Unintended consequences of farm input subsidies: women’s contraceptive usage and knock-on effects on children

Mwale, Martin Limbikani (2022): Unintended consequences of farm input subsidies: women’s contraceptive usage and knock-on effects on children.

Abstract

Sub-Saharan Africa’s countries adopted farm input subsidies, with a twin goal of bolstering food security and reducing poverty. Many scholars evaluate the subsidies against these intended impacts, while ignoring the potential unintended consequences. In this paper, I take advantage of a rare combination of information on both contraceptive usage and a subsidy program, from Malawi’s 2020 Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey (MICS), to investigate whether Malawi’s Farm Input Subsidy Program (FISP) affected women’s contraceptive usage. I find that women that lived in FISP households increased contraceptives usage. This is in line with the hypothesis that the women aimed to prevent pregnancy, and hence dedicate uninterrupted time to farming, complementing the FISP. More of women’s time in farming could imply less of their time in domestic chores. I therefore further investigated whether children, in the same households, increased participation in the domestic chores, to take up roles left by the farming women. I find that this is the case. These findings therefore suggest that past studies evaluating the subsidies, and failed to consider the unintended consequences on fertility choices and domestic child labour, may have over- or underestimated the benefits of the subsidies

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Women; Contraceptive Usage; Children; Domestic Chores; Subsidies; Malawi
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D13 - Household Production and Intrahousehold Allocation; D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D61 - Allocative Efficiency ; Cost-Benefit Analysis; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I15 - Health and Economic Development; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q12 - Micro Analysis of Farm Firms, Farm Households, and Farm Input Markets; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q18 - Agricultural Policy ; Food Policy

References

Abou, P. E. (2016). Does domestic work affect the academic performance of girls in primary school in côte d’ivoire? empirical evidence from probit model. European Scientific Journal, 12(35):368–381.

Al-Samarrai, S. and Zaman, H. (2007). Abolishing school fees in malawi: The impact on education access and equity. Education Economics, 15(3):359–375.

Arndt, C., Pauw, K., and Thurlow, J. (2016). The economy-wide impacts and risks of malawi’s farm input subsidy program. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 98(3):962–980.

Assaad, R., Levison, D., and Zibani, N. (2010). The effect of domestic work on girls’ schooling: Evidence from egypt. Feminist Economics, 16(1):79–128.

Banful, A. B. (2011). Old problems in the new solutions? politically motivated allocation of program benefits and the “new” fertilizer subsidies. World Development, 39(7):1166-1176.

Baruwa, O. J., Amoateng, A. Y., and Biney, E. (2020). Socio-demographic changes in age at first marriage in malawi: evidence from malawi demographic and health survey data,1992–2016. Journal of Biosocial Science, 52(6):832–845.

Bastagli, F. (2009). Conditionality in public policy targeted to the poor: promoting resilience? Social Policy and Society, 8(1):127–140.

Basurto, M. P., Dupas, P., and Robinson, J. (2020). Decentralization and efficiency of subsidy targeting: Evidence from chiefs in rural malawi. Journal of public economics, 185:104047.

Behrman, J. A. (2017). Women’s land ownership and participation in decision-making about reproductive health in malawi. Population and Environment, 38(4):327–344.

Berge, E., Kambewa, D., Munthali, A., and Wiig, H. (2014). Lineage and land reforms in malawi: Do matrilineal and patrilineal landholding systems represent a problem for land reforms in malawi? Land Use Policy, 41:61–69.

Biran, A., Abbot, J., and Mace, R. (2004). Families and firewood: a comparative analysis of the costs and benefits of children in firewood collection and use in two rural communities in sub-saharan africa. Human Ecology, 32(1):1–25.

Bornstein, M., Huber-Krum, S., Norris, A. H., and Gipson, J. D. (2021). Infertility, perceived certainty of pregnancy, and contraceptive use in malawi. Studies in Family Planning, 52(2):143–163.

Boserup, E. (1985). Economic and demographic interrelationships in sub-saharan africa. Population and development review, pages 383–397.

