“Safe” Annuity Retirement Products and a Possible US Retirement Crisis

Lambert, Thomas and Tobe, Christopher (2024): “Safe” Annuity Retirement Products and a Possible US Retirement Crisis.

Abstract

This paper examines a looming possible crisis in many Americans’ retirement plans due to the proliferation of annuity products in their retirement investment portfolios. As defined benefit pension plans have almost completely disappeared as a means of retirement savings and have been replaced by defined contribution retirement plans over the last 40 to 50 years, a great number of private and public sector defined contribution retirement plans have become laden with insurance contracts called annuities. Of the remaining solid defined benefit plans many, through a process called Pension Risk Transfer are being converted to high-risk single entity annuities. Such products have been sold to employers and employees as “safe” and “guaranteed’ financial instruments that that are just as good as a defined retirement benefit plan backed by Federal PBGC (Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation) insurance. The results of the analysis in this paper calls this into question, and with so many of these annuities having ties to investments and loans related to risky assets, the authors find that many annuity products are exposed to systemic risk that could lead to a bust in the pensions of many retirees and soon-to-be retirees. The “Emperor has no Clothes” as the life insurance industry has poured billions of dollars into advertising, lobbying, commissions & trade articles with misinformation on annuities with everyone afraid to call out the obvious fiduciary problems. To invest in annuities one must look the other way at one of most basic investment principals -diversification, i.e., “do not put your eggs in one basket.” Excessive monopolistic profits through secret spread fees have remained hidden with no US Federal regulation or oversight. This paper shows the drawbacks, weaknesses, and pitfalls of annuities as investments for retirement plans as well as the injustices of such plans toward lower income workers.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: annuities, financialization, monopoly capital, pensions, retirement, risky assets, systemic risk.
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B51 - Socialist ; Marxian ; Sraffian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B52 - Institutional ; Evolutionary; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G18 - Government Policy and Regulation; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G22 - Insurance ; Insurance Companies ; Actuarial Studies

References

Applebaum, Eileen. 2023. “Letter to ERISA Advisory Council on Private Equity and Life Insurance and Annuity Companies.” https://cepr.net/letter-to-erisa-advisory-council-on-private-equity-and-life-insurance-and-annuity-companies/ . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Associated Press. 2022. “AIG unit that had big role in 2008 crisis nears official end.” December 14, 2022. https://apnews.com/article/business-delaware-financial-crisis-services-american-international-group-inc-28076a06ed9c2d596f092afc094a8306 . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Bahney, Anna. 2024. “Office vacancy rate hits record high.” CNN.com. January 8, 2024. https://edition.cnn.com/2024/01/08/economy/office-space-vacancies-hit-a-record-high/index.html . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Bailey, Jeffrey V. and Thomas M. Richards. A Primer for Investment Trustees: Understanding Investment Committee Responsibilities, Second Edition. Charlottesville, VA: CFA Institute Research Foundation.

Bernanke, Ben S. 2009. American International Group. Testimony Before the Committee on Financial Services, U.S. House of Representatives, Washington, D.C. March 24, 2009. https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/testimony/bernanke20090324a.htm . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (US). Life Insurance Companies; Pension Entitlements, Excluding Unallocated Insurance Contracts and Individual Annuity Reserves; Liability, Level [BOGZ1FL543150035Q], retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis; https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/BOGZ1FL543150035Q . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

Bond, Casey. 2023. “Retirement 2023: Here’s How Much the Average American Has in Their 401(k).” Yahoo Finance. September 7, 2023. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/retirement-2023-much-average-american-120022301.html . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Clark, Robert L. and Sylvester J. Schieber. 2004. “The Transition to Hybrid Pension Plans in the United States: An Empirical Analysis,” in William G. Gale, John B. Shoven, and Mark J. Warshawsky, editors, Private Pensions and Public Choices. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.

Colliers International. 2017 to 2023. "Quarterly office vacancy rates in the United States from 4th quarter 2017 to 1st quarter 2023." Chart. June 2, 2023. Statista. Accessed February 01, 2024. https://www-statista-com.echo.louisville.edu/statistics/194054/us-office-vacancy-rate-forecasts-from-2010/ .

Cortes, Fabio, Mohamed Diaby, and Peter Windsor. 2023. Private Equity and Life Insurers, Global Financial Stability Notes No 2023/001, Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund. December 19, 2023.

Cumbo, Josephine. 2015. “Most Pensioners Reject Annuity Sales.” Financial Times. June 22, 2015. https://www.ft.com/content/dd9dd792-18cf-11e5-8201-cbdb03d71480 . Accessed on March 16, 2024.

Donnelly, Catherine, Montserrat Guillen, and Jens Perch Nielsen. 2014. “Bringing cost transparency to the life annuity market.” Insurance: Mathematics and Economics, 56(May 2014): 14-27. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0167668714000201?via%3Dihub . Accessed on March 16, 2024.

Duesenberry, James S. 1949. Income, Saving and the Theory of Consumer Behavior. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.

