Instilling cooperation in turbulent times: some issues before the 16th Finance Commission

Pethe, Abhay and Karnik, Ajit and Lalvani, Mala and Kelkar, Hemangi (2024): Instilling cooperation in turbulent times: some issues before the 16th Finance Commission.

Abstract

The geopolitical situation globally and in the immediate neighborhood, as well as the domestic fault lines that have been magnified by the recent Indian national elections, provide a context to the paper. As the 16th Finance Commission begins its deliberations, this paper underlines the crucial need, going forward, to instill co-operation between the three tiers of government in the Indian federation. We believe that a rules-based cooperative federalism, explicitly recognized and accepted by all players, will provide an appropriate institutional architecture for tackling many of the problems and challenges that India faces. Carrying out a few computational exercises, we propose that focusing on fiscal space available to state governments would be better than focusing on revenue deficits that has been the case so far, and suggest a few measures of fiscal space too. The instrument of incentives introduced by the various Finance Commissions to elicit co-operation from states and local bodies are critically discussed. We urge the 16th FC to strengthen this aspect. Empowering the third-tier of government, we believe, will give the much needed fillip to co-operative federalism. For this we recommend that the good work done by the earlier FCs be continued, using a quasi-formulaic approach in working out the magnitude of the fund flow. Finally, recognizing the importance of climate change in the future, we suggest a tweak in the treatment of Ecology while designing incentives for state and local governments.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Fiscal federalism, Cooperative federalism, Indian federation, Indian Finance Commissions, Fiscal space, Incentive grants, 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments, Third tier of government, Urbanization
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H72 - State and Local Budget and Expenditures; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession

References

Adeny, K. (2003), Centrifugal and Centripetal Elements of Indian Federalism, in S. Mitra, and B. Rill (eds.) Indien heute: Bennpunkte seiner Innenpolitik, https://www.academia.edu/7504896/Centrifugal_and_Centripetal_Elements_of_Indian_Federalism?auto=download (accessed 19 August 2024)

Agarwal V., J. Felman, T. Reji, A. Subramanian (2024), GST's revenue performance: Centre's sacrifice for cooperative federalism, Business Standard, July 03, 2024 https://www.business-standard.com/economy/news/gst-s-revenue-performance-centre-s-sacrifice-for-cooperative-federalism-124070300006_1.html

Bader, C.K. (2014), A Dynamic Defense of Cooperative Federalism, Whittier Law Review, Vol. 35(2)

Bhaskar, V. (2018), “Challenges before the Fifteenth Finance Commission”, Economic and Political Weekly, 53(10): 39-46

Comptroller and Auditor General of India (2021), Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India on Compliance of the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act, 2003, Chapter 3 of Report No. 6 of 2021, https://cag.gov.in/uploads/media/Report-No-6-of-2021-FRBM-2017-18-064cb70a9d7fc23-77991397.pdf (accessed 19 August 2024)

Development Committee (2006), Fiscal Policy for Growth and Development- An Interim Report. Paper presented at the Development Committee Meeting, Washington D.C., https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/774881468314692549/pdf/406220BRI00BOX1SED0PRMEDKB01PUBLIC1.pdf (accessed 19 August 2024)

Digital Sansad (2023), Rise in the Collection of Cess and Surcharges, Reply to un-starred question no. 4268 by Minister of State in the Ministry of Finance, https://sansad.in/getFile/loksabhaquestions/annex/1711/AU4268.pdf?source=pqals (accessed 19 August 2024)

Finance Commission of India (1995), Report of the Tenth Finance Commission, https://fincomindia.nic.in/commission-reports-tenth (accessed 20 August 2024)

Finance Commission of India (2004), Report of the Twelfth Finance Commission for 2005-10, https://fincomindia.nic.in/commission-reports-twelfth (accessed 20 August 2024)

Finance Commission of India (2009), Report of the Thirteenth Finance Commission for 2010-2015, https://fincomindia.nic.in/commission-reports-thirteenth (accessed 20 August 2024)

Finance Commission of India (2015), Report of the Fifteenth Finance Commission, https://fincomindia.nic.in/commission-reports-fourteenth (accessed 20 August 2024)

Finance Commission of India (2020), Report of the Fifteenth Finance Commission for 2021-26, Annexe 1.1, https://fincomindia.nic.in/commission-reports-fifteenth (accessed 20 August 2024)

