On the Stabilizing Role of Cash for Societies

Seitz, Franz and Rösl, Gerhard (2022): On the Stabilizing Role of Cash for Societies.

Abstract

In this paper, we focus on the stabilizing role of cash from a society-wide perspective. Starting with conceptual remarks on the importance of money for the economy in general, special attention is paid to the unique characteristics of cash. As these become apparent especially during crisis periods, a comparison of the Great Depression (1929 – 1933) and the Great Recession 2008/09 shows the devastating effects of a severe monetary contraction and how a fully elastic provision of cash can help to avoid such a situation. We find interesting similarities to both crises in two separate case studies, one on the demonetization in India 2016 and the other on cash supply during various crises in Greece since 2008. The paper concludes that supply-driven cash withdrawals from circulation (either by demonetization or by capital controls) destabilize the economy if electronic payment substitutes are not instantly available. However, as there is no perfect substitute for cash due to its unique properties, from the viewpoint of the society as a whole an efficient payment mix necessarily includes cash: It helps to stabilize the economy not only in times of crises in general, no matter which government is in place. Consequently, it should be the undisputed task of central banks to ensure that cash remains in circulation in normal times and is provided in a fully elastic way in times of crisis.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Cash, banknotes, money, crises, stabilization
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E4 - Money and Interest Rates > E41 - Demand for Money; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E51 - Money Supply ; Credit ; Money Multipliers; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E58 - Central Banks and Their Policies

References

Abadi, J. & M. Brunnermeier (2022), Blockchain Economics, Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, Working paper WP 22-15, May.

Aggarwal, B., N. Kulkarni & S. K. Ritadhi, (2020), Cash is King: The Role of financial infrastructure in digital adoption, Working paper, University of Berkeley.

Ahir, H., N. Bloom & D. Furceri (2022), The World Uncertainty Index, NBER Working paper 29763, February.

Anderson, R. G., M. D. Bordo & J. V. Duca (2016), Money and Velocity During Financial Crises: From the Great Depression to the Great Recession, NBER Working Paper No. w22100.

Arango-Arango, C. A. & N. F. Suárez-Ariza (2019), Digital Payments Adoption and the Demand for Cash: New International Evidence, Banco de la República de Colombia, Discussion Paper No. 1074.

Ardizzi, G., Nobili A. & G. Rocco (2020), A Game Changer in Payment Habits: Evidence from daily data during a pandemic, Banca d'Italia, Occasional Paper Number 591, December.

Ashworth, J. & C. A. E. Goodhart (2020), The Surprising Recovery of Currency Usage, International Journal of Central Banking 16, 239-277.

Ashworth, J & C. A. E. Goodhart (2021), The Great Covid Cash Surge – Digitalisation Hasn't Dented Cash's Safe Haven Role, CEPR Discussion Paper 16618, October.

Bagehot, W. (1873), Lombard Street: A Description of the Money Market, New York, Scribner, Armstong & Co.

Bagnall, J., D. Bounie, K. P. Huynh, A. Kosse, T. Schmidt, S. Schuh & H. Stix (2016), Consumer Cash Usage: A cross-country comparison with payment diary survey data, International Journal of Central Banking 12(4), 1-61.

Banerjee, A. & N. Kala (2017), The Economic and Political Consequences of India’s Demonetization, VoxDev, http://voxdev.org/topic/institutions-politicaleconomy/economic-and-politicalconsequences-india-s-demonetisation.

Banerjee, A., E. Breza, A. G. Chandrasekhar & B. Golub (2018), When Less is More: Experimental evidence on information delivery during India's demonetization, NBER Working Paper 24679.

Bank of Greece (2017), Key Findings of the Survey on Capital Controls and Cash withdrawal restrictions, 8 November.

Barnett, W. A., D. Fischer & A. Serletis (1992), Consumer Theory and the Demand for Money, Journal of Economic Literature 30, 2086-2119.

Bartzsch, N., G. Rösl & F. Seitz (2011a), Foreign Demand for Euro Banknotes issued in Germany: Estimation using direct approaches, Deutsche Bundesbank Discussion Paper No 20/2011.

Bartzsch, N., G. Rösl & F. Seitz (2011b), Foreign Demand for Euro Banknotes issued in Germany: Estimation using indirect approaches, Deutsche Bundesbank Discussion Paper No 21/2011.

Bartzsch, N., G. Rösl & F. Seitz (2013a), Currency Movements Within and Outside a Currency Union: The case of Germany and the euro area, Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 53, 393-401.

