Evolution of cost recovery levels in the Portuguese water supply and wastewater industry 1998-2005

Monteiro, Henrique (2008): Evolution of cost recovery levels in the Portuguese water supply and wastewater industry 1998-2005.

Abstract

This paper assesses the situation in Portugal in 2005 regarding cost recovery in the water supply (WS) and wastewaterdrainage and treatment (WWDT) industry by type of system (bulk and retail water and wastewater), by type of utility and by NUTS III, halfway between the publication of the Water Framework Directive (WFD) and the meeting of the 2010 deadline. For that purpose, we build on the previous contribution by Monteiro (2007), which reported the situation in 2002, by updating the indicators to 2005 and assessing the evolution since 1998. We also present a brief historical overview of the presence of the cost recovery principle in Portuguese law regarding the industry. The main conclusions that stand out are: the introduction of the cost recovery principle is prior to the WFD and the more recent Water Law, although it lacked practical implementation; the level of revenues collected by the WS and WWDT utilities is insufficient to meet the financial costs of their activities; the situation is worse for wastewater than for WS systems, revealing evidence of cross-subsidization within the utilities which manage both systems; the situation has worsened in recent years; cost recovery levels are lower in the less densely populated and poorer inland regions; finally, we find no evidence associating cost recovery levels and the type of utility.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Water Supply Systems; Wastewater Drainage and Treatment; Cost Recovery; Water Framework Directive; Water Law
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q2 - Renewable Resources and Conservation > Q25 - Water

References

Alves, António and Bernardino Pinto (eds.) (2004), Economia da Água do Plano Nacional da Água, [Water Economics in the National Water Plan] Lisbon: INAG – National Water Institute.

APDA (2006), Água e Saneamento Em Portugal: O Mercado e Os Preços. [Water and Sewage in Portugal – The market and the Prices] Lisbon: APDA – Associação Portuguesa de Distribuição e Drenagem de Águas - Comissão Especializada de Legislação e Economia [Portuguese Association of Water Supply and Drainage – Specialized Commission for Legislation and Economics].

Assembleia da República (2008), Law nº 12/2008 of February 26. [Legislation regarding the protection of the customers of essential public services]

Assembleia da República (2007), Law nº 2/2007 of January 15. [Local/Municipal Finance Law]

Assembleia da República (2005), Law nº 58/2005 of December 29. [Water Law]

Baptista, Jaime Melo, Dulce Álvaro Pássaro and Rui Ferreira Dos Santos (2006), A Nova Lei Da Água e Os Serviços de Abastecimento Público de Água e de Saneamento de Águas Residuais Urbanas [The New Water Law and the Public Urban Water Supply and Wastewater Sewage Services], Lisbon: IRAR – Regulating Authority for Water and Waste.

Bithas, Kostas (2008), “The sustainable residential water use: Sustainability, efficiency and social equity. The European experience”, Ecological Economics, 68(1): 221-229.

Dahan, Momi and Udi Nisan (2007), “Unintended Consequences of Increasing Block Tariffs Pricing Policy in Urban Water”, Water Resources Research, 43(3): 1-10.

European Commission (2008), Guide to Cost-Benefit Analysis of Investment Projects: Structural Funds, Cohesion Fund and Instrument for Pre-Accession, Final Report, Directorate General Regional Policy, European Commission.

European Union (2000), “Directive 2000/60/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a framework for the community action in the field of water policy – EU Water Framework Directive”, Official Journal (OJL 327, 22-12-2000, pp. L327/1-L327/72).

Foster, Vivien and Tito Yepes (2006), “Is Cost Recovery a Feasible Objective for Water and Electricity? The Latin American Experience”, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 3943.

Evans, D. and H. Sezer (2005), “Social discount rates for member countries of the European Union”, Journal of Economic Studies, 32(1): 47-59.

INAG (2008), Relatório do Estado do Abastecimento de Água e de Saneamento de Águas Residuais - Campanha INSAAR 2006, [Report on the State of Water Supply and Wastewater Sewage] Lisbon: INAG – National Water Institute, Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Regional Development.

INAG (2007), Relatório Sobre o Estado dos Sistemas Públicos de Abastecimento de Água e de Drenagem e Tratamento de Águas Residuais - INSAAR 2005, [Report on the State of Water Supply and Wastewater Drainage and Treatment Public Systems] Lisbon: INAG – National Water Institute, Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Regional Development.

