Performance of business groups: Evidence from post-crisis Russia

Shumilov, Andrei (2008): Performance of business groups: Evidence from post-crisis Russia.

Abstract

Transition economies like Russia lack properly functioning financial markets and institutions, which results in severe agency and information problems. Business groups in such markets have the potential to offer benefits to member firms, but they also may destroy value. Using a unique database on membership in Russian business groups, we analyze the relationship between group affiliation and firm performance on the basis of a large panel of manufacturing firms for the period 1999-2002. We find that group membership has a positive effect on productive efficiency, but gains from improved productivity in group affiliates do not adequately translate into higher profitability. This is consistent with the expropriation hypothesis, according to which controlling owners of groups extract private benefits by siphoning profits from their members. Among the different group categories delineated by type of controlling owner, the extent of profit dissipation is especially large in groups controlled by private domestic owners, who face a greater risk of possible future expropriation of property. Finally, we examine two potential sources of benefits of membership in business groups: mutual insurance among affiliated firms and preferential treatment from the state via subsidies and tolerated tax arrears. We find that, during the period studied, groups neither provided mutual insurance nor did they receive larger support from the state than unaffiliated firms. Together with findings from the previous literature indicating that, prior to the 1998 financial crisis, group firms benefited from more efficient allocation of capital within groups than in the rest of the economy but not after the crisis, our results suggest that the advantages of group membership recede as the economic and institutional environment gradually improves.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: business groups; firm performance; transition economy; Russia
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G30 - General; L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior; L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior > L20 - General

References

Alfandari, G. and M. Schaffer (1996) “Arrears in the Russian Enterprise Sector’, CERT Discussion Paper 96-08

Almeida, H., M. Campello and M. Weisbach (2004), “The Cash Flow Sensitivity of Cash’, Journal of Finance, 59, pp. 1777-1804

Aoki, M. (Ed.) (1984) “The Economic Analysis of the Japanese Firm’, North-Holland, Amsterdam

Arnold, J. and B. Javorcik (2005) “Gifted Kids or Pushy Parents? Foreign Acquisitions and Plant Performance in Indonesia’, CEPR Discussion Paper Series, No. 5065

Bae, K.H., J.K. Kang and J.M. Kim (2002) “Tunneling or Value Addition? Evidence from Mergers by Korean Business Groups’, Journal of Finance, 57, pp. 2695-2740

Bevan, A.A., S. Estrin and M.E. Schaffer (1999) “Determinants of Enterprise Performance during Transition’, CERT Discussion Papers 99-03

Berger, P. and E. Ofek (1995) “Diversification’s Effect on Firm Value’, Journal of Financial Economics, 37, pp.39–65

Black, B., R. Kraakman and A. Tarassova (2000) “Russian Privatization and Corporate Governance: What Went Wrong?’, Stanford Law Review, 52(6), pp. 1731-1808

Blundell, R. and M. Costa Dias (2002) “Alternative Approaches to Evaluation in Empirical Microeconomics’, CEMMAP Working Paper CWP10/02

Boycko, M., A. Shleifer and R. W. Vishny, (1996). “A Theory of Privatization’, Economic Journal, 106, pp. 309-319

Bertrand, M., M. Paras and S. Mullainathan (2002) “Ferreting Out Tunneling: An Application to Indian Business Groups’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 117(1), pp. 121–148

Braguinsky, S. and R. Myerson (2007) “Capital and Growth with Oligarchic Property Rights’, Review of Economic Dynamics, 10(4), pp. 676-704

Brown, J. D., J. S. Earle, and Á. Telegdy (2004) “Does Privatization Raise Productivity? Evidence from Comprehensive Manufacturing Firm Panel Data in Hungary, Romania, Russia, and Ukraine’, Upjohn Institute Working Paper 04-107

Chang, J. and U. Choi (1988) “Strategy, Structure and Performance of Korean Business Groups: a Transaction Cost Approach’, Journal of Industrial Economics, 37(2), pp.141-158

Chang, S.J., and J. Hong (2000) “Economic Performance of the Korean Business Groups: Intragroup Resource Sharing and Internal Business Transaction’, Academy of Management Journal, 43(3), pp. 429–448

Cuervo-Cazurra, A. (2006) “Business Groups and Their Types’, Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 23, pp. 419-437

Desai M., A. Dyck and L. Zingales (2007) “Theft and Taxes’, Journal of Financial Economics, 84(3), pp. 591-623

Earle, J. S. and S. Estrin (1997) “After Voucher Privatization: The Structure of Corporate Ownership in Russian Manufacturing Industry’, CEPR Discussion Paper No. 1736

Fazzari, S., R. Hubbard and B. Petersen (1988), “Financing Constraints and Corporate Investment’, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1, pp. 141-195

Fisman, R. (2001), “Estimating the Value of Political Connections’, American Economic Review, 91, pp. 1095-1102

Fortescue, S. (2006), “Russia's Oil Barons and Metal Magnates: Oligarchs and the State in Transition’, Palgrave Macmillan

Girma S., and S. Gorg (2007) “Evaluating the Foreign Ownership Wage Premium Using a Difference-in-differences Matching Approach’, Journal of International Economics, Vol.72, No.1, pp. 97-112

Guriev, S. and A. Rachinskiy (2005) “The Role of Oligarchs in Russian capitalism’, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 19, pp. 131-150

Johnson, S., R. La Porta, F. Lopez-de-Silanes, and A. Shleifer (2000) “Tunneling’, American Economic Review, 90(2), pp. 22-27

