Public vs. private sector : an examination of neo-liberal ideology

Khan, Iram (2006): Public vs. private sector : an examination of neo-liberal ideology.

Abstract

The paper reviews the theoretical underpinnings of the debate on the superiority of the public or private sector, and supports theoretical perspectives with help from empirical literature on the subject. The theoretical part covers issues relating to public choice, property rights and principal-agents relationship, while the empirical evidence includes review of literature on macroeconomic, microeconomic and welfare impacts of privatization. The paper finds that despite numerous studies and unending discussions, the debate on the superiority of the public or private sector has remained inconclusive and is likely to remain so in the future. Notwithstanding the practical difficulties of making this assessment, the paper concludes that this debate is more ideological rather than empirical, since it is not possible to determine the superiority of one over the other through case studies, which can only be selective in nature.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: New Public Management
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B0 - General > B00 - General; A - General Economics and Teaching > A1 - General Economics > A11 - Role of Economics ; Role of Economists ; Market for Economists

References

Aharoni, Yair. (1982). State-Owned Enterprises: An Agent without a Principal. In Leroy P. Jones (Ed.), Public Enterprises in Less Developed Countries. NY: Cambridge University Press.

Assaad, Ragui. (1999). Matching Severance Payments with Worker Losses in the Egyptian Public Sector. The World Bank Economic Review, 13(1), 117-153.

Atkinson, A. B. (1989). The Failure of the State. Swalwell: Compuprint Publishing.

Barnett, Steven. (2000). Evidence on the Fiscal and Macroeconomic Impact of Privatisation, IMF Working Paper No. 00/130. Washington D.C.: International Monetary Fund.

Beyer, Hans-Joachim, Dziobek, Claudia, & Garrett, John R. (1999). Economic and Legal Considerations of Optimal Privatization - Case Studies of Mortgage Firms (Depfa Group and Fannie Mae), IMF Working Paper No. 99/69. Washington D.C.: International Monetary Fund.

Bhaskar, V. (1992). Privatisation and the Developing Countries: The Issues and the Evidence, UNCTAD Discussion Paper No. 47. Geneva: UNCTAD.

Bhaskar, V., & Khan, M. (1995). Privatisation and Employment: A Study of the Jute Industry in Bangladesh. The American Economic Review, 85(1), 267-273.

Birdsall, Nancy, & Nellis, John R. (2002). Winner and Losers: Assessing the Distributional Impact of Privatisation, Working Paper No.6. Washington D.C.: Center for Global Development.

Bishop, Matthew R., & Kay, John A. (1988). Does Privatisation Work: Lessons from the UK. London: Centre for Business Strategies, London Business School.

Boettke, P. J. (1994). Review of Privatisation, Public Ownership the Regulation of Natural Monopoly. Journal of Economic Literature, 32(4), 1916-1918.

Boubakri, Narjess, & Cosset, Jean-Claude. (1998). The Financial and Operating Performance of Newly Privatised Firms: Evidence from Developing Countries. Journal of Finance, 53(3), 1081-1110.

Boycke, M., Shleifer, Andrei, & Vishny, Robert W. (1997). Privatising Russia. Cambridge, MA.: MIT Press.

Boylaud, Olivier, & Nicoletti, Giuseppe. (2000). Regulation, Market Structure and Performance in Telecommunications, Economics Department Working Papers No. 2000/10. Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.

Brenan, G., & Buchanan, M.J. (1985). The Reasons of Rules: Constitutional Political Economy. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Cam, Surhan. (1999). Job Security, Unionisation, Wages and Privatisation: A Case Study in the Turkish Cement Industry. The Sociological Review, 695-714.

Chan, H. S., & Rosenbloom, D. H. (1994). Legal Control of Public Administration: A Principal-Agent Perspective. International Review of Administrative Sciences, 60(4).

Chisari, Omar O., Estache, Antonio, & Romero, C. (1999). Winners and Losers from the Privatisation and Regulation of Utilities: Lessons from a General Equilibrium Model of Argentina. The World Bank Economic Review, 13, 357-378.

Clarke, George R. G., Menard, Claude, & Zuluaga, Ana Maria. (2002). Measuring the Welfare Effects of Reform: Urban Water Supply in Guinea. World Development, 30(9), 1515–1537.

Cook, Paul. (1997). Privatisation, Public Enterprise Reform and the World Bank: Has ‘Bureaucrats in Business’ Got It Right? Journal of International Development, 9(6), 887-897.

Cook, Paul, & Kirkpatrick, Colin. (1988). Privatisation in Less Developed Countries: An Overview. In Paul Cook & Colin Kirkpatrick (Eds.), Privatisation in Less Developing Countries. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

Cook, Paul, & Kirkpatrick, Colin. (1998). Privatisation, Employment and Social Protection in Developing Countries. In Paul Cook, Colin Kirkpatrick & Fredrick Nixson (Eds.), Privatisation, Entrepreneurship and Economic Reform. London: Edward Elgar.

