Investigating Tax Compliance with Mixed-Methods Approach: The Effect of Normative Appeals Among the Firms in Latvia

Saulitis, Andris and Chapkovski, Philipp (2023): Investigating Tax Compliance with Mixed-Methods Approach: The Effect of Normative Appeals Among the Firms in Latvia.

Abstract

This study employs a field experiment and qualitative content analysis to examine the effect of various behaviourally-informed messages on increasing tax compliance in Latvia. In a field experiment, more than 3,000 businesses received a message with a normative appeal to increase the relatively low salaries compared to firms operating in the same industry and region. Other treatment groups received the same message with an additional paragraph that varied audit probabilities or included prosocial messages. All treatments effectively increased the average declared salaries in the enterprises relative to not sending a message. Even though the overall fiscal effect was positive, the qualitative analysis of the feedback by the firms indicates that messages, particularly those that did not state the future actions of the tax administration, provoked discontent and distrust between the taxpayer and the tax administration. Our findings demonstrate that clear communication of the intended actions of the tax administration is the most effective approach to promoting tax compliance. Furthermore, our research indicates that a relatively small audit probability (5%) is as effective as a larger probability (66%), implying that there is no need to carry out audits on a large scale to address tax evasion.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: tax collection; shadow economy; prosocial behaviour; tax audits; mixed-methods
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments > C93 - Field Experiments; D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D03 - Behavioral Microeconomics: Underlying Principles; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H26 - Tax Evasion and Avoidance; H - Public Economics > H3 - Fiscal Policies and Behavior of Economic Agents > H32 - Firm; H - Public Economics > H8 - Miscellaneous Issues > H83 - Public Administration ; Public Sector Accounting and Audits

References

Adhikari, Bibek, James Alm, and Timothy F. Harris. 2021. “Small Business Tax Compliance under Third-Party Reporting.” Journal of Public Economics 203: 104514.

Allingham, Michael G., and Agnar Sandmo. 1972. “Income Tax Evasion: A Theoretical Analysis.” Journal of Public Economics 1(3–4): 323–38.

Alm, James, John Deskins, and Michael McKee. 2009. “Do Individuals Comply on Income Not Reported by Their Employer?” Public Finance Review 37(2): 120–41.

Alm, James, Jorge Martinez‐Vazque, and Benno Torgler. 2006. “Russian Attitudes toward Paying Taxes – before, during, and after the Transition.” International Journal of Social Economics 33(12): 832–57.

Alm, James, and Benno Torgler. 2011. “Do Ethics Matter? Tax Compliance and Morality.” Journal of Business Ethics 101(4): 635–51.

Ariel, Barak. 2012. “Deterrence and Moral Persuasion Effects on Corporate Tax Compliance: Findings from a Randomized Controlled Trial.” Criminology (1): 27–70.

Arsić, Milojko et al. 2015. “Causes of the Shadow Economy.” In Formalizing the Shadow Economy in Serbia, Contributions to Economics, eds. Gorana Krstić and Friedrich Schneider. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 21–46. http://link.springer.com/10.1007/978-3-319-13437-6_4 (October 28, 2022).

Bergolo, Marcelo et al. 2019. “Tax Audits as Scarecrows: Evidence from a Large-Scale Field Experiment.” Proceedings. Annual Conference on Taxation and Minutes of the Annual Meeting of the National Tax Association 112: 1–xxix.

Beshears, John, and Harry Kosowsky. 2020. “Nudging: Progress to Date and Future Directions.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 161: 3–19.

Bíró, Anikó, Dániel Prinz, and László Sándor. 2022. “The Minimum Wage, Informal Pay, and Tax Enforcement.” Journal of Public Economics 215: 104728.

Bjørneby, Marie, Annette Alstadsæter, and Kjetil Telle. 2021. “Limits to Third-Party Reporting: Evidence from a Randomized Field Experiment in Norway.” Journal of Public Economics 203: 104512.

Blumenthal, Marsha, Charles W. Christian, and Joel Slemrod. 2001. “Do Normative Appeals Affect Tax Compliance? Evidence From a Controlled Experiment in Minnesota.” National Tax Journal 54(1): 125–38.

Boning, William C., John Guyton, Ronald Hodge, and Joel Slemrod. 2020. “Heard It through the Grapevine: The Direct and Network Effects of a Tax Enforcement Field Experiment on Firms.” Journal of Public Economics 190: 104261.

