A Meta-Analysis of Attitudes Towards Migrants and Displaced

Weber, Sigrid and Stoop, Nik and Van der Windt, Peter and Zhai, Haoyu (2024): A Meta-Analysis of Attitudes Towards Migrants and Displaced.

Abstract

Since the early 2010s, social scientists have conducted (survey-) experimental studies that explore what factors drive public attitudes towards migrants to understand who provokes backlash and who is welcomed. We conduct a systematic meta-analysis building on 83 studies that experimentally vary migrant characteristics to assess attitudes towards migrants. The study has several findings: a) sociotropic concerns play a key role: individuals are more welcoming towards migrants that contribute to the economy through their professional occupation, education or language skills; this evidence is particularly strong in developed countries compared to developing countries, b) there is no evidence hosts evaluate migrants through the lens of egocentric economic concerns, c) cultural concerns are important; in particular a persistent anti-Muslim bias; d) humanitarian concerns also shape attitudes toward migrants; particularly towards those that are forcefully displaced in contrast to economic migrants.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: migration; displacement; attitudes; survey experiment; conjoint; meta-analysis
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D0 - General; H - Public Economics > H0 - General; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers

References

Adem, Muna and Denise Ambriz. 2023. “What Makes a Citizen? Contemporary Immigration and the Boundaries of Citizenry.” Social Forces 102(2):730–752.

Adida, Claire L, Adeline Lo and Melina R Platas. 2019. “Americans preferred Syrian refugees who are female, English-speaking, and Christian on the eve of Donald Trump’s election.” PloS one 14(10).

Alrababa’h, Ala’, Andrea Dillon, Scott Williamson, Jens Hainmueller, Dominik Hangartner and Jeremy Weinstein. 2021. “Attitudes toward migrants in a highly impacted economy: Evidence from the Syrian refugee crisis in Jordan.” Comparative Political Studies 54(1):33– 76.

Arzheimer, Kai. 2018. “Explaining electoral support for the radical right.” The Oxford handbook of the radical right 1:143–165.

Bakewell, Oliver. 2021. Unsettling the boundaries between forced and voluntary migration. In Handbook on the governance and politics of migration. Edward Elgar Publishing pp. 124– 136.

Bansak, Kirk, Jens Hainmueller and Dominik Hangartner. 2016. “How economic, humanitarian, and religious concerns shape European attitudes toward asylum seekers.” Science 354(6309):217–222.

Bansak, Kirk, Jens Hainmueller and Dominik Hangartner. 2023. “Europeans’ support for refugees of varying background is stable over time.” Nature 620(7975):849–854.

Benesch, Christine, Simon Loretz, David Stadelmann and Tobias Thomas. 2019. “Media coverage and immigration worries: Econometric evidence.” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 160:52–67.

Brooks, Clem, Je! Manza and Emma D Cohen. 2016. “Political ideology and immigrant acceptance.” Socius 2.

Buonfino, Alessandra. 2004. “Between unity and plurality: the politicization and securitization of the discourse of immigration in Europe.” New political science 26(1):23–49.

Cheung, Mike W-L. 2015. Meta-analysis: A structural equation modeling approach. John Wiley & Sons.

Cogley, Nathaniel Terence, John Andrew Doces and Beth Elise Whitaker. 2019. “Which immigrants should be naturalized? Which should be deported? Evidence from a survey experiment in Cˆote d’Ivoire.” Political Research Quarterly 72(3):653–668.

Cools, Sara, Henning Finseraas and Ole Rogeberg. 2021. “Local immigration and support for anti-immigration parties: A meta-analysis.” American Journal of Political Science 65(4):988–1006.

Czymara, Christian S and Alexander W Schmidt-Catran. 2017. “Refugees unwelcome? Changes in the public acceptance of immigrants and refugees in Germany in the course of Europe’s ‘immigration crisis’.” European Sociological Review 33(6):735–751.

Denney, Steven and Christopher Green. 2021. “Who should be admitted? Conjoint analysis of South Korean attitudes toward immigrants.” Ethnicities 21(1):120–145.

Dionne, Kim Yi and Beth Wellman. 2024. “How immigration issues are steering South Africa’s 2024 elections.” https://goodauthority.org/news/ south-africa-immigration-diaspora-2024-elections/. Accessed: 2024-07-08.

Doleman, Brett, Suzanne C Freeman, Jonathan N Lund, John P Williams and Alex J Sutton. 2020. “Funnel plots may show asymmetry in the absence of publication bias with continuous outcomes dependent on baseline risk: presentation of a new publication bias test.” Research Synthesis Methods 11(4):522–534.