Bartzsch, N., G. Rösl & F. Seitz (2013b), Estimating the Foreign Circulation of Banknotes, Economics Letters 119, 165-167.

Bautista-González M. A. (2022), A Full-on Humanitarian Catastrophe, Cash Essentials, January 28, 2022.

Bech, M., U. Faruqui, F. Ougaard & C. Picillo (2018), Payments are a-changin’, but Cash still Rules, BIS Quarterly Review, March, 67-80.

Bernanke, B. (2000), Essays on the Great Depression, Princeton, Princeton University Press.

Bernanke, B. (2002), Remarks at the Conference to Honor Milton Friedman, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, November 8, On Milton Friedmans’ Ninetieth Birthday, in The Great Contraction, 1929 -1933, by M. Friedman and S.J. Schwartz, 227-249.

Boar, C. & A. Wehrli (2021), Ready, Steady, Go? – Results of the third BIS survey on central bank digital currency Bank of international Settlements, BIS Papers No 114, January.

Bruner, R. F. & S. D. Carr (2007), The Panic of 1907: Lessons Learned from the Market's Perfect Storm, Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons.

Calomiris, C. W. & J. R. Mason (2000), Causes of U.S. Banking Distress during the Depression, NBER Working Paper 7919, September.

Carson, M. & J. Clark (2013), Asian Financial Crisis, available at https://www.federalreservehistory.org/essays/asian-financial-crisis

Caswell, E., M. Hewkin Smith, D. Learmonth & G. Pearce (2020), Cash in the Time of Covid, Bank of England, Quarterly Bulletin 2020 Q4, 1-18.

CashEssentials (2019), ECB calls for Greece to drop Cash Payment Limitations. But what about the other Countries? 3 December, https://cashessentials.org/ecb-calls-for-greece-to-drop-cash-payment-limitations-but-what-about-the-other-countries/.

Chanda C. & J. Cook (2019), Who Gained from India’s Demonetization? Insights from Satellites and Surveys, LSU, Department of Economics Working paper series 2019-06, August.

Chandrasekhar, C.P. & J. Ghosh (2017), The Financialization of Finance? Demonetization and the Dubious Push to Cashlessness in India, Development and Change 49(2), 1-17.

Chen, H., W. Engert, K. P. Huynh, D. O'Habib, J. Wu & J. Zhu (2022), Cash and COVID-19: What happened in 2021, Bank of Canada Staff Discussion Paper No. 2022-8, April.

Cheney, J.S. & S.L.W. Rhine (2006), How Effective Were the Financial Safety Nets in the Aftermath of Katrina?, Discussion Paper, Payment Cards Center, Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, January.

Chodorow-Reich, G., G. Gopinath, P. Mishra & A. Narayanan (2018), Cash and the Economy: Evidence from India’s Demonetization, NBER Working Paper 25370, December.

Croushore, D. (1993), Money in the Utility Function: A Functional Equivalence to a Shopping-time Model, Journal of Macroeconomics 15, 175-182.

Currie, L. (1934), The Failure of Monetary Policy to Prevent the Depression of 1929-32, Journal of Political Economy 42, 145-177.

Das, S., L. Gadenne, T. Nandi & R. Warwick (2022), Does Going Cashless make you Tax-rich? Evidence from India's demonetization experiment, Warwick Economics Research Papers No. 1393, January.

Dasgupta, M. (2017), Moving towards “Cashlessness” in an Emerging Economy: A case study of latest policy steps in India, in: Deutsche Bundesbank (ed.), War on cash: Is there a future for cash?, conference volume "International Cash Conference 2017", Seiters, Frankfurt am Main, 616-685.

Deutsche Bundesbank (2016), Cash as a Means of Payment and a Store of Value, Annual Report 2015, 25-45.

Deutsche Bundesbank (2017a), Payment Behaviour in Germany in 2017, Fourth study of the utilisation of cash and cashless payment instruments, Frankfurt am Main.

Deutsche Bundesbank (2017b), Ten years of TARGET2 – a single shared platform for high-value payments, in Monthly Report, December, 70-88.

Deutsche Bundesbank (2022), Demand for Euro Banknotes issued by the Bundesbank: Current developments, Monthly Report, April, 67-83.

Dhingra, S. & M. Ghatak (2022), India: The economic impact of Covid-19, CentrePiece Spring 2022, 8-10.

