Least Present Value of Net Revenue: a new auction-mechanism for highway concessions

de Rus, Gines and Nombela, Gustavo (2000): Least Present Value of Net Revenue: a new auction-mechanism for highway concessions.

Abstract

This paper presents a new mechanism for awarding tolled-highways, based on the variable-term concept proposed by Engel et al (1997). These authors claim that a mechanism based on bids for least-present-value of revenue (LPVR) eliminates the risk of demand and simplifies renegotiations. However, if maintenance and operation costs are non-negligible, it is proven that, under LPVR, bidders need to estimate future traffic to make their offers, so the risk of demand is still present. Moreover, LPVR does not guarantee the selection of the best concessionaire. An alternative mechanism (least-present-value of net revenue, LPVNR) is proposed. The idea is to use bids that do not force firms to estimate future traffic. Under LPVNR, firms must make offers on: (i) total amount of revenue, net of maintenance costs; (ii) annual operation and routine-maintenance costs; and (iii) cost of road re-pavement. The concession is awarded to the firm with the lowest total expected cost, and the selection rule is adapted to the information available. The new mechanism is simple, does not impose additional efforts from firms, and eliminates the risk of demand more effectively. Although initially conceived for the road sector, the idea of LPVNR could easily be extended to other infrastructure sectors.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Highways, roads, concessions, auctions
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D4 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design > D44 - Auctions; L - Industrial Organization > L9 - Industry Studies: Transportation and Utilities > L91 - Transportation: General

References

Atkinson, K.(ed) (1990): Highway Maintenance Handbook, Thomas Telford, London.

Engel, E.; R. Fischer and A. Galetovic (1997): ‘Highway Franchising: Pitfalls and Opportunities’, American Economic Review, 87 (2), 68-72.

Fishbein, G. and S. Babbar (1996): ‘Private Financing of Toll Roads’, RMC Discussion Paper Series, 117, World Bank, Washington.

French Highway Directorate (1997): Analysis of highway concessions in Europe, Report for the Western European Road Directors (WERD), Ministry of Public Works, Transportation and Housing, France.

Gomez-Ibañez, J.A. and M.M. O’Keeffe (1986): The benefits from improved investment rules: a case study of the interstate highway system, US Department of Transportation, University Research Program, Washington DC.

______ (1997): ‘Mexico’s Private Toll Road Program’, mimeo, Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, Case Study C15-97-1402.0.

Gómez-Lobo, A. and S. Hinojosa (2000): ‘Broad Roads in a Thin Country: Infrastructure Concessions in Chile’, Policy Research Working Paper 2279, World Bank, Washington.

Guasch, J.L. (2000): ‘Impact of Concessions’ Design in Sector Performance: An Empirical Analysis of Ten Years of Performance’, mimeo, World Bank, Washington.

Louzan, A.; J.Arraiza, J.A. Martínez and A. Casado (1998): Conservación y explotación de la red de autopistas de peaje, Convención COEX, Ministry of Public Works, Spain.

McAfee, R. and J. McMillan (1987): ‘Auctions and Bidding’, Journal of Economic Literature, 25, 699-738.

Milgrom, P. (1989): ‘Auctions and Bidding: A Primer’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 3, 3-22.

NatWest (1997): Spanish and Portuguese motorways: Stand and Deliver, NatWest Securities Limited, London.

Paterson, W. (1987): Road Deterioration and Maintenance Effects: Models for Planning and Management, Johns Hopkins Univ. Press, Baltimore.

Ramaswamy, R. and M. Ben-Akiva (1990): ‘Estimation of Highway Pavement Deterioration from In-Service Pavement Data’, Transportation Research Record, 1272, 96-106.

Sayers, M.W.; T.D. Gillespie and W.D.O. Paterson (1986a): ‘Guidelines for Conducting and Calibrating Road Roughness Measurements’, World Bank Technical Paper 46, Washington.

Sayers, M.W.; T.D. Gillespie and C.A.V. Queiroz (1986b): ‘The International Road Roughness Experiment: Establishing Correlation and a Calibration Standard for Measurements’, World Bank Technical Paper 45, Washington.

Small, K.A.; C. Winston and C.A. Evans (1989): Road Work: A New Highway Pricing and Investment Policy, The Brookings Institution, Washington DC.

Stivers, M.L.; K.L. Smith; T.H. Hoerner, and A.R. Romine (1999): ‘Maintenance QA Program Implementation Manual’,

NCHRP Report 422, Transportation Research Board, National Research Council, Washington DC.

Tirole (1997): ‘Comentario a la propuesta de Engel, Fischer y Galetovic sobre licitación de carreteras’, Estudios Públicos, 65, (Chile), 201-214.