Carpio, Lucia Del. 2014. Are the Neighbors Cheating? Evidence from a Social Norm Experiment on Property Taxes in Peru. Princeton: Princeton University. Unpublished Manuscript. https://faculty.insead.edu/lucia-del-carpio/documents/Are_the_neighbors_cheating_Apr2014.pdf.

Cartwright, Nancy. 2021. “Rigour versus the Need for Evidential Diversity.” Synthese 199(5–6): 13095–119.

Castro, Lucio, and Carlos Scartascini. 2015. “Tax Compliance and Enforcement in the Pampas: Evidence from a Field Experiment.” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 116: 65–82.

Chamlee-Wright, Emily. 2010. “Qualitative Methods and the Pursuit of Economic Understanding.” The Review of Austrian Economics 23(4): 321–31.

Chater, Nick, and George Loewenstein. 2022. “The I-Frame and the s-Frame: How Focusing on Individual-Level Solutions Has Led Behavioral Public Policy Astray.” Behavioral and Brain Sciences: 1–60.

Cialdini, Robert B., Carl A. Kallgren, and Raymond R. Reno. 1991. “A Focus Theory of Normative Conduct: A Theoretical Refinement and Reevaluation of the Role of Norms in Human Behavior.” In Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, ed. Mark P. Zanna. Academic Press, 201–34. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0065260108603305 (December 2, 2015).

Cranor, Taylor, Jacob Goldin, Tatiana Homonoff, and Lindsay Moore. 2020. “Communicating Tax Penalties to Delinquent Taxpayers: Evidence from a Field Experiment.” National Tax Journal 73(2): 331–60.

Dasgupta, Partha. 1990. “Trust as a Commodity.” In Trust: Making and Breaking Cooperative Relations, ed. Diego Gambetta. Oxford, UK Cambridge, Mass., USA: Blackwell Pub.

Davidescu, Adriana Ana Maria, and Friedrich Schneider. 2019. “The Minimum Wage Fuels Romania’s Shadow Economy?” In Subsistence Entrepreneurship, Contributions to Management Science, eds. Vanessa Ratten, Paul Jones, Vitor Braga, and Carla Susana Marques. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 155–81. http://link.springer.com/10.1007/978-3-030-11542-5_9 (October 28, 2022).

De Neve, Jan-Emmanuel et al. 2021. “How to Improve Tax Compliance? Evidence from Population-Wide Experiments in Belgium.” Journal of Political Economy 129(5): 1425–63.

Deaton, Angus, and Nancy Cartwright. 2018. “Understanding and Misunderstanding Randomized Controlled Trials.” Social Science & Medicine 210: 2–21.

Dwenger, Nadja, Henrik Kleven, Imran Rasul, and Johannes Rincke. 2016. “Extrinsic and Intrinsic Motivations for Tax Compliance: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Germany.” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 8(3): 203–32.

Enachescu, Janina et al. 2019. “The Role of Emotions in Tax Compliance Behavior: A Mixed-Methods Approach.” Journal of Economic Psychology 74: 102194.

Fehr, Ernst, and Urs Fischbacher. 2006. “The Economics of Strong Reciprocity.” In Moral Sentiments and Material Interests : The Foundations of Cooperation in Economic Life, eds. Herbert Gintis, Samuel Bowles, Robert Boyd, and Ernst Fehr. Cambridge, UNITED STATES: MIT Press, 151–91. http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/yale-ebooks/detail.action?docID=3338575.

Feinmann, Javier, Roberto Hsu Rocha, and Maximiliano Lauletta. 2022. “Payments Under the Table.” SSRN Electronic Journal. https://www.ssrn.com/abstract=4270665 (February 23, 2023).

Fellner, Gerlinde, Rupert Sausgruber, and Christian Traxler. 2013. “Testing Enforcement Strategies in the Field: Threat, Moral Appeal and Social Information.” Journal of the European Economic Association 11(3): 634–60.

Gangl, Katharina et al. 2017. “Coercive and Legitimate Authority Impact Tax Honesty: Evidence from Behavioral and ERP Experiments.” Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 12(7): 1108–17.

Ganzach, Yoav, and Nili Karsahi. 1995. “Message Framing and Buying Behavior: A Field Experiment.” Journal of Business Research 32(1): 11–17.

