Russian federalism and post-Soviet integration: Divergence of development paths

Libman, Alexander (2009): Russian federalism and post-Soviet integration: Divergence of development paths.

Abstract

The paper compares the development of two institutional systems organizing the intergovernmental relations in the former Soviet Union: Russian federalism and post-Soviet regional integration. In spite of common origins, random selections of actors and common development trends in the first decade of their existence, in the 2000s both systems experienced significant divergence. The paper discusses the interaction of four factors explaining differences in the development of post-Soviet integration and Russian federalism: formal vs. informal nature of political property rights of elites; impact of economic asymmetry on political bargaining; role of (potential) federal political arena in terms of interests of territorial elites; and impact of large business groups. It also addresses direct links between the centralization in Russia and the regional integration in the post-Soviet space.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: post-Soviet integration, Russian federalism, decentralization
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F15 - Economic Integration; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession

References

Allison, Roy (2008): Virtual Regionalism, Regional Structures and Regime Security in Central Asia. Central Asian Survey 27(2):185-202

Amrbosio, Thomas (2006): The Political Success of Russia-Belarus Relations: Insulating Minsk from a Color Revolution. Demokratizatsiya 14(3):407-434

Ambrosio, Thomas (2008): Catching the ‘Shanghai Spirit’: How the Shanghai Cooperation Organization Promotes Authoritarian Norms in Central Asia. Europe-Asia Studies 60(8):1321-1344

Badinger, Harald, and Fritz Breuss (2006): Country Size and Gains from Trade Bloc Enlargement: An Empirical Assessment for the European Community. Review of International Economics 14(4):615-631

Baev, Pavel K. (2006): Russian Quasi-Federalism and Georgia’s Non-Existent Territorial Integrity. Central Asia – Caucasus Analyst, March 5

Bahry, Donna (2005): The New Federalism and the Paradoxes of Regional Sovereignty in Russia. Comparative Politics 37:127-146

Bandyopadhyay, Subhayu and Howard J. Wall (1999): Customs Union or Free Trade Area? The Role of Political Asymmetries. Review of International Economics 7(4):665-672

Belin, Laura (1997): Russia’s 1996 Gubernatorial Elections and the Implications for Yeltsin. Demokratizatsiya 5(2):165-184

Blankart, Charles B., and Gerrit B. Koester (2008): Refocusing the EU Budget – an Institutional View. Mimeo

Boeckenfoerde, Markus, Dann, Philipp, and Verena Wiesner (2007): Max Planck Manual on Different Forms of Decentralization. Heidelberg

Bond, Eric W., and Constantinos Syropoulos (1996): The Size of Trading Blocs: Market Power and World Welfare Effects. Journal of International Economics 40:411-437

Bond, Eric W., and Jee-Hyeong Park (2002): Gradualism in Trade Agreements with Asymmetric Countries. Review of Economic Studies 69: 379-406

Bremmer, Ian, and Alyson Bailes (1998): Sub-Regionalism in the Newly Independent States. International Affairs 74(1):131-147

Bucovetsky, Sam (1991): Asymmetric Tax Competition. Journal of Urban Economics 30: 167-181

Casella, Alessandra (1992): Participation in a Currency Union. American Economic Review 82:847-863

Casella, Alessandra (1996): Large Countries, Small Countries and the Enlargement of Trade Blocks. European Economic Review 40:389-415

Chebankova, Elena (2005): The Limitations of Central Authority in the Regions and the Implications for the Evolution of Russia’s Federal System. Europe-Asia Studies 57(7):933-949

Chebankova, Elena (2006): The Unintended Consequences of Gubernatorial Appointments in Russia, 2005-6. Journal of Communist Studies and Transition Politics 22(4):457-484

Colton, Timothy J., and Michael McFoul (2003): Popular Choice and Managed Democracy: The Russian Elections of 1999 and 2000. Brookings Institution Press

Coppieters, Bruno (ed., 1996): Contested Borders in the Caucasus. Brussels: Vub Brussels University Press

Crane, Keith, Peterson, D.J., and Olga Oliker (2005): Russian Investment in the Commonwealth of Independent States. Eurasian Geography and Economcis 46(6):405-444

Cummings, Sally N. (2000): Kazakhstan: Centre-Periphery Relations. London: Royal Institute of International Affairs

D’Anieri, Paul (1997): International Cooperation among Unequal Partners: The Emergence of Bilateralism in the Former Soviet Union. International Politics 34:417-448

Dabrowski, Marke (1995): The Reasons of the Collapse of the Ruble Zone. Unpublished manuscript, CASE