Dolls, M., C. Fuest, C.Krolage, F .Neumeier & D. Stöhlke (2018), Convergence in EMU: What and how?, Euro Area Scrutiny, In-Depth Analysis requested by the ECON committee, Economic Governance Support Unit Directorate-General for Internal Policies of the Union, May.

Ebner, T., T. Nellen & J. Tenhofen (2021), The Rise of Digital Watchers, SNB Working Papers 1/2021.

Ecorys (2017), Study on an EU Initiative for a Restriction on Payments in Cash, Final Report, Brussels, 15 December.

Eichengreen, B. (1992), Golden Fetters: The Gold Standard and the Great Depression, 1919-1939, NBER Books.

Eichengreen, B. & P. Temin (2000), The Gold Standard and the Great Depression, Contemporary European History 9(2), 183–207.

Engert, W., B. S. Fung & S. Hendry (2018), Is a Cashless Society Problematic?, Bank of Canada Staff Discussion Paper No. 2018-12, October.

Esselink, H. & L. Hernández (2017), The Use of Cash by Households in the Euro Area, Occasional Paper No 201, November.

ESTA (2022), Demand for Cash at a time of War in Ukraine, Statement – 8 March 2022.

Eurobank (2016a), Third Quarter 2016 Results, 16 November, https://www.eurobank.gr/Uploads/pdf/3Q2016_Results_Presentation_Final.pdf.

Eurobank (2016b), One Year Capital Controls in Greece: Impact on the domestic economy & lessons from the Cypriot experience, 1 August, https://www.eurobank.gr/Uploads/Reports/GLOBAL_FOCUS_NOTE_20160805.pdf

European Central Bank (2010), The Payment System: Payments, securities and derivatives, and the role of the Eurosystem.

European Central Bank (2017), ECB Occasional Paper Series No 201 / November 2017.

European Central Bank (2019), Opinion of the European Central Bank of 20 November 2019 on tax disincentives for the use of cash (CON/2019/39).

European Central Bank (2020a), Study on the Payment Attitudes of Consumers in the Euro Area (SPACE), Frankfurt am Main, December.

European Central Bank (2020b), Agreement on Emergency Liquidity Assistance, 9 November, https://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/other/ecb.agreementemergencyliquidityassistance202012~ba7c45c170.en.pdf.

European Central Bank (2022), Annual Accounts of the ECB for 2021.

European Commission (2009), Report from the Commission – Greece, Report prepared in accordance with Article 104(3) of the Treaty, SEC(2009) 197 final, 18 February.

European Monetary Institute (1998), Convergence Report, Report required by Article 109j of the Treaty establishing the European Community, Frankfurt am Main, March.

EUROSTAT (2004), Report by EUROSTAT on the Revision of the Greek Government Deficit and Debt Figures, November.

Feenstra, R.C. (1986), Functional Equivalence between Liquidity Costs and the Utility of Money, Journal of Monetary Economics 17, 271-291.

Fouillet, C. I. Guérin & J.-M. Servet (2021), Demonetization and Digitalization: The Indian government’s hidden agenda, Telecommunications Policy 45(2), 102079.

Friedman, M. & A. J. Schwartz (1963), A Monetary History of the United States, 1867–1960, NBER Books.

Friedman, M. & A. J. Schwartz (1964), The Great Contraction, 1929-1933, Princeton, Princeton University Press.

Fuest C. & H.-W. Sinn (2018), Target Risks without Euro Exits, CESifo Forum 19, No. 4(4), Dezember, 36-48.

Garín, J., W. D. Lastrapes & R. Lester (2021), On the Welfare Effects of Phasing out Paper Currency, European Economic Review, 137, Article 103780.

GOAL (2021), Provisional Impact of repeat Multi-purpose Cash Assistance on Meeting Basic Needs and Supporting Food Security in North-West Syria, Learning Brief, 11th March 2021.

Goodhart, C. A. E. & J. Ashworth, (2020), Coronavirus Panic Fuels a Surge in Cash Demand, CEPR Discussion Paper 14910, June.

Goodhart, C. (1999), Myths about the Lender of Last Resort, International Finance 2:3, 339–60.

Hall, M., A. Singh, J. Morrison & and A. O’Doherty (2022), The Cash census - Britain’s relationship with cash and digital payments, March.

Hamilton, J. D. (1987), Monetary Factors in the Great Depression, Journal of Monetary Economics 19, 145-69.

