Driving while black: do police pass the test?

Mason, Patrick L. (2007): Driving while black: do police pass the test? Published in: Driving while black: do police pass the test? , Vol. 14, (2007): pp. 79-113.

Abstract

Biased policing against racial and ethnic minorities is an important public policy issue. Theoretical analysis and empirical results on this issue has been plagued by an assortment of problems which confront research on the nature and significance of police discrimination against social groups. This paper presents and applies a nonparametric test that is robust to a host of methodological difficulties. We theoretically and empirically contrast our non-parametric test with other tests that are prominent in the literature. Utilizing data provided by the Florida Highway Patrol, our empirical results strongly reject the null hypothesis that FHP troopers of different races do not engage in racially biased searches of stopped drivers. More particularly, there is evidence of police bias against African American male and Latino drivers by all officers and no evidence of police bias against white male drivers by any group of officers.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: biased policing; racial profiling; African Americans; discrimination and the law; police; evolutionary game
• Subjects: K - Law and Economics > K4 - Legal Procedure, the Legal System, and Illegal Behavior > K42 - Illegal Behavior and the Enforcement of Law; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J15 - Economics of Minorities, Races, Indigenous Peoples, and Immigrants ; Non-labor Discrimination; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C7 - Game Theory and Bargaining Theory > C73 - Stochastic and Dynamic Games ; Evolutionary Games ; Repeated Games

References

Antonovics, K.L. and Knight, B.G. (2004), A new look at racial profiling: Evidence from the Boston Police Department, NBER Working Paper 10634, National Bureau of Economic Reserach.

Anwar, S. and Fang, H. (2006), An alternative test of racial prejudice in motor vehicle searches: Theory and evidence, American Economic Review 96, 127-51.

Becker, G. (1957), The Economics of Discrimination, University of Chicago Press,Chicago.

Benson, B.L. (2003), Understanding bureaucratic behavior: Implications from the public choice literature, Mimeo, Tallahassee, Florida State University.

Blalock, H.M. Jr. (1967), Toward a Theory of Minority Group Relations, John Wiley and Sons Publishers, New York.

Blomberg, T., Waldo, G. and Chester, D. (2002), Assessment of the program implementation of comprehensive victim services a one-stop location, International Review of Victimology 9, 149-174.

Bjerk, D. (2004), Racial profiling, statistical discrimination, and the effect of a colorblind policy on the crime rate, Working Paper 2004-11, McMaster University.

Button, J., Richards, S. and Bethune, E. (1998), A look at the second generation of black elected officials in Florida, State and Local Government Review 30, 118-189.

Choongh, S. (1998), Policing the dross: A social disciplinary model of policing, British Journal of Criminology 38, 623-634.

Close, B. and Mason, P.L. (2002), Traffic stop data analysis: The Florida highway patrol and racial differences in traffic stops and driver treatment, Project No. FT-02-24-01, Contract No: AL521. Florida Department of Transportation, Tallahassee, Florida.

Close, B. and Mason, P.L. (2003a), What’s race and ethnicity got to do with it? Officer characteristics and driver searches, Manuscript, Florida State University.

Close, B. and Mason, P.L. (2003b), Race, Ethnicity, Gender and Traffic Searches: Efficient Enforcement or Biased Policing?, Manuscript, Florida State University.

Close, B. and Mason, P.L. (2006), After the traffic stops: Officer characteristics and enforcement actions, Topics in Economic Analysis & Policy 6, Article 24 (http://www.bepress.com/bejeap/topics/vol6/iss1/art24).

Close, B. and Mason, P.L. (2007), Searching for efficient enforcement: Officer characteristics and racially biased policing, Review of Law and Economics 3, 263-321.

Cureton, S.R. (2001), An empirical test of the social threat phenomenon—using 1990 census and uniform crime reports, Journal of Criminal Justice 29, 157-166.

Darity, W.A. Jr., Mason, P.L. and Stewart, J.B. (2006), The economics of identity: The origin and persistence of racial identity norms, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 60, 283-305.

