Commuting to Work in Cities: Bus, Car, or Train?

Batabyal, Amitrajeet and Beladi, Hamid (2021): Commuting to Work in Cities: Bus, Car, or Train?

Abstract

In this paper, we study the commuting behavior of citizens living in or near a city who must decide how to get to work. Such citizens can always use their own car and drive to work. However, they can also take public transport to work. The two public transport options we consider involve taking either a bus or a train to work. In this setting, we perform two broad tasks. First, we analyze the car versus train choice. We compute the deadweight loss from the negative externality generated by car travel, i.e., the traffic congestion, and then discuss how a toll can achieve the efficient allocation of commuters between the car and the train modes of transport. Second, we analyze the car versus bus choice. Once again, we calculate the deadweight loss from the traffic congestion resulting from car travel and then discuss how a toll can achieve the efficient allocation of commuters between the car and the bus modes of transport that would be beneficial for all commuters.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Bus, Car, Toll, Traffic Congestion, Train, Travel Time
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D62 - Externalities; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R4 - Transportation Economics > R41 - Transportation: Demand, Supply, and Congestion ; Travel Time ; Safety and Accidents ; Transportation Noise

References

Abdalla, M.F., and Abdel-Aty, M. 2006. Modeling travel time under ATIS using mixed linear models, Transportation, 33, 63-82.

Basso, L.J., and Jara-Diaz, S.R. 2012. Integrating congestion pricing, transit subsidies and mode choice, Transportation Research Part A, 46, 890-900.

Batabyal, A.A., and Nijkamp, P. 2013. Ought a green citizen to bicycle or take public transport to work? Ecological Economics, 86, 93-96.

Batabyal, A.A., and Nijkamp, P. 2020. Workplace choice, commuting costs, and wage taxation in urban and adjacent rural regions, Annals of Regional Science, 65, 775-786.

Beladi, H., Liu, L., and Oladi, R. 2013. On pollution permits and abatement, Economics Letters, 119, 302-305.

Bergantino, A.S., and Madio, L. 2020. Intermodal competition and substitution: HSR versus air transport: Understanding the socio-economic determinants of modal choice, Research in Transportation Economics, 79, 100823.

Bovy, P.H.L., Bliemer, M.C. J., and Van Nes, R. 2006. Course CT4801 Transportation Modeling. Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands.

Brundtland, G.H. 1987. Our Common Future. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK.

Buehler, R. 2010. Transport policies, automobile use, and sustainable transportation: A comparison of Germany and the USA, Journal of Planning Education and Research, 30, 76-93.

Chou, J. 2009. Generalized linear model-based expert system for estimating the cost of transportation projects, Expert Systems with Applications, 36, 4253-4267.

Colak, S., Lima, A., and Gonzalez, M.C. 2016. Understanding congested travel in urban areas, Nature Communications, 7, 10793.

Hirshleifer, J., Glazer, A., and Hirshleifer, D. 2005. Price Theory and Applications, 7th edition. Cambridge University Press, New York, NY.

Holden, D.J. 1989. Wardrop’s third principle: Urban traffic congestion and traffic policy, Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 23, 239-262.

Huang, H. 2002. Pricing and logit-based mode choice models of a transit and highway system with elastic demand, European Journal of Operational Research, 140, 562-570.

Huang, Z., Niu, H., Gao, R., Fan, H., and Liu, C. 2021. Optimizing train timetable based on departure time preference of passengers for high-speed rails, Journal of Advanced Transportation, 2021, Article ID 6611289.

Korsu, E., and Le Nechet, F. 2017. Would fewer people drive to work in a city without excess commuting? Explorations in the Paris metropolitan area, Transportation Research Part A, 95, 259-274.

Liao, Y., Gil, J., Perreira, R.H.M., Yeh, S., and Verendel, V. 2020. Disparities in travel times between car and transit: Spatiotemporal patterns in cities, Scientific Reports, 10, 4056.

Pariota, L., Bifulco, G.N., and Brackstone, M. 2016. A linear dynamic model for driving behavior in car following, Transportation Science, 50, 1032-1042.

Parry, I.W.H., and Small, K.A. 2009. Should urban transit subsidies be reduced? American Economic Review, 99, 700-724.

Pucher, J., and Buehler, R. 2009. Integrating bicycling and public transport in North America, Journal of Public Transportation, 12, 79-104.

Rizzi, L.I., and De La Maza, C. 2017. The external costs of private versus public road transport in the metropolitan area of Santiago, Chile, Transportation Research Part A, 98, 123-140.

Saberi, M., Hamedmoghadam, H., Ashfaq, M., Hosseini, S.A., Gu, Z., Shafiei, S., Nair, D.J., Dixit, V., Gardner, L., Waller, S.T., and Gonzalez, M.C. 2020. A simple contagion process describes spreading of traffic jams in urban networks, Nature Communications, 11, 1616.

Schmitt, E.J., and Jula, H. 2007. On the limitations of linear models in predicting travel times, Proceedings of the IEEE Intelligent Transportation Systems Conference, Seattle, WA.

Stopher, P.S. 1969. A probability model of travel mode choice for the work journey, Highway Research Record, 283, 57-65. https://onlinepubs.trb.org/Onlinepubs/hrr/1969/283/283-006.pdf. Accessed on 24 December 2021.

Van Exel, N.J.A., and Rietveld, P. 2009. Could you also have made this trip by another mode? An investigation of perceived travel possibilities of car and train travelers on the main travel corridors to the city of Amsterdam, the Netherlands, Transportation Research Part A, 43, 374-385.

Verhoef, E., Nijkamp, P., and Rietveld, P. 1996. Second-best congestion pricing: The case of an untolled alternative, Journal of Urban Economics, 40, 279-302.

Zhu, W., Fan, W., Wei, J., and Fan, W. 2020. Complete estimation approach for characterizing passenger travel time distributions at rail transit stations, Journal of Transportation Engineering, Part A, 156, 04020050.