Górecki, Maciej A., and Natalia Letki. 2021. “Social Norms Moderate the Effect of Tax System on Tax Evasion: Evidence from a Large-Scale Survey Experiment.” Journal of Business Ethics 172(4): 727–46.

Hallsworth, Michael, John A. List, Robert D. Metcalfe, and Ivo Vlaev. 2017. “The Behavioralist as Tax Collector: Using Natural Field Experiments to Enhance Tax Compliance.” Journal of Public Economics 148: 14–31.

Harju, Jarkko, Tuomas Kosonen, and Olli Ropponen. 2014. “Do Honest Hairdressers Get a Haircut?” Proceedings. Annual Conference on Taxation and Minutes of the Annual Meeting of the National Tax Association 107: 1–32.

Hofmann, Eva et al. 2017. “Authorities’ Coercive and Legitimate Power: The Impact on Cognitions Underlying Cooperation.” Frontiers in Psychology 8. http://journal.frontiersin.org/article/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00005/full (October 6, 2022).

Holz, Justin E. et al. 2023. “The $100 Million Nudge: Increasing Tax Compliance of Firms Using a Natural Field Experiment.” Journal of Public Economics 218: 104779.

Iyer, Govind S., Philip M. J. Reckers, and Debra L. Sanders. 2010. “Increasing Tax Compliance in Washington State: A Field Experiment.” National Tax Journal 63(1): 7–32.

Jamison, Julian C., Nina Mazar, and Iman Sen. 2021. “Applying Behavioral Insights to Tax Compliance: Experimental Evidence from Latvia.” Journal of Tax Administration 6(2). http://jota.website/index.php/JoTA/article/view/271 (January 26, 2022).

John, Peter, and Toby Blume. 2018. “How Best to Nudge Taxpayers? The Impact of Message Simplification and Descriptive Social Norms on Payment Rates in a Central London Local Authority.” Journal of Behavioral Public Administration 1(1). http://www.journal-bpa.org/index.php/jbpa/article/view/10 (March 6, 2018).

Kahneman, Daniel, and Amos Tversky. 1979. “Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk.” Econometrica 47(2): 263–91.

Kamleitner, Bernadette, Christian Korunka, and Erich Kirchler. 2012. “Tax Compliance of Small Business Owners: A Review.” International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research 18(3): 330–51.

Kirchler, Erich, Christoph Kogler, and Stephan Muehlbacher. 2014. “Cooperative Tax Compliance: From Deterrence to Deference.” Current Directions in Psychological Science 23(2): 87–92.

Kleven, Henrik Jacobsen, Claus Thustrup Kreiner, and Emmanuel Saez. 2016. “Why Can Modern Governments Tax So Much? An Agency Model of Firms as Fiscal Intermediaries.” Economica 83(330): 219–46.

Kucher, Marcel, and Lorenz Götte. 1998. “Trust Me. An Empirical Analysis of Taxpayer Honesty.” FinanzArchiv / Public Finance Analysis 55(3): 429–44.

Kumler, Todd, Eric Verhoogen, and Judith Frías. 2020. “Enlisting Employees in Improving Payroll Tax Compliance: Evidence from Mexico.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 102(5): 881–96.

Mas’ud, Abdulsalam, Nor Aziah Abd Manaf, and Natrah Saad. 2019. “Trust and Power as Predictors to Tax Compliance: Global Evidence.” Economics & Sociology 12(2): 192–204.

Mendoza, Juan P., Jacco L. Wielhouwer, and Erich Kirchler. 2017. “The Backfiring Effect of Auditing on Tax Compliance.” Journal of Economic Psychology 62: 284–94.

Mortenson, Jacob A., and Andrew Whitten. 2020. “Bunching to Maximize Tax Credits: Evidence from Kinks in the US Tax Schedule.” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 12(3): 402–32.

Murphy, Kristina. 2008. “Enforcing Tax Compliance: To Punish or Persuade?” Economic Analysis and Policy 38(1): 113–35.

Nguyen, Thi Thuy Du’o’ng et al. 2020. “Determinants Influencing Tax Compliance: The Case of Vietnam.” The Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business 7(2): 65–73.

Olsen, Jerome et al. 2018. “Emotions and Tax Compliance among Small Business Owners: An Experimental Survey.” International Review of Law and Economics 56: 42–52.

