The divide-and-conquer and employer/employee models of discrimination: neoclassical competition as a familial defect

Mason, Patrick L. (1992): The divide-and-conquer and employer/employee models of discrimination: neoclassical competition as a familial defect. Published in: The divide-and-conquer and employer/employee models of discrimination: neoclassical competition as a familial defect , Vol. 20, No. 4 (1992): pp. 73-89.

Abstract

This article is an examination of the similarities between Michael Reich’s divide-and-conquer model of discrimination and the Becker-Arrow taste model of discrimination. It shows that Reich’s model of discrimination is analytically identical to Arrow’s employer discrimination model when employer utility is a function of total profits and the racial employment ratio. It also shows that the Becker-Arrow distinction between employer and employee discrimination is invalid. Finally, the author argues that neoclassical competition is the major defect of both models. After discussing the implications of these results the article points to new directions in the literature on the economics of discrimination.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: dsicrimination; labor market competition; divide-and-conquer
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J7 - Labor Discrimination

References

Marcus Alexis and Marshall Medoff, "Becker's Utility Approach to Discrimination: A Review of the Issues," Review of Black Political Economy, 12(4) (Spring 1984): 41-58.

Almen A. Alchian, and Reuben A. Kessel, "Competition, Monopoly, and the Pursuit of Money," in Aspects of Labor Economics, edited by H. G. Lewis (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1962), pp. 156-175.

Kenneth Arrow, "Some Mathematical Models of Race Discrimination in the Labor Market," in Racial Discrimination in Economic Life, edited by Anthony Pascal (Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1972), pp. 187-203.

Gary Becker, The Economics of Discrimination (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1957).

Howard Botwinick, "Wage Differentials and the Competition of Capitals: A New Explanation for Inter- and Intra-Industry Wage Differentials Among Workers of Similar Skill (Princeton: Princeton University Press, forthcoming).

Glen C. Cain, "The Economic Analysis of Labor Market Discrimination: A Survey," in Handbook of Labor Economics, edited by O. Ashenfelter and R. Layard, (Amsterdam: North Holland Press, 1986), pp. 693-785.

Thomas F. D'Amico, "The Conceit of Labor Market Discrimination," American Economic Review, 77(2)(May 1987):310-315.

William Darity, "What's Left of the Economics of Discrimination," in Shulman and Darity, eds., 335-374.

William Darity and Rhonda Williams, "Peddlers Forever? Culture, Competition, and Discrimination," American Economic Review 75 (May 1985):256-261.

J. Divine and Michael Reich, "The Microeconomics of Conflict and Hierarchy under Capitalist Production: A Reply to Watts," Review of Radical Political Economy, XV(2) (Summer 1983): 133-135.

R. England and M. Greene, "A Comment on John Roemer's Theory of Differentially Exploited Labor," Review of Radical Political Economics, 12(4)(Winter 1981):71-74.

O. C. Galle, C. Wiswell, and J. Burr, "Racial Mix and Industrial Productivity," American Sociological Review, 50 (February 1985):20-23.

Donald Harris, "The Black Ghetto as 'Internal Colony': A Theoretical Critique and Alternative Formulation," Review of Black Political Economy (Summer 1972): 3-33.

Glenn Loury, "Why Do We Care About Group Inequality?" in The Question of Discrimination, edited by Steve Shulman and William Darity (Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 1989), pp. 268-292.

Patrick Mason, "Race, Culture, and the Market," Journal of Black Studies (forthcoming).

Patrick Mason, Competition, Non-Compensating Wage Differentials, and Racial Discrimination in the Labor Market (unpublished dissertation, New School for Social Research, 1991).

Michael Reich, Racial Inequality (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1981).

Joan Robinson, The Economics of Imperfect Competition, 2d. ed. (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1969).

John Roemer, "Divide and Conquer: Microfoundations of Marxian Theory of Wage Discrimination," Bell Journal of Economics, 10(2) (Autumn 1979):695-705.

________. "Differentially Exploited Labor: A Marxian Theory of Discrimination," Review of Radical Political Economics, 10(2) (Summer 1978):43-54.

______. "Reply to England and Greene," Review of Radical Political Economics, 12(4) (Winter 1981):75.

Steve Shulman, "Racial Inequality and White Employment: An Interpretation and Test of the Bargaining Power Hypothesis," Review of Black Political Economy, 18(3) (Winter 1990):5-20.

Steve Shulman, "The Causes of Black Poverty: Evidence and Interpretation, Journal of Economic Issues, XXIV(4) (December 1990), pp. 995-1016.

Steve Shulman. "Discrimination, Human Capital and Black-White Unemployment: Evidence from Cities," Journal of Human Resources 22 (Summer 1987), pp. 361-76.

Steve Shulman and William Darity, eds., The Question of Discrimination: Racial Inequality in the U.S. Labor Market (Middletown, CT: Wesleyan University Press, 1989).

Eugene Silverberg, The Structure of Economics: A Mathematical Analysis (New York: McGraw-Hill 1978), pp. 84-93.

James P. Smith, and Finis R. Welch, "Black Economic Progress After Myrdal," Journal of Economic Literature, 27(2) (June 1989):519-562.

Thomas Sowell, Ethnic America (New York: Basic Books, 1981).

Pierro Sraffa, "The Laws of Returns Under Competitive Conditions," The Economic Journal, XXXVI (1926):535-550.

David Swinton, "A Labor Force Competition Model of Racial Discrimination in the Labor Market," Review of Black Political Economy 9 (Fall 1978):5-42.

Tomaskovic-Devey, D., "Market Concentration and Structural Power as Sources of Industrial Productivity," in G. Farkas and P. England, eds., Industries, Firms, and Jobs: Sociological and Economic Approaches (New York: Plenum Press, 1988).

Hal Varian, Microeconomic Analysis (New York: Norton, 1978).

Rhonda Williams, "Capital, Competition, and Discrimination: A Reconsideration of Racial Earnings Inequality," Review of Radical Political Economy, 19(2) (Summer 1987), pp. 1-15.