Cook, Paul, & Uchida, Yuichiro. (2001). Privatisation and Economic Growth in Developing Countries, CRC Working Paper No. 7. Manchester: Centre on Regulation and Competition, IDPM, University of Manchester.

Davis, Jeffrey, Ossowski, Rolando, Richardson, Thomas, & Barnett, Steven. (2000). Fiscal and Macroeconomic Impact of Privatisation, Occasional Paper No. 194. Washington D.C.: International Monetary Fund.

De Luca, L (Ed.). (1997). Labour and Social Dimensions of Privatization and Restructuring - Public Utilities Water, Gas, Electricity. Geneva: International Labour Organisation.

Dewenter, Kathryn L., & Malatesta, Paul H. (1997). Public Offerings of State-Owned and Privately-Owned Enterprises: An International Comparison. Journal of Finance, 52, 1659-1679.

Downs, A. (1967). Inside Bureaucracy. Boston: Little Brown. D'souza, Juliet, & Megginson, William L. (1999). The Financial and Operating Performance of Privatized Firms during the 1990s. Journal of Finance, 54(5), 1397-1438.

D'souza, Juliet, Megginson, William L., & Nash, Robert C. (2001). Determinants of Performance Improvement in Privatized Firms: Does Restructuring and Corporate Governance Matter?, Working Paper. Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma.

Dunleavy, Patrick. (1991). Democracy, Bureaucracy and Public Choice: Economic Explanations in Political Science. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

Eckel, Catherine, Eckel, Doug, & Singal, Vijay. (1997). Privatization and Efficiency: Industry Effects of the Sale of British Airways. Journal of Finance and Economics, 43, 275-298.

Ehrlich, Isaac, Gallais-Hamonno, Georges, Liu, Zhiqiang, & Lutter, Randall. (1994). Productivity Growth and Firm Ownership: An Empirical Investigation. The Journal of Political Economy, 102, 1006-1038.

Ernst, J. (1994). Whose Utility: The Social Impact of Public Utility Privatisation and Regulation in Britain. Buckingham: Open University Press.

Ernst, Ulrich F.W., Edwards, Nelson, Gladstone, Deborah, Gregory, Peter, & Holt, Tyler. (1999). Assessing the Impacts of Privatization: The Experience of Morocco. Washington D.C.: USAID.

Estache, Antonio, Gomez-Lobo, Andres, & Leipzeiger, Danny. (2001). Utility Privatisation and the Poor: Evidence from Latin America. World Development, 29(7), 1179-1198.

Galal, Ahmed, Jones, Leroy P., Tandon, Pankaj, & Vogelsang, I. (1994). Welfare Consequences of Selling Public Enterprises: An Empirical Analysis. NY: Oxford University Press.

Grosh, Barbara. (1991). Public Enterprises in Kenya. London: Lynn Reinner.

Haltiwanger, J., & Singh, M. (1999). Cross Country Evidence on Public Sector Retrenchment. The World Bank Economic Review, 13(1), 23-66.

Harris, C. (1995). Employees and the Privatisation of the Water Industry in England and Wales. In P. Morgan (Ed.), Privatisation and the Welfare State: Implications for Consumers and the Welfare. Aldershot: Aldershot.

Haskel, Jonathan, & Szymanski, K. (1996). Privatization and the Labour Markets: Facts, Theory, and Evidence. In Matthew R. Bishop, J. Kay & C. Mayer (Eds.), Privatization and Economic Performance. NY: Oxford University Press.

Haskel, Jonathan, & Szymanski, Stefan. (1993). Privatisation, Liberalisation, Wages and Employment: Theory and Evidence for the UK. Economica, 60(238), 161-181.

Heller, Peter S., & Schiller, Christian. (1989). The Fiscal Impact of Privatisation, with Examples from Arab Countries. World Development, 17(5), 757-767.

Howard, J.B. (1982). Social Accountability of Public Enterprises: Law and Community Controls in the New Development Strategies. In Leroy P. Jones (Ed.), Public Enterprises in Less Developed Countries. NY: Cambridge University Press.

ILO. (1996). Pakistan: Privatisation, Employment, Retraining and Social Protection. New Delhi: International Labour Organisation.

Jackson, P.M. (1982). The Political Economy of Bureaucracy. Deddington, Oxford: Phillip Allan. Jones, Leroy P. (Ed.). (1982). Public Enterprises in Less Developed Countries. Cambridge, UK.

