Keynes’s slip of the pen: aggregate supply curve vs employment function

Heller, Claudia (2009): Keynes’s slip of the pen: aggregate supply curve vs employment function.

Abstract

This paper focuses on Keynes’s exposition of the Principle of Effective Demand and its generalised mathematical representation – the basis of a Z-D type model. It elaborates on Keynes’s algebraic formulation in the General Theory, relying on interpreters who contributed to the generalisation of his most restrictive hypotheses on competition and returns to scale as well as on those who developed the algebraic argumentation that Keynes left only indicated. Instead of correcting Keynes’s mathematics (which is right), the paper concludes that there has been a “slip of the pen” in his own description of these concepts on the footnote to page 55 of the General Theory. Keynes’s employment function, the inverse of his aggregate supply curve is not the same thing as his aggregate supply function. Therefore, in the controversial footnote, it is not the aggregate supply function but the employment function that is linear with a slope given by the reciprocal of the money-wage.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Principle of effective demand; D/Z-mode´; Aggregate demand; Aggregate supply
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B3 - History of Economic Thought: Individuals > B31 - Individuals; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B22 - Macroeconomics; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925

References

Amadeo, E. J. S. 1989. Keynes’s Principle of Effective Demand, London, Edward Elgar

Ambrosi, G. M. 1981. Keynes and the 45-degree cross, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, vol. 3, 503-9

Asimakopulos, A. 1982. Keynes's theory of effective demand revisited, Australian Economic Papers, vol. 21, 18-36

Brady, M. E. 1990. The mathematical development of Keynes's aggregate supply function in the General Theory, History of Political Economy, vol. 22, 167-72

Brady, M. E. 1996. A comparison-contrast of J. M. Keynes’ mathematical modeling approach in the General Theory with some of his General Theory interpreters, especially J. E. Meade. History of Economics Review, vol. 25, 129-59

Brady, M. E. 1999. A study of the 1954-1956 Economic Journal aggregate supply function debate and the post-keynesian theoretical wrong turn, Indian Journal of Applied Economics, vol. 8, 57-74

Brady, M. E. 2004. Essays on J.M. Keynes and...., Xlibris Corp.

Casarosa, C. 1978. Un contributo all'analisi dei fondamenti microeconomici della teoria keynesiana della domanda effettiva, Rivista di Politica Economica, vol. 11, 1371-409

Casarosa, C. 1981. The microfoundations of Keynes’s aggregate supply and expected demand analysis, Economic Journal, vol. 361, 188-94

Casarosa, C. 1982. Aggregate supply and expected demand analysis in Keynes’ General Theory: an essay on the micro-foundations, pp. 67-79, in Baranzini, M. (ed.), Advances in Economic Theory, London, Blackwell

Casarosa, C. 1984. The microfoundations of Keynes's aggregate supply and expected demand analysis: a reply, Economic Journal, vol. 94, 941-5

Chick, V. 1983. Macroeconomics After Keynes: a reconsideration of the General Theory, Oxford, Philip Alan

Chick, V. 1992. A comment on John Nevile’s notes on aggregate supply, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, vol. 15, 261-2

Davidson, P. 1962. More on aggregate supply function, Economic Journal, vol. 72, 452-7

Davidson, P. 1989A. Patinkin’s interpretation of Keynes and the Keynesian cross, History of Political Economy, vol. 21, 549-53

Davidson, P 1989B. Corrected version of Patinkin’s interpretation of Keynes and the Keynesian cross, History of Political Economy, vol. 21, 737-41

De Jong, F. J. 1954A. Supply functions in Keynesian economics, Economic Journal, vol. 64, 3-24

De Jong, F. J. 1954B. Keynes and supply functions: a rejoinder, Economic Journal, vol. 64, 840-2

De Jong, F. J. 1955. Keynes and supply functions: second rejoinder with a note on the concept of monetary equilibrium, Economic Journal, vol. 65, 479-84

De Jong, F. J. 1956. Third rejoinder and final observations, Economic Journal, vol. 66, 488-92

Dillard, D. 1948. The Economics of John Maynard Keynes – The Theory of a Monetary Economy, New York, Prentice-Hall

Ferreira, R. S and Michel, P. 1988. Reflections on the microeconomic foundations of the Keynesian aggregate supply function, pp. 251-62, in Barrere, A. (ed.), The Foundation of Keynesian Analysis, London, Macmillan

Ferreira, R. S. and Michel, P. 1991. Keynes' aggregate supply function and the principle of effective demand, Recherches Économiques de Louvain, vol. 57, 159–87

Fusfeld, D. R. 1985. Keynes and the Keynesian cross: a note, History of Political Economy, vol. 17, 385-9

Fusfeld, D. R. 1989. Keynes and the Keynesian cross: reply to Don Partinkin, History of Political Economy, vol. 21, 545-7

Hansen, A. H. 1953. A Guide to Keynes, New York, Mc-Graw-Hill

Hartwig, J. 2007. Keynes vs the Post Keynesians on the principle of effective demand, European Journal of the History of Economic Thought, vol. 14, 725-39

Hartwig, J and Brady, M. E. 2008. Comment: Hayes on Z, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 32, 815-9

Hawtrey, R. G. 1954. Keynes and supply functions, Economic Journal, vol. 64, 834-9