INAG (2005), Relatório Síntese sobre a Caracterização das Regiões Hidrográficas Prevista na Directiva-Quadro da Água, [Synthesis Report on River Basin Characterization referred in the Water Framework Directive] Lisbon: INAG – National Water Institute, Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Regional Development.

INAG (2002), INSAAR – Glossário, Lisbon: INAG – National Water Institute, Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Regional Development.

Komives, Kristin, Quentin Wodon, Vivien Foster, Roohi Abdullah and Jonathan Halpern (2006), “The Distributional Incidence of Residential Water and Electricity Subsidies”, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 3878.

IRAR (2008), Nota sobre a nova legislação relativa a serviços públicos essenciais. [Comment on the new legislation regarding essential public services] Lisbon: IRAR – Regulating Authority for Water and Waste.

IRAR (2007), Relatório Anual Do Sector de Águas e Resíduos Em Portugal – 2006. [Annual Report on Water and Waste Industry in Portugal] Lisbon: IRAR – Regulating Authority for Water and Waste.

Martins, Rita, Fernando Coelho and Adelino Fortunato (2008), “Water Losses and Hydrographical Regions Influence on the Cost Structure of the Portuguese Water Industry”, Estudos do GEMF, 06/2008, Monetary and Financial Research Group, School of Economics, University of Coimbra.

Mendes, Adérito, João Avillez, Pedro Mendes, Fernanda Gomes, Simone Martins, Patrícia Cardoso, Sónia Cardoso, Djamila Costa, Sara Mendes, Gisela Robalo and Sónia Silva (2006), “Inventário nacional de sistemas de abastecimento de água e de águas residuais” [National Inventory of Water Supply and Wastewater Systems], Tecnologia da Água, I, March 2006, pp. 34-42.

MAOTDR (2006), PEAASAR II – Plano Estratégico de Abastecimento de Água e Saneamento de Águas Residuais 2007-2013. [Strategic Plan for Water Supply and Wastewater Drainage] Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Regional Development.

MAOTDR (2008), Decree-Law nº 97/2008 of June 11. Ministry of Environment, Spatial Planning and Regional Development [Economic and Financial Regime for Water Resources]

Monteiro, Henrique and Catarina Roseta-Palma (2007), “Caracterização dos tarifários de abastecimento de água e saneamento em Portugal” [Portuguese Water Supply and Sewage Tariffs Report], Working Paper n. 07/58, Dinâmia – Research Centre on Socioeconomic Change.

Monteiro, Henrique (2007), “Recuperação de custos no sector de abastecimento de água e drenagem e tratamento de águas residuais em Portugal” [Cost Recovery in the Portuguese Water Supply and Wastewater Drainage and Treatment Industry], Working Paper n.º 2007/57, Dinâmia, Research Centre on Socioeconomic Change.

OECD (2006), “Water: The Experience in OECD Countries”, Environmental Performance Reviews, Paris, OECD - Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.

UNDP (2006), Human Development Report 2006 – Beyond scarcity: Power, poverty and the global water crisis, United Nations Development Programme.

Ribeiro, Ana Katila (2007), “A recuperação dos custos e a Lei da água” [Cost recovery and the Water Law], Master’s thesis in Civil Engineering, Specialization in Hydraulics, Water Resources and Environment. Civil Engineering Department, School of Science and Technology, University of Coimbra.

Ribeiro, Ana Katila, Pedro Cunha Serra and Maria da Conceição Cunha (2006), “Os antecedentes do princípio da recuperação de custos na DQA” [The background of the cost recovery principle in the WFD], presented at the 5th Iberian Conference on Water Planning and Management held in Faro in December 2006.

Roseta-Palma, Catarina, Henrique Monteiro, Mónica Meireles, Francisco Mestre and Gustavo Sugahara (2006), “Strategic Evaluation of Environment and Risk Prevention – National Evaluation Report – Portugal”, Technical Report, GHK for the European Commission.

Serra, Pedro (2001), “Water pricing policies in Portugal”, in European Commission, Pricing Water: Economics, Environment and Society - Conference Proceedings, Sintra, 6 and 7 September 1999, European Commission, pp. 283-288.

WATECO (2003), “Economia e Ambiente, Metodologia de Aplicação da Directiva Quadro da Água: Documento de Orientação”, Wateco Group, European Commission. Published by INAG (National Water Institute), Ministry of Cities, Spatial Planning and Environment

WWAP (2006), Water: A Shared Responsibility. The 2nd United Nations World Water Development Report, United Nations World Water Assessment Programme. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and Berghahn Books.