Diversity in Teams: Collaboration and Performance in Experiments with Different Tasks

Darova, Ornella and Duchene, Anne (2024): Diversity in Teams: Collaboration and Performance in Experiments with Different Tasks.

Abstract

We run two field experiments on team diversity in a large undergraduate economics class. Small groups with random compositions are generated and assigned team tasks. In the first experiment, tasks are creative and complex, while in the second one they are more standard. We use a multidimensional measure of diversity based on gender, race, and migration status. We estimate its impact on teamwork quality and group performance. We find a significant U-shaped effect on teamwork quality in both experiments. However, the impact on performance depends on the type of task: it is positive for creative tasks, but negative for standard ones. We interpret these results as the consequence of two conflicting forces: diversity is a source of creativity, but it can hamper communication and coordination between team members. When tasks are creative, the first (positive) force dominates; for standard tasks, instead, communication challenges do. The U-shaped impact on teamwork quality suggests that faultlines – dividing lines that split a group into subgroups based on demographic characteristics – can cause inter-subgroup cohesion to break down, while very homogeneous or very heterogeneous groups collaborate better. These results allow us to build a comprehensive framework to better understand the impact of diversity on teamwork.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Diversity, Knowledge Production, Creativity, Teamwork, Education
• Subjects: A - General Economics and Teaching > A2 - Economic Education and Teaching of Economics > A22 - Undergraduate; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I21 - Analysis of Education; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J15 - Economics of Minorities, Races, Indigenous Peoples, and Immigrants ; Non-labor Discrimination

References

Akerlof, G. A. (1997). “Social Distance and Social Decisions”. In: Econometrica 65.5, pp. 1005–1027.

Alesina, A., A. Devleeschauwer, et al. (2003). “Fractionalization”. In: Journal of Economic Growth 8.2, pp. 155–94.

Alesina, A. and E. La Ferrara (2005). “Ethnic Diversity and Economic Performance”. In: Journal of Economic Literature 43.3, pp. 762–800.

Borghans, L. et al. (2008). “The Economics and Psychology of Personality Traits”. In: Journal of Human Resources 43.4, pp. 972–1059.

Borjas, G. J. (2003). “The Labor Demand Curve Is Downward Sloping: Reexamining the Impact of Immigration on the Labor Market”. In: The Quarterly Journal of Economics 118.4, pp. 1335–1374.

Brixy, U., S. Brunow, and A. D’Ambrosio (2020). “The unlikely encounter: Is ethnic diversity in start-ups associated with innovation?” In: Research Policy 49.4. Burns, J. (2006). “Racial stereotypes, stigma and trust in post-apartheid South Africa”. In: Economic Modelling 23.5, pp. 805–821.

Burns, J. (2012). “Race, diversity and pro-social behavior in a segmented society”. In: Journal of Economic Behavior Organization 81.2, pp. 366–378.

Carton, A. M. and J. N. Cummings (2013). “The impact of subgroup type and subgroup configurational properties on work team performance.” In: The Journal of applied psychology 98.5, pp. 732–58.

Chiu, Y.-T. and D. S. Staples (2013). “Reducing Faultlines in Geographically Dispersed Teams: Self-Disclosure and Task Elaboration”. In: Small Group Research 44.5, pp. 498–531.

Coleman, J. S. (1958). “Relational Analysis: The Study of Social Organizations with Survey Methods”. In: Human Organization 17.4, pp. 28–36.

Cross, R. et al. (2021). “Collaboration overload is sinking productivity”. In: Harvard Business Review.

Currarini, S., M. O. Jackson, and P. Pin (2009). “An Economic Model of Friendship: Homophily, Minorities, and Segregation”. In: Econometrica 77.4, pp. 1003–1045.

Daan Van Knippenberg Caarsten K.W. De Dreu, A. C. H. (2004). “Work group diversity and group performance: An integrative model and research agenda”. In: Journal of Applied Psychology 89, pp. 1008–1022.

Deming, D. J. (2017). “The growing importance of social skills in the labor market”. In: Quarterly Journal of Economics 132.4, pp. 1593–1640.