Bryceson, D. F. (2006). Ganyu casual labour, famine and hiv/aids in rural malawi: causality and casualty. The Journal of Modern African Studies, 44(2):173–202.

Castineira, B. R. and Nunes, L. C. (1999). Testing endogeneity in a regression model: An application of instrumental variable estimation. Investigacion Operativa, 8:197–206.

Chikhungu, L., Kadzamira, E., Chiwaula, L., and Meke, E. (2020). Tackling girls dropping out of school in malawi: Is improving household socio-economic status the solution? International Journal of Educational Research, 103:101578.

Chinsinga, B. and Poulton, C. (2014). Beyond technocratic debates: the significance and transience of political incentives in the malawi farm input subsidy programme (fisp). Development Policy Review, 32(s2):s123–s150.

Chinyoka, K. and Naidu, N. (2014). Influence of home based factors on the academic performance of girl learners from poverty stricken families: A case of zimbabwe. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 5(6):223.

Daniele, M. A. S. (2021). Male partner participation in maternity care and social support for childbearing women: a discussion paper. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B, 376(1827):20200021.

Dasgupta, I. (2000). Women’s employment, intra-household bargaining, and distribution: a two-sector analysis. Oxford Economic Papers, 52(4):723–744.

De Brauw, A. and Hoddinott, J. (2011). Must conditional cash transfer programs be conditioned to be effective? the impact of conditioning transfers on school enrollment in mexico. Journal of development Economics, 96(2):359–370.

Diao, X., Hazell, P. B., Resnick, D., and Thurlow, J. (2007). The role of agriculture in development: Implications for Sub-Saharan Africa, volume 153. Intl Food Policy Res Inst.

Dwibedi, J. K. and Chaudhuri, S. (2014). Agricultural subsidy policies fail to deal with child labour under agricultural dualism: What could be the alternative policies? Research in Economics, 68(3):277–291.

Ellis, F., Kutengule, M., and Nyasulu, A. (2003). Livelihoods and rural poverty reduction in malawi. World Development, 31(9):1495–1510.

Fisher, M. (2004). Household welfare and forest dependence in southern malawi. Environment and Development Economics, 9(2):135–154.

Forty, J., Rakgoasi, S. D., and Keetile, M. (2021). Patterns and determinants of modern contraceptive use and intention to usecontraceptives among malawian women of reproductive ages (15–49 years). Contraception and reproductive medicine, 6(1):1–12.

Francavilla, F. and Giannelli, G. C. (2010). The relation between child work and the employment of mothers in india. International Journal of Manpower.

Gennetian, L. A., Magnuson, K., and Morris, P. A. (2008). From statistical associations to causation: what developmentalists can learn from instrumental variables techniques coupled with experimental data. Developmental psychology, 44(2):381.

Harou, A. P. (2018). Unraveling the effect of targeted input subsidies on dietary diversity in household consumption and child nutrition: The case of malawi. World Development, 106:124–135.

Hazarika, G. and Sarangi, S. (2008). Household access to microcredit and child work in rural malawi. World Development, 36(5):843–859.

He, X. and Zhu, R. (2016). Fertility and female labour force participation: Causal evidence from urban China. The Manchester School, 84(5):664–674.

Heath, R. (2014). Women’s access to labor market opportunities, control of household resources, and domestic violence: Evidence from bangladesh. World Development, 57:32–46.

Holden, S. T. (2018). Fertilizer and sustainable intensification in sub-saharan africa. Global food security, 18:20–26.

Holden, S. T. (2019). Economics of farm input subsidies in Africa. Annual Review of Resource Economics, 11:501–522.

Horrace, W. C. and Oaxaca, R. L. (2006). Results on the bias and inconsistency of ordinary least squares for the linear probability model. Economics Letters, 90(3):321–327.

House, W. J. and Zimalirana, G. (1992). Rapid population growth and poverty generation in malawi. The Journal of Modern African Studies, 30(1):141–161.