Erdal, Marta Bivand and Ceri Oeppen. 2020. Forced to leave? The discursive and analytical significance of describing migration as forced and voluntary. In Aspiration, desire and the drivers of migration. Routledge pp. 73–90.

Erlich, Aaron, Thomas Soehl and Annie Y Chen. 2023. “Discriminatory Immigration Bans Elicit Anti-Americanism in Targeted Communities: Evidence from Nigerian Expatriates.” Journal of Experimental Political Science 10(1):76–87.

Flores, Ren´e D and Ariela Schachter. 2018. “Who are the “illegals”? The social construction of illegality in the United States.” American Sociological Review 83(5):839–868.

Gaikwad, Nikhar and Gareth Nellis. 2017. “The majority-minority divide in attitudes toward internal migration: Evidence from Mumbai.” American Journal of Political Science 61(2):456–472.

Gaikwad, Nikhar and Gareth Nellis. 2021. “Do politicians discriminate against internal migrants? Evidence from nationwide field experiments in India.” American Journal of Political Science 65(4):790–806.

Hainmueller, Jens and Daniel J. Hopkins. 2014. “Public Attitudes Toward Immigration.” Annual Review of Political Science 17(1):225–249.

Hainmueller, Jens and Daniel J Hopkins. 2015. “The hidden American immigration consensus: A conjoint analysis of attitudes toward immigrants.” American Journal of Political Science 59(3):529–548.

Hainmueller, Jens and Michael J Hiscox. 2010. “Attitudes toward highly skilled and lowskilled immigration: Evidence from a survey experiment.” American Political Science Review 104(1):61–84.

Halikiopoulou, Daphne and Tim Vlandas. 2020. “When economic and cultural interests align: the anti-immigration voter coalitions driving far right party success in Europe.” European Political Science Review 12(4):427–448.

Hamlin, Rebecca. 2021. Crossing: How we label and react to people on the move. Stanford University Press.

Hardy, Emily. 2024. “The Role of Migration in a Year of Crucial Elections.” https:// goodauthority.org/news/south-africa-immigration-diaspora-2024-elections/. Accessed: 2024-07-08.

Hartman, Alexandra C and Benjamin S Morse. 2020. “Violence, empathy and altruism: Evidence from the Ivorian refugee crisis in Liberia.” British Journal of Political Science 50(2):731–755.

Hartman, Alexandra C, Benjamin S Morse and Sigrid Weber. 2021. “Violence, Displacement, and Support for Internally Displaced Persons: Evidence from Syria.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 65(10):1791–1819.

Hartman, Todd K, Benjamin J Newman and C Scott Bell. 2014. “Decoding prejudice toward Hispanics: Group cues and public reactions to threatening immigrant behavior.” Political Behavior 36:143–163.

Helbling, Marc. 2020. “Attitudes towards climate change migrants.” Climatic Change 160(1):89–102.

Helbling, Marc and Hanspeter Kriesi. 2014. “Why citizens prefer high-over low-skilled immigrants. Labor market competition, welfare state, and deservingness.” European Sociological Review 30(5):595–614.

Helbling, Marc and Richard Traunmu¨ller. 2020. “What is Islamophobia? Disentangling citizens’ feelings toward ethnicity, religion and religiosity using a survey experiment.” British Journal of Political Science 50(3):811–828.

Hopkins, Daniel J. 2010. “Politicized places: Explaining where and when immigrants provoke local opposition.” American political science review 104(1):40–60.

Igarashi, Akira, Hirofumi Miwa and Yoshikuni Ono. 2022. “Why do citizens prefer highskilled immigrants to low-skilled immigrants? Identifying causal mechanisms of immigration preferences with a survey experiment.” Research & Politics 9(2).

IOM. 2022. “World Migration Report.”. URL: https://publications.iom.int/books/world-migration-report-2022

Jeannet, Anne-Marie. 2018. “Revisiting the labor market competition hypothesis in a comparative perspective: Does retirement a!ect opinion about immigration?” Research & Politics 5(3).

Kage, Rieko, Frances M Rosenbluth and Seiki Tanaka. 2022. “Varieties of Public Attitudes toward Immigration: Evidence from Survey Experiments in Japan.” Political Research Quarterly 75(1):216–230.

Krzyz˙anowski, Micha#l, Anna Triandafyllidou and Ruth Wodak. 2018. “The mediatization and the politicization of the “refugee crisis” in Europe.”.