Hawtrey, R. G. 1956. Keynes and supply functions – a further note, Economic Journal, vol. 66, 482-4

Hayes, G. M. 2007. Keynes's Z function, heterogeneous output and marginal productivity, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 31, 741-53

Hayes, G. M. 2008. Keynes’s Z function – a reply to Hartwig and Brady, Cambridge Journal of Economics. vol. 32, 811-4

Keynes, J. M. 1936. The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, London, Macmillan

King, J. E. 1994. Aggregate supply and demand analysis since Keynes: A partial history, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, vol. 17, 3-32

Kooros, A. 1961. Keynes' aggregate supply function – a comment, Economic Journal, vol. 71, 849

Leijonhufvud, A. 1974. Keynes employment function: comment, History of Political Economy, vol. 6, 164-70

Marty, A. 1959. The aggregate supply function, Metroeconomica, vol. 11, 179-87

Marty, A. 1961. A geometrical exposition of the Keynesian supply function, Economic Journal, vol. 71, 560-5

Marty, A. 1981. The aggregate supply function once again, Economic Enquiry, vol, 19, 350-1

Moggridge, D. E. (ed.) 1979. The General Theory and after – a supplement, vol. XXIX, The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes, London, Macmillan

Neissen, H. 1961. Keynes' aggregate supply function - further comments, Economic Journal, vol. 71, 850-2

Nevile, J. 1992. Notes on Keynes’s aggregate supply curve, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, vol. 15, 255-60

Parrinello, S. 1980. The price level implicit in Keynes´s effective demand, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, vol. 3, 63-87

Pasinettti, L. L. 1997. The principle of effective demand, pp. 93-104, in Harcourt, G. C. and Riach, R.A. (eds,), A ‘Second Edition’ of the General Theory, Vol. I, London, Routledge

Patinkin, D. 1949. Involuntary unemployment and the Keynesian supply function, Economic Journal, vol. 59, 360-83

Patinkin, D. 1976. Keynes’ monetary thought: a study of its development, History of Political Economy, vol. 8, 1-150

Patinkin, D. 1977. The aggregate supply function: a correction, History of Political Economy, vol. 9, 156-9

Patinkin, D. 1978. Keynes’s aggregate supply function: a plea for common sense, History of Political Economy, vol. 10, 577-96

Patinkin, D. 1979. A study of Keynes’ theory of effective demand, Economic Enquiry, vol. 17, 155-76

Patinkin, D. 1984. A critique of Keynes’ theory of effective demand, pp. 123-62, in Anticipations of the General Theory? And Other Essays on Keynes. Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 2nd revised ed.

Patinkin, D. 1989. Keynes and the Keynesian cross: a further note, History of Political Economy, vol. 21, 537-44

Roberts, D. L. 1978. Patinkin, Keynes, and aggregate supply and demand analysis, History of Political Economy, vol. 10, 549-76

Robertson, D. H. and Johnson, H. G. 1955. Keynes and supply functions, Economic Journal, vol. 65, 474-8

Robertson, D. H. 1956. Keynes and supply functions, Economic Journal, vol. 66, 485-7

Soper, C. S. 1956. The supply curve in Keynesian economics, South African Journal of Economics, vol. 24, 1-8

Tarshis, L. 1947. The Elements of Economics: an introduction of the theory of price and employment, Boston, Houghton Mifflin

Tarshis, L. 1979. The aggregate supply function in Keynes’s General Theory, pp. 361-92, in Boskin, M. (ed.), Economics and Human Welfare: Essays in honour of Tibor Scitovsky, New York, Academic Press

Torr, C. S. W. 1981. Microfoundations for Keynes’s point of effective demand, South African Journal of Economics, vol. 49, 334-48

Torr, C. S. W. 1984. The microfoundations of Keynes's aggregate supply and expected demand analysis: a comment, Economic Journal, vol. 94, 936-40

Veendorp, E. C. H. and Werkema, H. G. 1961. Mr. Well’s aggregate supply function: a comment, Economic Journal, vol. 71, 634-6

Vickers, D. 1987. Aggregate supply and the producer´s expected demand curve, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics vol. 10, 84-104

Weintraub, E. R. 1974. Keynes employment function: comment, History of Political Economy, vol. 6, 162-4

Weintraub, S. 1951. Income and Employment Analysis, New York, Pitman

Weintraub, S. 1957. The microfoundations of aggregate demand and supply, Economic Journal, vol. 67, 455-70

Weintraub, S. 1961. Classical 450 Keynesianism: a plea for its abandonment, pp. 1-25, in Classical Keynesianism. Monetary Theory and the Price Level, Philadelphia, Chilton

Wells, P. 1960. Keynes’s aggregate supply function: a suggested interpretation, Economic Journal, vol. 70, 536-42

Wells, P. 1961. A further comment, Economic Journal, vol. 71, 636-7

Wells, P. 1962. Aggregate supply and demand: an explanation of chapter III of the ‘General Theory’, Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Sciences, vol. 28, 585-90

Wells, P. 1973. Keynes’s dynamic disequilibrium theory of employment, Quarterly Review of Economics and Business, vol. 13, 89-93

Wells, P. 1974. Keynes employment function. History of Political Economy, vol. 6, 158-62

Wells, P. 1978. In review of Keynes, Cambridge Journal of Economics, vol. 2, 315-25