Isran, S. and Ali Isran, M. (2012). Low female labour participation in pakistan: Causes and consequences. Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences (PJSS), 32(2).

Jacobstein, R. (2013). Lessons from the recent rise in use of female sterilization in malawi.

Jacobstein, R., Curtis, C., Spieler, J., and Radloff, S. (2013). Meeting the need for modern contraception: effective solutions to a pressing global challenge. International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics, 121:S9–S15.

Jayne, T., Mather, D., Mason, N., and Ricker-Gilbert, J. (2013). How do fertilizer subsidy programs affect total fertilizer use in sub-saharan africa? crowding out, diversion, and benefit/cost assessments. Agricultural economics, 44(6):687–703.

Jayne, T. S., Mason, N. M., Burke, W. J., and Ariga, J. (2018). Taking stock of africa’s second-generation agricultural input subsidy programs. Food Policy, 75:1–14.

Jayne, T. S. and Rashid, S. (2013). Input subsidy programs in sub-saharan africa: a synthesis of recent evidence. Agricultural economics, 44(6):547–562.

John, N. A., Tsui, A. O., and Roro, M. (2020). Quality of contraceptive use and women’s paid work and earnings in peri-urban ethiopia. Feminist Economics, 26(1):23–43.

Kanyamuka, J. S., Jumbe, C. B., and Ricker-Gilbert, J. (2022). Making agricultural input subsidies more effective and profitable in africa: The role of complementary interventions. In Research Anthology on Strategies for Achieving Agricultural Sustainability, pages 896–908. IGI Global.

Karamba, R. W. and Winters, P. C. (2015). Gender and agricultural productivity: implications of the farm input subsidy program in malawi. Agricultural Economics, 46(3):357–374.

Kilic, T., Whitney, E., and Winters, P. (2015). Decentralised beneficiary targeting in large-scale development programmes: insights from the malawi farm input subsidy programme. Journal of African Economies, 24(1):26–56.

Lunduka, R., Ricker-Gilbert, J., and Fisher, M. (2013). What are the farm-level impacts of malawi’s farm input subsidy program? a critical review. Agricultural Economics, 44(6):563–579.

Mason, N. M. and Ricker-Gilbert, J. (2013). Disrupting demand for commercial seed: Input subsidies in malawi and zambia. World Development, 45:75–91.

Messina, J. P., Peter, B. G., and Snapp, S. S. (2017). Re-evaluating the malawian farm input subsidy programme. Nature plants, 3(4):1–9.

Munthali, M. G., Davis, N., Adeola, A. M., Botai, J. O., Kamwi, J. M., Chisale, H. L., and Orimoogunje, O. O. (2019). Local perception of drivers of land-use and land-cover change dynamics across dedza district, central malawi region. Sustainability, 11(3):832.

Mwale, M., Von Fintel, D., Marchetta, F., Smith, A., and Kamninga, T. (2021a). The negative impact of farm input subsidies on women’s agency in malawi’s matrilocal settlements. PEP Working Paper.

Mwale, M. L., Kamninga, T. M., and Cassim, L. (2021b). The effects of the malawi farm input subsidy program on household per-capita consumption convergence. Development in Practice, pages 1–13.

Mwaniki, A. (2006). Achieving food security in africa: Challenges and issues. UN Office of the Special Advisor on Africa (OSAA).

Ngcamu, B. S. and Chari, F. (2020). Drought influences on food insecurity in africa: A systematic literature review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(16):5897.

Oreffice, S. (2007). Did the legalization of abortion increase women’s household bargaining power? evidence from labor supply. Review of Economics of the Household, 5(2):181–207.

Peipert, J. F., Madden, T., Allsworth, J. E., and Secura, G. M. (2012). Preventing unintended pregnancies by providing no-cost contraception. Obstetrics and gynecology, 120(6):1291.

Pezzini, S. (2005). The effect of women’s rights on women’s welfare: Evidence from a natural experiment. The Economic Journal, 115(502):C208–C227.