Finance Commission of India (undated-a) Commission Reports, https://fincomindia.nic.in/commission-reports (accessed 19 August 2024)

Finance Commission of India (undated-b) Sixteenth Finance Commission of India – Notifications, https://fincomindia.nic.in/notification-and-media (accessed 19 August 2024)

Ganguli, B. and Sinha, B.A.K. (2024), 16th Finance Commission: Towards vertical and horizontal balance, Ideas for India, https://www.ideasforindia.in/topics/money-finance/16th-finance-commission-towards-vertical-and-horizontal-balance.html (accessed 20 August 2024)

Government of India, Ministry of Law and Justice (undated) The Constitution of India 2024 (English Version), https://legislative.gov.in/constitution-of-india/ (accessed 19 August 2024)

Heller, P.S. (2005), Understanding Fiscal Space, IMF Policy Discussion Paper, PDP/05/4

Inman R.P. and D.L. Rubinfeld (1994), "The Political Economy of Federalism", processed, University of California at Berkeley and Pennsylvania University, June 1994.

Inman, R. P., and D. L Rubinfield. (2014), Economics of Federalism, in Francesco Parisi (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Law and Economics: Volume 3: Public Law and Legal Institutions

Karnik, A.V. and M. Lalvani (2005), Urban Local Governments and the Flypaper Effect: Evidence from Maharastra, India. Publius: The Journal of Federalism 35, 273–295.

Karnik A.V. and M. Lalvani (2008), Flypaper Effect Incorporating Spatial Interdependence, Review of Urban and Regional Development Studies, 20(2), pp. 85-176

Kelkar, V. and A. Pethe (2019), Reimagining the NITI Aayog, The Hindu, June 24 2019, https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/reimagining-the-niti-aayog/article62109595.ece (accessed 21 August 2024)

Kelkar, V. and A. Pethe (2024), Wake up government most on India live in her cities, February 26, in Voices, India, Times of India, TOI. Kincaid, J. (1990), From Cooperative to Coercive Federalism, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, Vol. 509, pp. 139-152

Kincaid, J. (2017), The Eclipse of Dual Federalism by One-way Cooperative Federalism, Arizona State Law Journal 49 (3), pp. 1061-1089, https://arizonastatelawjournal.org/2017/11/14/the-eclipse-of-dual-federalism-by-one-way-cooperative-federalism/ (accessed 19 August 2024)

Kincaid, J. (2023), Distribution of powers in federal systems: federalism's heart, in J. Kincaid and J. Leckrone (eds) Teaching Federalism, Edward Elgar Publishing, https://www.elgaronline.com/edcollbook-oa/book/9781800885325/9781800885325.xml (accessed 19 August 2024)

Kose, M.A., Kurlat, S., Ohnsorge, F. and Sugawara, N. (2017), A Cross-Country Database of Fiscal Space, Policy Research Working Paper, World Bank, WPS8157

Lahiri, I. (2022), How census-based delimitation for Lok Sabha seats could shake up politics & disadvantage south, The Print, https://theprint.in/india/governance/how-census-based-delimitation-for-lok-sabha-seats-could-shake-up-politics-disadvantage-south/1287536/ (accessed 21 August 2024)

Lall, S (2009), Reshaping Urban Geography, World Bank Report, World Bank.

Lall, S (2013), Beyond Municipal Boundaries, World Bank Study, World Bank.

Lalvani, M. (2002), The Flypaper Effect: Evidence from India. Public Budgeting and Finance 22, 67–88

Marcel, M. (2013), Budgeting for fiscal space and government performance beyond the great recession, OECD Journal on Budgeting. Volume 2013/2

Ministry of Finance (2023), Notification, The Gazette of India, December 31 2023, https://fincomindia.nic.in/asset/doc/doc20231231295101.pdf (accessed 19 August 2024)

Ministry of Panchyati Raj (2022), Vice President calls for devolving 3 Fs--Funds, Functions and Functionaries to local bodies, https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1815682 (accessed 19 August 2024)

Nerlich, C. and Reuter, W.H. (2015), Fiscal rules, fiscal space and pro-cyclical fiscal policy, ECB Working Paper, No. 1872, ISBN 978-92-899-1685-1, European Central Bank (ECB), Frankfurt a. M.

