The Great, Greater, and Greatest Recessions of US States

Wall, Howard J. (2022): The Great, Greater, and Greatest Recessions of US States. Forthcoming in: Journal of Regional Analysis and Policy

Abstract

This paper examines state-level differences in the timing, depth, and total employment effects of the Great Recession. It finds that several states were in recession prior to the official start of the recession, while more than a dozen states didn’t enter recession until six months or more after it. States’ exits from recession were similarly staggered. As a result, 11 states’ recessions were one year long or shorter, while the recessions for five states were at least 24 months long. Further, there were geographic patterns to the spread of the recession across states. I use these state-level estimates to introduce a new approach for calculating the total effects of recessions on state employment, one that accounts for lost employment growth as well the decrease in employment. States formed distinct geographic groupings according to these total effects, with states in the West and Southeast tending to have seen the greatest harm. Finally, many of the state-level differences in the effects of the Great Recession were related to differences in industry mix and the prevalence of sub-prime mortgages. The states with the longest and deepest recessions also tended to have been those with the highest shares of subprime mortgages.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: State recessions
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E2 - Consumption, Saving, Production, Investment, Labor Markets, and Informal Economy > E24 - Employment ; Unemployment ; Wages ; Intergenerational Income Distribution ; Aggregate Human Capital ; Aggregate Labor Productivity; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E32 - Business Fluctuations ; Cycles; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R12 - Size and Spatial Distributions of Regional Economic Activity

References

Barker, M.M., 2011. Manufacturing employment hard hit during 2007-09 recession. Monthly Labor Review. 134(4). 28-33.

Beraja, M., Fuster A., Hurst, E, Vavra, J., 2019. Regional heterogeneity and the refinancing channel of monetary policy. Quarterly Journal of Economics. 134(1), 109-183.

Beraja, M., Hurst, E., Ospina, J., 2019. The aggregate implications of regional business cycles, Econometrica. 87(6). 1789-1833.

Beyers, W.B., 2013. The Great Recession and state unemployment trends, Economic Development Quarterly. 27(2), 114-123.

Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2012. BLS Spotlight on Statistics: The Recession of 2007-2009. February 2012 (www.bls.gov/spotlight/2012/recession/).

Burns, A.F., Mitchel W.C., 1946. Measuring Business Cycles. New York: NBER.

Giulio, C., Lupi, C., Tabasso, M., 2021. Business cycle synchronization among the US states: Spatial effects and regional determinants. Spatial Economic Analysis. 16(3), 397-415.

Carlino, G.A., DeFina R.H., 1998. The differential regional effects of monetary policy. Review of Economics and Statistics. 80, 572-587.

Carlino, G.A., DeFina R.H., 2004. How strong is co-movement in employment over the business cycle? Evidence from state/sector data. Journal of Urban Economics. 55, 298-315.

Carlino, G., Sill K., 2001. Regional income fluctuations: Common trends and common cycles. Review of Economics and Statistics. 83, 446-456.

Chauvet, M., Piger, J., 2013. Employment and the business cycle. The Manchester School. 81(S2), 16-42.

Connaughton, J.E., Swartz, C., 2017. Regional implications of the Great Recession. Journal of Regional Analysis and Policy. 47(1), 29-43.

Davidson, B., 2011. Mining employment trends of 2007-09: A question of prices. Monthly Labor Review. 134(4), 19-23.

Deller, S., Watson, P., 2016. Did regional economic diversity influence the effects of the Great Recession? Economic Inquiry, 54(4), 1824-38.

Fogli, A., Hill, E., Perri, F., 2013, The geography of the Great Recession. NBER International Seminar on Macroeconomics 2012, 9(1), 305-331.

Gadea, M.D., Gomez-Loscos, A., Montanes, A., 2012. Cycles inside cycles: Spanish regional aggregation. SERIES. 3, 423-456.

Garfaoui, J., Girardin, E., 2015, Comovement of Chinese provincial business cycles. Economic Modelling. 44, 294-306.

Gjerde. L. P., Prescott, P., and Rice, J., 2019. The impact of state fiscal policy on states’ resilience entering the Great Recession. Journal of Regional Analysis and Policy. 49(1), 13-30.

Gomez-Loscos, A., Gadea, M.D., Bandres, E., 2019. Business cycle patterns in European regions. Empirical Economics. 59, 2639-2661.

Guren, A., McKay, A., Nakamura, E., Steinsson, J., 2021. What do we learn from cross-regional empirical estimation in macroeconomics? NBER Macroeconomics Annual. 35(1), 175-223.