Putnick, D. L. and Bornstein, M. H. (2016). Girls’and boys’labor and household chores in low-and middleincome countries. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 81(1):104.

Rakotoarisoa, M., Iafrate, M., and Paschali, M. (2011). Why has Africa become a net food importer. FAO. Rome, Italy.

Ray, R. and Lancaster, G. J. (2003). Does child labour affect school attendence and school performance?: Multi country evidence on SIMPOC data. School of Economics, University of Tasmania Canberra.

Reich, J., Hein, S., Krivulskaya, S., Hart, L., Gumkowski, N., Grigorenko, E. L., Project, T. L. D., et al. (2013). Associations between household responsibilities and academic competencies in the context of education accessibility in zambia. Learning and individual differences, 27:250–257.

Ricker-Gilbert, J. (2014). Wage and employment effects of malawi’s fertilizer subsidy program. Agricultural Economics, 45(3):337–353.

Riley, T., Sully, E., Ahmed, Z., and Biddlecom, A. (2020). Estimates of the potential impact of the covid-19 pandemic on sexual and reproductive health in low-and middle-income countries. International perspectives on sexual and reproductive health, 46:73–76.

Sánchez-Páez, D. A. and Ortega, J. A. (2018). Adolescent contraceptive use and its effects on fertility. Demographic Research, 38:1359–1388.

Sankhulani, L. (2007). Responding to the needs of the community: Examining the educational opportunities for girls in rural malawi. International Education Journal, 8(1):100–107.

Schultz, T. P. (1990). Women’s changing participation in the labor force: a world perspective. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 38(3):457–488.

Shahidul, S. and Karim, A. (2015). Factors contributing to school dropout among the girls: A review of literature. European Journal of research and reflection in educational sciences, 3(2).

Sheahan, M. and Barrett, C. B. (2017). Ten striking facts about agricultural input use in sub-saharan africa. Food Policy, 67:12–25.

Shimamura, Y. and Lastarria-Cornhiel, S. (2010). Credit program participation and child schooling in rural malawi. World Development, 38(4):567–580.

Shively, G. E. and Ricker-Gilbert, J. (2013). Measuring the impacts of agricultural input subsidies in subsaharan africa: Evidence from malawi’s farm input subsidy program. Purdue Policy Research Institute (PPRI) Policy Briefs, 1(1):4.

Sibande, L., Bailey, A., and Davidova, S. (2017). The impact of farm input subsidies on maize marketing in malawi. Food Policy, 69:190–206.

Sikod, F. (2007). Gender division of labour and women’s decision-making power in rural households in cameroon. Africa Development Review, 32(3).

Singh, S., Bankole, A., and Darroch, J. E. (2017). The impact of contraceptive use and abortion on fertility in sub-saharan africa: estimates for 2003–2014. Population and development review, 43(Suppl 1):141.

Susanli, Z. B., Inanc-Tuncer, O., and Kologlugil, S. (2016). Child domestic labour and mothers’ employment in turkey. Economic research-Ekonomska istraživanja, 29(1):967–979.

Thornton, P., Saka, A., Singh, U., Kumwenda, J., Brink, J., and Dent, J. (1995). Application of a maize crop simulation model in the central region of malawi. Experimental Agriculture, 31(2):213–226.

Vlek, P. L., Le, Q. B., and Tamene, L. (2010). Assessment of land degradation, its possible causes and threat to food security in sub-saharan africa. Food Security and Soil Quality. CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida, pages 57–86.

Walker, R. S. (1988). Women as food producers in developing countries: Impact on families. Journal of Home Economics, 80(2):24–29.

Wietzke, F.-B. (2020). Poverty, inequality, and fertility: the contribution of demographic change to global poverty reduction. Population and Development Review, 46(1):65–99.

Yaya, S., Uthman, O. A., Ekholuenetale, M., and Bishwajit, G. (2018). Women empowerment as an enabling factor of contraceptive use in sub-saharan africa: a multilevel analysis of cross-sectional surveys of 32 countries. Reproductive health, 15(1):1–12.