Perez-Truglia, Ricardo, and Ugo Troiano. 2018. “Shaming Tax Delinquents.” Journal of Public Economics 167: 120–37.

Piore, Michael J. 2006. “Qualitative Research: Does It Fit in Economics?” European Management Review 3(1): 17–23.

Pomeranz, Dina. 2015. “No Taxation without Information: Deterrence and Self-Enforcement in the Value Added Tax.” The American Economic Review 105(8): 2539–69.

Privitera, Alessandra, Janina Enachescu, Erich Kirchler, and Andre Julian Hartmann. 2021. “Emotions in Tax Related Situations Shape Compliance Intentions: A Comparison between Austria and Italy.” Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics 92: 101698.

Robinson, Scott E., James W. Stoutenborough, and Arnold Vedlitz. 2017. “Assessing Public Support for Government Policy: Comparing Experimental and Attitudinal Approaches.” In Experiments in Public Management Research, eds. Oliver James, Sebastian R. Jilke, and Gregg G. Van Ryzin. Cambridge University Press, 376–93. https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/9781316676912%23CN-bp-18/type/book_part (November 9, 2022).

Roll, Stephen P., Blair D. Russell, Dana C. Perantie, and Michal Grinstein‐Weiss. 2019. “Encouraging Tax-Time Savings with a Low-Touch, Large-Scale Intervention: Evidence from the Refund to Savings Experiment.” Journal of Consumer Affairs 53(1): 87–125.

Saulītis, Andris. 2016. “Komunikatīvā Atmiņa, Vēsturiskā Iztēle: Raidījuma ‘Labvakar’ Vēstules Un Atmoda.” In Atmiņu Kopienas: Atceres Un Aizmiršanas Kultūra Latvijā, eds. Mārtiņš Kaprāns, Gustavs Strenga, and Norberts Bekmans-Dīrkess. Rīga: Zelta Grauds, 173–98.

Silverman, Henry I. 2011. “Qualitative Analysis In Financial Studies: Employing Ethnographic Content Analysis.” Journal of Business & Economics Research (JBER) 7(5). https://clutejournals.com/index.php/JBER/article/view/2300 (February 9, 2023).

Slemrod, Joel. 2003. “Trust in Public Finance.” In Public Finance and Public Policy in the New Century, eds. Sijbren Cnossen and Hans-Werner Sinn. MIT Press, 49–88.

———. 2019. “Tax Compliance and Enforcement.” Journal of Economic Literature 57(4): 904–54.

Slemrod, Joel, Marsha Blumenthal, and Charles Christian. 2001. “Taxpayer Response to an Increased Probability of Audit: Evidence from a Controlled Experiment in Minnesota.” Journal of Public Economics 79(3): 455–83.

Smith, Robin. 2020. “Contesting the Social Contract: Tax Reform and Economic Governance in Istria, Croatia.” Social Analysis 64(2): 79–100.

Stoler, Ann Laura. 2009. Along the Archival Grain: Epistemic Anxieties and Colonial Common Sense. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Storr, Virgil Henry, and Arielle John. 2018. “Why Use Qualitative Methods to Study Culture in Economic Life?” In Research in Experimental Economics, eds. Anna Gunnthorsdottir and Douglas A. Norton. Emerald Publishing Limited, 25–51. https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/S0193-230620180000020002/full/html (February 9, 2023).

Thaler, Richard H., and Cass R. Sunstein. 2008. Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Uslaner, Eric M. 2010. “Tax Evasion, Corruption, and the Social Contract in Transition.” In Developing Alternative Frameworks for Explaining Tax Compliance, eds. James Alm, Jorge Martinez-Vazquez, and Benno Torgler. London: Routledge, 174–90.

Vainre, Maris et al. 2020. “Nudging towards Tax Compliance: A Fieldwork-Informed Randomised Controlled Trial.” Journal of Behavioral Public Administration 3(1). https://www.journal-bpa.org/index.php/jbpa/article/view/84 (June 2, 2020).

Verdery, Katherine. 2018. My Life as a Spy: Investigations in a Secret Police File. Durham: Duke University Press.

Zeitlyn, David. 2012. “Anthropology in and of the Archives: Possible Futures and Contingent Pasts. Archives as Anthropological Surrogates.” Annual Review of Anthropology 41(1): 461–80.