Hansen, A. & D. Meyer (2020), NFA and the Asset Purchase Programmes of the Eurosystem: Non-monetary Policy Operations that Restrict the ECB’s Monetary Policy?, Journal of International Banking Law & Regulation, Vol. 35, Issue 6, 231-242.

Hellwig, M. & I. Schnabel (2019), Verursachen Target-Salden Risiken für die Steuerzahler? [Do Target Balances Create Risks for Taxpayers?], Wirtschaftsdienst 99(8), August, 553-561.

Holman, J. A. (1998), GMM Estimation of a Money-in-the-Utility-Function Model: The Implications of Functional Forms, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 30, 679-698.

Ingves, S. (2020), Future Money and Payments, Sveriges Riksbank, Economic Commentaries No. 9, 15 October 2020.

Jobst, C. & H. Stix (2017), Doomed to Disappear? The surprising return of cash across time and across countries, CEPR Discussion Paper No. 12327, September.

Joseph, M. (2009), Global Financial Crisis: How was India Impacted? paper prepared for the InWEnt-DIE Conference on Global Financial Governance – Challenges and Regional Responses, September 3-4, 2009 in Berlin.

Kahn, C. M., J. McAndrews & W. Roberds (2005), Money is Privacy, International Economic Review 46, 377-399.

Karau, S. (2020), Buried in the Vaults of Central Banks – Monetary Gold Hoarding and the Slide into the Great Depression, 2020, Bundesbank Discussion Paper 63/2020.

Karmakar, S. & A. Narayanan (2019), Do Households Care About Cash? Exploring the Heterogeneous Effects of India's Demonetization, February 19, available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3337472 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3337472

Kiyotaki, N. & R. Wright (1989), On Money as a Medium of Exchange, Journal of Political Economy 97, 927-954.

Kosse, A. & I. Mattei (2022), Gaining Momentum – Results of the 2021 BIS survey on central bank digital currencies, BIS Papers No 125, May.

Krüger, M. & F. Seitz (2017), The Benefits of Cash (Module 2), Fritz Knapp Publisher, Frankfurt/Main.

Kumar, R. & P. Vashisht (2009), The Global Economic Crisis: Impact on India and Policy Responses, ADBI Working Paper Series No. 164, November.

Lahiri, A. (2020), The Great Indian Demonetization, Journal of Economic Perspectives 34, 55-74.

Lalouette, L. & H. Esselink (2018), Trends and Developments in the Use of Euro Cash over the past ten Years, European Central Bank, Economic Bulletin 6/2018, 87-109.

Lepecq, G. (2021), From Military Coup to Cash Crisis, Cash Essentials, June 8, 2021.

Lepecq, G. & M. A. Bautista-González (2022), Russia: Cash, Payments, and Western Sanctions, Cash Essentials, March 8, 2022.

Madigan, B. F. (2009), Bagehot's Dictum in Practice: Formulating and Implementing Policies to Combat the Financial Crisis, Speech at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City's Annual Economic Symposium, Jackson Hole, August 21, 2009.

Martin, N. & D. Picherit (2020), Commonwealth & Comparative Politics 58,Special issue: Electoral fraud and manipulation in India and Pakistan, 1-20.

Metcalf, W. E. (ed.) (2020), The Oxford Handbook of Greek and Roman Coinage, Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Meyer, D. (2018), Schuldenerleichterungen für Griechenland – ein Überblick, Wirtschaftsdienst 6/2018, 405-410.

Mink, R. (2018), Eine griechische Tragödie – Staatsschuldenkrise und kein Ende? Metropolis-Verlag, Marburg.

Mitchell, T. (2020), COVID 19 – The Reaction of Some Central Banks, and Market Trends, Currency News, Special Supplement Issue 2, June, 2-3.

Mitchener, K. J. (2004), Bank Supervision, Regulation, and Instability during the Great Depression, National Bureau of Economic Research, NBER, Working Paper 10475, May.

Modi, N. (2016), Prime Minister's speech from 8 November, 2016, available as transcript at https://www.firstpost.com/business/demonetisation-anniversary-a-year-later-heres-what-prime-minister-narendra-modi-had-said-on-8-november-2016-4198753.html

Mohan, R. & P. Ray (2018), Indian Monetary Policy in the Time of Inflation Targeting and Demonetisation, Brookings India Working Paper 4, May.

Neely, C. J. & E. Karson (2021), More Stories of Unconventional Monetary Policy, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review, 207-70.