Kaplan, S. and L. Zingales (1997) “Do Financial Constraints Explain Why Investment is Correlated with Cash Flow?’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 115, pp.565-592

Keister, L. (1998) “Engineering Growth: Business Group Structure and Firm Performance in China’s Transition Economies’, American Journal of Sociology, 104(2), pp.404-440

Khanna, T. (2000) “Business Groups and Social Welfare in Emerging Markets: Existing Evidence and Unanswered Questions’, European Economic Review, 44, pp.748-761

Khanna, T. and T. Ghemawat (1998) “The Nature of Diversified Business Groups: a Research Design and Two Case Studies’, Journal of Industrial Economics, 46(1), pp. 35-61

Khanna, T. and K. Palepu (1999) “Policy Shocks, Market Intermediaries, and Corporate Strategy: The Evolution of Business Groups in Chile and India’, Journal of Economics and Management Strategy, 8, pp.271-310

Khanna, T. and K. Palepu (2000). “Is Group Membership Profitable in Emerging Markets? An Analysis of Diversified Indian Business Groups’, Journal of Finance, 55, pp.867-891

Khanna, T. and J. Rivkin (1999) “Estimating the Performance Effects of Groups in Emerging Markets’, HBS Working Paper

Khanna, T. and Y. Yafeh (2005) “Business Groups and Risk Sharing around the World’, Journal of Business, Vol. 78, pp. 301-340

Khanna, T. and Y. Yafeh (2007) “Business Groups in Emerging Markets: Paragons or Parasites?’, Journal of Economic Literature, XLV, pp. 331-372

La Porta, R., F. Lopez-De-Salinas and A. Shleifer (1999) “Corporate Ownership Around the World’, Journal of Finance, 54, pp. 471-517

Lang, L.H.P. and R.M. Stulz (1994) “Tobin’s Q, Corporate Diversification and Firm Performance’, Journal of Political Economy, 102, pp. 1248–1280

Muravyev, A. (2002) “Federal State Shareholdings in Russian Companies: Origin, Forms, and Consequences for Enterprise Performance’, BOFIT Discussion Paper No. 12

Nakatani, I. (1984) “The Economic Role of Financial Corporate Grouping’, in M.Aoki (ed.), “The Economic Analysis of the Japanese Firm’, New York, North Holland

Orlov, E. (2000) “Government Subsidies to Russian firms: Efficient or Not?’, NES Working paper, BSP/00/033E

Pappe, Y. (2000) “The Oligarchs’, Higher School of Economics, Moscow (in Russian)

Pappe, Y. and Y. Galukhina (2006) “Russian Big Business 2000-2005: Key Trends in Its Transformation and Development’, Studies on Russian Economic Development, 17(3), pp. 248-258

Perotti, E. and S. Gelfer (2001) “Red Barons or Robber Barons? Governance and Investment in Russian Financial-Industrial Groups’, European Economic Review, 45, pp. 1601-1617

Ponomareva, M. and E. Zhuravskaya (2004) “Federal Tax Arrears in Russia. Liquidity Problems, Federal Redistribution or Regional Resistance?’, Economics of Transition, 12(3), pp. 373-398

Rajan, R., H. Servaes and L. Zingales (2000) “The Cost of Diversity: The Diversification Discount and Inefficient Investment’, Journal of Finance, 55 (1), pp. 35-46

Rosembaum, P. R. and D. B. Rubin (1983) “The Central Role of the Propensity Score in Observational Studies for Causal Effects’, Biometrika, 70, pp. 41-55

Sabirianova, K., J. Svejnar, and K. Terrell (2005) “Foreign Investment, Corporate Ownership, and Development: Are Firms in Emerging Markets Catching up to the World Standard?’, IZA Discussion Paper No. 1457

Schaffer, M. (1998) “Do Firms in Transition Economies Have Soft Budget Constraints? A Reconsideration of Concepts and Evidence’, Journal of Comparative Economics, 26, pp. 80-103

Scharfstein, D. and Stein, J. 2000, “The Dark Side of Internal Capital Markets: Divisional Rent-seeking and Inefficient Investment’, Journal of Finance, 55(6), pp. 2537-2564

Shleifer, A. and R. W. Vishny (1994). “Politicians and Firms’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 109(4), pp. 995–1025

Shumilov, A. and N. Volchkova (2004) “Russian Business Groups: Substitutes for Missing Institutions?’, CEFIR Working Paper

Slinko, I., E. Yakovlev and E. Zhuravskaya (2004) “Laws for Sale: Evidence from Russia’, American Law and Economics Review, 7(1), pp.284-318

Vickers, J., and G. Yarrow, (1990) “Privatization: An Economic Analysis’, Cambridge, Massachusetts, MIT Press

Volchkova, N. (2001) “Does Financial-Industrial Group Membership Affect Fixed Investment: Evidence from Russia’, CEFIR Working Paper

Wooldridge, J. (2002) “Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data’, Cambridge: MIT Press

World Bank (2004) “From Transition to Development: A Country Economic Memorandum for the Russian Federation’, Moscow

Yudaeva, K., K. Kozlov, N. Melentieva and N. Ponomareva (2003) “Does Foreign Ownership Matter? The Russian Expierence’, Economics of Transition, 11(3), pp.383-409

“1000 Best Russian Enterprises. Russian Industry: Markets, Sectors, Regions’ (2003) Moscow, Expert Institute informational-analytical publication