Dharmapala, D. and Ross, S.L. (2004), Racial bias in motor vehicle searches: Additional theory and evidence, Contributions to Economic Analysis and Policy 3, 1-21.

Donohue, J. and Levitt, S. (2001), The impact of race on policing, arrest patterns, and crime, Journal of Law and Economics XLIV, 367-394.

Fridell, L., Lunney, R., Diamond, D. and Kubu, B. (2001), Racially Biased Policing: A Principled Response, Police Executive Research Forum, Washington, D.C. (http://www.cops.usdoj.gov/mime/open.pdf?Item=1598).

Georges-Abeyie, D. (1989), Race ethnicity, and the spatial dynamic: Toward a realistic study of black crime, crime victimization, and criminal justice processing of blacks, Social Justice 16, 35-54.

Georges-Abeyie, D. (1990a), The myth of a racist criminal justice system?, in B.D. MacLean and D. Milovanovic (eds.), Racism, Empiricism, and Criminal Justice, The Collective Press, Vancouver, Canada.

Georges-Abeyie, D. (1990b), Criminal justice processing of non-white minorities, in B.D. MacLean and D. Milovanovic (eds.), Racism, Empiricism, and Criminal Justice, The Collective Press Vancouver, Canada.

Gordon, D. (1971), Capitalism, class, and crime in America, Review of Radical Political Economy 3, 51-75.

Harris, D. (1999a), Driving While Black: Racial Profiling on Our Nation’s Highways, American Civil Liberties Union, Washington, D.C.

Harris, D. (1999b), The stories, the statistics, and the law: Why driving while black matters, Minnesota Law Review 84, 265-326.

Harris, D. (2002), Profiles in Injustice: Why Racial Profiling Cannot Work, New Press, New York.

Joint Center for Political and Economics Studies (2003), Black elected officials (http://www.jointcenter.org/publications_recent_publications/black_ elected_officials/black_elected_officials_a_statistical_summary_2001).

Klein, M.W. (1979), Deinstitutionalization and diversion of juvenile offenders: A litany of impediments, In N. Morris and M. Tonry (eds.), Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research, University Chicago Press, Chicago.

Knowles, J., Persico, N. and Todd, P. (2001), Racial bias in motor vehicle searches: Theory and evidence, Journal of Political Economy 109, 203-29.

Leadership Conference on Civil Rights (2003), Justice on trial: Racial disparities in the American criminal justice system, Leadership Conference Education Fund (http://www.civilrights.org/publications/reports/cj/).

Mason, P.L. (1999), Male interracial wage differentials: Competing explanations, Cambridge Journal of Economics 23, 1-39.

Meehan, A.J. and Ponder, M.C. (2002), Race and place: The ecology of racial profiling African American motorists, Justice Quarterly 19, 399-430.

Myers, S.L. Jr. (2002). Analysis of racial profiling as policy analysis, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 21, 287-300.

National Organization of Black Law Enforcement Executives (2001), A NOBLE Perspective: Racial Profiling—A system of Biase-Based Policing (Next Steps—Creating Blindfolds of Justice) (http://www.noblenatl.org/ associations/4230/files/RacialProfiling901.pdf)

Persico, N. (2002), Racial profiling, fairness, and effectiveness of policing, American Economic Review 92, 1472-1497.

Persico, N. and Todd, P. (2005), Using hit rates to test for racial bias in law enforcement: Vehicle searches in Wichita, Institute for Economic Research Working Paper 05-004, University of Pennsylvania.

Ramirez, D., McDevitt, J. and Farrell, A. (2000), A Resource Guide on Racial Profiling Data Collection Systems: Promising Practices and Lessons Learned, US Department of Justice, NCJ 184768, November.

Zingraff, M., Smith, W., Tomaskovic-Devey, D., Mason, M., Warren, P., Wright, C., Chambers, C., McMurray, H. and Fenlon, R. (2000), Method and data in racial profiling research: The North Carolina highway traffic study, National Institute of Justice Research and Evaluation Conference, July.