Nivette, A. E., R. Zahnow & M. P. Eisner (2021), A Global Analysis of the Impact of COVID-19 stay-at-home Restrictions on Crime, Nature Human Behaviour 5, 868–877.

Ongan, S. & I. Gocer (2022), Demand for Money in Greece after Euro Area and Policy Uncertainties, Review of Economic Analysis 14, forthcoming.

Panagiotidis, V. (2019), Greece’s Steady Progress towards a Cashless Society, November, https://www.europeanpaymentscouncil.eu/news-insights/insight/greeces-steady-progress-towards-cashless-society,

Research & Markets (2022), Cryptocurrency Market 2022. Reserve Bank of India (2018), Annual Report 2017-18.

Rogoff, K. S. (2016), The Curse of Cash, Princeton University Press, Princeton and Oxford.

Rösl, G. (2006), Regional Currencies in Germany, Local Competition for the Euro?, Discussion paper, Series 1: Economic Studies, No 53/2006, Deutsche Bundesbank, Frankfurt.

Rösl, G., F. Seitz & K.-H. Tödter (2019), The Cost of Overcoming the Zero Lower-Bound: A Welfare Analysis, in: Economies 7(67), 1-18.

Rösl, G. & F. Seitz (2021), Cash and Crises, No surprises by the virus, IMFS Working Papers, No 150, Institute for Monetary and Financial Stability, Frankfurt.

Rösl, G. & F. Seitz (2022), Cash Demand in Times of Crisis, in: Journal of Payment Systems & Strategies, 2022.

Ruberton, P. M., J. Gladstone & S. Lyubomirsky (2016), How your Bank Balance Buys Happiness: The importance of “cash on hand” to life satisfaction, Emotion 16, 575–580.

Rule, G. (ed.) (2015), Understanding the Central Bank Balance Sheet, Centre for Central Banking Studies, Bank of England.

Shirai, S. & E. A. Sugandi (2019), What Explains the Growing Global Demand for Cash? ADBI Working Paper Series, No. 1006.

Sinn, H.-W. & T. Wollmershäuser (2012), Target Loans, Current Account Balances and Capital Flows: The ECB’s rescue facility, International Tax and Public Finance 19, 468–508.

Sinn, H.-W. (2014), Austerity, Growth and Inflation: Remarks on the Eurozone’s unresolved competitiveness problem, The World Economy 37(1), 1-13.

Smith, M. (2014), Cash is Vital to Disaster Recovery: How IADs can help, ATM Marketplace.

Tharoor, S (2016), India’s Demonetization Disaster, Project Syndicate, 6 December, https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/india-demonetization-policy-consequences-by-shashi-tharoor-2016-12.

Temin, P. (1976), Did Monetary Forces Cause the Great Depression? New York, W.W. Norton.

Tucker, P. (2009), The Repertoire of Official Sector Interventions in the Financial System: Last Resort Lending, Market-Making, and Capital, Bank of Japan 2009 International Conference, 27–28 May.

Vimukt, D. (2017), Demonetisation Effect: Rural India still faces cash shortage, April 29, https://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/demonetisation-effect-rural-india-still-faces-cash-shortage-117042900725_1.html.

Wadhwa, S. (2019), Impact of Demonetization on Household Consumption in India, Brown University.

Walsh, C. E. (2017), Monetary Theory and Policy, 4th ed., The MIT Press, Cambridge (MA).

White, E. N. (1984), A Reinterpretation of the Banking Crisis of 1930, Journal of Economic History 44, 119-38.

Whittaker, J. (2011), Eurosystem Debts, Greece, and the Role of Banknotes, Lancaster University Management School, Monetary Research, 14 November.

Wicker, E. (1980), A Reconsideration of the Causes of the Banking Panic of 1930, Journal of Economic History 40, 571-83.

Wicker, E. (1996), The Banking Panics of the Great Depression, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Yoshizawa, K., K. Maehashi, H. Yanagihara, Y. Kadogawa & M. Inada (2021), Developments in Banknotes in Circulation since the Start of the Pandemic, Bank of Japan Review 2021-E-6, December, 1-7.

Zamora-Pérez, A. (2021), The Paradox of Banknotes: Understanding the demand for cash beyond transactional use, European Central Bank, Economic Bulletin 2/2021, 121-137.

Zhu, H., Gupta, A., Majumder, B. & S. Steinbach (2017), Macro Shocks and Micro Woes: Short-term effects of India's demonetization on the poor, February 10.