Hadi, A., 2011. Construction employment peaks before the recession and falls sharply throughout it. Monthly Labor Review. 134(4), 24-27.

Hall, V.B., McDermott, J, 2007. Regional business cycles in New Zealand: Do they exist? What might drive them? Papers in Regional Science. 86(2), 167-191.

Hamilton, J.D., 1989. A new approach to the economic analysis of nonstationary time series and the business cycle. Econometrica. 57, 357-384.

Hamilton, J.D., Owyang, M.T., 2012. The propagation of regional recessions. Review of Economics and Statistics. 94(4), 935-947.

Han, Y., Goetz, S.J., 2015. The economic resilience of US counties during the Great Recession. The Review of Regional Studies. 45, 131-149.

Hoynes, H., Miller, D.L., Schaller, J., 2012. Who suffers during recessions? Journal of Economic Perspectives. 26(3), 27-47.

Kim, C.J., Nelson, C.R., 1999, State-Space Models with Regime Switching: Classical and Gibbs-Sampling Approaches with Applications, MIT Press, Cambridge.

Kondo, K., 2021. Spatial dependence in regional business cycles: Evidence from Mexican states. RIEB, Kobe University, DP2015-27.

Lange, R.H., 2017. Regional business cycles in Canada: A regime-switching VAR approach. Journal of Regional Analysis & Policy. 47(1), 57-74.

Martin, R., Sunley, P., Gardiner, B., and Tyler, P., 2016. How regions react to recessions: Resilience and the role of economic structure. Regional Studies. 50(4), 561-585.

Mayer, C., Pence, K., 2009. Subprime Mortgages: What, Where, and To Whom? In Housing Markets and the Economy: Risk, Regulation, and Policy: Essays in Honor of Karl E. Case (Lincoln Land Institute, Cambridge, MA), ed. by E. Glaeser and J. Quigley.

Mian, A., and Sufi, A., 2014. What explains the 2007-2009 drop in employment? Econometrica. 82(6), 2197-2223. Olney, M.M., Pacitti, A., 2017. The rise of services, deindustrialization, and the length of economic recovery, Economic Inquiry. 2017 55(4) 1625-1647.

Owyang, M.T., Piger, J., Wall, H.J., 2005. Business cycle phases in U.S. states. The Review of Economics and Statistics. 87, 604-616.

Owyang, M.T., Piger, J., Wall, H.J., 2008. A state-level analysis of the great moderation. Regional Science and Urban Economics. 38(6), 578-589.

Owyang, M.T., Piger J., Wall, H.J., 2013. Discordant city employment cycles. Regional Science and Urban Economics. 43(2), 367-84.

Owyang, M.T., Piger, J., Wall, H.J., 2015. Forecasting national recessions using state level data, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking. 47(5), 847-866.

Partridge, M.D., Rickman, D.S., 2005. Regional cyclical asymmetries in an optimal currency area: An analysis using U.S. state data. Oxford Economic Papers. 57(3), 373-397.

Prassas, G., 2011. Employment in financial activities: Double billed by housing and financial crises. Monthly Labor Review. 104(4), 40-44.

Prescott, P., Gjerde, K.P., 2022. The impact of state fiscal policy on states’ resilience during the Great Recession.” Journal of Regional Analysis and Policy. 52(1), 1–18.

Rembert, M., 2018. Creative destruction and inter-regional job reallocation during the Great Recession. Journal of Regional Analysis and Policy. 48(1), 77-91.

Rickman, D.S., Guettabi, M., 2014. The Great Recession and nonmetropolitan America. Journal of Regional Science. 55(1), 93-112.

Stumpner, S., 2019. Trade and the geographic spread of the Great Recession. Journal of International Economics. 119, 169-180.

Walden, M.L. 2014. Recovery from the Great Recession: Explaining Differences Among the States. Journal of Regional Analysis & Policy. 44 (2): 166–74.

Wall, H.J., 2007. Regional business cycle phases in Japan. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review. 89, 61-80.

Wall, H.J., 2013. The employment cycles of neighboring cities. Regional Science and Urban Economics. 43(1), 177-185.

Thiede B.C., Monnat, S.M., 2016. The Great Recession and America’s geography of unemployment. Demographic Research. 35, 891-928.

Yagan, D., 2019, Employment hysteresis from the Great Recession. Journal of Political Economy, 127(5), 2505–2558.