Dinesen, P. T., M. Schaeffer, and K. M. Sønderskov (2020). “Ethnic Diversity and Social Trust: A Narrative and Meta-Analytical Review”. In: Annual Review of Political Science 23.1, pp. 441–465.

Easterly, W. and R. Levine (1997). “Africa’s Growth Tragedy: Policies and Ethnic Divisions”. In: The Quarterly Journal of Economics 112.4, pp. 1203–1250.

Eckel, C. C. and P. J. Grossman (2005). “Managing diversity by creating team identity”. In: Journal of Economic Behavior Organization 58.3, pp. 371–392.

Fearon, J. D. (2003). “Ethnic and Cultural Diversity by Country”. In: Journal of Economic Growth. 8.2, pp. 195–222.

Ferrucci, E. and F. Lissoni (2019). “Foreign inventors in Europe and the United States: Diversity and. Patent Quality”. In: Research Policy 48.9.

Fershtman, C. and U. Gneezy (2001). “Discrimination in a Segmented Society: An Experimental Approach”. In: The Quarterly Journal of Economics 116.1, pp. 351–377.

Finseraas, H. et al. (2019). “Trust, ethnic diversity, and personal contact: A field experiment”. In: Journal of Public Economics 173, pp. 72–84.

Foged, M. and G. Peri (2016). “Immigrants’ Effect on Native Workers: New Analysis on Longitudinal Data”. In: American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 8.2, pp. 1–34.

Freeman, R. and W. Huang (2015). “Collaborating with people like me: Ethnic coauthorship within the United States”. In: Journal of Labor Economics 33.1, pp. 289–318.

Garicano, L. and E. Rossi-Hansberg (2006). “Organization and inequality in a knowledge economy”. In: Quarterly Journal of Economics 121.4, pp. 1383–1435.

Gilovich, T. et al. (2013). Social Psychology. 3rd. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.

Gower, J. C. (1971). “A General Coefficient of Similarity and Some of Its Properties”. In: Biometrics 27.4, pp. 857–871.

Guillaume, Y. R. F. et al. (2017). “Harnessing demographic differences in organizations: What moderates the effects of workplace diversity?” In: Journal of Organizational Behavior 38, pp. 276–303.

Hamilton, B. H., J. A. Nickerson, and H. Owan (2012). “Diversity and Productivity in Production Teams”. In: Advances in the Economic Analysis of Participatory and Labor-Managed Firms. Vol. 13. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, pp. 99–138.

Hjort, J. (2014). “Ethnic Divisions and Production in Firms”. In: The Quarterly Journal of Economics 129, pp. 1899–1946.

Hoogendoorn, S., H. Oosterbeek, and M. Van Praag (2012). “Ethnic Diversity and Team Performance: A Randomized Field Experiment”. In: Academy of Management Proceedings 2012.1.

Horwitz, I. and S. Horwitz (2007). “The Effects of Team Diversity on Team Outcomes: A Meta-Analytic Review of Team Demography”. In: Journal of Management 33.6, pp. 987–1015.

Hunt, J. and M. Gauthier-Loiselle (2010). “How Much Does Immigration Boost Innovation?” In: American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics 2.2, pp. 31–56.

Jackson, S. E. and A. Joshi (2004). “Diversity in social context: a multi-attribute, multilevel analysis of team diversity and sales performance”. In: Journal of Organizational Behavior 25, pp. 675–702.

Johnson, D., R. Johnson, and K. Smith (2007). “The state of cooperative learning in postsecondary and professional settings”. In: Educational Psychology Review, 19.1, pp. 15–29.

Kahane, L., N. Longley, and R. Simmons (2013). “The Effects of Coworker Heterogeneity on Firm-Level Output: Assessing the Impacts of Cultural and Language Diversity in the National Hockey League”. In: The Review of Economics and Statistics 95.1, pp. 302–314.

Lacerenza, C. et al. (2018). “Team development interventions: Evidence-based approaches for improving teamwork”. In: American Psychologist 73.4, pp. 517–531.

