Tax Haven and Development Partner: Incoherence in Dutch Government Policies

Weyzig, Francis and Van Dijk, Michiel (2008): Tax Haven and Development Partner: Incoherence in Dutch Government Policies.

Abstract

This paper focuses on a relatively new issue in the debate on policy coherence for development: the incoherence between tax and aid policies, using a case study of the Netherlands as illustration. Although the Netherlands cannot be considered a ‘pure’ tax haven like the Cayman Islands and the British Virgin Islands, evidence indicates that it does play a key role as ‘conduit’ country in tax planning structures of multinationals that wish to channel funds to ‘pure’ tax havens. This paper shows that as a consequence of the Dutch fiscal regime, other countries, including developing countries, are failing to collect important tax revenues which otherwise could have been used to finance health care, education and other essential public goods and services. It is estimated that developing countries miss about € 640 million in tax revenue – about 15 % of Dutch ODA. This suggests the Dutch tax policy is incoherent with the Dutch policy on development cooperation.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: development policy; tax policy; policy coherence; policy incoherence
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making; F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue

References

Bols, D., D. Frans, D. van den Berghe, and R. van Tulder (2001), Fiscaliteit, Locatieconcurrentie en Eerlijke Belastingafdracht, Position Paper for Ministry of Foreign Affairs (Rotterdam: Erasmus University Rotterdam).

Booijink, L., and F. Weyzig (2007), “Identifying tax havens and offshore finance centres, http://www.taxjustice.net/cms/upload/pdf/Identifying_Tax_Havens_Jul_07.pdf

Braütigam, D., O.H. Fjeldstad, and M. Moore, (2008) Taxation and State-Building in Developing Countries: Capacity and Consent.

De Goede, J.J.P et al. (2004), Tax Systems and Tax Treaties: A study assigned by the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Development Co-operation, IBFD.

Desai, M.A., C.F. Foley, and J.R. Hines Jr. (2003). Chains of Ownership, Regional Tax Competition, and Foreign Direct Investment. In: H. Herrmann and R. Lipsey (Eds.) Foreign Direct Investment in the Real and Financial Sector of Industrial Countries. Springer Verlag, Heidelberg, pp. 61-98.

DNB Statistical Bulletin, various issues

DNB Quarterly Bulletin, various issues.

DNB 2004, “Direct Investment Technical Expert Group: Background paper on Special Purpose Entities,” Background Paper Issues #9 and 11, Prepared by Balance of Payments and Financial Accounts Department, May 2004.

DNB statistics, Table 5.6d, Direct investment abroad (stocks), last updated 12 Oct 2006. ECDPM/Particip GmbH/ICEI, Evaluation Study on The EU Institutions & Member States’ Mechanisms for Promoting Policy Coherence for Development: Final Report, Maastricht, 2007.

European Commission, Commission Staff Working Paper Accompanying the EU Report on Policy Coherence for Development, Commission working paper, Brussels, 2007a COM(2007)545 final.

European Central Bank (2004), “Foreign direct investment task force report”.

European Commission, EU Report on Policy Coherence for Development, Commission working paper, Brussels, 2007b.

Grubert, H. (1998). Taxes and the division of foreign operating income among royalties, interest, dividends and retained earnings. Journal of Public Economics 68, p. 269-90

Grubert, H. (2003). Intangible income, intercompany transactions, income shifting, and the choice of location. National Tax Journal 56, p. 221-42

Herfkens, E., Minister for Development Cooperation, “Monterrey: Harvest the seeds we have sown,” Speech, 28 Jan 2002, <http://www.minbuza.nl/nl/actueel/speeches,2002/01/monterreyx_harvest_the_seeds_we_have_sown.html> (Apr 2007).

Hoebink, P. (2005). Coherence and Development Policy: An autopsy with some European examples, in: ÖFSE: Österreichische Entwicklungspolitik - Analysen, Informationen 2004. EU Entwicklungspolitik - Quo vadis?, Wien, pp. 37-50.

Martens, J. “What if Developing Countries could Finance Poverty Eradication from their own Public Resources?” Global Policy Forum, 2006 <http://www.globalpolicy.org/socecon/ffd/domestic/2006/jensmartens.htm> (May 2007).

McLean Hilker, L., A Comparative Analysis of Institutional Mechanisms to Promote Policy Coherence for Development, paper for OECD policy workshop Institutional Approaches to Policy Coherence for Development, 18-19 May 2004.

Ministry of Foreign Affairs, MDG 8: Progress Report 2006 (OSDR0564/E), Jul 2006 <http://www.minbuza.nl/binaries/en-pdf/mdg-8-rapport-2006-engels.pdf> (Apr 2007).

Ministry of Foreign Affairs, MDG 8: Progress Report by the Netherlands (OSDR0526/E), May 2004 <http://www.undg.org/archive_docs/4532-Netherlands_- _MDG_8___Develop_a_Global_Partnership_for_Development__-_Report.pdf> (Apr 2007).

Mintz, J and A.J. Weichenrieder (2005). Taxation and the Financial Structure of German Outbound FDI. CESifo Working Paper Series No. 1612;

Muller, A., D. Frans, and R. Van Tulder (2004), Assessing the Development Squeeze: The impact of tax incentives, tax evasion and tax avoidance on Less Developed Countries (LDCs) (Rotterdam: SCOPE Expert Centre/Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

Murphy, R., J. Christensen, and K. Kimmis, (2005) ‘Tax Us If You Can’, The Tax Justice Network, London, www.taxjustice.net.

Neumayer, A. (2006). Do double taxation treaties increase foreign direct investment to developing countries? SSRN, <http://ssrn.com/abstract=766064>.

Noseweek (2003a), SAB’s dirty secret

Noseweek (2003b), SAB’s lying Dutchmen

OECD (2003). Policy coherence: Vital for global development. OECD observer Policy Brief, July, Paris, OECD.

Oxfam, Tax havens: Releasing the hidden billions for poverty eradication, 2000.

Riesco, M., G. Lagos, and M. Lima (2005). The “Pay Your Taxes” Debate: Perspectives on Corporate Taxation and Social Responsibility in the Chilean Mining Industry. UNRISD Technology, Business and Society Programme Paper No. 16

Summer, A. (2005), “Is foreign direct investment good for the poor? A review and stocktake,” Development in Practice, Vol. 15, Nos. 3 & 4, Jun 2005, p. 269-85.

Tanzi, V. & H.H. Zee (2000). Tax policy for emerging markets: developing countries. IMF working paper WP/00/35.

UNCTAD, (2006), World Investment Report.

Unger, B. (2006), The amounts and the effects of money laundering, Report for the Ministry of Finance.

Van Dijk, M., F. Weyzig, and R. Murphy (2006), “The Netherlands: A tax Haven?”, SOMO.

Weyzig, F., and M. van Dijk (2007), Tax Haven and Development Partner: Incoherence in Dutch Government Policies?, SOMO.