Danilovich, Alex (2006): Russian-Belarus Integration: Playing Games behind the Kremlin Wall. Ashgate

Das, Satya P., and Subhadip Ghosh (2006): Endogenous Trading Bloc Formation in a North-South Global Economy. Canadian Journal of Economics 39: 809-830

Efird, Brian, and Gaspare M. Genna (2002): Structural Conditions and the Propensity for Regional Integration. European Union Politics 3:267-295

Eggert, Wolfgang, and Andreas Haufler (1998): When Do Small Countries Win the Tax Wars? Public Finance Review 26:327-361

Ellingsen, Tore (1998): Externalities versus Internalities: A Model of Political Integration. Journal of Public Economics 68:251-268

Fel’dman, Dmitriy (2005): Politicheskoe Vzaimodeistvie Elit Stran SNG. POLIS (4):89-98

Filippov, Mikhail, and Olga Shvetsova (1999): Asymmetric Bilateral Bargaining in the New Russian Federation: A Path-Dependence Explanation. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 32:61-76

Filippov, Mikhail, Ordershook, Peter C., and Olga Shvetsova (2004): Designing Federalism: A Theory of Self-Sustainable Federal Institutions, Cambridge

Forslid, Rikard (2005): Tax Competition and Agglomeration: Main Effects and Empirical Implications. Swedish Economic Policy Review 13:113-137

Fruchtmann, Jakob (2003): Der russische Föderalismus unter Präsident Putin: Diskurse – Realitäten. PhD Thesis, University of Bremen

Fung, K.C., and Patricia Higino Schneider (2006): Asymmetric Integration. International Journal of Applied Economics 2:83-110

Gel’man, Vladimir (2006): Vozvrashenie Leviafana? Politika Recentralizatsii v Sovremennoi Rossii. POLIS (2):90-109

Gel’man, Vladimir (2008): Out of the Frying Pan, Into the Fire? Post-Soviet Regime Changes in Comparative Perspective. International Political Science Review 29(2):157-180

Gibson, Edward L., and Tulia G. Falleti (2004): Unity by the Stick: Regional Conflict and the Origins of Argentine Federalism. In: Gibson, Edward L. (ed.): Federalism and Democracy in Latin America. Baltimore

Gilpin, Robert (2001): Global Political Economy: Understanding the International Economic Order. Princeton University Press

Goyal, Sanjeev, and Klaas Staal (2004): The Political Economy of Regionalism. European Economic Review 48:563-593

Gradstein, Mark (2004): Political Bargaining in a Federation: Buchanan Meets Coase. European Economic Review 48:983-999

Grinberg, Ruslan (2004): Integration und Desintegration im postsowjetischen Raum, in Cassel, Dieter, and Paul J.J. Welfens, P.J.J. (eds.): Regionale Integration und Osterweiterung der Europäischen Union, Stuttgart, Lucius & Lucius

Guriev, Sergei M., Yakovlev, Evgeny, and Ekaterina Zhuravskaya (2007): Inter-Regional Trade and Lobbying. CEFIR Working Paper 100

Haufler, Andreas, and Ian Wooton (1999): Country Size and Tax Competition for Foreign Direct Investments. Journal of Public Economics 71:121-139

Jensen, Henrik (1994): Sustaining Policy Coordination Between Economies of Different Size. Journal of International Economics 289-307

Jones Luong, Pauline (2004): Economic Decentralization in Kazakhstan: Causes and Consequences. In: Jones Luong, Pauline (ed.): The Transformation of Central Asia, Ithaca: Cornell University Press

Jones Luong, Pauline, and Erika Weinthal (2004): Contra Coercion: Russian Tax Reform, Exogenous Shocks and Negotiated Institutional Change. American Political Science Review 98(1):139-152

Jones, Philip (2007): Colluding Victims: A Public Choice Analysis of International Alliances. Public Choice 132:319-332

Kanbur, Ravi, and Michael Keen (1993): Jeux Sans Frontieres: Tax Competition and Tax Coordination when Countries Differ in Size. American Economic Review 83(4):877-892

Kang, David C. (2004): The Theoretical Roots of Hierarchy in International Relations. Australian Journal of International Affairs 58(3):337-352

Kennan, John, and Raymond Riezman (1988): Do Big Countries Win Tariff Wars? International Economic Review 29(1):81-85

Kindleberger, C.P. (1973): The World in Depression: 1929-1939. Berkley: University of California Press

Kheyfets, Boris, and Alexander Libman (2008): Korporativnaya Integraciya: Al’ternativa dlya Postsovetskogo Prostranstva. Moscow: LKI