Lau, D. C. and J. K. Murnighan (1998). “Demographic Diversity and Faultlines: The Compositional Dynamics of Organizational Groups”. In: The Academy of Management Review 23.2, pp. 325–340.

Leonard, J. and D. Levine (2006). “The Effect of Diversity on Turnover: A Large Case Study”. In: ILR Review 59.4, pp. 547–572.

Lyons, E. (2017). “Team Production in International Labor Markets: Experimental Evidence from the Field”. In: American Economic Journal: Applied Economics 9.3, pp. 70–104.

Marx, B., V. Pons, and T. Suri (2021). “Diversity and team performance in a Kenyan organization”. In: Journal of Public Economics 197.

Mathieu, J. E. et al. (2014). “A Review and Integration of Team Composition Models: Moving Toward a Dynamic and Temporal Framework”. In: Journal of Management 40.1, pp. 130–160.

Mello, A. S. and M. E. Ruckes (2006). “Team Composition”. In: The Journal of Business 79.3, pp. 1019–1039.

Montalvo, J. G. and M. Reynal-Querol (2005). “Ethnic Polarization, Potential Conflict, and Civil Wars”. In: American Economic Review 95.3, pp. 796–816.

Morgan, J. and F. V´ardy (2009). “Diversity in the Workplace”. In: American Economic Review 99.1, pp. 472–85.

Moser, P., A. Voena, and F. Waldinger (2014). “German Jewish ´Emigr´es and US Invention”. In: American Economic Review 104.10, pp. 3222–55.

Østergaard, C. R., B. Timmermans, and K. Kristinsson (2011). “Does a different view create something new? The effect of employee diversity on innovation”. In: Research Policy 40.3, pp. 500–509.

Ozgen, C., P. Nijkamp, and J. Poot (2012). “Immigration and innovation in European regions”. In: Migration Impact Assessment. Edward Elgar Publishing. Chap. 8, pp. 261–298.

Ozgen, C., P. Nijkamp, and J. Poot (2013). “The impact of cultural diversity on firm innovation: evidence from Dutch micro-data”. In: IZA Journal of Migration 2.18.

Parrotta, P., D. Pozzoli, and M. Pytlikova (2014). “Labor diversity and firm productivity”. In: European Economic Review 66.C, pp. 144–179.

Prat, A. (2002). “Should a team be homogeneous?” In: European Economic Review 46.7, pp. 1187–1207.

Richard, O. C. and R. M. Shelor (2002). “Linking top management team age heterogeneity to firm performance: juxtaposing two mid-range theories”. In: The International Journal of Human Resource Management 13.6, pp. 958–974.

Shannon, C. E. (1948). “A mathematical theory of communication”. In: The Bell System Technical Journal 27.3, pp. 379–423.

Simsarian Webber, S. and L. M. Donahue (2001). “Impact of highly and less job-related diversity on work group cohesion and performance: A meta-analysis”. In: Journal of Management 27, pp. 141–162.

Springer, L., M. E. Stanne, and S. S. Donovan (1999. “Effects of Small-Group Learning on Undergraduates in Science, Mathematics, Engineering, and Technology: A Meta-Analysis”. In: Review of Educational Research 69.1, pp. 21–51.

Vogel, R. et al. (2014). “Funding decisions and entrepreneurial team diversity: A field study”. In: Journal of Economic Behavior Organization 107. Empirical Behavioral Finance, pp. 595–613.

Wegge, J. et al. (2008). “Age and gender diversity as determinants of performance and health in a public organization: The role of task complexity and group size”. In: Journal of Applied Psychology 93.6, pp. 1301–1313.

Williams, K. Y. and C. A. O’Reilly (1998). “Demography and diversity in organizations: A review of 40 years of research”. In: Research in Organizational Behavior 20, pp. 77–140.

Wuchty, S., B. F. Jones, and B. Uzzi (2007). “The Increasing Dominance of Teams in Production of Knowledge”. In: Science 316.5827, pp. 1036–1039.