J. Martinez-Vazquez (eds), Taxation and Development: The Weakest Link? Essays in Honor of Roy Bahl. Cheltenham, UK and Northampton, MA, USA: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Borges Sugiyama, N. (2011). The diffusion of conditional cash transfer programs in the Americas. Global Social Policy 11 (2–3), 250–78.

Brooks, S.M. (2007). When does diffusion matter? Explaining the spread of structural pension reforms across nations. Journal of Politics 69 (3), 701–15.

Brooks, S.M. (2015). Social protection for the poorest: The adoption of antipoverty cash transfer programs in the Global South. Politics and Society 43 (4), 551–82.

Carter, B.L. (2016). The struggle over term limits in Africa: How international pressure can help. Journal of Democracy 27 (3), 36–50.

Casey, B.H. and R. McKinnon (2009). Social pensions and policy learning: The case of Southern Africa.

International Social Security Review 62 (4), 81–102. Cruz, C. and P. Keefer (2015). Political parties, clientelism, and bureaucratic reform. Comparative Political Studies 48 (14), 1942–73.

Curato, N. (2017). Flirting with authoritarian fantasies? Rodrigo Duterte and the new terms of Philippine populism. Journal of Contemporary Asia 47 (1), 142–53.

Currie, J. and F. Gahvari (2008). Transfers in cash and in-kind: Theory meets the data. Journal of Economic Literature 46 (2), 333–83.

Dalgaard, C.-J. and H. Hansen (2013). The Political Economy of Redistributive Taxation and Growth: Reconciling Theory with Evidence. Mimeo.

De La O, A.L. (2013). Do conditional cash transfers affect electoral behavior? Evidence from a randomized experiment in Mexico. American Journal of Political Science 57 (1), 1–14.

De La O, A.L. (2015). Crafting Policies to End Poverty in Latin America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Díaz-Cayeros, A. and B. Magaloni (2009). Poverty, inequality, and democracy (II): Aiding Latin America’s poor. Journal of Democracy 20 (4), 36–49.

Dixit, A. and J. Londregan (1996). The determinants of success of special interests in redistributive politics. Journal of Politics 58 (4), 1132–55.

Dodlova, M., A. Giolbas and J. Lay (2017). Social transfers and conditionalities under different regime types. European Journal of Political Economy 50, 141–56.

Enke, B. 2020. Moral values and voting. Journal of Political Economy 128 (10), 3679–729.

Esping-Andersen, G. (1990). The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Faye, M. and P. Niehaus (2012). Political aid cycles. American Economic Review 102 (7), 3516–30.

Filipovich, D., M. Niño-Zarazúa and A. Santillán-Hernández (2018). Campaign Externalities, Programmatic Spending, and Voting Preferences in Rural Mexico. WIDER Working Paper 2018/27. Helsinki: United Nations University World Institute for Development Economics Research.

Fioretos, O., T.G. Falleti and A. Sheingate (2016). Historical institutionalism in political science. In O. Fioretos, T.G. Falleti and A. Sheingate (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Historical Institutionalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 3–28.

Garay, C. (2016). Social Policy Expansion in Latin America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Gisselquist, R.M., S. Leiderer and M. Niño-Zarazúa (2016). Ethnic heterogeneity and public goods provision in Zambia: Evidence of a subnational ‘diversity dividend.’ World Development 78 (February), 308–23.

Hadiz, V.R. (2016). Islamic Populism in Indonesia and the Middle East. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Haile, F. and M. Niño-Zarazúa (2018). Does social spending improve welfare in low-income and middle-income countries? Journal of International Development 30 (3), 367–98.

Hickey, S., T. Lavers, M. Niño-Zarazúa and J. Seekings (2019). The Politics of Social Protection in Eastern and Southern Africa. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hillier-Brown, F., K. Thomson, V. Mcgowan, J. Cairns, T.A. Eikemo, D. Gil-Gonzále and C. Bambra (2019). The effects of social protection policies on health inequalities: Evidence from systematic reviews. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health 47 (6), 655–65.

Huntington, S.P. (1993). The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late Twentieth Century, Vol. 4. Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma Press.

ILO (2001). Social Security: A New Consensus. Geneva: International Labour Office.

Jaffrelot, C. and L. Tillin (2017). Populism in India. In C. Rovira Kaltwasser, P. Taggart, P. Ochoa Espejo and P. Ostiguy (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Populism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 179.

Kabeer, N. and H. Waddington (2015). Economic impacts of conditional cash transfer programmes: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Development Effectiveness 7 (3), 290–303.

Knutsen, C.H. and M. Rasmussen (2017). The autocratic welfare state: Old-age pensions, credible commitments, and regime survival. Comparative Political Studies 51 (5), 659–95.

Koehler, G. and D. Chopra (2014). Development and Welfare Policy in South Asia. New York: Routledge.

Konrad, K.A. (2002). Investment in the absence of property rights: The role of incumbency advantages. European Economic Review 46 (8), 1521–37.

Kroeger, A.M. (2020). Dominant party rule, elections, and cabinet instability in African autocracies. British Journal of Political Science 50 (1), 79–101.

Lagarde, M., A. Haines and N. Palmer (2007). Conditional cash transfers for improving uptake of health interventions in low-and middle-income countries: A systematic review. Journal of the American Medical Association 298 (16), 1900–10.

Lavers, T. (2019). Understanding elite commitment to social protection: Rwanda’s Vision 2020 Umurenge Programme. In S. Hickey, T. Lavers, M. Niño-Zarazúa and J. Seekings (eds), The Politics of Social Protection in Eastern and Southern Africa. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 95–121.