Kolerov, Modest (2007): Chto My Znaem o Postsovetskikh Stranakh? Accessed online at < http://www.polit.ru/lectures/2006/07/04/kolerov.html>, January 3, 2008

Konitzer, Andrew, and Stephen K. Wegren (2006): Federalism and Political Recentralization in the Russian Federation: United Russia as the Party of Power. Publius: The Journal of Federalism 36(4): 503-522

Kordonskiy, Simeon (2001): Administrativnye Rynki SSSR i Rossii. Moscow: OGI

Kosikova, Lidia (2008): Itogi Pyatnadtsatiletnego Razvitiya Gosudarstv SNG i Ikh Vsaimnogo Sotrudnichestva. Kontinent Partnerstva (5):36-48

Kurdiukov, Gennadi, and Katlijn Malfliet (2007): Integration by Absorption: New Subjects for the Russian Federation, in: Malfliet, Katlijn, Verpoesten, Lien, and Evgeny Vinokurov (eds.): The CIS, the EU, and Russia: Challenges of Integration. London: Palgrave Macmillan

Lake, David (1999): Entangling Relations: American Foreign Policy in This Century. Princeton University Press

Latin, David (2000): Post-Soviet Politics. Annual Review of Political Science 3:117-148

Lavrov, Aleksei (2005): Budzhetnaya Reforma v Rossii: Ot Upravlenia Zatratami k Upravleniu Resultatami. Moscow: IROF

Libman, Alexander (2008): Constitutions, Regulations, and Taxes: Contradictions of Different Aspects of Decentralization. Mimeo

Libman, Alexander, and Lars P. Feld (2008): Strategic Tax Collection and Fiscal Decentralization: The Case of Russia. Mimeo

Malashenko, Aleksei (2005): Glavnyi Itog Chechenksikh Vyborov: Dve Vertikali Vlasti. Brifing Moskovskogo Centra Karnegi 7(11)

Markedonov, Sergei (2006): Kavkaz v Poiskakh “Svoei Zemli”: Etnichnost’ i Konflity v Regione. Svobodnaya Mysl (4):70-76

Matsuzato, Kimitaka (2004): A Populist Island in the Ocean of Clan Politics: The Lukashenka Regime as an Exception among CIS Countries. Europe-Asia Studies 56(2):235-261

Mayer, Wolfgang (1981): Theoretical Considerations on Negotiated Tariff Adjustments. Oxford Economic Papers 33: 135-153

Mayes, David G., and Vesa Korhonen (2007): The CIS – Does the Regional Hegemon Facilitate Monetary Cooperation. BOFIT Discussion Paper No. 17

Melvin, Neil J. (2001): Patterns of Centre-Regional Relations in Central Asia: The Cases of Kazakhstan, the Kyrgyz Republic, and Uzbekistan. Regional and Federal Studies 11(3):165-193

Motyl, Alexander J. (2001): Imperial Ends: The Decay, Collapse, and Revival of Empires. New York: Columbia University Press

Niou, Emerson M.S., and P.C. Ordeshook (1998): Alliances versus Federations: An Extension of Riker’s Analysis of Federal Formation. Constitutional Political Economy 9:271-288

Offe, Claus (1991): Capitalism by Democratic Design? Democratic Theory Facing the Triple Transition in East Central Europe. Social Research 58:865-892

Olson, Mancur, and Richard Zeckhauser (1966): An Economic Theory of Alliances. Review of Economics and Statistics 48: 266-279

Peralta, Susan, and Tanguy van Ypersele (2005): Factor Endowment and Welfare Levels in an Asymmetric Tax Competition Game. Journal of Urban Economics 57:258-274

Pedersen, Thomas (2002): Cooperative Hegemony: Power, Ideas and Institutions in Regional Integration. Review of International Studies 28:677-696

Petrov, Nikolai (2006): Naznacheniya Gubernatorov: Itogi Pervogo Goda. Brifing Moskovskogo Centra Karnegi 8(3)

Polishchuk, Leonid (1998): Rossiiskaia Model’ Peregovornogo Federalisma (Politiko-Ekonomicheskii Aspekt), Voprosy Ekonomiki (3):68-88

Portinkov, Vitaliy (2006): Mif Umer – Da Zdravstvuet Mif! Neprikosnovennyi Zapas (6)

Rector, Chad (2006): Federalism and International Organizations. Mimeo

Riker, William (1964): Federalism: Origin, Operation, Significance. Boston: Little Brown

Rutland, Peter (1993): The Politics of Economic Stagnation in the Soviet Union: The Role of Local Party Organs in Economic Management. Cambridge

Ryabov, Andrei (2005): Moskva Prinimaet Vyzov Tsvetnykh Revoluciy. Pro et Contra 9(1):18-27