Fabozzi, Frank J. (Editor). 1998. The Handbook of Stable Value Investments. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Publishing.

Ferreiro, Jesus and Felipe Serrano. 2011. “Uncertainty and Pension Systems Reforms,” Journal of Economic Issues, 45:2, 317-322, DOI: 10.2753/JEI0021-3624450208 .

Foley-Fisher, Nathan and Heinrich, Nathan and Verani, Stephane. 2023. “Are US Life Insurers the New Shadow Banks?” (April 20, 2023). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3534847 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3534847 .

Friedman, Milton. 1957. A Theory of Consumption Function. Princeton University Press. ISBN 0-691-04182-2.

Ghilarducci, Teresa. 2006. “The End of Retirement,” Monthly Review, Vol. 58, No. 1. May 1, 2006. https://monthlyreview.org/2006/05/01/the-end-of-retirement/ .

Ghilarducci, Teresa. 2024. “No, I Don’t Hate 401(k)s — I Want Pensions For All, Not Just A Few.” Forbes, March 7, 2024. https://www.forbes.com/sites/teresaghilarducci/2024/03/07/no-i-dont-hate-401ks---i-want-pensions-for-all-not-just-a-few/?sh=517cb63e6016#open-web-0 . Accessed on March 11, 2024.

Kirti, Divya and Sarin, Natasha. 2020. “What Private Equity Does Differently: Evidence from Life Insurance.” (February 14, 2020). U of Penn, Inst for Law & Econ Research Paper No. 20-17, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3538443 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3538443 . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Kress, Jeremy. 2018. “The Last SIFI: the Unwise and Illegal Deregulation of Prudential Financial,” Stanford Law Review, 71. https://www.stanfordlawreview.org/online/the-last-sifi-the-unwise-and-illegal-deregulation-of-prudential-financial/ . Accessed on March 11, 2024.

Larkspur-RIXTREMA. Database. https://larkspurweb.com/ . Accessed on March 11, 2024.

Liberto, Daniel. 2023. “Systemically Important Financial Institution (SIFI) Overview,” Investopedia, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/systemically-important-financial-institution-sifi.asp . Accessed on March 11, 2024.

Mackenzie, George A. Annuity Markets and Pension Reform, Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press, 2006.

Manganaro, John. 2021. “Settlement Details Published in Norton Healthcare ERISA Suit.” Plansponsor. https://www.plansponsor.com/settlement-details-published-norton-healthcare-erisa-suit/ . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

Mason, Roger. 2000. “The Social Significance of Consumption: James Duesenberry’s Contribution to Consumer Theory,” Journal of Economic Issues, 34:3, 553-572, DOI: 10.1080/00213624.2000.11506294 .

Markowitz, Harry M. 1952. "Portfolio Selection". The Journal of Finance. 7 (1): 77–91. March 1952. doi:10.2307/2975974 . JSTOR 2975974 .

Morgenson, Gretchen. 2020. “As insurance companies take over pension plans, are your payments at risk?” NBC News. June 14, 2020. https://www.nbcnews.com/business/personal-finance/insurance-companies-take-over-pension-plans-are-your-payments-risk-n1229226 . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Morgenson, Gretchen and Joshua Rosner. 2023. These Are the Plunderers : How Private Equity Runs--And Wrecks--America. New York NY: Simon & Schuster.

National Association of Government Defined Contribution Administrators. 2010. 2010 Issue Brochure – What Plan Sponsors Should Know About Stable Value Funds (SVF) www.nagdca.org/documents/StableValueFunds.pdf

Perez, Andrew. 2016. “Wall Street Firms Managing Pension Money Spend Millions To Support Governors, Despite Pay-To-Play Rule.” MapLight News. October 24, 2016. https://maplightarchive.org/story/wall-street-firms-managing-pension-money-spend-millions-to-support-governors-despite-pay-to-play-rule/ . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Poterba, James, Rauh, Joshua, Venti, Steven and Wise, David. 2007. "Defined contribution plans, defined benefit plans, and the accumulation of retirement wealth," Journal of Public Economics, Elsevier, vol. 91(10), pages 2062-2086, November.

ProQuest. 2019. Individual Retirement Account assets held in life insurance companies in the United States from 2000 to 2018 (in billion U.S. dollars). Statista. Statista Inc.. https://www-statista-com.echo.louisville.edu/statistics/187864/ira-life-insurance-company-assets-in-the-us-since-2000/ . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

Reckenthaler, John. 2022. “What Belongs in 401(k) Plans? Setting reasonable limits.” Morningstar News. https://www.morningstar.com/articles/1090732/what-belongs-in-401k-plans . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Secunda, Paul M. and Brendan S. Maher. 2016. “Pension De-risking,” Washington University Law Review, 93(3): (2016), available at https://openscholarship.wustl.edu/law_lawreview/vol193/iss3/7.

