Evaluating the effects of short and medium-term temporary work reduction schemes: the case of Spain’s ERTEs during the COVID-19 outbreak

Garcia-Clemente, Javier and Rubino, Nicola and Congregado, Emilio (2022): Evaluating the effects of short and medium-term temporary work reduction schemes: the case of Spain’s ERTEs during the COVID-19 outbreak.

Abstract

This paper presents an average treatment effect analysis of the Spain’s furlough program during the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, using propensity score matching techniques. Merging 2020 labor force quarterly microdata, we find that the probability to be re-employed after treatment was significantly higher among the treated (furlough granted group) than in the control group (comparable non-furloughed individuals who lost their job). These results seem to be robust across models, having tested a wide range of matching specifications. Furthermore, we also explore if the Spanish furlough scheme had an uniform impact across regions with different industrial structures, concluding that the furlough participation was positively related to the probability of re�employment across any region and economic activity. Nevertheless, a different time arrangement did affect the magnitude of the effect, suggesting that it may decrease with the furlough duration. This finding advises against long lasting schemes under persistent recessions, notwithstanding, short time work schemes still stand as useful strategies to face essentially transitory adverse shocks.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Furlough, short-time work, ERTE, propensity score matching, Covid-19, Spain.
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J0 - General > J08 - Labor Economics Policies; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J3 - Wages, Compensation, and Labor Costs > J38 - Public Policy; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J65 - Unemployment Insurance ; Severance Pay ; Plant Closings; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J68 - Public Policy

References

Abadie, A. and Imbens, G. W. (2006). Large sample properties of matching estimators for average treatment effects. Econometrica, 74:235–267.

Abadie, A. and Imbens, G. W. (2011). Bias-corrected matching estimators for average treatment effects. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 29(1):1–11.

Abadie, A. and Imbens, G. W. (2012). Matching on the estimated propensity score. Working Paper 15301, Harvard University and National Bureau of Economic Research.

Abraham, K. G. and Houseman, S. N. (1994). Does employment protection inhibit labor market flexibility? lessons from germany, france, and belgium. Social protection versus economic flexibility: Is there a trade-off, pages 59–94.

Arranz, J. M., Garc´ıa-Serrano, C., and Hernanz, V. (2018). The changing use of short-time work schemes: Evidence from two recessions:. European Journal of Industrial Relations, 25:5–22.

Arranz, J. M., Garc´ıa-Serrano, C., and Hernanz, V. (2020). Hope for the best and prepare for the worst. Do short-time work schemes help workers remain in the same firm? International Journal of Manpower, 42:935–959.

Biancardi, D., Lucifora, C., and Origo, F. (2022). Short-time work and unionisation. Labour Economics, page 102188.

Boeri, T. and Bruecker, H. (2011). Short-time work benefits revisited: some lessons from the great recession. Economic Policy, 26(68):697–765.

Burdett, K. and Wright, R. (1989). Unemployment insurance and short-time compensation: The effects on layoffs, hours per worker, and wages. Journal of Political Economy, 97(6):1479–1496.

Cahuc, P. (2019). Short-time work compensation schemes and employment. IZA World of Labor.

Cahuc, P. and Carcillo, S. (2011). Is short-time work a good method to keep unemployment down? Nordic Economic Policy Review, 1(1):133–165.

Cahuc, P., Kramarz, F., and Nevoux, S. (2021). The heterogeneous impact of short-time work: From saved jobs to windfall effects. IZA Discussion Paper No. 14381.

Calavrezo, O. and Lodin, F. (2012). Short-time working arrangements in france during the crisis: An empirical analysis of firms and employees. Comparative Economic Studies, 54(2):299–320.

Crimmann, A., Wießner, F., and Bellmann, L. (2012). Resisting the crisis: short-time work in germany. International Journal of Manpower.

Dengler, T. and Gehrke, B. (2021). Short-time work and precautionary savings. IZA Discussion Paper No. 14329.

Drahokoupil, J. and M¨uller, T. (2021). Job retention schemes in europe: a lifeline during the covid-19 pandemic. ETUI Research Paper - Working Paper 2021.07.

Fitzroy, F. R. and Hart, R. A. (1985). Hours, layoffs and unemployment insurance funding: Theory and practice in an international perspective. The Economic Journal, 95(379):700–713.

Gehrke, B. and Hochmuth, B. (2021). Counteracting unemployment in crises: non-linear effects of short-time work policy. The Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 123(1):144–183.

Giupponi, G. and Landais, C. (2020). Subsidizing labor hoarding in recessions: The employment & welfare effects of short time work. CEPR Discussion Paper 13310.

Giupponi, G., Landais, C., and Lapeyre, A. (2022). Should we insure workers or jobs during recessions? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 36(2):29–54.

Hijzen, A. and Martin, S. (2013). The role of short-time work schemes during the global financial crisis and early recovery: a cross-country analysis. IZA Journal of Labor Policy, 2:1–31.

Hijzen, A. and Venn, D. (2011). The role of short-time work schemes during the 2008-09 recession. OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers, (115).

Izquierdo, M., Puente, S., and Regil, A. (2021). Furlough schemes in the covid-19 crisis: An initial analysis of furloughed employees resuming work. Banco de Espana Article 11/21.

Kato, T. and Kodama, N. (2019). The consequences of short-time compensation: Evidence from japan. IZA Discussion Paper No. 12596.

Kopp, D. and Siegenthaler, M. (2021). Short-time work and unemployment in and after the great recession. Journal of the European Economic Association, 19(4):2283–2321.

Kruppe, T. and Scholz, T. (2014). Labour hoarding in germany: employment effects of short-time work during the crises. Technical report, IAB-Discussion Paper.

Lydon, R., Math¨a, T. Y., and Millard, S. (2019). Short-time work in the great recession: firm-level evidence from 20 eu countries. IZA Journal of Labor Policy, 8(1):1–29.

M¨uller, T. and Schulten, T. (2020). Ensuring fair short-time work - a european overview. SSRN Electronic Journal - ETUI Research Paper - Policy Brief 07/2020, 7.

Osuna, V. and Garc´ıa-P´erez, J. I. (2015). On the effectiveness of short-time work schemes in dual labor markets. De Economist 2015 163:3, 163:323–351.

Osuna, V. and P´erez, J. I. G. (2021). Temporary layoffs, short-time work and covid-19: the case of a dual labour market. Applied Economic Analysis, ahead-of-print.

Pavlopoulos, D. and Chkalova, K. (2019). Short-time work: a bridge to employment security or a springboard to unemployment? Economic and Industrial Democracy.

Rosenbaum, P. R. and Rubin, D. B. (1983). The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects. Biometrika, 70(1):41–55.