Sheng, Yumin (2007): Global Market Integration and Central Political Control: Foreign Trade and Intergovernmental Relations in China. Comparative Political Studies 40(4): 405-434

Söderlund, Peter (2003): The Significance of Structural Power Resources in the Russian Bilateral Treaty Process 1994-1998. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 36:311-324

Solnick, Steven L. (2002): Federalism and State-Building: Post-Communist and Post-Colonial Perspectives. In: Reynolds, A. (ed.): The Architecture of Democracy: Constitutional Design, Conflict Management, and Democracy. Oxford University Press

Spechler, Martin C. (2008): Is Russia Winning in Central Asia? Paper presented at the conference on “Institutions, Institutional Change, and Economic Performance in Central Asia”, Göttingen, Germany, September

Speckhard, Christopher Tomas (2004): The Ties that Bind: Big Business and Center-Periphery Relations in the Russian Federation. PhD Thesis at University Texas at Ausin

Stack, Graham (1998): Neoinstitutionalist Perspectives on Regionalization in Russia. Arbeitspapier des Osteuropa-Instituts der FU Berlin No. 21

Stöwhase, Swen (2005): Asymmetric Capital Tax Competition with Profit Shifting. Journal of Economics 85(2):175-196

Tolz, Vera, and Irina Busygina (1997): Regional Governors and the Kremlin: The Ongoing Battle for Power. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 30:401-426

Treisman, Daniel S. (1997): Russia’s „Ethnic Revival“: The Separatist Activism of Regional Leaders in a Post-Communist Order. World Politics 49:212-249

Trenin, Dmitriy (2004): Identichnost’ i Integraciya: Rossiya i Zapad v XXI veke. Pro et Contra 8(3):9-22

Trenin, Dmitriy (2004a): Rossiyskaya Vneshnyaya Politika Posle Beslana. Brifing Moskovskogo Centra Karnegi 6(11)

Tsygankov, Andrei (2003): Mastering Space in Eurasia: Russia’s Geopolitical Thinking after the Soviet Break-Up. Communist and Post-Communist Studies 36:101-127

Tsygankov, Andrei (2006): If Not By Tanks, Than By Banks? The Role of Soft Power In Putin’s Foreign Policy. Europe-Asia Studies 58(7):1079-1099

Turovskiy, Rostislav (1999): Sravnitel’nyi Analiz Tendencii Regional’nogo Razvitiia Rossii i Ukrainy. POLIS (6):49-61 29

Vahtra, Peeter (2005): Russian Investments in the CIS – Scope, Motivation and Leverage. Electronic Publication of the Pan-European Institute, Turku School of Economics, No.9

Vahtra, Peeter (2007): Expansion or Exodus? – The New Leaders among the Russian TNCs. Electronic Publication of the Pan-European Institute, Turku School of Economics, No. 13

Walt, Stephen (1987): The Origin of Alliances. Ithaca: Cornel University Press

Waltz, Kenneth (1979): Theory of International Politics. New-York: McGraw-Hill

Way, Lucan A. (2002): The Dilemmas of Reform in Weak States: The Case of Post-Soviet Fiscal Decentralization. Politics and Society 30(4):579-598

Welfens, Paul J.J. (2004): Regionale Integration in der Ordnungs-, Aussenwirtschafts- und Wachstumstheorie, in: Cassel, Dieter, and Paul J.J. Welfens (eds.): Regionale Integration und Osterweiterung der Europäischen Union. Stuttgart: Lucius & Lucius

Wilson, John D. (1991): Tax Competition with Interregional Differences in Factor Endowments. Regional Science and Urban Economics 21:423-451

Yakovlev, Andrei (2005): Evolutciya Strategiy Vzaimodeistviya Biznesa i Vlasti v Rossiyskoy Ekonomike. Rossiyskiy Zhurnal Menedzhmenta 3(1):27-52

Yazkova, Alla (2007): Sodruzhestvo Nezavisimykh Gosudarstv: Stranicy Istorii. Informacionno-Analiticheskiy Biulleten Centra Problem Integracii IE RAN (1): 40-54

Zakharov, Andrei (2008): Imperskiy Federalizm. Neprikosnovennyi Zapas (1)

Zubarevich, Nataliya (2002): Prishel, Uvidel, Pobedil? (Krupnyi Biznes i Regional’naya Vlast‘). Pro et Contra 7(1):107-119

Zubarevich, Nataliya (2005): Krupnyi Biznes v Regionakh Rossii: Territorial’nye Strategii Razvitia i Social’nye Interesy. Moscow: NISP