Shames, Mitch. 2022. “Annuities: The straw that breaks the back of retirement plan fiduciaries,” Benefits Pro. May 3, 2022. https://www.benefitspro.com/2022/05/03/annuities-the-straw-that-breaks-the-back-of-retirement-plan-fiduciaries/?slreturn=20240312164319 . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Siedle, Edward. 2011. “SEC Snoozed As ‘Shadow Marketers’ Skimmed Billions From Retirement Plans.” Forbes. February 3, 2011. https://www.forbes.com/sites/edwardsiedle/2011/02/03/sec-snoozed-as-shadow-marketers-skimmed-billions-from-retirement-plans/?sh=f05f1f220c21 . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

Siedle, Edward. 2023. “NEA Rakes In Millions Selling Annuities To Teachers.” Pension Warriors by Edward Siedle. November 2, 2023. https://pensionwarriorsdwardsiedle.substack.com/p/nea-rakes-in-millions-selling-annuities . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

Stafford, Frank P. 1974. "Permanent income, wealth, and consumption: A critique of the permanent income theory, the life cycle hypothesis, and related theories". Econometrics. Berkeley: University of California Press. 2 (2): 195–196. doi:10.1016/0304-4076(74)90040-2. hdl:2027.42/22322. ISSN 0304-4076 – via Elsevier Science Direct.

Steyer, Robert. 2024. “Columbus Regional Health settles 403(b) lawsuit for $2 million.” Pensions & Investments. February 2, 2024. https://www.pionline.com/courts/columbus-regional-health-settles-403b-lawsuit-2-million . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

Thaler, Richard H. 1990. “Anomalies: Savings, Fungibility, and Mental Accounts,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 4(1): 193-205.

Tobe, Christopher B. 2004. “The Consultants Guide to Stable Value.” Journal of Investment Consulting, 7(1), Summer 2004, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=577603 . Accessed on March 12, 2024.

Tobe, Christopher B. 2015. Consultants & Plan Sponsor's Guide to Stable Value. CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform (August 26, 2015).

Tobe, Christopher B. 2022. “Annuities Are a Fiduciary Breach,” The Commonsense 401k Project Blog, https://commonsense401kproject.com/2022/05/11/annuities-are-a-fiduciary-breach/ . Accessed on March 11, 2024.

Tobe, Christoper B. 2023. “Annuity Junk Fees in Current 401(k) Plans.” The Commonsense 401k Project Blog. https://commonsense401kproject.com/2023/11/05/annuity-junk-fees-in-current-401k-plans/ . Accessed on March 11, 2024.

Todd, Richard M. and Neil Wallace. 1992. “SPDAs and GICs: Like Money in the Bank?” Quarterly Review, 16(3): 2-17 Summer 1992.. Minneapolis, MN: Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis.

Tracer, Zachary. 2013. “Prudential Says Annuity Fees Would Make Bankers Dance.” Bloomberg. March 6, 2013. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2013-03-06/prudential-says-annuity-fees-would-make-bankers-dance . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

US Department of Labor. 2023. Department of Labor Employee Benefits Security Administration, Interpretive Bulletin 95-1. Consultation Paper – ERISA Advisory Council. https://www.dol.gov/sites/dolgov/files/ebsa/about-ebsa/about-us/erisa-advisory-council/eac-consultation-paper07142023-r.pdf . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

US Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Department of Labor, The Economics Daily, Retirement plans for workers in private industry and state and local government in 2022 at https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2023/retirement-plans-for-workers-in-private-industry-and-state-and-local-government-in-2022.htm (visited February 27, 2024).

US Government Accountability Office (GAO). 2021. 401(k) Retirement Plans: Many Participants Do Not Understand Fee Information, but DOL Could Take Additional Steps to Help Them. GAO-21-357. Published: Jul 27, 2021. Publicly Released: Aug 26, 2021. https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-21-357 . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

US Security and Exchange Commission, Office of Investor Education and Accountability. No Date. “How Fees and Expenses Affect Your Investment Portfolio.” https://www.sec.gov/investor/alerts/ib_fees_expenses.pdf . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

Watkins, James. 2022. “At What Cost?: Annuities, Cryptocurrency, and Fiduciary Law” The Prudent Investment Fiduciary Rules. Posted on May 9, 2022. https://fiduciaryinvestsense.com/2022/05/09/at-what-cost-annuities-cryptocurrency-and-fiduciary-law/ . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

Weinberg, Neil. 2007. “Payola Disclosure.” Forbes. July 10, 2007. https://www.forbes.com/2007/07/10/funds-nationwide-naco-biz-cz_nw_0710funds.html?sh=19ddd6e735cc . Accessed on March 13, 2024.

Zajac, Andrew and Ian Katz. 2015. “U.S. Asks Judge to Throw Out MetLife ‘Too Big to Fail’ Suit,” Bloomberg.com, May 8, 2015. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-05-08/u-s-asks-judge-to-throw-out-metlife-s-too-big-to-fail-lawsuit .

Zalewski, David A. 2002. Retirement Insecurity in the Age of Money-Manager Capitalism, Journal of Economic Issues, 36:2, 349-356, DOI: 10.1080/00213624.2002.11506477 .