Kustov, Alexander. 2024. “Politicians on all sides campaign on restricting immigration.” https://goodauthority.org/news/immigration-white-house-restrictions-border-asylum-starmer-labour-uk/. Accessed: 2024-07-08.

Leeper, Thomas J., Sara B. Hobolt and James Tilley. 2020. “Measuring Subgroup Preferences in Conjoint Experiments.” Political Analysis 28(2):207–221.

Lin, Lifeng and Haitao Chu. 2018. “Quantifying publication bias in meta-analysis.” Biometrics 74(3):785–794.

Malhotra, Neil and Benjamin Newman. 2017. “Explaining immigration preferences: Disentangling skill and prevalence.” Research & Politics 4(4).

Margalit, Yotam and Omer Solodoch. 2022. “Against the flow: Di!erentiating between public opposition to the immigration stock and flow.” British Journal of Political Science 52(3):1055–1075.

Mayda, Anna Maria. 2006. “Who Is against Immigration? A Cross-Country Investigation of Individual Attitudes toward Immigrants.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 88(3):510–530.

Naumann, Elias, Lukas F. Stoetzer and Giuseppe Pietrantuono. 2018. “Attitudes towards highly skilled and low-skilled immigration in Europe: A survey experiment in 15 European countries.” European Journal of Political Research 57(4):1009–1030.

Newman, Benjamin J and Neil Malhotra. 2019. “Economic reasoning with a racial hue: is the immigration consensus purely race neutral?” The Journal of Politics 81(1):153–166.

Peisakhin, Leonid, Nik Stoop and Peter Van der Windt. 2024, Forthcoming. “Who Hosts? The Correlates of Hosting the Internally Displaced.”.

Pew Research Center. 2012. “Faith on the Move – The Religious A”liation of International Migrants.”. URL: https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2012/03/08/religious-migration-exec/

Ravn, Rasmus Lind and Thomas Bredgaard. 2021. “Employer preferences towards recruitment of refugees–a Danish vignette study.” Nordic Journal of Migration Research 11(3):301–315.

Rich, Timothy S, Kaitlyn Bison and Aleksandra Kozovic. 2021. “Who is welcome? South Korean public opinion on North Koreans and other refugees.” Japanese Journal of Political Science 22(3):117–129.

Scheve, Kenneth F. and Matthew J. Slaughter. 2001. “Labor Market Competition and Individual Preferences Over Immigration Policy.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 83(1):133–145.

Schwarzer, Guido, James R Carpenter, Gerta Ru¨cker et al. 2015. Meta-analysis with R. Vol. 4784 Springer.

Semyonov, Moshe, Rebeca Raijman, Anastasia Gorodzeisky and Thomas Hinz. 2023. “The impact of immigrants’ characteristics on anti-immigrant sentiment among the Jewish majority and the Arab minority in Israel.” Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies pp. 1–22.

Shaffer, Robert, Lauren E Pinson, Jonathan A Chu and Beth A Simmons. 2020. “Local elected offcials’ receptivity to refugee resettlement in the United States.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117(50):31722–31728.

Shockley, Bethany and Justin J Gengler. 2024. “Sharing citizenship: economic competition, cultural threat, and immigration preferences in the Rentier state.” Political Science Research and Methods 12(1):59–75.

Singer, David A and Kai Quek. 2022. “Public Attitudes toward Internal and Foreign Migration: Evidence from China.” Public Opinion Quarterly 86(1):82–106.

Solodoch, Omer. 2021. “Do sociotropic concerns mask prejudice? Experimental evidence on the sources of public opposition to immigration.” Political Studies 69(4):1009–1032.

Spilker, Gabriele, Quynh Nguyen, Vally Koubi and Tobias B¨ohmelt. 2020. “Attitudes of urban residents towards environmental migration in Kenya and Vietnam.” Nature Climate Change 10(7):622–627.

Tremblay-Boire, Joannie, Aseem Prakash and Maria Apolonia Calderon. 2023. “Delivering public services to the underserved: Nonprofits and the Latino threat narrative.” Public Administration Review 83(1):78–91.

Turper, Sedef, Shanto Iyengar, Kees Aarts and Minna van Gerven. 2015. “Who is less welcome?: The impact of individuating cues on attitudes towards immigrants.” Journal of ethnic and migration studies 41(2):239–259.

UNHCR. 2024. “Global Trends 2023: Forced Displacement in 2023.”.

Viechtbauer, Wolfgang. 2010. “Conducting Meta-Analyses in R with the metafor Package.” Journal of Statistical Software 36:1–48. URL: https://www.jstatsoft.org/index.php/jss/article/view/v036i03