National Institute of Rural Development & Panchayati Raj (2017-18), Rural Development Statistics (2017-18). Hyderabad: NIRD & PR

Oates W. (1972), Fiscal Federalism, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, New York

Oomen, M.A. (2015), Local Governments in The Fiscal Space of Indian Federalism: Towards More Rational Arrangements, RULSG Occasional Paper 2015 : 2, Research Unit on Local Self Governments, Centre For Development Studies, Thiruvananthapuram, http://14.139.171.199:8080/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/603/RULSG2_MAOommen.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y (accessed 19 August 2024)

Ostry, J.D., A.D. Ghosh, J.I. Kim and M.S. Qureshi (2010), Fiscal Space, IMF Staff Position Paper, SPN/10/11

Park, S.G. (2012), Quantifying Impact of Aging Population on Fiscal Space, IMF Working Paper, WP/12/164

Pethe, A. and M. Lalvani (2008), Finances of Panchayti Raj Institutions: A Simple Story but a Messy Plot, Working Paper 28,

Vibhooti Shukla Unit in Urban Economics, Department of Economics, University of Mumbai; Reprinted as a Chapter in ‘Independent Evaluation of Panchayati Raj in India’ IRMA, Anand. Commissioned by MoPR, GoI.

Pethe A, B. M. Misra and Rakhe P B (2009), Strengthening Decentralization: Augmenting the Consolidated fund of the states by the thirteenth Finance Commission-A Normative Approach, Development Research Group (DRG), Study No-29, Reserve Bank of India.

Pethe, A and M. Lalvani (2022), Critical Importance of Fiscal Federalism, Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) Vol. L V No.11, pages 34-39, March 12

Ramakumar, R. (2024), Are States getting funds they are entitled from the Centre?, The Hindu, February 28, 2024, https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/are-states-getting-funds-they-are-entitled-from-the-centre/article67897234.ece (accessed 19 August 2024)

Reserve Bank of India (various years), State Finances: A Study of Budgets, Reserve Bank of India, Mumbai

Routray, B.P. (2024), Communist Party of India, Encyclopedia Britannica, https://www.britannica.com/topic/Communist-Party-of-India (accessed 21 August 2024)

Roy, R., A. Heuty, and E. Letouzé (2007), Fiscal Space For What? Analytical Issues From A Human Development Perspective, UNDP, Paper For The G-20 Workshop On Fiscal Policy - Istanbul, June 30-July 2, 2007, https://www.undp.org/sites/g/files/zskgke326/files/publications/FiscalSpaceforWhat.pdf (accessed 19 August 2024)

Samuelson, P.A. (1955), The Pure Theory of Public Expenditure, The Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol. 36, No. 4, pp. 387-389

Schick, A. (2009), "Budgeting for fiscal space," OECD Journal on Budgeting, OECD Publishing, vol. 9(2), pages 1-18.

Schik, A. (2010), Post-Crisis Fiscal Rules: Stabilising Public Finance while Responding to Economic Aftershocks, OECD Journal of Banking, Volume 2010/2

Shukla V. (1995), Urbanization and Economic Growth, OUP.

Srinivasan, T.N. and J. Wallack (2004), From Economics to Politico-Economics: Evolution of the Analysis of Federalism, Working Paper no. 220, Stanford Center for International Development, https://kingcenter.stanford.edu/sites/g/files/sbiybj16611/files/media/file/220wp_0.pdf (accessed 19 August 2024)

Sobel R.S. and G.R. Crowley (2014), Do intergovernmental grants create ratchets in state and local taxes? Public Choice, 158, pp. 167–187

Tandel, V., K. Hiranandani, and M. Kapoor (2019), What’s in a definition? A study on suitability of current urban definition in India through its employment guarantee program, Journal of Asian Economics, Elsevier, Vol. 60 C, pages 69-84.

Tiebout, C.M. (1956), A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures, The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 64, No. 5, (Oct., 1956), pp. 416-42

Wyplosz, C. (2020), What’s Wrong with Fiscal Space, CEPR Discussion Paper No. DP14431, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3547364 (accessed 20 August 2024)

Zimmerman J. (2001), National-State Relations: Cooperative Federalism in the Twentieth Century, Publius: The Journal of Federalism, Vol. 31, No. 2, Essays in Memory of Daniel J. Elazar (Spring, 2001), pp. 15-30.