Lazar, S. (2004). Personalist politics, clientelism and citizenship: Local elections in El Alto, Bolivia. Bulletin of Latin American Research 23 (2), 228–43.

Leisering, L. (2018). The Global Rise of Social Cash Transfers: How States and International Organizations Constructed a New Instrument for Combating Poverty. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lipset, S.M. (1959). Some social requisites of democracy: Economic development and political legitimacy. American Political Science Review 53 (1), 69–105.

Luccisano L. and L. Macdonald (2012). Neo-liberalism, semi-clientelism and the politics of scale in Mexican anti-poverty policies. World Political Science 8 (1), 1.

Lührmann, A., M. Tannenberg and S.I. Lindberg (2018). Regimes of the World (RoW): Opening new avenues for the comparative study of political regimes. Politics and Governance 6 (1).

Mainwaring, S. and A. Pérez-Liñán (2013). Democracies and Dictatorships in Latin America: Emergence, Survival, and Fall. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Malerba, D. and M. Niño-Zarazúa (Forthcoming). Social assistance and wellbeing in developing countries: A systematic review and meta-analysis. WIDER Working Paper. Helsinki: United Nations University World Institute for Development Economics Research.

Mejía, D. and C.-E. Posada (2007). Populist policies in the transition to democracy. European Journal of Political Economy 23 (4), 932–53.

Meltzer, A.H. and S.F. Richard (1981). A rational theory of the size of government. Journal of Political Economy 89 (5), 914–27.

Newey, W.K. (1987). Efficient estimation of limited dependent variable models with endogenous explanatory variables. Journal of Econometrics 36 (3), 231–50.

Niño-Zarazúa, M. (2019). Welfare and redistributive effects of social assistance in the Global South. Population and Development Review 45 (4), 1–20.

Niño-Zarazúa, M., A. Barrientos, S. Hickey and D. Hulme (2012). Social protection in Sub-Saharan Africa: Getting the politics right. World Development 40 (1), 163–76.

Owusu-Addo, E. and R. Cross (2014). The impact of conditional cash transfers on child health in low-and middle-income countries: A systematic review. International Journal of Public Health 59 (4), 609–18.

Persson, T. and G. Tabellini (2009). Democratic capital: The nexus of political and economic change. American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 1 (2), 88–126.

Pierson, P. (1996). The new politics of the welfare state. World Politics 48 (2), 143–79.

Przeworski, A., R.M. Alvarez, M.E. Alvarez, J.A. Cheibub and F. Limongi (2000). Democracy and Development: Political Institutions and Well-Being in the World, 1950–1990, Vol. 3. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Puig, S.M. (2000). Los noventa en América Latina: ¿La década de las oportunidades o las quimeras? América Latina Hoy: Revista de Ciencias Sociales 26, 11–19.

Remmer, K.L. (2007). The political economy of patronage: Expenditure patterns in the Argentine provinces, 1983–2003. Journal of Politics 69 (2), 363–77.

Robinson, J.A. and T. Verdier (2013). The political economy of clientelism*. Scandinavian Journal of Economics 115 (2), 260–91.

Robinson, J.A., R. Torvik and T. Verdier (2006). Political foundations of the resource curse. Journal of Development Economics 79 (2), 447–68.

Ross, M.L. (1999). The political economy of the resource curse. World Politics 51 (2), 297–322.

Schmitt, C. (2020). The coverage of social protection in the Global South. International Journal of Social Welfare 29 (1), 6–19.

Schmitt, C., H. Lierse, H. Obinger and L. Seelkopf (2015). The global emergence of social protection: Explaining social security legislation 1820–2013. Politics and Society 43 (4), 503–24.

Stiglitz, J.E. (2002). Globalization and Its Discontents. New York: Norton.

Tanzi, V. (1990). Public Finance in Developing Countries. Cheltenham, UK and Northampton, MA, USA: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Teichman, J. (2008). Redistributive conflict and social policy in Latin America. World Development 36 (3), 446–60.

Thelen, K.A. (2014). Varieties of Liberalization and the New Politics of Social Solidarity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Thompson, M.R. (2016). The moral economy of electoralism and the rise of populism in the Philippines and Thailand. Journal of Developing Societies 32 (3), 246–69.

UNDP (2016). Leaving No One Behind: A Social Protection Primer for Practitioners. New York: United Nations Development Programme.

UNU-WIDER (2018). Social Assistance, Politics, and Institutions Database. Helsinki: United Nations University World Institute for Development Economics Research. www .wider .unu .edu/ project/ sapi-social -assistance -politics -and -institutions -database

UNU-WIDER (2019). GRD – Government Revenue Dataset. Helsinki. www .wider .unu .edu/ project/ government -revenue -dataset

Wantchekon, L. (2003). Clientelism and voting behavior: Evidence from a field experiment in Benin. World Politics 55 (3), 399–422.

Weyland, K. (2005). Theories of policy diffusion lessons from Latin American pension reform. World Politics 57 (2), 262–95.

Wood, G. and I. Gough (2006). A comparative welfare regime approach to global social policy. World Development 34 (10), 1696–712.

World Bank (2019). World Development Indicators 2019. Washington, DC: World Bank. https:// data.worldbank .org/

Wyatt, A. (2013). Combining clientelist and programmatic politics in Tamil Nadu, South India. Commonwealth and Comparative Politics 51 (1), 27–55.