Jones, Leroy P., Jammal, Y., & Gokgur, N. (1998). Impact of Privatisation in Cote D'ivoire, Report prepared for the Privatisation Committee. Boston: Boston Institute for Developing Economies.

Karatas, C. (1995). Has Privatisation Improved Profitability and Performance of the Public Enterprises in Turkey? In Paul Cook & Colin Kirkpatrick (Eds.), Privatisation Policy and Performance: International Perspectives. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

Kikeri, Sunita, & Nellis, John R. (2002). Privatization in Competitive Sectors: The Record So Far, World Bank Working Paper No. 2860. Washington D.C.: World Bank.

Kumar, A. (1995). An Assessment of Effectiveness of Structural Adjustment Policies in India with Particular Reference to Its Privatisation Policy. Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of Manchester, Manchester.

La Porta, Rafael, & Lopez-De-Silanes, Florencio. (1999). The Benefits of Privatisation: Evidence from Mexico. The Quarterly Journal of Economics(November), 1193-1242.

Lane, R. (1991). The Market Experience. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Laporte, Robert, & Ahmed, Muntazir Bashir. (1989). Public Enterprises in Pakistan: The Hidden Crisis in Economic Development. Boulder: Westview Press.

Li, D. D. (1996). A Theory of Ambiguous Property Rights in Transitional Economies: The Case of the Chinese Non-State Sector. Journal of Comparative Economics, 23(1), 1-19.

Looney, Robert E. (1996). Privatization of Public Enterprises in Pakistan: Macroeconomic Impacts on Private Industrial Investment. Economia Internazionale, 49(3), 385-400.

Mackintosh, M. (1992). The State: A Crisis of Governance. In M. Wuyts, M. Mackintosh & T. Hewitt (Eds.), Development Policy and Public Action. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Majumdar, Sumit, K. (1998). Assessing Comparative Efficiency of the State-Owned, Mixed, and Private Sectors in the Indian Industry. Public Choice, 96(1-2), 1-24.

Martin, B. (1993). In the Public Interest: Privatisation and Public Sector Reform: Zed Books. Martin, S., & Parker, David M. (1997). The Impact of Privatisation: Ownership and Corporate Performance in the UK. London & NY: Routledge.

Megginson, William L., Nash, R. C., & Van-Randenborgh, M. (1994). The Financial and Operating Performance of Newly Privatised Firms: An International Empirical Analysis. Journal of Finance, 49(2), 403-452.

Mohnot, S. R. (1993). Privatisation in India. In V. V. Ramanadham (Ed.), Constraints and Impact of Privatisation. London & NY: Routledge.

Nelson, Adrian, Cooper, Cary L., & Jackson, Paul R. (1995). Uncertainty Amidst Change: The Impact of Privatisation on Employee Job Satisfaction and Well-Being. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 85, 57-71.

Newbery, David M. (2001, November 1). Regulating Electricity to Ensure Efficient Competition. Paper presented at the the CEPR/ESRC Workshop on 'The Political Economy of Regulation', London.

Newbery, David M., & Pollitt, Michael G. (1997). The Restructuring and Privatisation of British CEGB - Was It Worth It?. The Journal of Industrial Economics, 65(3), 269-303.

Niskanen, W. A. (1973). Bureaucracy: Master or Servant. London: Institute of Economic Affairs.

Omran, Mohammed. (2001). Detecting the Performance Consequences of Privatizing Egyptian State-Owned Enterprises: Does Ownership Structure Really Matter? (Mimeo).

Pinheiro, A. C., & Schneider, B. R. (1994). Fiscal Impact of Privatisation in Latin America. Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 34(Summer), 9-42.

Pinheiro, A. C., & Schneider, B. R. (1995). Fiscal Impact of Privatisation in Latin America. Journal of Development Studies, 31(5), 751-785.

Plane, Patrick. (1997a). Privatisation and Economic Growth: An Empirical Investigation from a Sample of Developing Market Economies. Applied Economics, 29, 161-178.

Plane, Patrick. (1997b). Privatization of Water and Electricity in Africa: Initial Constraints, Methods of Implementation and Evaluation of Processes. In L. De Luca (Ed.), Labour and Social Dimensions of Privatization and Restructuring - Public Utilities Water, Gas, Electricity. Geneva: International Labour Organisation.

Pollitt, Michael G., & Smith, Andrew S. J. (2001). The Restructuring and Privatisation of British Rail: Was It Really That Bad?, DAE Working Paper No. 0118. Cambridge, UK: University of Cambridge.

Rama, M., & Maclsaac, D. (1999). Earnings and Welfare after Downsizing: Central Bank Employees in Ecuador. The World Bank Economic Review, 13(1), 89-116.

Ramamurti, Ravi. (1997). Testing the Limits of Privatization: Argentine Railroads. World Development, 25(12), 1973-1993.

Rees, R. (1985). The Theory of Principal and Agent: Parts 1 & 2. Bulletin of Economic Research, 37(2), 46-49, 79-90.

Saunders, P. (1995). Consumers and Privatisation: The Case of Water Industry. Aldershot: Dartmouth.

Saunders, P., & Harris, C. (1994). Privatisation and Popular Capitalism. Buckingham: Open University Press.

Saygili, Seref, & Taymaz, Erol. (2001). Privatization, Ownership and Technical Efficiency: A Study of the Turkish Cement Industry. Annals of Public and Co-operative Economics, 72(4), 581-605.

Schnytzer, A. (1985). Why Do Communists Not Obstruct the Transformation Process? Public Choice, 85(1-2), 143-156.

Serra, Pablo. (2000). Evidence from Utility and Infrastructure Privatisation in Chile. In OECD (Ed.), Privatisation, Competition and Regulation. Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.

Shaoul, Jean. (1997). A Critical Financial Analysis of the Performance of Privatised Industries: The Case of the Water Industry in England and Wales. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 8, 479-504.

Shaoul, Jean. (1999). Railpolitick: A Stakeholder Analysis of the Railways in Britain. Manchester: University of Manchester.

Sheshinski, Eytan, & Lopez-Calva, Luis Felipe. (1999). Privatization and Its Benefits: Theory and Evidence, CAER II Discussion Paper No. 35. Cambridge, MA.: Harvard Institute for International Development, Harvard University.

Stiglitz, Joseph E. (1992). Some Theoretical Aspect of the Privatization: Applications to Eastern Europe, NBER Working Paper No. 1749. Cambridge, MA.: National Bureau of Economic Research.

Suleiman, Ezra N., & Waterbury, John. (1990). Introduction: Analyzing Privatization in Industrial and Developing Countries. In Ezra N. Suleiman & John Waterbury (Eds.), The Political Economy of Public Sector Reform and Privatization. Boulder, Co.: Westview Press.

Tansel, Aysit. (1998a). Earnings of Turkish Workers before and after Dismissal Due to Privatisation. Ankara: Department of Economics, Middle East Technical University.

Tansel, Aysit. (1998b). Workers Displaced Due to Privatisation in Turkey: Before Versus after Displacement. METU Studies in Development, 25(4), 625-647.

Taylor, T. (1983). Structural Macroeconomics, Applicable Models for the Third World. New York: Basic Books.

Torero, Maximo, & Pasco-Font, Alberto. (2001). The Social Impact of Privatisation and the Regulation of Utilities in Peru, WIDER Discussion Paper No.2001/17. Helsinki: WIDER, United Nations University.

Van Brabanti, J. M. (1995). On the Economics of Property Rights and Privatisation in Transitional Economics. In Paul Cook & Colin Kirkpatrick (Eds.), Privatisation Policy and Performance: International Perspectives. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

Van Mierlo, H. G. A. (1986). Improvement of Public Provision of Goods and Services. In J. Lane (Ed.), State and Market: The Politics of the Public and the Private. London: Sage Publications.

Veljanovski, C. (1989). Privatisation: Monopoly Money or Competition? In C. Veljanovski (Ed.), Privatisation and Competition: A Market Perspective. London: Institute of Economic Affair.

Vickers, John, & Yarrow, George. (1988). Privatisation: An Economic Analysis. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Wallsten, Scott J. (1999). An Empirical Analysis of Competition, Privatization, and Regulation in Africa and Latin America, World Bank Working Paper No. 2316. Washington D.C.: World Bank.

Wallsten, Scott J. (2000). Telecommunications Privatization in Developing Countries: The Real Effects of Exclusivity Periods: University of Stanford.

Weiss, John. (1995). Mexico: Comparative Performance of State and Private Industrial Corporations. In Paul Cook & Colin Kirkpatrick (Eds.), Privatisation Policy and Performance: International Perspectives. Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

White, Oliver Campbell, & Bhattia, Anita. (1998). Privatization in Africa. Washington D.C.: World Bank.

Wiseman, J. (1978). The Political Economy of Nationalised Industry, The Economics of Politics, Reading No. 18. London: Institute of Economic Affairs.

World Bank. (1995). Bureaucrats in Business: The Economics and Politics of Government Ownership. NY: Oxford University Press.

Yarrow, George. (1986). Privatisation in Theory and Practice. Economic Policy, 1(2), 319-378.

Yarrow, George. (1989). Does Ownership Matter? In C. Veljanovski (Ed.), Privatisation and Competition. London: Institute of Economic Affairs.

Yarrow, George. (1993). Privatisation in the UK. In V.V. Ramanadham (Ed.), Privatisation in Developing Countries. London & NY: Routledge.